Idiotype regulation: evidence for the involvement of Igh-C-restricted T cells in the M-460 idiotype suppressive pathway

Affinity columns containing anti-DNA Id+ human myeloma proteins adsorb human epibodies from intravenous gamma globulin

OBJECTIVE

To study eluates of intravenous gamma globulin (IVGG) prepared from affinity columns of human cationic IgG myeloma proteins bearing anti-DNA idiotype (Id) markers 16/6, F4, 3I, and 8.12 for possible anti-Id (combining site) blocking activity.

METHODS

Anti-DNA idiotypic antibody activity was studied in 3 preparations of IVGG containing high, medium, and low levels of IgG anti-F(ab')2, and in 4 other commercial IVGG preparations. Affinity-purified IgG anti-DNA (APAD) from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients was biotinylated, and binding to DNA coated on enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay plates was used to measure anti-DNA antibody activity. IVGG was adsorbed to Sepharose 4B affinity columns linked to a panel of cationic human IgG myeloma proteins positive for anti-DNA Id markers 16/6, F4, 3I, and 8.12. Material adsorbing to such columns was eluted at low pH (2.5) and after neutralization, tested for its ability to inhibit biotinylated APAD reacting with DNA.

RESULTS

Only 0.05-0.9% of IVGGs bound firmly to Id affinity columns. These IVGGs were then eluted, using pH 2.5 glycine-saline and eluates neutralized to pH 7.4. Column flowthrough and eluate fractions were compared for their ability to block SLE APAD reacting with DNA. Significant inhibition of SLE APAD combining sites was observed with eluates from anti-DNA Id affinity columns; however, no correlation between IVGG anti-F(ab')2 activity and true anti-Id blocking of APAD was apparent. No residual anti-Id activity remained in column flowthrough fractions. No anti-Id blocking activity was recorded for IVGG eluates from human cationic myeloma columns devoid of the 4 anti-DNA Id markers. DNase treatment of IVGG or Id column eluates did not affect anti-Id blocking activity. Thus, all detectable anti-DNA idiotypic antibody capable of blocking SLE anti-DNA combining sites bound to Id+ affinity columns. Column eluates also showed some relative concentration of IgG anti-DNA activity, which was of lower affinity for DNA than antibodies also present in eluates which blocked anti-DNA combining sites.

CONCLUSION

The presence of both anti-DNA and antiidiotypic (anti-combining site) activity in human anti-DNA Id column eluates indicates that epibodies from IVGG are relatively concentrated when this strategy is used. This approach may lead to a new strategy for treatment of SLE nephritis.

The frequency of LPS-responsive B cells to autologous and heterologous thyroglobulin

The frequency of precursors within the mouse splenic B cell pool, reactive with mouse thyroglobulin (mTg) was estimated using a limiting dilution assay system. The mean frequency was found to be 1/3900 B cells. The results provide a minimal estimate of the frequency of mTg-reactive B cells. The frequency of mTg-reactive B cells was not influenced by the MHC locus, as both high- and low-responder strains showed similar frequencies. While the frequency of B cells reactive to human Tg was found to be similar to that reactive to mTg, only 20% of the mTg-reactive clones also cross-react with human Tg. Similarly, only 30% of huTg reactive clones were found to react with mTg. Therefore, a large proportion of Tg-reactive antibodies are restricted to self-determinants and not determinants to conserved regions of the Tg molecule.

Antigen-specific augmentation factor involved in murine delayed-type footpad reaction. III. Genetic restriction of delayed hypersensitivity augmentation factor (DAF)

We found an antigen-specific factor capable of augmenting delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) in the culture supernatant of the mixture of immune T cells and specific antigen, or in the serum of mice immunized with xenogeneic erythrocytes and elicited for DTH footpad reaction. Previous experiments on the genetic restriction of this factor (DTH-augmentation factor; DAF) indicated that DAF activity was effective across the MHC-barrier in C3H/He (H-2k)--BALB/c (H-2d) system. The genetic restriction between DAF and its acceptor cells was then investigated precisely using Igh (immunoglobulin heavy chain locus)-congeneic mice: 1) Expression of DAF activity was MHC-nonrestricted, 2) but was restricted by the Igh-linked gene on the 12th chromosome, 3) such Igh-linked gene restriction was also demonstrated by an absorption test with normal spleen cells. The acceptor cells for DAF were Thy-1+,L3T4+,Lyt-2- T cells.

