High diagnostic accuracy of core needle biopsy of soft tissue tumors: An institutional experience

Analysis on diagnostic failure of US-guided core needle biopsy for soft tissue tumors

Purpose

To evaluate the diagnostic yield of ultrasonography (US)-guided core needle biopsy (CNB) in the diagnosis of soft tissue tumors (STTs) and to analyze the failure factors.

Methods

139 patients with STTs that underwent both US-guided CNB and surgical resection were collected retrospectively. Compared with the histopathological results of surgical resection, the biopsy failure was defined as the following conditions: indefinitive diagnosis, including insufficient samples and unknown subtypes with correct biological potential classification; wrong diagnosis, including wrong biological potential classification and wrong subtypes with correct biological potential classification. Univariate and multivariate analyses from the perspectives of histopathological, demographic and US features together with biopsy procedures were performed to determine risk factors for diagnostic failure.

Results

The diagnostic yield of US-guided CNB for STTs in our study was 78.4%, but when only considering the correct biological potential classification of STTs, the diagnostic yield was 80.6%. The multivariate analysis showed that adipocytic tumors (odds ratio (OR) = 10.195, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.062 - 97.861, p = 0.044), vascular tumors (OR = 41.710, 95% CI: 3.126 - 556.581, p = 0.005) and indeterminate US diagnosis (OR = 8.641, 95% CI: 1.852 - 40.303, p = 0.006) were correlated with the diagnostic failure. The grade III vascular density (OR = 0.019, 95% CI: 0.001 - 0.273, p = 0.007) enabled a higher diagnostic accuracy.

Conclusion

US-guided CNB can be an effective modality for the diagnosis of STTs. The diagnostic yield can be increased when the tumor vascular density was grade III in Color Doppler US, but can be decreased in adipocytic tumors, vascular tumors and masses with indeterminate US diagnosis.

Percutaneous biopsy of musculoskeletal tumors and the potential for needle tract seeding: technical considerations, current controversies, and outcomes

Multidisciplinary communication and planning between the musculoskeletal radiologist and orthopedic oncologist are essential for proper biopsy planning when a primary musculoskeletal malignancy is suspected. Image-guided percutaneous biopsy allows for real-time visualization of the biopsy needle and surrounding structures, combining high diagnostic accuracy with safety and cost-effectiveness. However, determining a surgically optimal biopsy trajectory for a mass can be technically challenging due to critical surrounding anatomy or challenging needle approach angles. Inappropriately placed biopsies can have serious repercussions on patient function and oncological survival. The potential for needle tract seeding and local recurrence after biopsy of sarcoma has been central to the debate regarding the need for excision of the biopsy tract. This multidisciplinary review highlights current controversies in the field, including the issue of core needle biopsy tracts and their excision, technical considerations and advances in image-guidance in the setting of challenging biopsies, advances in histopathological diagnostics with implications for targeted therapy in sarcoma, as well as surgical and oncological outcomes after needle tract biopsy.

Accuracy and Safety of Ultrasound-Guided Core Needle Biopsy of Soft Tissue Tumors in an Outpatient Setting: A Sarcoma Center Analysis of 392 Consecutive Patients

Simple Summary

In patients with unclear soft tissue lesions, treatment planning largely depends on histology. Core needle biopsy is the diagnostic standard in these cases. The aim of this retrospective study was to investigate accuracy and safety of ultrasound guided core needle biopsy at a tertiary referral center. We show that ultrasound guided biopsy was feasible as a one stop shop procedure in an outpatient setting in 87.6% of the cases. The rate of conclusive biopsies was 88.5%. After surgical resection, the dignity, tumor type and histopathological grading of the biopsy matched one of the resection specimens in 97.2%, 92.7% and 92.5% of the cases, respectively. Major complications occurred in 0.8% of the cases. With this study, we confirm that ultrasound guided core needle biopsy is safe, effective and can be performed at the first outpatient presentation to speed up the diagnostic and therapeutic cascade in sarcoma patients.

