Split unresponsiveness to the trinitrophenyl determinant. I. Manoeuvers which suppress either humoral or cell-mediated immune responses

From Mysterious Supernatant Entity to miRNA-150 in Antigen-Specific Exosomes: a History of Hapten-Specific T Suppressor Factor

Soon after the discovery of T suppressor cells by Gershon in 1970, it was demonstrated that one subpopulation of these lymphocytes induced by i.v. hapten injection suppresses contact sensitivity response mediated by effector CD4+ or CD8+ T cells in mice through the release of soluble T suppressor factor (TsF) that acts antigen specifically. Our experiments showed that biologically active TsF is a complex entity consisting of two subfactors, one antigen specific and other non-specific, produced by differently induced populations of cells. In following years, we found that the antigen-specific subfactor is a light chain of IgM antibody that is produced by B1a lymphocytes. However, the exact nature of non-specific part remained a mystery for about 30 years. Our current studies characterized TsF as regulatory miRNA-150 carried by T suppressor cell-derived exosomes that are antigen specific due to a surface coat of IgM antibody light chains produced by B1a cells. The present communication briefly summarizes our studies on TsF that led to discovery of regulating miRNA that acts antigen specifically to suppress immune response.

Macrophages play an essential role in antigen-specific immune suppression mediated by T CD8⁺ cell-derived exosomes

Murine contact sensitivity (CS) reaction could be antigen-specifically regulated by T CD8(+) suppressor (Ts) lymphocytes releasing microRNA-150 in antibody light-chain-coated exosomes that were formerly suggested to suppress CS through action on macrophages (Mφ). The present studies investigated the role of Mφ in Ts cell-exosome-mediated antigen-specific suppression as well as modulation of Mφ antigen-presenting function in humoral and cellular immunity by suppressive exosomes. Mice depleted of Mφ by clodronate liposomes could not be tolerized and did not produce suppressive exosomes. Moreover, isolated T effector lymphocytes transferring CS were suppressed by exosomes only in the presence of Mφ, demonstrating the substantial role of Mφ in the generation and action of Ts cell regulatory exosomes. Further, significant decrease of number of splenic B cells producing trinitrophenyl (TNP) -specific antibodies with the alteration of the ratio of serum titres of IgM to IgG was observed in recipients of exosome-treated, antigen-pulsed Mφ and the significant suppression of CS was demonstrated in recipients of exosome-treated, TNP-conjugated Mφ. Additionally, exosome-pulsed, TNP-conjugated Mφ mediated suppression of CS in mice pre-treated with a low-dose of cyclophosphamide, suggesting de novo induction of T regulatory (Treg) lymphocytes. Treg cell involvement in the effector phase of the studied suppression mechanism was proved by unsuccessful tolerization of DEREG mice depleted of Treg lymphocytes. Furthermore, the inhibition of proliferation of CS effector cells cultured with exosome-treated Mφ in a transmembrane manner was observed. Our results demonstrated the essential role of Mφ in antigen-specific immune suppression mediated by Ts cell-derived exosomes and realized by induction of Treg lymphocytes and inhibition of T effector cell proliferation.

Tolerogenic role of Kupffer cells in allergic reactions

Drug-induced allergic reactions (DIARs), including allergic hepatitis, cutaneous reactions, and blood dyscrasias, are unpredictable and can be life threatening. Although current studies suggest that DIARs are caused by immunogenic drug-protein adducts, it remains unclear what factors determine the susceptibility to DIARs. We hypothesized that most individuals may be resistant to DIARs in part because they become immunologically tolerant to drug-protein adducts in the liver, an organ with tolerogenic properties. Because animal models of DIARs are elusive, we tested this hypothesis using a murine model of 2,4-dinitrochlorobenzene (DNCB)-induced delayed type hypersensitivity reaction that is mediated by immunogenic 2,4-dinitrophenylated (DNP)-protein adducts. Intravenous pretreatment of mice with DNP-BSA led to its accumulation in hepatic Kupffer cells (KC) and induced immunological tolerance to subsequent DNCB sensitization. Tolerance could be abrogated by prior depletion of KC or induced in naïve mice by transferring a T cell-depleted, KC-enriched fraction of liver nonparenchymal cells from mice tolerized 1 month earlier by DNP-BSA pretreatment. These findings implicate KC as a primary and sustained inducer of tolerance against DNP-protein adducts and suggest a similar role in modulating allergic reactions against drug-protein adducts. Perhaps genetic and/or environmental factors affecting the activities of these cells may play a role in determining individual susceptibility to DIARs.