Production of auto-anti-idiotypic antibody during the normal immune response. IX. Characteristics of the auto-anti-idiotype antibody and its production

Using hapten-reversible inhibition of plaque formation as an assay for auto-anti-idiotype antibody (anti-Id) and as a means for following idiotype (Id) expression, we have obtained evidence that following immunization with trinitrophenyl (TNP) conjugates (a) there are differences in Id expression in the anti-TNP antibody response to different TNP conjugates although there is some overlap; (b) different strains, although showing some differences in Id expression, tend to produce cross-reactive Ids, thus no obvious allotype linked inheritance of Id expression is observed in this heterogeneous immune response; (c) the auto-anti-Id produced following immunization with TNP-Brucella abortus or TNP-Ficoll tends to be of the IgG2a and IgG2b isotypes.

Genetic control of the murine IgM plaque-forming cell response to type III pneumococcal polysaccharide

The direct 5-day plaque-forming cell response of different inbred mouse strains to pneumococcal polysaccharide type III (SSS-III) varied from more than 10,000 per spleen, in BALB/c mice, to less than 2000 in C57BL mice. Responses of Igh congenic and recombinant inbred lines bearing different combinations of BALB/c and C57BL genes indicate that two or more gene loci are involved in controlling high or low responses. At least one is in the Igh-V region since BALB/c, BAB-14, and CB-8 KN mice (Igh-Va) had two to four times higher responses than CB-20 and CB-16 KN mice (Igh-Vb). Other gene loci must be involved, but nothing can be said about them at present.

Tolerance for self IG at the level of the Ly1+ T cell

Experiments presented in this report demonstrate that specificity of the Ly1+ T cell proliferative response to NP-modified Ig is controlled by Igh-C-linked genes. In addition, we describe the mechanism whereby Igh-C-encoded molecules influence Ly1+ T cell activity. We show that Igh-C-linked control of T cell responses to NP-modified Ig is a secondary consequence of naturally acquired tolerance for self Ig. Unresponsiveness to self Ig is not due to a defect expressed functionally at the level of the antigen-presenting cell, nor is it associated with active suppression. These results suggest that tolerance for self Ig at the level of the Ly1+ T cell is due to functional deletion of Ly1+ T cell clones specific for self Ig. The possibility is considered that regulatory effects mediated by passively administered antibodies may in part be due to induction of Ly1+ T cell tolerance for self Ig.

Induction of a cross-reactive idiotype dextran-positive antibody response in two IgH-Cb mouse strains treated with anti-J558 cross-reactive idiotype antibodies

The effect of IdX-specific rabbit and allogeneic antiidiotype antibodies (Ab2) was investigated in vivo in Igh-Cb mouse strains with respect to the induction of a cross-reactive idiotype (IdX)-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dextran (Dex) response. These C.B20 and C57Bl/6 mice have an allotype-linked incapacity to respond with IdX-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies upon conventional immunization with Dex B1355. 7 d after the rabbit Ab2 injections, IdX-positive Ig (Ab3) and IdX-positive anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies (Ab1') were detected in the sera of each tested mouse. The affinity-purified Ab1' were idiotypically indistinguishable from reference BALB/c IdX-positive myeloma proteins and BALB/c anti-alpha (1-3) Dex antibodies (Ab1) in a competitive inhibition radioimmunoassay, while Ab3 Ig appeared idiotypically deficient and did not bind to Dex. The response to the alpha (1-6) linkage of Dex was not affected in these mice. A large fraction of the Ab1' and Ab3 responses of both mouse strains were of the IgG1 class. The Ab1' antibodies differed from BALB/c Ab1 by lower relative binding to five of eight tested Dex, and by expressing the Igh4b allotype determinants on the IgG1 antibodies. This study identifies the products of a VHDex gene that appears to be under regulatory control in the Ighb mice. Its association with the b haplotype suggests that this gene may differ structurally from the BALB/c VHDex gene.

