Genetic control of the immune response to the terpolymer L-glutamic acid(60)-L-alanine(30)-L-tyrosine(10)(GAT). II. Characterization of a cross-reactive idiotype associated with anti-GAT antibodies from responder and nonresponder mice

Involvement of histamine or tumor necrosis factor in early-type hypersensitivity

A novel early-type hypersensitivity (ETH) reaction, manifested as capillary congestion, increase of vasopermeability, and plasma protein leakage, can be induced within 1 h after challenge of antigen-sensitized mice. The mediators involved in ETH varied among different strains of mice. The poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT)-induced ETH in BALB/c mice was blocked by diphenhydramine (histamine H1 antagonist) and ketanserine (serotonin antagonist), but not by cimetidine (histamine H2 antagonist). These results indicate that both histamine and serotonin are involved, and that the histamine effect is mediated through a H1 receptor. Meanwhile, GAT-induced ETH in B6 mice was inhibited by anti-TNF alpha antibody suggesting that TNF alpha is involved. The mice can be classified into either histamine or TNF alpha type based on the pattern of mediator involved in ETH. A/J and CBA strains as well as BALB/c mice were classified as histamine type while A. TL, B10.BR, and C3H/He in addition to B6 mice were TNF alpha type. The observation that GAT-induced ETH in (BALB/c x B6)F1 mice was inhibited by both diphenhydramine and anti-TNF alpha suggests that the mediation of the actions of histamine or TNF alpha by GAT was genetically controlled and inherited as the dominant trait in (BALB/c x B6)F1 mice. ETH could be passively transferred by heat (56 degrees C, 4 h)-treated anti-GAT sera. Sera derived from the histamine type transferred ETH across the type barrier and histamine was the mediator, irrespective of the type of the recipient. However, sera derived from TNF alpha type only transferred ETH to the mice of the same TNF alpha type and TNF alpha was the mediator.

The T-cell independent antigen, NP-ficoll, primes for a high affinity IgM anti-NP response

In a number of different strains of inbred mice, immunization with a hapten coupled to a protein carrier results in production of homogeneous serum antibodies. At the genetic level this corresponds to the use of a very limited set of variable region genes in the actively secreting B-cells. In contrast, immunization with the same hapten coupled to a T-cell independent (TI) carrier produces a heterogeneous antibody response. Here we show that successive immunizations of C57BL/6 mice, first with the hapten NP coupled to ficoll, a TI carrier, and then one month later with a subliminal dose of the same hapten coupled to a protein carrier, generate a novel set of hybridomas. These hybridomas produce antibodies which are of the IgM isotope and which lack somatic mutation. Some of these antibodies have a much higher affinity for NP than do antibodies which use the prototypical gene combination (VH186.2-lamda 1) of the strain specific response in C57BL/6 mice.

Murine transfer factor. IV. Studies with genetically regulated immune responses

Transfer factor-containing dialysates from mice that were either high or low responders to GAT10, GLA5, or ovalbumin were assayed for their ability to transfer delayed hypersensitivity to murine recipients of either high or low responder phenotype. Dialysates from high responder strains contained transfer factor that would transfer delayed hypersensitivity to both high and low responder recipients. These transfers were not restricted by disparities at the MHC or Igh loci. Identically prepared materials from low responder donors contained little or no transfer factor activity and would not transfer delayed hypersensitivity to either high or low responder recipients. Thus, administration of transfer factor transfers the high responder phenotype to low responder recipients. The data also suggest that production of transfer factor is regulated by Ir genes but that the immunologic activities of transfer factor are not.

