In vivo administration of major histocompatibility complex class I-specific peptides from influenza virus induces specific cytotoxic T cell hyporesponsiveness

Return of inactivated whole-virus vaccine for superior efficacy

The swine, influenza, H1N1 outbreak in 2009 highlighted the inadequacy of the currently used antibody-based vaccine strategies as a preventive measure for combating influenza pandemics. The ultimate goal for successful control of newly arising influenza outbreaks is to design a single-shot vaccine that will provide long-lasting immunity against all strains of influenza A virus. A large amount of data from animal studies has indicated that the cross-reactive cytotoxic T (Tc) cell response against conserved influenza virus epitopes may be the key immune response needed for a universal influenza vaccine. However, decades of research have shown that the development of safe T-cell-based vaccines for influenza is not an easy task. Here, I discuss the overlooked but potentially highly advantageous inactivation method, namely, γ-ray irradiation, as a mean to reach the Holy Grail of influenza vaccinology.

Pharmacokinetic differences between a T cell-tolerizing and a T cell-activating peptide

Vaccination with a peptide representing a CTL epitope from the human papillomavirus (HPV)16 E7 protein induces a specific CTL response that prevents the outgrowth of HPV16 E7-expressing tumors. In contrast, vaccination with a peptide encoding an adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) E1A CTL epitope results in CTL tolerance and enhanced growth of an Ad5 E1A-expressing tumor. It is unclear why these peptides induce such opposite effects. To determine whether a difference in pharmacokinetics can explain the functional contrasts, tritiated Ad5 E1A and HPV16 E7 peptides were injected into mice. Results show that the tolerizing peptide spread through the body 16 times faster than the activating peptide and was cleared at least 2 times faster. The HPV16 E7 peptide kinetics correlated with the kinetics of HPV16 E7-specific CTL induction. In contrast, Ad5 E1A peptide injection resulted in physical deletion of preexisting Ad5 E1A-specific CTLs within 24 h after injection. This tolerization occurred at the time when the peptide reached its maximum peptide concentration in the organs. These data suggest that ubiquitous expression of the tolerizing Ad5 E1A peptide within a short period of time causes activation-induced cell death of Ad5 E1A-specific CTLs. Therefore, information on the pharmacokinetics of peptides is vital for the safety and efficacy of peptide-based vaccines.

Self-veto mechanism of CD8+ cytotoxic effector T cells. Peptide-induced paralysis affects the peptide-MHC-recognizing cytotoxic T lymphocytes and is independent of Fas/Fas ligand interactions

The lytic activity of CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) cell lines or clones can be inhibited by addition of the peptide recognized by these cells. The mechanisms underlying this phenomenon are not fully understood. Here we have analyzed peptide-induced CTL paralysis using in vivo generated ovalbumin (OVA)-specific CTL. Lytic activity of OVA-specific CTL was inhibited by addition of the immunodominant OVA-peptide SIINFEKL in a dose-dependent manner. Paralysis was induced rapidly and binding of the peptide to MHC class I molecules was required. Using mixing experiments with CTL populations of different peptide specificities restricted to the same MHC class I molecule we identified a veto-like mechanism: the cytotoxic activity of the peptide-recognizing CTL was inhibited while the lytic activity of the peptide-presenting CTL was unaltered. Only CD8+ CTL but not CD4+ T cells or B+ cells induced paralysis. After removal of the peptide-presenting CTL by magnetic cell sorting, paralysis was maintained and paralyzed CTL showed no signs of apoptosis. Loss of cytotoxicity could be induced in CTL populations from Fas-deficient (lpr+/lpr+) or Fas ligand-deficient (gld+/gld+) mice and mixtures thereof, implying that Fas/Fas ligand interactions are not involved during induction of paralysis. Hence, peptide-induced paralysis of CTL is due to a self-veto mechanism rather than to mutual killing of CTL. These findings may have implications for in vivo immunization with peptides, viral escape and peripheral tolerance mechanisms.

The generation of memory antigen-specific cytotoxic T cell responses by CD28/CD80 interactions in the absence of antigen

The interaction of co-stimulatory molecules CD80/CD86 on antigen-presenting cells with CD28 on naive CD8+ cytotoxic T (Tc) cells is understood to be critical in the induction of Tc effectors. CD80 is capable of providing signal 2 for the activation of Tc cells, but has no effect if encountered in the absence of specific peptide/MHC complexes (signal 1). We have found that CD80 presented in vitro to resting memory viral-immune or alloimmune Tc cells can provide sufficient stimulus for the generation of effector Tc cells in the absence of specific antigen, the peptide/MHC class I complex. Effector Tc cells generated in vitro from influenza- or class I alloantigen-primed mice by co-stimulation in the absence of antigen require exogenous interleukin (IL)-2 signaling via the cell surface-expressed IL-2 receptor or, under conditions of IL-2 blockade, exogenous IL-7. Activation of memory Tc cells by signal 1 and 2 is independent of IL-2 and IL-7. Although memory influenza-immune Tc cells did respond to CD80 in the absence of antigen, the presence of antigen +CD80 enabled an earlier induction of these Tc cells and they retained their lytic activity in vitro over a longer time period. The capacity of memory Tc cells to be activated by signal 2 alone provides one explanation for the observed heterogeneity of phenotype of memory T cells in vivo and a possible mechanism for the maintenence of memory in the absence of persisting antigen.

