Bio-inspired, Multifunctional Metal-Thiolate Motif: From Electron Transfer to Sulfur Reactivity and Small-Molecule Activation

Sulfur-rich metalloproteins and metalloenzymes, containing strongly covalent metal-thiolate (cysteinate) or metal-sulfide bonds in their active site, are ubiquitous in nature. The metal-sulfur motif is a highly versatile tool involved in various biological processes: (i) metal storage, transport, and detoxification; (ii) electron transfer; (iii) activation of the sulfur atom to promote different types of S-based reactions including S-alkylation, S-oxygenation, S-nitrosylation, or disulfide or thiyl radicals formation; (iv) activation of small earth-abundant molecules (such as water, dioxygen, superoxide radical anion, carbon oxides, nitrous oxide, and dinitrogen).This Account describes our investigations carried out during the past 10 years on bio-inspired and biomimetic low-nuclearity complexes containing metal-thiolate bonds. The general objective of these structural, spectroscopic, electrochemical, and catalytic studies was to determine structure-properties-function correlations useful to (i) understanding the peculiar features or the mechanism of the mimicked natural systems and/or (ii) reproducing enzymatic reactivities for specific catalytic applications.By employing a unique highly preorganized N₂S₂-donor ligand with two thiolate functions, in combination with different first-row transition metals (Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, or V), we got access to a series of bio-inspired sulfur-rich complexes displaying a widespread spectrum of structures, properties, and functions. We isolated a dicopper(I) complex that, for the first time, mimicked concomitantly the key structural, spectroscopic, and redox features of the biological Cu_A center, a highly efficient electron transfer agent involved in the respiratory enzyme cytochrome c oxidase. In the field of sulfur activation, we explored (i) sulfur methylation promoted by a Zn-dithiolate complex that mimics Zn-dependent thiolate alkylation proteins and shows different selectivity compared to the Ni and Co congeners and (ii) a series of Co, Fe, and Mn complexes as the first copper-free systems able to promote thiolate/disulfide interconversion mediated by (de)coordination of halides. Concerning metal-centered reactivity, we investigated two families of metal-thiolate catalysts for small-molecule activation, especially relevant in the fields of sustainable fuel production and energy conversion: (i) two isostructural Mn and Fe dinuclear complexes that activate and reduce dioxygen selectively, either to hydrogen peroxide or water as a function of the experimental conditions; (ii) a family of dinuclear MFe (M = Ni or Fe) hydrogenase mimics active for catalytic H₂ evolution both in organic solution and on modified electrodes in water.This Account thus illustrates how the versatility of thiolate ligation can support selected functions for transition metal complexes, depending on the nature of the metal, the nuclearity of the complex, the presence and type of co-ligands, the second coordination sphere effects, and the experimental conditions.

A bioinspired thiolate-bridged dinickel complex with a pendant amine: synthesis, structure and electrocatalytic properties

By employing X(CH₂CH₂S^-)₂ (X = S, tpdt; X = O, opdt; X = NPh, npdt) as bridging ligands, four thiolate-bridged dinickel complexes supported by phosphine ligands, [(dppe)Ni(μ-1SSS':2SS-tpdt)Ni(dppe)][PF₆]₂ (1[PF₆]₂, dppe = Ph₂P(CH₂)₂PPh₂), [(dppe)Ni(μ-1SSN:2SS-npdt)Ni(dppe)][PF₆]₂ (2[PF₆]₂) and [(dppe)Ni(t-Cl)(μ-1SSX:2SS-C₄H₈S₂X)Ni(dppe)][PF₆] (3[PF₆], X = S; 4[PF₆], X = O) were facilely obtained by the salt metathesis reaction. These four thiolate-bridged dinickel complexes have all been fully characterized by spectroscopic methods and X-ray crystallography. In 2[PF₆]₂, elongation of the Ni-N bond distance, possibly caused by steric hindrance, indicates that the pendant nitrogen group shuttles between the two nickel centers in solution, which is evidenced by ³¹P{¹H} NMR spectroscopic results. Furthermore, these thiolate-bridged dinickel complexes have all been proved to be electrocatalysts for proton reduction to hydrogen. Notably, complex 2[PF₆]₂ featuring a pendant amine group in the secondary coordination sphere exhibits the best catalytic activity at a relatively low overpotential.