Two BALB/c anti-arsonate idiotype families: two heavy chain variable regions (Vh) shared with anti-DNP antibodies are used by one family while a Vh similar to anti-GAT antibodies is used by the other

Amino terminal amino acid sequences were obtained for both the heavy (H) and light (L) chains of seven BALB/c anti-arsonate (Ar) monoclonal antibodies representing the 5AF6 and 3C6 idiotype (id) families described in this strain. 5AF6 family H chains showed strong homology to the germ-line gene sequence for the A strain 36-60 family. However, four to five identical H chain sequence differences for two of these antibodies (5AF6 and 95B5), as well as two previously reported related sequences (92D5, 94B10), suggested they were encoded by a different Vh. The 36-60 family Vh genes have been shown to be identical to the Vh gene of the anti-DNP binding myeloma M460 [Dzierzak et al., J. Immun. 136, 1864-1870 (1986)]. H chains amino acid sequences derived from an id-460+ anti-DNP hybridoma and a germ-line gene differing from the 30-60-like Vh sequence [Dzierzak et al., J. Immun. 136, 1864-1870 (1986)] were found to be virtually identical to the 95B5 and 5AF6 Vh sequences. This suggests that the same two related H chains making up two subsets of the 5AF6 anti-Ar id family are also both used in two subsets of the id-460 anti-DNP response. 5AF6 family L chains were highly homologous to the other Vk2 L chains of the 36-60 family. 3C6 family H chains can be placed in the Vh l group, are unrelated to the described anti-Ar H chain families, and have been placed in a new anti-Ar Vh family, Ars-E. The 3C6 H is similar, however, to a Vh used by a BALB/c anti-GAT idiotype family of antibodies. 3C6 L chains were of the murine kappa chain group, Vk8 and most resembled an L chain from an A strain monoclonal anti-Ar having no defined idiotype.

Genetic basis for expression of the idiotypic network. One unique Ig VH germline gene accounts for the major family of Ab1 and Ab3 (Ab1') antibodies of the GAT system

Ig germline genes have been isolated from recombinant clones prepared in separate libraries constructed from adult BALB/c liver DNA either in pBR328 plasmid or in EMBL 3 phage. Three clones that gave a very strong positive hybridization signal with a VH anti-GAT-specific probe were completely characterized and sequenced. All three were greater than 95% homologous, with the exception of the 5' noncoding region, which was only 85% homologous but contained characteristic regulatory signals. One of these genes, H10, had a sequence that was completely identical to that of a cDNA derived from a GAT-specific BALB/c hybridoma. Southern blot analysis using Eco RI-digested DNA from rearranged GAT-specific hybridomas revealed that the same gene was used for other GAT-specific VH regions, including one differing from the H10 sequence by 12 nucleotides, which must have been generated by a somatic mechanism. The same H10 germline gene was also used, in most cases without any nucleotide substitution, in hybridomas of the Ab1' set of the GAT idiotypic cascade, suggesting that immunization with Ab2 (antiidiotypic) antibodies preferentially stimulates the direct expression of VH germline genes. Finally, the previous hypothesis that NPa and GAT VH genes were derived from the same germline gene was definitively confirmed, both from sequence data and Southern blot analysis.

The T-cell-independent immune response to the hapten NP uses a large repertoire of heavy chain genes

Hybridomas generated from C57BL/6 mice immunized with the hapten NP coupled to ficoll, a T-cell-independent carrier, produce monoclonal antibodies that use a large repertoire of VH regions and light chains. This contrasts with the homogeneity of the strain-specific response to NP observed with T-cell-dependent carriers, where most of the antibodies use a single VH region, V186.2, in combination with the lambda-1 light chain. There is no evidence for somatic mutation in any of the sequenced regions of the antibodies generated by NP-ficoll. Thus T cell participation is required for the homogeneity of the strain-specific hapten response, and probably for somatic mutation as well.

Gene repertoire of the anti-poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) immune response: comparison of VH, V kappa, and D regions used by anti-GAT antibodies and monoclonal antibodies produced after anti-idiotypic immunization

Eight monoclonal antibodies were selected from BALB/c mice immunized with two different monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies recognizing two discrete idiotopes characteristic of the anti-poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) antibody response. These monoclonal antibodies were previously classified as Ab1 (anti-GAT-like) and Ab3 (anti-anti-idiotype) on the basis of expression of the public idiotypic specificity (p.GAT) studied with a xenogeneic serum, anti-GAT activity, and expression of various public idiotopes. All the heavy chain variable region (VH) sequences from Ab1 are nearly identical to the VH sequences of Ab1 anti-GAT monoclonal antibodies. The same type of results has been found with the Ab1 kappa light chain variable region (V kappa) sequences. Confirming our classification, Ab3 VH and V kappa sequences were found to be completely different from Ab1 VH and V kappa sequences. The Ab1 diversity (D) regions are different from one another and different from the D regions found on monoclonal anti-GAT antibodies but function similarly. These D regions are not simply derived from already described D genes. Finally, our results suggest that in the anti-GAT response VH and V kappa sequence are mainly responsible for idiotype expression.