Antiidiotypes against anti-H-2 monoclonal antibodies. V. In vivo antiidiotype treatment induces idiotype-specific helper T cells

Mice have been treated in vivo with xenogeneic antiidiotypes prepared against a murine monoclonal anti-H-2Kk antibody, 11-4.1. B cell immune responses have been found to be altered by such treatment as evidenced by a modification in the idiotypic repertoire of the humoral response to H-2 antigens. Transfer of purified T cells into nude mice before anti-idiotype treatment showed that T cells are involved in the induction of idiotope-bearing antibodies by xenogeneic antiidiotype. Studies using bone marrow chimeras indicate that the environment in which either T or B cells mature does not appear to alter VH region genetic control of induction of antiidiotype-induced molecules. By adoptive transfer studies, T cells from antiidiotype-treated mice were found capable of modifying the idiotypic repertoire of B cells subsequently exposed to antigen even when the T cells were obtained from antiidiotype-primed mice of inappropriate allotype. Although it still must be determined whether idiotypic or antiidiotypic T cells are involved in such B cell idiotype regulation, these results indicate that some T cell functions are altered by xenogeneic antiidiotypes prepared against B cell products and suggest that T cell immunity to major histocompatibility complex antigens may also be affected by such reagents.

The selection and maintenance of the V region determinant repertoire is germ-line encoded and T cell-independent

The number of lipopolysaccharide-sensitive precursor cells synthesizing immunoglobulin (Ig) which reacts with the monoclonal anti-M460 antibody F6(51) has been determined in the spleen and in the bone marrow of different strains of mice. These precursor frequencies fall into two quantitatively different groups. The first group includes mice with the same Igh haplotype as BALB/c animals (Igha). In this group, spleen cells contained between 1:10(4) to 1:5 X 10(4) B cell precursors secreting Ig which bound F6(51). The second level of precursor was obtained with animals with allotypic haplotypes other than Igha. These values were too low to allow accurate frequency determinations. The frequency of these cells in mice of the latter group, however, increased dramatically when these animals were hyperimmunized with the monoclonal anti-M460 antibody. Similar results were obtained when the frequencies were determined using the Ig- fraction of bone marrow cells. Surprisingly, the numbers of lipopolysaccharide-sensitive B cell precursors secreting F6(51)-binding Ig in spleen cells of nude mice was found to be similar to the one in splenocytes of normal mice, and even in this case, the frequencies reflected the genetic background of the animals tested. Taken together these data support the notion that the establishment and the maintenance of the M460 idiotypic repertoire is germ-line encoded and independent of regulatory T cells.

The immune response against anti-idiotope antibodies. I. Induction of idiotope-bearing antibodies and analysis of the idiotope repertoire

In the present analysis we dissect the idiotype repertoire, independently of hapten-binding specificity, by immunizing different strains of mice with cross-linked monoclonal anti-idiotope antibodies against antibody B1-8. B1-8 is a monoclonal antibody with specificity for the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitro-phenyl)acetyl (NP) and carries a germ line gene-encoded variable region. The results demonstrate that the expression of B1-8 idiotopes and their association with each other and with NP-binding specificity are strain-specific. Certain idiotopes are expressed on antibodies differing in antigen-binding specificity, whereas one of the idiotopes appears strictly associated with NP-binding antibodies. The genetic analysis provides strong evidence that the strain specificity of the idiotope repertoire is a result of V region polymorphism in the mouse.

Antibody-specific immunoregulation is restricted by the major histocompatibility gene complex

Experiments were carried out to examine the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction of an antibody-specific immunoregulatory function that develops following conventional immunization with hapten-carrier conjugates. It was found that carrier-primed hosts reconstituted with Ly-2.2+ T cells from hapten-carrier-immunized donors were able to suppress adoptively transferred primary B cells. The effective suppression of primary B cell responses was dependent on syngeny between the suppressing T cell population and the target B cells at both MHC and Igh. These findings indicate that T cells that function through the recognition of B cell antibody are restricted in their function by gene products of the MHC, similar to the restrictions observed for the recognition of conventional antigens.