Abstract

Background: The aim of this study was to investigate diagnostic accuracy, safety and histologic results of ultrasound guided core needle biopsy (CNB) in patients with soft tissue lesions (STL) at a tertiary referral center. Methods: A retrospective analysis of all consecutive patients undergoing ultrasound guided CNB for STL at our sarcoma outpatient service between January 2015 and August 2020 was performed. Results: A total of 392 patients were identified. Main histologic entities were sarcomas, lipomas and desmoid tumors. Biopsy was performed in an outpatient setting in 87.6% of the cases. Conclusive biopsies were obtained in 88.5% of the cases. In patients who underwent surgical resection after CNB, the concordance of dignity, tumor entity and histopathological grading between biopsy and resection specimen were 97.2%, 92.7% and 92.5% respectively. The risk of inconclusive CNB was highest in intraabdominal or retroperitoneal tumors (19.5%) and lowest in lesions at the lower extremity (4.4%). Major complications after CNB occurred in three cases (0.8%). No case of biopsy tract seeding was observed during the study period. Conclusions: Ultrasound guided CNB for STL at first presentation in a dedicated surgical outpatient setting is a safe procedure and yields a high diagnostic accuracy.

Role of Intraoperative Pathology Consultation by Imprint and Scrape Cytology in Soft Tissue Tumors and Tumor-Like Lesions

Intraoperative pathologic consultation plays an essential role in therapeutic decision making, possibly avoiding under or overtreatment of the patient. Common indications for intraoperative consultation include obtaining a diagnosis in an unknown pathology, ruling out malignancy, confirming a provisional diagnosis, and assessing margin status. Fifty patients undergoing surgery for soft tissue tumors or tumor-like lesions were included in the present prospective study to evaluate the role of intraoperative pathologic consultation by imprint and scrape cytology. Careful and quick gross examination of the specimen was performed, followed by processing for imprint and scrape smears. The prepared smears were evaluated by three pathologists and the cytological diagnosis compared subsequently with final histopathological diagnosis. Intraoperative consultation was primarily requested to make or confirm preoperative diagnosis. In 44.0% cases, no previous tissue/cytological diagnosis was available. In 56.0% cases, previous pathological diagnosis was available, but the reports were inconclusive or were reported from outside our institute. The diagnostic yield of imprint smears was 24% (5 malignant, 6 benign, and 1 inconclusive), and scrape smears was 100% (10 malignant, 38 benign, and 2 inconclusive). Paraffin-embedded sections yielded diagnosis in 100% cases (11 malignant, 38 benign, and 1 nonneoplastic). Imprint smears alone were not of much help in intraoperative diagnosis. Scrape smears were found to be superior to imprint smears in terms of diagnostic yield and accuracy. Combined imprint and scrape smear cytology did not provide any advantage in intraoperative provisional tissue diagnosis in soft tissue tumors.

Diagnostic accuracy of image-guided core needle biopsy of non-central nervous system tumors in children

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Core needle biopsies (CNB) are less invasive, cause less morbidity, and have lower costs than open biopsies (OB). However, the number of studies reporting CNB accuracy in pediatric tumors is limited and series are small. The aim of this study is to investigate if CNB diagnosis is concordant with the final diagnosis in pediatric solid non-central nervous system (CNS) tumors.

METHODS

Data from all patients treated in a single center between November 2014 and December 2019 were collected from the national pathology database and from local medical records. Data collection included age, sex, CNB diagnosis, final diagnosis, number of cores obtained, number of cores used for histology, cumulative core length, greatest dimension of the lesion, lesion volume, and complications.

RESULTS

Out of 361 CNB, 95.6% (345/361) provided a diagnosis. A resection or follow-up biopsy was performed in 201 cases. The final diagnosis was concordant with the CNB in 100% (201/201) of cases. The age, number of cores used for histology, and the greatest dimension of the lesion did not significantly differ between diagnostic and nondiagnostic CNB. The cumulative core length of diagnostic CNB was significantly higher than in the nondiagnostic group (24.72 mm vs. 13.37 mm, p-value .022). Complications occurred in 2.1% (7/337) of CNB procedures. Molecular analysis was successful in 228/233 (98%) of cases in which it was performed.

CONCLUSIONS

CNB diagnosis is highly concordant with the final diagnosis and the diagnostic rate is high. The complication rate in CNB is low.

Dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans: the diagnosis of high-grade fibrosarcomatous transformation

OBJECTIVES

Dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans (DFSP) is an intermediate-grade tumour which may undergo fibrosarcomatous transformation to a high-grade sarcoma (DFSP-FST). DFSP-FST requires wide local resection, and therefore, pre-operative identification is important. The aims of this study are to see if DFSP and DFSP-FST can be differentiated based on MRI appearances, and to determine the ability of ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy (US-CNB) to identify DFSP-FST.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective review of patients with a histological diagnosis of DFSP with/without transformation to DFSP-FST. Patient age, gender, lesion location and maximal size were recorded, as were several MRI features. MRI studies were reviewed independently by 2 musculoskeletal radiologists and the assessed features were then compared with final surgical resection histology. Histological results of US-CNB were also compared with final surgical pathology.