Immune response against poly(Glu60,Ala30,Tyr10) (GAT): immunization with monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies leads to the predominant stimulation of idiotypically similar immunoglobulins with anti-GAT activity

Two monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (HP-Id20 and HP-Id22) recognizing two different public idiotopes expressed in the anti-poly(Glu60,Ala30,Tyr10) (GAT) response were used to immunize BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice. From these animals hybridomas were isolated. From BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice eight and seven monoclonal antibodies were characterized, respectively. The reagents were classified according to the expression of the public idiotypic specificity p.GAT (recognized by a rabbit antiserum). The anti-GAT activity and the expression of the various idiotopes characterized on anti-GAT polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies were also studied. Most of the reagents are Ab1'-type of antibody resembling anti-GAT antibodies. One anti-anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody (Ab3) was also isolated from BALB/c mice. This suggests that in this experimental model the repertoire induced after HP-Id immunization and antigen stimulation is comparable. The idiotypic analysis of a large number of anti-GAT and of Ab1' monoclonal antibodies suggests that only two public idiotopes are involved in the anti-GAT response.

Induction by monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies of an anti-poly(Glu60 Ala30 Tyr10) (GAT) immune response in GAT-responder and GAT-nonresponder mice

Two different monoclonal anti-idiotypic (Id) antibodies, HP-Id20 and HP-Id22, recognizing two discrete idiotopes characteristic of the anti-poly(Glu60 Ala30 Tyr10) (GAT) response were used to immunize BALB/c (GAT-responder) and DBA/1 (GAT-nonresponder) mice. The monoclonals were injected either copolymerized with keyhole limpet haemocyanin or polymerized with glutaraldehyde. The specific response was studied by two assays: (a) inhibition of binding of monoclonal anti-GAT antibody G5Bb2-2 to HP-Id20 and HP-Id22 and (b) GAT binding assays. In BALB/c GAT-responder mice, HP-Id20 and HP-Id22 immunization led to the preferential stimulation of immunoglobulin idiotypically related to anti-GAT antibodies (Ab1') and expressing anti-GAT activity. The results obtained with BALB/c nu/nu mice indicated that this response is T-cell-dependent. By means of the same experimental protocol GAT-nonresponder animals could be induced to produce anti-GAT antibodies after HP-Id immunization. This last result indicates that anti-Id immunization can bypass Ir gene control and does not preferentially stimulate the induction of GAT-specific T suppressor cells.

Poly(Glu60,Ala30,Tyr10) (GAT)-specific T cells do not express B cell public idiotopes but can be primed by monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies

Eight monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies directed against public idiotopes have been further characterized: (a) they bind to public idiotopes with a high affinity; (b) they recognize all anti-poly(Glu60,Ala30,Tyr10) (GAT) antibodies as measured by inhibition of the anti-GAT plaque-forming cell response. This has been verified in three strains of mice. These reagents were not able to detect idiotope expression on eight GAT-specific helper T cell lines and clones. This result was obtained by two techniques: (a) idiotope expression at the T cell surface was measured by indirect immunofluorescence using a cell sorter with surface antigens H-2D, Thy-1.2, Lyt-1 and L3T4 as positive controls; (b) after immunoadsorption of [35S] methionine-labeled cellular extracts from two lines, no unique molecule was retained by the HP-idp22 monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody coupled to Sepharose. Despite these negative results, this antibody was found to prime lymph node cells in vivo, which were able to proliferate specifically in response to GAT. Two T cell lines derived from this lymphocyte population do not express any of the idiotopes tested. These results suggest that monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies may be influencing T lymphocyte activity indirectly.