Synthetic Designs and Structural Investigations of Biomimetic Ni-Fe Thiolates

Described are the syntheses of several Ni(μ-SR)₂Fe complexes, including hydride derivatives, in a search for improved models for the active site of [NiFe]-hydrogenases. The nickel(II) precursors include (i) nickel with tripodal ligands: Ni(PS₃)^- and Ni(NS₃)^- (PS₃^3- = tris(phenyl-2-thiolato)phosphine, NS₃^3- = tris(benzyl-2-thiolato)amine), (ii) traditional diphosphine-dithiolates, including chiral diphosphine R,R-DIPAMP, (iii) cationic Ni(phosphine-imine/amine) complexes, and (iv) organonickel precursors Ni( o-tolyl)Cl(tmeda) and Ni(C₆F₅)₂. The following new nickel precursor complexes were characterized: PPh₄[Ni(NS₃)] and the dimeric imino/amino-phosphine complexes [NiCl₂(PCH═N^An)]₂ and [NiCl₂(PCH₂NH^An)]₂ (P = Ph₂PC₆H₄-2-). The iron(II) reagents include [CpFe(CO)₂(thf)]BF₄, [Cp*Fe(CO)(MeCN)₂]BF₄, FeI₂(CO)₄, FeCl₂(diphos)(CO)₂, and Fe(pdt)(CO)₂(diphos) (diphos = chelating diphosphines). Reactions of the nickel and iron complexes gave the following new Ni-Fe compounds: Cp*Fe(CO)Ni(NS₃), [Cp(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)Ni(dppbz)]BF₄, [( R,R-DIPAMP)Ni(μ-pdt)(H)Fe(CO)₃]BAr^F₄, [(PCH═N^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(Cl)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(PCH₂NH^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(Cl)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(PCH═N^An)Ni(μ-pdt)(H)Fe(dppbz)(CO)]BF₄, [(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni, {H[(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni]}BF₄, and (C₆F₅)₂Ni(μ-pdt)Fe(CO)₂(dppv) (DIPAMP = (CH₂P(C₆H₄-2-OMe)₂)₂; BAr^F₄^- = [B(C₆H₃-3,5-(CF₃)₂]₄^-)) Within the context of Ni-(SR)₂-Fe complexes, these new complexes feature new microenvironments for the nickel center: tetrahedral Ni, chirality, imine, and amine coligands, and Ni-C bonds. In the case of {H[(dppv)(CO)Fe(μ-pdt)]₂Ni}⁺, four low-energy isomers are separated by ≤3 kcal/mol, one of which features a biomimetic HNi(SR)₄ site, as supported by density functional theory calculations.

CO2 fixation and transformation on a thiolate-bridged dicobalt scaffold under oxidising conditions

CO2 fixation and conversion promoted by a thiolate-bridged dicobalt complex in the presence of an oxidant.

Biomimetic catalytic oxidative coupling of thiols using thiolate-bridged dinuclear metal complexes containing iron in water under mild conditions

A green approach to disulfides via aerobic oxidative coupling of thiols was developed with a thiolate-bridged heteronuclear complex in water.

Methylene insertion into an Fe2S2 cluster: formation of a thiolate-bridged diiron complex containing an Fe-CH2-S moiety

Reduction of a thiolate-bridged FeIIFeIII complex leads to the cleavage of an Fe-S bond by the insertion of the methylene unit from CH2Cl2 to give a neutral FeIIFeIII complex with a novel Fe-CH2-S fragment. The structural and electrochemical differences of the alkylated and the non-alkylated Fe2S2 complexes are also examined.

Terminal alkyne insertion into a thiolate-bridged dirhodium hydride complex derived from heterolytic cleavage of H2

Thiolate-bridged dirhodium and diiridium complexes can facilely realize heterolytic cleavage of H2 across the metal-sulfur bond to generate the corresponding hydride bridged complexes. Furthermore, terminal alkynes can insert the Rh-H-Rh fragment to afford σ:π alkenyl bridged complexes and then convert to the corresponding alkenes in the presence of a reductant and an acid.

Highly β( Z)-Selective Hydrosilylation of Terminal Alkynes Catalyzed by Thiolate-Bridged Dirhodium Complexes

A series of novel monothiolate-bridged dirhodium complexes, [Cp*Rh(μ-SR)(μ-Cl)₂RhCp*][BF₄] {Cp* = η⁵-C₅Me₅, R = tertiary butyl ( ^tBu), 1a; R = ferrocenyl (Fc), 1b; R = adamantyl (Ad), 1c} were designed and successfully synthesized, which can smoothly facilitate highly regioselective and stereoselective hydrosilylation of terminal alkynes to afford β( Z) vinylsilanes with good functional group compatibility. Furthermore, the hydride bridged dirhodium complex [Cp*Rh(μ-S ^tBu)(μ-Cl)(μ-H)RhCp*][BF₄] (5) as a potential intermediate was obtained by the reaction of 1a with excess HSiEt₃.