Immunological signals which control T cell responses

A number of identifiable immunological parameters can influence the elicitation and regulation of antigen-specific inflammatory responses to immunogenic epitopes. Injection of antigen in vivo can lead to the activation of type IV hypersensitivity responses, or to the induction of immunological tolerance to that antigen. We have used the hapten trinitrophenol as a model system for studying the factors which influence the generation and regulation of hypersensitivity responses to immunogenic epitopes in vivo. The generation of hypersensitivity or tolerance to trinitrophenyl depends on a number of immunological factors, including the form of the antigen, the route of immunization, and the presence of immune complexes of antibody and antigen on the surface of the antigen-presenting cell. Immunization with trinitrophenyl resulting in unresponsiveness can be the result of either the inability to prime inflammatory cells in vivo or the induction of suppressor T cells.

Regulatory responses in contact sensitivity: afferent suppressor T cells inhibit the activation of efferent suppressor T cells

Two types of suppressor cells regulate the contact sensitivity (CS) response to picryl chloride (PCL). Afferent suppressor T cells (Ts-aff) inhibit the generation of CS responses to PCL, while efferent suppressor T cells (Ts-eff) inhibit the activity of Th 1 cells that mediate CS reaction. Intravenous injection of mice with TNP-substituted peritoneal exudate cells (TNP-PEC) induces Ts-eff cells that block the adoptive transfer of contact sensitivity. The induction of Ts-eff cells is prevented by the presence of Ts-aff cells, which in turn are induced by the injection of TNP-PEC coupled with antibodies of the IgG2a and IgG2b isotype (TNP-PEC-Ab). If an animal is injected with TNP-PEC prior to or simultaneously with TNP-PEC-Ab, it generates only Ts-aff cells, while if it is injected with TNP-PEC alone or TNP-PEC prior to TNP-PEC-Ab, it generates Ts-eff cells. Ts-aff cells effect only the generation of Ts-eff cells, as the addition of Ts-eff cells to assays for Ts-eff cells has no inhibitory effect on the suppressive effects of Ts-eff cells in adoptive transfer. Our experiments show that Ts-aff cells induced by TNP-PEC-Ab are phenotypically either Lyt 1+2- or Lyt 1-2+, but only the latter inhibit the generation of Ts-eff cells in vivo. The Ts-aff cells that inhibit Ts-eff activity adhere to the lectin Vicia villosa (VV), while Ts-eff cells are VV nonadherent. In addition, Ts-aff cells can prevent the generation of Ts-eff to linked haptens presented on the same PEC. It appears that a cascade of Ts cell interactions are involved in the regulation of CS responses.

Role of dextran-specific suppressor T cells in the regulation of the immune response by a reactive form of dextran

Reactive forms of antigens or haptens have been shown to induce a state of hyporesponsiveness mediated in part by suppressor T cells. Injection of Balb/c x C57B16 F1 (CB6F1) mice with a reactive form of dextran B1355S (periodate oxidized dextran, dex-P) specifically reduced responses to dextran immunization within 1 day after dex-P treatment. This unresponsiveness lasted at least 23 days and required a reactive form of dextran for its induction since native dextran and oxidized/reduced dextran failed to induce tolerance. Furthermore, hyporesponsiveness could be induced by iv injection of dextran-coupled cells, especially peripheral blood lymphocytes, a result which suggests that in vivo coupling to cellular antigens is involved in dex-P-induced hyporesponsiveness. Suppression of the anti-dextran response could be transferred to normal mice with T-cell-enriched spleen cell populations from dex-P-injected mice. Interestingly, the presence of B cells in the transferred cell preparations interfered with detection of suppression. Both Lyt 1+2- and Lyt 1-2+ cells were involved in the dex-P-induced suppression; indeed, mixtures of these types of T cells led to the most profound degree of suppression. The suppressive activity of spleen cells from dex-P-injected mice could be removed by passage over dextran-coated plates. Moreover, cells eluted from the plates specifically suppressed anti-dextran responses of normal mice, indicating that dex-P injection induces a population of antigen-binding suppressor cells. This system will allow the study of the suppressor-T-cell receptors in a well-defined idiotypic system.