Idiotype restriction in human autoantibodies to DNA in systemic lupus erythematosus

Antibodies (Ab) to double stranded DNA (dsDNA) were immunoaffinity-purified from the serum of patient TOF with active systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Anti-idiotypic Ab to TOF anti-DNA were raised in rabbit. They were shown to recognize TOF F(ab')2 fragments, but they did not interact with human Ab of other specificities or with TOF IgG depleted of anti-DNA activity. In addition, their binding to TOF idiotype was specifically inhibited by DNA molecules. These anti-idiotype Ab therefore recognized idiotopes associated with a variable region of TOF anti-DNA-combining site. Thirty-one purified IgG anti-DNA preparations from unrelated SLE sera were able to inhibit this idiotype-anti-idiotype reaction by up to 90%. However, there was no linear correlation between anti-dsDNA Ab levels and idiotype-blocking capacity. These findings suggest that, in SLE, the idiotypic repertoire of autoAb to dsDNA is more restricted than thought previously.

Public and individual idiotopes in the anti-poly(Glu60, Ala30, Tyr10) response: analysis by monoclonal antibodies

From BALB/c mice immunized with anti-GAT monoclonal antibody (mAb) G5, we have obtained anti-idiotypic mAb against individual (or private) idiotopes, expressed by G5 as well as anti-GAT mAb, that are heteroclitic because they recognize poly-(Glu50, Tyr50) (GT) better than poly(Glu60, Ala30, Tyr10) (GAT). From BALB/c mice immunized with BALB/c polyclonal anti-GAT antibodies, anti-idiotypic mAb directed against public idiotopes expressed following GAT immunization in all individuals of all mouse strains tested have been obtained. Nine anti-idiotypic mAb were studied in detail. One of these mAb recognizes only polyclonal anti-GAT antibodies; the other eight recognize polyclonal anti-GAT antibodies and anti-GAT mAb. The distribution of the structures recognized by the different anti-idiotypic mAb on a battery of 20 anti-GAT mAb allows definition of two families of public idiotopes.

V kappa gene family in (Glu60 Ala30 Tyr10)n (GAT)-specific antibodies that express CGAT (or pGAT) public idiotypic specificities. Protein and mRNA sequencing of eight monoclonal V kappa chains

A large proportion of (Glu60 Ala30 Tyr10)n (GAT)-specific antibodies expresses public idiotypic specificities, termed CGAT (or pGAT), that require the presence of both the heavy and the light chains in order to be expressed. We report in this paper the complete sequence of eight V kappa regions pertaining to eight anti-GAT monoclonal antibodies derived from three strains of mice: BALB/c, DBA/2, and C57BL/6. The methodology used a combination of NH2-terminal amino acid and mRNA nucleotide sequencing. All eight sequences analyzed, although highly homologous and all pertaining to the same V kappa 1 subgroup, allowed definition of three germline genes that are likely to be present in all three strains of mice and also in NZB. It seems likely, however, that any given strain may not necessarily use all three genes for making anti-GAT antibodies. The search for structural correlates of idiotypes could not be framed in a simple picture, but our data suggest that similar idiotopes may result from different interacting primary structures, leading to structural homologies that should be visualized at three-dimensional level.

Primary response to GAT in F344 rats: anti-GAT antibodies, nonspecific immunoglobulins, and expression of the GAT-13 idiotype

It has been reported that antigen induces differentiation of two populations of Ig-containing cells: the first one to appear, IgCC, synthesizes nonspecific Ig and the second, AbCC, synthesizes antibodies. Along with other arguments, the observation that nonspecific Ig bear idiotypic determinants, which cross-react with those of antibodies, had led to the hypothesis that IgCC are precursors of AbCC. However, the synthesis of such idiotype-positive nonspecific Ig before the appearance of the antibodies has not yet been proven. This problem was investigated by analyzing the primary response to poly(Glu60-Ala30-Tyr10) (GAT) in F344 rats. Kinetics studies of cells synthesizing Ig expressing a major idiotype (GAT-13), and of cells synthesizing Ig not expressing GAT-13 idiotype, revealed that these two cell populations were undetectable before the appearance of the anti-GAT antibodies. This demonstrates that IgCC differentiation is not a necessary condition for the development of all antibody responses.