Memory alloreactive cytotoxic T cells do not require costimulation for activation in vitro

We have studied the costimulation requirements for the generation of cytotoxic T (Tc) cells in an in vitro recall response to alloantigens. Firstly, we demonstrate that recombinant vaccinia viruses encoding class I MHC can stimulate primary in vivo responses and prime for secondary in vitro responses specific for the immunizing alloantigen. The secondary in vitro response comprises both naive and memory components that are distinguishable kinetically. Naive alloreactive Tc cell precursors are dependent upon the presence of CD80 on the in vitro stimulating population for activation and generation of effector function, as described previously. However, Tc cells from animals primed in vivo with vaccinia virus (VV) encoding allo-MHC do not require CD28-CD80 interactions to respond to the alloantigen presented in vitro. This finding provides further evidence that memory Tc cells have less stringent activation requirements in vitro than naive cells. From limiting dilution analysis of the relative contribution of naive and memory Tc cell precursors in 'primary' responses, to MHC class I alloantigen, memory alloreactive Tc cell precursors, possibly primed by cross-reactive environmental antigens, contribute approximately one-fifth of the precursors. Memory responses exhibit similar precursor frequencies as primary responses. Thus, we conclude that memory is largely a result of qualitative rather than quantitative changes in Tc cell precursors.

Flavivirus-induced up-regulation of MHC class I antigens; implications for the induction of CD8+ T-cell-mediated autoimmunity

Infection of a wide variety of cells of human, mouse and other species' origin by flaviviruses such as WNV, YF, Den, MVE, KUN and JE, increases the cell-surface expression of MHC class I. This MHC class I up-regulation is not due to increased MHC class I synthesis per se, but the result of increased peptide availability in the ER for MHC class I assembly. This is most likely due to the interaction of the viral polyprotein with the ER membrane during viral replication. Flavivirus infection can overcome peptide deficiency in TAP-deficient or non-permissive cell lines such as RMA-S and Syrian hamster cells, BHK and NIL-2. The consequence of this increased MHC class I expression manifests itself in reduced susceptibility to NK cells and augmented lysis by Tc cells. In mice, long-term flavivirus-immune Tc cell memory formation is impaired, following the appearance of strong anti-self Tc cell reactivity observed in in vitro cultures from splenocytes of flavivirus-primed animals. We hypothesize that flavivirus-induced MHC class I up-regulation leads to transient T-cell autoimmunity, followed by down-regulation of both autoimmunity and virus-specific Tc cell memory. Furthermore, we speculate that flavivirus infections of humans in the tropics may be responsible for the observed lower incidence of overt autoimmunity in these geographic regions than in temperate climates where flaviviruses are not endemic.

In vivo induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for a single epitope introduced into an unrelated molecule

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) recognise antigenic peptides in the context of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules on virus-infected cells. The formation and transportation of antigenic peptides to class I MHC in the cells are multi-step reactions known as antigen processing. In order to design a good DNA vaccine, it is important to dissect the specificity of antigen processing. Here we describe the construction of an epitope-based plasmid vector as a device to investigate antigen processing in transfected cells. The epitope-based plasmid vector was constructed by insertion of an epitope-encoding minigene into the lacZ gene. We used a CTL epitope on influenza A virus nucleoprotein (NP366-374 epitope) as a model. Upon transfection, the epitope-based plasmid vector induced the expression of NP epitope antigenically as well as immunogenically. Immunization of mice with plasmid-transfected cells was able to induce NP epitope-specific CTLs in vivo. Moreover, the plasmid vector functioned as a gene vaccine; NP epitope-specific CTLs were primed in vivo upon transfection of the vector into dermis by electroporation. The results suggest that this epitope-based DNA delivery system may provide a new strategy for in vivo induction of epitope-specific CTLs to investigate antigen processing and presentation.

Aspects of cytotoxic T cell memory

Immunological T cell memory manifest itself in an accelerated second-set graft, or allogeneic tumour cell, rejection. Memory viral-immune cytotoxic T cells have shortened kinetics of induction in vivo and differentiate into more potent effector cells in vitro. The requirements for induction of memory T cells are less stringent than for naive T cells. Memory T cells can be activated by antigen (signal 1) or interaction with co-stimulatory molecules (CD28/CD80, signal 2) alone. Memory T cells are phenotypically distinguishable from naive T cells by a number of cell surface markers, but not from activated T cells. Persistence of antigen is not required for the maintenance of long-lived memory. Continuous stimulation by signal 2 alone and or longevity is sufficient to explain life-long persistence of T cell memory. All available data on memory T cells are consistent with a deterministic model of T cell memory formation, following a precise pathway of T cell differentiation.