Induction and suppression of contact sensitivity to fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)

Although both fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) and trinitrophenyl (TNP) covalently couple primarily to the epsilon-amino group of lysine residues of surface glycoprotein, FITC is structurally different from TNP. In this paper, we investigated the immune regulatory mechanisms in contact sensitivity (CS) to FITC by the administration of FITC and FITC-conjugated epidermal cells (FITC-EC) via various routes. Mice injected with FITC via i.p. or i.v. route did not induce CS but induced hyporesponsiveness to the following sensitization with FITC painting. Mice injected with FITC via s.c. route induced neither CS nor hyporesponsiveness to the following FITC painting. Administration of FITC via i.v. route was demonstrated to induce hapten-specific suppressor T cells. Inoculation of FITC-EC via s.c. or i.p. route induced CS, whereas injection of FITC-EC via i.v. route did not induce CS but induced hyporesponsiveness to the following FITC painting. The results are compared with the previous data obtained by trinitrobenzene sulfonate and trinitrophenyl-conjugated epidermal cells.

Role of antigen-presenting cells in the development and persistence of contact hypersensitivity

Three outcomes pertinent to contact sensitivity (CS) follow immunization with various forms of trinitrophenylated (TNP) substrates: (a) specific immunological unresponsiveness for CS is induced when immunization favors activation of splenic suppressor cells. This state is achieved by intravenous injection of trinitrophenyl-conjugated to various types of cells, such as peritoneal exudate cells (PEC). (b) A short-lived or evanescent form of CS is induced when immunization reduces activation of the suppressor circuit. This can be achieved by subcutaneous immunization with trinitrophenyl conjugated to syngeneic PEC, by pretreatment with cyclophosphamide to diminish suppression before intravenous immunization, or by altering the mode of antigen presentation by using TNP-substrate that has undergone phagocytosis. (c) A long-lived form of CS is induced when trinitrophenyl is presented to the immune system on skin cells either by contact skin painting with reactive trinitrophenyl, or by subcutaneous, or even intravenous injection of trinitrophenyl-conjugated epidermal cells. In fact, trinitrophenyl-conjugated epidermal cells induced CS even when the suppressor circuit was activated by intravenous coadministration of TNP-PEC. This implies that antigen presentation on epidermal cells induces sensitized cells that are relatively resistant to suppression. The cell type(s) in the skin that are primarily responsible for this potent form of antigen presentation are most likely Langerhans cells, because they can be concentrated by virtue of their Fc receptors and they are Ia positive. Thus, both the anatomical site where antigen is first encountered by the immune apparatus, as well as the nature of the cells which present the antigen, determine whether a CS response will ensue, as well as whether it will be evanescent or long-lasting.

Induction of suppressor cells and cells producing antigen-specific suppressor factors by haptens bound to self carriers

Injection of TNP-, DNP- or oxazolone-substituted syngeneic cells into mice causes the development of hapten-specific T suppressor cells which prevent the animals from being activity sensitized with homologous hapten. These cells injected together with immunized cells abrogate the latter's ability to transfer passively the contact sensitivity (CS) reaction into normal recipients. T lymphocytes from animals made unresponsive and sensitized with homologous hapten synthesize in vitro antigen-specific suppressor factors (SF) which when incubated with immune lymphocytes prevent them transferring adoptively the CS reaction. The type of cell used to induce suppression or production of suppressor factor (haptenated erythrocytes, thymocytes or macrophages) is not critical suggesting that a hapten-substituted common membrane structure is recognized as a tolerogen. The present work demonstrates that while the specific unresponsiveness induced by cell-bound hapten in vivo is long lasting, cells from tolerized animals are able to suppress the immunized cells in passive transfer or produce in vitro antigen-specific suppressor factors only when tested several days after tolerization.