Structural bases for public idiotypic specificities of monoclonal antibodies directed against poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) and poly(Glu60Ala40) random copolymers

NH2-terminal amino acid sequences of heavy and light chains of seven poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) specific hybridoma products derived from DBA/2 and (DBA/2 X BALB/c)F1 hybrid mice and those of BALB/B polyclonal antibodies have been determined over the first 40 residues. Comparison of these sequences with those of nine other GAT or poly(Glu60Ala40) (GA) specific hybridoma products previously reported allowed the following conclusions. (i) Sequences of hybridoma H and L chains are present in the pool of polyclonal antibodies. (ii) The public CGAT (or pGAT) idiotypic specificities are strictly confined to antibodies exhibiting limited heterogeneity with regard to both the variable heavy (VH) and the variable kappa (V kappa) sequences that may be accounted for by one and two germ-line genes, respectively. (iii) The public idiotypic specificities GA-1, expressed by some anti-GAT and most anti-GA antibodies, make use of the same (or similar) VH germ-line genes as the CGAT or pGAT antibodies but possess a distinctive V kappa sequence. (iv) Antibodies expressing neither of the alternative public specificities mentioned above appear to be more heterogeneous and express VH and V kappa sequences that were found to differ from the basic structures defining the CGAT (pGAT) or GA-1 correlates. It is concluded that CGAT (or pGAT) and GA-1 public idiotypic specificities are germ-line markers of both VH and V kappa regions, an observation in agreement with previously reported serological data.

Idiotype expression and fine specificity of Glu60Ala30Tyr10-specific T proliferating cells

The fine specificity of anti-Glu60Ala30Tyr10 (GAT) and anti-Glu60Ala40 (GA) proliferating cells was studied. T cells primed with GAT proliferate both to GAT and GA and GA-primed T cells proliferate also to GA and GAT. This cross-reactivity was unexpected given the results previously reported on the fine specificity of anti-GAT antibodies. The effect on the proliferation of BALB/c lymph node cells (LNC) of a syngeneic anti-idiotypic serum, prepared in BALB/c against anti-GAT antibodies, was studied. Two major points are made in this paper: (i) the in vitro addition of the anti-idiotypic serum in cultures containing GAT-primed LNC and GAT enhances the proliferation of GAT-specific T cells; (ii) the anti-idiotypic serum is effective in priming in vivo LNC which then acquire the capacity to proliferate specifically with GAT in vitro. These results further confirm the existence of idiotype-like determinants on T cells.

Analysis of a major rat idiotype associated with Anti-GAT antibodies

An anti-idiotypic antiserum was raised in a rabbit against a pool of purified F.344 rat anti-GAT antibodies. GAT-13, the idiotype defined by this serum, is present in all F.344 anti-GAT sera from primary and secondary anti-GAT responses. Anti-GAT sera of 13 inbred rat strains, with different RT1 haplotypes and with different heavy- and light-chain allotypes, all express idiotypic determinants cross-reacting with GAT-13. Thus, like in mice anti-GAT antibodies from rats express public idiotypic determinants. The anti-idiotypic serum also recognizes a highly conserved idiotypic specificity present on mouse and guinea-pig anti-GAT antibodies. The mouse, rat and guinea-pig express a similar highly conserved idiotypic specificity after immunization with GAT. All anti-GAT antibodies from the mouse and guinea-pig bear this idiotypic specificity. These results confirm the existence in the anti-GAT response of interspecies cross-reactive idiotypic determinants.

Monoclonal anti-GAT antibodies with different fine specificities express the same public idiotype

