Human leukocyte antigen-B27 typing by flow cytometry: Comparison of three CE-IVD methods

A Cost-Effective and Labor-Saving Method for Detecting Human Leukocyte Antigen B27 Status via Sequence-Encoded Fluorescence Amplification Assay

Identification of human leukocyte antigen B27 (HLA-B27) by flow cytometry (FCM) has been widely applied in clinical practice for auxiliary diagnosis of ankylosing spondylitis (AS). However, FCM requires freshly prepared samples and relies on expensive equipment, reagents, and an experienced operator. To provide a cheaper and more convenient method for HLA-B27 detection, we proposed a new method termed sequence-encoded fluorescence amplification assay (SEFA), which specially recognized sequences of HLA-B27 gene (HLA-B∗27) covering current common subtypes in a single closed tube. SEFA could detect as low as 10 pg (equal to 3 copies) genomic DNA per reaction and distinguish HLA-B∗27 from other HLA-B alleles with highly similar sequences. A total of 288 clinical samples were tested by SEFA, including 181 patients with AS and 107 healthy controls. Compared with the detection results from FCM, two controversial samples of patients with AS were obtained and further confirmed to be consistent with SEFA by Sanger sequencing, indicating that this method was more accurate than FCM. Moreover, SEFA could detect HLA-B27 status by using supernatant from crude extract of 10-μL blood without commercial reagents. Overall, SEFA has the potential to be an alternative for HLA-B27 identification with the advantage of convenience and low cost, especially suitable for early diagnosis of AS in areas with limited medical resources.

Comparative study of two laboratory techniques for the detection of HLA-B27 in patients with axial spondyloarthritis: a cross-sectional analysis

BACKGROUND

The diagnostic and prognostic relevance of Human Leukocyte Antigen B-27 (HLA-B27) in Axial Spondyloarthritis (AxSpA) is undeniable, with 70% of Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS) patients carrying the B27 gene, contrasted with a mere 4.35% in the general population. Flow cytometry (FC) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) have emerged as the predominant techniques for routine HLA-B27 typing. While various studies have compared these methods, none have catered to the unique characteristics of the Brazilian demographic. Therefore, this research aims to compare FC and PCR in a Brazilian cohort diagnosed with AxSpA.

METHODS

An analytical cross-sectional study was undertaken involving 62 AxSpA outpatients from a Brazilian University Hospital. Both FC and PCR-SSP assays were utilized to ascertain HLA-B27 typing. The outcomes (either confirming or refuting the allele's presence) underwent rigorous scrutiny. Agreement between the methodologies was assessed using the kappa statistic. A p-value of < 0.05 was deemed statistically significant.

RESULTS

Of the participants, 90.3% (n = 56) were HLA-B27 positive according to FC, while 79% (n = 49) were identified as positive using the PCR method. FC exhibited a sensitivity rate of 98% paired with a specificity of 38.5%. The Positive Predictive Value for FC stood at 85.7%, and the Negative Predictive Value was 83.5%. Consequently, the overall accuracy of the FC method was gauged at 85.5%. A kappa coefficient of κ = 0.454 was derived.

CONCLUSIONS

FC demonstrated noteworthy sensitivity and satisfactory accuracy in HLA-B27 detection, albeit with a reduced specificity when contrasted with PCR-SSP. Nevertheless, given its cost-effectiveness and streamlined operation relative to PCR, FC remains a pragmatic option for preliminary screening in clinical practice, especially in low-income regions. To optimize resource allocation, we advocate for a refined algorithm that initiates by assessing the relevance of HLA-B27 typing based on Choosing Wisely recommendations. It then leans on FC, and, if results are negative yet clinical suspicion persists, advances to PCR. This approach aims to balance diagnostic accuracy and financial prudence, particularly in regions contending with escalating medical costs.

Anti-HLA-B7/HLA-B44 strong cross immunoreactivity observed in flow cytometry HLA-B27 immunotyping

Cross reactivities are known for human leukocyte antigen inside HLA-B7 related Cross-Reactive Group (B7CREG). Some CE-IVD flow-cytometry kits use double monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to distinguish HLA-B27 and HLA-B7 but practice reveals more complexes results. This study explores the performances of this test. Analysis of 466 consecutive cases using HLA-B27 IOTest™ kit on a Navios™ cytometer from Beckman-Coulter, partially compared to their genotypes. Expected haplotypes HLA-B27-/HLA-B7- (undoubtedly HLA-B27 negative) and HLA-B27+/HLA-B7- (undoubtedly HLA-B27+) were clearly identified according to the manufacturer's instructions. On the opposite, patients strongly labeled with anti-HLA-B7 showed three different phenotypes regarding anti-HLA-B27 labeling: (1) most of the cases were poorly labeled in accordance with cross reactivity inside B7CREG (HLA-B27-/HLA-B7+ haplotype); (2) rare cases had strong B7 and B27 labeling corresponding to HLA-B27+/HLA-B7+ haplotype; (3) even less cases had strong labeling by anti-HLA-B7 but non for anti-HLA-B27, all expressing HLA-B44 and no B7CREG molecules. Surprisingly, more cases were not labeled with anti-HLA-B7 antibody but partially labeled with anti-HLA-B27 suggesting another cross reactivity out of B7CREG. mAb HLA typing suggests new, cross reactivities of anti-HLA-B27 antibody to more molecules out of B7CREG and of anti-HLA-B7 antibody but not anti-HLA-B27 to HLA-B44 molecule also out of B7CREG. HLA-B27 could surely be excluded in most samples labeled with HLA-B27, below a "grey zone" on intermediate intensity. More comparison is needed in future studies.

High-Throughput and Automated Detection of HLA-B*27 Using the LabTurboTM AIO System

The adoption of an automated system can decrease the hands-on time requirements in a clinical laboratory setting. For the detection of HLA-B*27, implementing a high-throughput and fully automated system has several advantages over using manual methods. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate automation efficiency for the detection of HLA-B*27. Peripheral blood samples were obtained from 50 participants, and DNA was isolated from these samples. A Pharmigene PG27 detection kit was used for the qualitative detection of HLA-B*27. The performances of the semi-automated and fully automated LabTurbo^TM AIO systems in the detection of HLA-B*27 were compared. The mean absorbance (optical density) values for the Maelstrom^TM 8 and LabTurbo^TM AIO systems were found to be 1.88 and 1.9, respectively. The housekeeping gene was amplified and quantified using a real-time PCR assay across all DNA extracts to check the quality of the extracted human DNA. The results were expressed as the cycle threshold (Ct) values for all DNA extracts from both platforms. The mean Ct values for the Roche Cobas z480 and LabTurbo^TM AIO systems were found to be 22.7 and 20.4, respectively. This study demonstrated that the semi-automated method and the LabTurbo^TM AIO system yield consistent results for the detection of HLA-B*27. However, compared to the semi-automated method, the LabTurbo^TM AIO system provides standardized procedures, avoids manual handling, and improves turnaround time.