RESULTS

A total of 42 patients were included, 26 males and 16 females with a mean age of 41.3 years (range 3-78 years). The upper limb was involved in 12 cases, the lower limb in 17 and the trunk in 13. Final surgical histological diagnosis was DFSP in 21 (50%) cases and DFSP-FST in 21 (50%) cases. Mean tumour dimension for DFSP was 32 mm and DFSP-FST 68 mm (p < 0.001). MRI features indicative of DFSP-FST included multi-lobular morphology (p = 0.03), T2W hypointensity compared with fat (p = 0.03), internal flow voids (p = 0.03) and peri-tumoral oedema (p < 0.001). Only 3 cases of DFSP-FST were correctly diagnosed on US-CNB.

CONCLUSIONS

Various MRI findings can suggest a diagnosis of DFSP-FST, but US-CNB is unreliable at identifying high-grade fibrosarcomatous transformation.

Nomogram Based on Ultrasonography and Clinical Features for Predicting Malignancy in Soft Tissue Tumors

Purpose

The objective of this study was to establish a predictive nomogram based on ultrasound (US) and clinical features for patients with soft tissue tumors (STTs).

Patients and Methods

A total of 260 patients with STTs were enrolled in this retrospective study and were divided into a training cohort (n=200, including 110 malignant and 90 benign masses) and a validation cohort (n=60, including 30 malignant and 30 benign masses). Multivariate analysis was performed by binary logistic regression analysis to determine the significant factors predictive of malignancy. A simple nomogram was established based on these independent risk factors including US and clinical features. The predictive accuracy and discriminative ability of the nomogram were measured by the calibration curve and the concordance index (C-index).

Results

The nomogram, comprising US features (maximum diameter, margin and vascular density) and clinical features (sex, age, and duration of disease), showed a favorable performance for predicting malignancy, with a sensitivity of 88.2% and a specificity of 78.7%. The calibration curve for malignancy probability in the training cohort showed good agreement between the nomogram predictions and actual observations. The C-indexes of the training cohort and validation cohort for predicting malignancy were 0.89 (95% CI: 0.85–0.94) and 0.83 (95% CI: 0.73–0.94), respectively.

Conclusion

The nomogram based on US and clinical features could be a simple, intuitive and reliable tool to individually predict malignancy in patients with STTs.

Non image-guided core needle biopsies can be used safely to improve diagnostic efficiency for soft tissue tumors

INTRODUCTION

Front-line biopsy remains the rule in the management of soft tissue mass syndromes. Although open biopsy has long been considered the gold standard, it has recently been shown that a percutaneous biopsy is associated with a reduction in the rate of complications and cost, while maintaining high diagnostic accuracy. Though there is much literature regarding the diagnostic accuracy of image-guided and open biopsies for soft tissue tumors, the accuracy of percutaneous non image-guided biopsies has not been well documented. The objective of this study was to compare the failure rate of non image-guided biopsies, image-guided biopsies and open biopsies for the diagnosis of soft tissue tumors. We also attempted to identify the failure risk factors for non image-guided biopsies and we compared the diagnostic delay of the three types of biopsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This was a continuous, single-center retrospective study. We reviewed the results from 337 patients managed with a biopsy (percutaneous or open) for a soft tissue tumor, all carried out in our center between January 2010 and December 2015. Biopsy technique was chosen by the treating orthopedic surgeon, according to the clinical and radiological characteristics of the mass. 141 patients (41.8%) had a non-image-guided biopsy as the first-line diagnostic procedure, 81 (24.0%) had an image-guided biopsy, and 115 (34.1%) an open biopsy. Diagnostic failure was defined either by a non-contributory biopsy, the need for repeat biopsy, or a major histological discordance obtained from the resected tumor piece. The risk factors studied were tumor characteristics, patient' characteristics and sampling modalities. Diagnostic delay was defined as the period between the day of the first external consultation at the hospital and the day of the notification of the diagnosis by the physician.

RESULTS

We obtained a failure rate of 9.9% (14 patients) for non image-guided biopsies. Eleven were non-contributive and three were considered as errors of diagnosis. The failure rate for image-guided biopsies was 18.5% (15 patients), with no significant difference compared with non image-guided biopsies. The open biopsies were associated with a failure rate of 6.9% (eight patients). We found no failure risk factors for non image-guided biopsies. Diagnostic delay was significantly shorter for non image-guided biopsies (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSION

When performed in a referral center by the patient's surgeon, a non-image-guided core needle biopsy is a safe procedure which ensures equivalent diagnostic accuracy for soft tissue tumors, while reducing the diagnostic delay.