We have studied the idiotypic specificities expressed by 22 anti-GAT hybridoma products (HP). These antibodies, although derived from cells of mice with three distinct heavy-chain linkage groups (BALB/c, Igh-1a, DBA/2, Igh-1c and C57BL/6, Igh-1b) all express the same public idiotypic specificity, p. GAT, defined by the heterologous binding of anti-idiotypic serum 715 to C57BL/6 anti-GAT antibodies. None of these antibodies expressed the strain-restricted idiotypic specificity, s.r. GAT-1, defined by the binding of anti-idiotypic serum JL 122 to BALB/c anti-GAT antibodies. BALB/c anti-GAT HP could be shown to fall into three subsets with respect to their fine antigenic specificity for GAT, GT and GA. An individual idiotypic specificity, i1-GAT (defined by syngeneic anti-idiotypic sera raised against one of the BALB/c HP), was also found on a group of BALB/c HP which all shared a similar fine antigenic specificity pattern. Taken together, these observations suggest that the expressed mouse anti-GAT repertoire derives from a very few V-germ-line genes (VH-GAT and VK-GAT) which are highly conserved in the species, and which determine the structure resulting in the p. GAT idiotypic specificity. The variations in fine specificity and individual idiotype are likely therefore to reflect somatic variations affecting these germ-line genes.

An immunoglobulin V gene polymorphism in the rat

Anti-phenyloxazolone (phOx) antibodies of different AVN rats (primary response) share several isoelectric focusing bands. These bands were not shared by antibodies of some other rat strains, including DA. An anti-idiotype reagent was prepared (in rabbits) that bound radioactive anti-phOx antibodies of AVN rats but not normal AVN immunoglobulin. This binding was strongly inhibited by AVN anti-phOx antisera, but not by AVN anti-BOC-p-azobenzene arsonate-tyrosine antisera or DA anti-phOx antisera. Anti-phOx antisera of (AVN X DA)F1 rats were also strongly inhibitory indicating the presence of the idiotype (Ox-r1). Antisera of backcross rats (AVN X DA) X DA either resembled F1 hybrid sera (31 rats) or DA sera (23 rats). The data suggest that the presence of idiotype Ox-r1 is controlled by one gene, or genes linked to each other. The gene(s) is not linked to the Ig kappa chain locus. It may be a V gene of the Ig H chain.

Genetic control of the immune response to the L-Glu60-L-Ala30-L-Tyr10 (GAT) terpolymer. V. Three types of idiotypic specificities on BALB/c anti-GAT antibodies

Three types of idiotypic specificities compose the major idiotype of anti-poly (L-Glu60-L-Ala30-L-Tyr10) (GAT) antibodies from BALB/c mice (idiotype termed GAT-715). Assays have been designed to analyzed and study the distribution of these specificities. The highly conserved idiotypic specificity (h.c.GAT) has been assayed by the binding of serum 715-7A4 to radiolabeled rat anti-GAT antibodies. Guinea pig and mouse anti-GAT antisera all express the same h.c.GAT specificity. The public specificity (p.GAT) has been shown to be present in an identical form in all anti-GAT antisera from all strains of mice studied. The assay used for p.GAT was the binding of serum 715-7A4 to C57BL/6 anti-GAT antibodies that express only p.GAT. Finally, the strain-restricted specificity s.r.GAT has also been investigated by radioimmunoassay; this specificity is expressed only by strains BALB/c, BALB/b, BUB/J, DBA/2, DBA/1 and ATL. This expression is independent of known allotypic markers. However, the expression of the s.r.GAT specificity of BALB/c mice follows the genetic distribution of VH genes of BALB/c origin indicating that s.r.GAT can be considered as a genetic marker of some VH gene(s) involved in the specific immune response to the GAT terpolymer.

Genetic control of the immune response to the terpolymer L-glutamic acid 60-L-alanine 30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT). III. Restricted heterogeneity of the anti-GAT response from BALB/c responder mice

The heterogeneity of the anti-GAT [terpolymer poly(Glu60, Ala30, Tyr10)] response of GAT responder mice has been analyzed. Purified anti-GAT antibodies from BALB/c mice belong only to the gamma 1 kappa subclass. The isoelectric focusing pattern obtained indicates that the anti-GAT antibodies are particularly basic and restricted. These results have been confirmed by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; by this technique, we have shown that the gamma 1 chain and the corresponding kappa chain of anti-GAT antibodies are restricted. All the anti-GAT antibodies from 10 BALB/c mice bear the cross-reactive GAT idiotype previously defined (J. Thèze and G. Sommé, Eur. J. Immunol. 1979, 9: 924). The present results indicate that the anti-GAT repertoire expressed in BALB/c mice is very limited.