Complexes of MN2S2·Fe(η5-C5R5)(CO) as platform for exploring cooperative heterobimetallic effects in HER electrocatalysis

The control of aggregation at sulfur by metallodithiolates (MN₂S₂) has made them prime candidates as building blocks for the synthesis of biomimetics of various bimetallic enzyme active sites, with reactivity consequences implicating redox control by both metal centers. Recent studies of MN₂S₂ (M = Ni²⁺, Fe(NO)²⁺) bound to [(η⁵-C₅H₅)Fe(CO)]⁺ as electrocatalysts for proton reduction, the hydrogen evolution reaction, demonstrated reduction-induced hemi-lability of the bridging cis-dithiolates as a key step in the electrochemical proton reduction process (Ding, et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2016, 138, 12920-12927). The MN₂S₂·Fe(η⁵-C₅R₅)(CO) platform offers numerous possibilities for tuning the electronic character of the M(μ-S₂)Fe core. As well as modifying M within the metallodithiolate ligand, replacing H by CH₃ at the η⁵-C₅R₅ moiety increases the electron density at the Fe center, which might facilitate the reductive Fe-S bond cleavage. Although release of a free thiolate in these hemi-labile ligands creates a needed internal pendant base, this benefit might be countered by the increase in over-potential for addition of the first electron. Herein we report the preparation and characterization of four bimetallic aggregates with the (η⁵-C₅R₅)Fe(CO) (R = H, CH₃; Fe' or Fe*', respectively) or the dicarbonyl (η⁵-C₅R₅)Fe(CO)₂ scaffold (R = H, CH₃; Fe'' or Fe*'', respectively) bound to redox active MN₂S₂ ligands (M = Ni²⁺, Co(NO)²⁺; N₂S₂ = bismercaptoethane diazacycloheptane) Co-Fe*', Ni-Fe*', Co-Fe' and Co-Fe*'' complexes. The bidentate complexes were found to be electrocatalysts for proton reduction, although at high over-potential, especially for the derivatives of the electron-rich (η⁵-C₅(CH₃)₅)Fe(CO)⁺. The turnover (TON) and turnover frequencies (TOF) were determined and found to be comparable to the previously reported MN₂S₂·Fe(η⁵-C₅H₅)(CO)⁺ analogues.

A matrix of heterobimetallic complexes for interrogation of hydrogen evolution reaction electrocatalysts

Experimental and computational studies address key questions in a structure-function analysis of bioinspired electrocatalysts for the HER. Combinations of NiN2S2 or [(NO)Fe]N2S2 as donors to (η5-C5H5)Fe(CO)+ or [Fe(NO)2]+/0 generate a series of four bimetallics, gradually "softened" by increasing nitrosylation, from 0 to 3, by the non-innocent NO ligands. The nitrosylated NiFe complexes are isolated and structurally characterized in two redox levels, demonstrating required features of electrocatalysis. Computational modeling of experimental structures and likely transient intermediates that connect the electrochemical events find roles for electron delocalization by NO, as well as Fe-S bond dissociation that produce a terminal thiolate as pendant base well positioned to facilitate proton uptake and transfer. Dihydrogen formation is via proton/hydride coupling by internal S-H+···-H-Fe units of the "harder" bimetallic arrangements with more localized electron density, while softer units convert H-···H-via reductive elimination from two Fe-H deriving from the highly delocalized, doubly reduced [Fe2(NO)3]- derivative. Computational studies also account for the inactivity of a Ni2Fe complex resulting from entanglement of added H+ in a pinched -S δ-···H+··· δ-S- arrangement.

Synthesis and reactivity of thiolate-bridged multi-iron complexes supported by cyclic (alkyl)(amino)carbene

The combined utilization of Me₂-cAAC (Me₂-cAAC = :C(CH₂)(CMe₂)₂N-2,6-ⁱPr₂C₆H₃) and thiolates as supporting ligands enables the access of unprecedented carbene coordinated thiolate-bridged diiron(ii) complexes [(Me₂-cAAC)Fe(μ-SR)(Br)]₂ (R = Me, 3; R = Et, 4). The coordination environment of each tetrahedral iron(ii) center in complexes 3 and 4 is composed of one terminal bromide atom, one carbene carbon atom and two thiolate sulfur atoms, which is similar to the carbide-containing sulfur-rich environment of iron centers in the belt region of the FeMo-cofactor. Interestingly, when NaSCPh₃ was chosen as the thiolate ligand, C-S bond homolysis occurred to form a rare [3 : 1] site-differentiated cubane-type cluster [(Me₂-cAAC)Fe₄S₄(Br)₃][Me₂-cAACH] (5). Furthermore, complexes 3 and 4 exhibit good exchange reactivity toward the azide anion to give novel thiolate-bridged diiron complexes with two azido ligands in a trans arrangement.