Diagnostic concordance between ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy and surgical resection specimens for histological grading of extremity and trunk soft tissue sarcoma

OBJECTIVE

Determination of accurate histological grade impacts on management for soft tissue sarcomas (STSs). Although ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy (US-CNB) accurately establishes tumour subtype compared with surgical specimens, the concordance for tumour grade is uncertain. The aim of this study was to assess the concordance between US-CNB and surgical resection specimens for tumour grade in trunk and extremity STS.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective review of consecutive patients presenting with extremity/trunk STS. Data collected included patient age, gender, lesion location, US-CNB diagnosis and grade, and surgical histology and grade. The histological diagnosis and tumour grade from US-CNB was compared with surgical resection histology.

RESULTS

A total of 118 patients were included, 76 males and 42 females with a mean age of 54 years (range 10 months-90 years old). STS size ranged from 26 to 350 mm (mean 89.5 mm). All US-CNB procedures were performed with a 14G biopsy needle with a mean number of 5 passes. First US-CNB was diagnostic for STS in all patients, and provided adequate tissue for tumour grading in all but one patient. Histological tumour subtype on US-CNB matched surgical specimens in all cases, with 25 (21.2%) STS being low grade and 93 (78.8%) high grade. The concordance for tumour grade was 96.6%, with no difference between low- and high-grade STSs (p > 0.05). The 4 cases of mismatch were considered low grade on US-CNB, but subsequently high grade on surgical resection.

CONCLUSION

US-CNB of STS can reliably predict histological tumour grade compared with surgical resection specimens, thus allowing confident treatment decisions to be made.

Core needle biopsy versus incisional biopsy for differentiation of soft-tissue sarcomas: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Controversies exist regarding the biopsy technique of choice for the accurate diagnosis of soft-tissue sarcoma (STS). The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to compare the diagnostic accuracy of core needle biopsy (CNB) versus incisional biopsy (IB) in STS with reference to the final histopathological result.

METHODS

Studies regarding the diagnostic accuracy of CNB and IB in detecting STS were searched systematically in the MEDLINE and EMBASE databases. Estimates of sensitivity and specificity with associated 95% CIs for diagnostic accuracy were calculated. The risk of bias was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies version 2 (QUADAS-2).

RESULTS

A total of 17 studies comprising 2680 patients who underwent 1582 CNBs and 241 IBs with subsequent tumor resection met the inclusion criteria. The sensitivity and specificity of CNB and IB to detect the dignity of lesions were 97% (95% CI, 95%-98%) and 99% (95% CI, 97%-99%), respectively, and 96% (95% CI, 92%-99%) and 100% (95% CI, 94%-100%), respectively. Estimates of the sensitivity and specificity of CNB and IB to detect the STS histotype were 88% (95% CI, 86%-90%) and 77% (95% CI, 72%-81%), respectively, and 93% (95% CI, 87%-97%) and 65% (95% CI, 49%-78%), respectively. Patients who underwent CNB had a significantly reduced risk of complications compared with patients who underwent IB (risk ratio, 0.14; 95% CI, 0.03-0.56 [P ≤ .01). Quality assessment of studies revealed a high risk of bias.

CONCLUSIONS

CNB has high accuracy in diagnosing the dignity of lesions and STS histotype in patients with suspected STS with fewer complications compared with IB. Therefore, CNB should be regarded as the primary biopsy technique.

Diagnosis and Management of Subcutaneous Soft Tissue Sarcoma

OPINION STATEMENT

The proper diagnosis and treatment planning for subcutaneous soft tissue sarcoma is very important. Soft tissue tumors can occur anywhere in the body, but if they occur subcutaneously, patients can easily notice a subcutaneous soft tissue mass. Therefore, it is possible to determine through recording, the growth speed of the mass, which is often difficult to obtain with deep-situated soft tissue masses. Palpation can also provide information about the firmness and mobility of the mass. Thus, history taking and physical examinations are informative for subcutaneous soft tissue tumors, compared to tumors that occur deeply. Because subcutaneous soft tissue tumors are easily recognized, they are often resected, without sufficient imaging analyses or thorough treatment planning. An operation performed based on such an inadequate preoperative plan is called a "whoops surgery." In the case of "whoops surgeries," subsequent radical surgery is required to remove additional areas, including hematomas that result from the initial surgery, that require a wider range of resection and soft tissue reconstruction. Therefore, as with deep-seated soft tissue tumors, it is important to conduct careful imaging examinations and make appropriate preoperative plans for subcutaneous soft tissue tumors. Subcutaneous soft tissue sarcomas often show an invasive pattern, and such tumors require a more careful assessment to prevent local recurrence after surgery. During surgery, it is necessary to remove the entire infiltration area along the fascia. Sometimes, an adequately wide excision is necessary, which is considered the minimum necessary procedure to eradicate the lesion. As noted above, clinicians who see patients with subcutaneous soft tissue tumors are encouraged to have sufficient knowledge and experience regarding the diagnosis and treatment. This article is intended for all doctors who deal with subcutaneous soft tissue tumors and focuses on essential points regarding their diagnosis and management.

A meta-analysis supports core needle biopsy by radiologists for better histological diagnosis in soft tissue and bone sarcomas

BACKGROUND

Although surgical biopsy has historically been considered to be the standard diagnostic biopsy for soft tissue and bone sarcomas, recent literature suggests that percutaneous core needle biopsy yields similar results. Therefore, an evaluation of the exact diagnostic accuracy and associated influential variables of core needle biopsy that is based on a large data set would be useful.

METHODS

We searched MEDLINE, Web of Science, and EMBASE to identify core needle biopsy studies for predicting final histological subtypes of musculoskeletal lesions. The diagnostic accuracies of core needle biopsy and of surgical biopsy were assessed and compared by using random-effect meta-analyses. The factors relevant to diagnostic accuracy were evaluated by meta-regression and subgroup analyses.

RESULTS

We selected 32 studies comprising 7209 musculoskeletal lesions. The pooled proportion estimate for the diagnostic accuracy of core needle biopsy was 0.84 (95% confidential interval, CI: 0.81-0.87), which indicated an approximate 84% concordance between core needle biopsy results and final histological diagnoses. The findings of meta-regression and subgroup analyses suggested that radiologists were better core needle biopsy operators than surgeons. An additional meta-analysis for direct comparison between core needle biopsy and surgical biopsy demonstrated that diagnostic accuracy was significantly lower for core needle biopsy than for surgical (pooled odds ratio: 0.39, 95% CI: 0.20-0.76).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggested that core needle biopsy should be performed by expert radiologists and that surgical biopsy should be performed if diagnosis following core needle biopsy does not match the clinical presentation and radiographic findings.

Comparative Study of Imprint Cytology and Histopathology of Soft Tissue Tumors

Background:

The components of soft tissue are fibroblasts, collagen, vascular structures, fatty tissue, skeletal muscles, smooth muscles, and neural tissue. The real incidence of soft tissue tumors (STTs) is difficult to estimate because most of them are benign (Benign: Malignant-100:1).

Aims:

The aim of the present study was undertaken to note the patterns of presentation of patients with STTs and to evaluate the findings of imprint cytology (IC) and histopathological examination (HPE) of STTs.

Materials and Methods:

The present study was undertaken for 1 year. A total of 41 patients with clinically and radiologically diagnosed STTs were included in the study. Following surgery, imprint smear was taken for each tumor, before delivering the tissue to 10% formalin. HPE was subsequently performed.

Results:

The age of the patients ranged from 4 months to 80 years with a mean of 35.6 ± 17.5 years. The ratio of males to females was 1.05:1. HPE revealed that 21 (51.2%) tumors were benign and 20 (48.8%) malignant. Imprint smears revealed 16 (39%) tumors to be benign and 20 (48.8%) malignant. IC was inconclusive in 5 (12.2%) cases. The sensitivity of IC was found to be 89.5% and specificity 82.35%. The positive predictive value of IC was 85%. The accuracy of IC for diagnosis of both benign and malignant tumors was found to be 75%.

Conclusion:

IC of STTs is a rapid and simple method of intraoperative diagnosis, and it can serve as a viable alternative to frozen section biopsy, particularly in rural settings.

Metastatic prostatic stromal sarcoma: A challenging diagnosis on fine-needle aspiration with broad differential diagnosis

Prostatic stromal sarcomas (PSS) are rare solid organ mesenchymal sarcomas. PSS may pose difficult diagnostic challenges on fine needle aspiration biopsy. We report a 48-year-old man diagnosed with metastatic high grade prostatic stromal sarcoma by a CT-scan guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of a right lower lung lobe nodule. We reviewed the literature on the epidemiologic, cyto-histological, and immunophenotypic findings and discussed the differential diagnosis for this rare entity.