Synthesis and characterization of a family of thioether-dithiolate-bridged heteronuclear iron complexes

The thioether-dithiolate-bridged heterotrinuclear complexes [Cp*Fe(μ-1_k³SSS':2_k²SS-tpdt)M(μ-2_k²SS:3_k³SSS'-tpdt)FeCp*][PF₆]₂ (Cp* = η⁵-C₅Me₅; tpdt = S(CH₂CH₂S)₂; 2, M = Co; 3, M = Ni; 4, M = Pd) have been prepared by a reaction of [Cp*Fe(η³-tpdt)] (1) with complexes CoCl₂, NiCl₂(PPh₃)₂, and PdCl₂(PPh₃)₂, respectively. Similarly, treatment of complex 1 with CuCl(PPh₃) or AgPF₆ afforded two heterotrinuclear complexes, [Cp*Fe(μ-1_k³SSS':2_k²SS-tpdt)M(μ-2_k²SS:3_k³SSS'-tpdt)FeCp*][PF₆] (5, M = Cu; 6, M = Ag), while reaction of 1 with the complex AuCl(PPh₃) gave a heterobinuclear complex, [Cp*Fe(μ-1_k³SSS':2_k¹S-tpdt)Au(PPh₃)][PF₆] (7). These complexes have been spectroscopically and crystallographically characterized. An X-ray diffraction analysis showed that complexes 2, 3, 5, and 6 feature a heterometal center binding four sulfur atoms of two tpdt ligands with a cis orientation. However, in the Pd-containing complex 4, two tpdt ligands are arranged in a trans configuration. The μ_eff data and EPR results indicate that complexes 2, 4, 5, 6, and 7 are paramagnetic and only complex 3 is diamagnetic. Electrochemical experiments on these heteronuclear clusters were performed at room temperature. Discrepancy of the redox couples in the CV plots of these complexes indicates different one-electron transfer processes.

Synthesis, structural characterization and conversion of dinuclear iron-sulfur clusters containing the disulfide ligand: [Cp*Fe(μ-η2:η2-bdt)(cis-μ-η1:η1-S2)FeCp*], [Cp*Fe(μ-S(C6H4S2))(cis-μ-η1:η1-S2)FeCp*], and [{Cp*Fe(bdt)}2(trans-μ-η1:η1-S2)]

The treatment of [Cp*Fe(μ-η²:η⁴-bdt)FeCp*] (1, Cp* = η⁵-C₅Me₅, bdt = benzene-1,2-dithiolate) with 1/4 equiv. of elemental sulfur (S₈) gave a dinuclear iron-sulfur cluster [Cp*Fe(μ-η²:η²-bdt)(cis-μ-η¹:η¹-S₂)FeCp*] (2), which contains a cis-1,2-disulfide ligand. When complex 2 further interacted with 1/8 equiv. of S₈, another sulfur atom inserted into an Fe-S bond to give a rare product [Cp*Fe(μ-S(C₆H₄S₂))(cis-μ-η¹:η¹-S₂)FeCp*] (3). Unexpectedly, a trans-1,2 disulfide-bridged diiron complex [{Cp*Fe(bdt)}₂(trans-μ-η¹:η¹-S₂)] (4) was isolated from the reaction of complex 1 with 1/2 equiv. of S₈, which represents a structural isomer of [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin-type clusters. In addition, cis-1,2-disulfide-bridged complex 3 can slowly convert into trans-1,2-disulfide-bridged complex 4 and the complex [Cp*Fe(μ-η²:η²-S₂)(cis-μ-η¹:η¹-S₂)FeCp*] (5) by self-assembly reaction at ambient temperature, which is evidenced by time-dependent ¹H NMR spectroscopy.

Comparisons of MN2S2vs. bipyridine as redox-active ligands to manganese and rhenium in (L–L)M′(CO)3Cl complexes

Electronic communication was established for a heterobimetallic complex which upon reduction at one metal center modulates ligand loss and subsequent electron uptake at the second metal.

Synthetic [NiFe] models with a fluxional CO ligand

A [NiFe] complex [(dppe)Ni(pdt)FeCp*(CO)]BF₄ was characterized as two isomers, and their interconversions were established by thermal process and electrochemistry.

Structural characterization and proton reduction electrocatalysis of thiolate-bridged bimetallic (CoCo and CoFe) complexes

Using an assembly method, dinuclear CoCo and CoFe complexes supported by a bdt ligand, [Cp*Co(μ–η²:η²-bdt)(μ-I)CoCp*][PF₆] (1[PF6], Cp* = η⁵-C₅Me₅, bdt = benzene-1,2-dithiolate), and [Cp*Co(μ–η²:η⁴-bdt)FeCp′][PF₆] (3[PF6], Cp′ = η⁵-C₅Me₄H) were synthesized in high yields.