Use of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to detect structural variations in kilobase-sized DNAs

Intrinsic curvature in the VP1 gene of SV40: comparison of solution and gel results

DNA restriction fragments that are stably curved are usually identified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis because curved fragments migrate more slowly than normal fragments containing the same number of basepairs. In free solution, curved DNA molecules can be identified by transient electric birefringence (TEB) because they exhibit rotational relaxation times that are faster than those of normal fragments of the same size. In this article, the results observed in free solution and in polyacrylamide gels are compared for a highly curved 199-basepair (bp) restriction fragment taken from the VP1 gene in Simian Virus 40 (SV40) and various sequence mutants and insertion derivatives. The TEB method of overlapping fragments was used to show that the 199-bp fragment has an apparent bend angle of 46 +/- 2 degrees centered at sequence position 1922 +/- 2 bp. Four unphased A- and T-tracts and a mixed A3T4-tract occur within a span of approximately 60 bp surrounding the apparent bend center; for brevity, this 60-bp sequence element is called a curvature module. Modifying any of the A- or T-tracts in the curvature module by site-directed mutagenesis decreases the curvature of the fragment; replacing all five A- and T-tracts by random-sequence DNA causes the 199-bp mutant to adopt a normal conformation, with normal electrophoretic mobilities and birefringence relaxation times. Hence, stable curvature in this region of the VP1 gene is due to the five unphased A- and T- tracts surrounding the apparent bend center. Discordant solution and gel results are observed when long inverted repeats are inserted within the curvature module. These insertion derivatives migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels but have normal, highly flexible conformations in free solution. Discordant solution and gel results are not observed if the insert does not contain a long inverted repeat or if the long inverted repeat is added to the 199-bp fragment outside the curvature module. The results suggest that long inverted repeats can form hairpins or cruciforms when they are located within a region of the helix backbone that is intrinsically curved, leading to large mobility anomalies in polyacrylamide gels. Hairpin/cruciform formation is not observed in free solution, presumably because of rapid conformational exchange. Hence, DNA restriction fragments that migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels are not necessarily stably curved in free solution.

Analysis of DNA bending by transient electric birefringence

Transient electric birefringence has been used to analyze DNA bending in six restriction fragments containing 171, 174, 207, 263, 289, and 471 bp in three different low ionic strength buffers. The target fragments contain sequences corresponding to the apparent bend centers in pUC19 and Litmus 28, previously identified by the circular permutation assay (Strutz, K.; Stellwagen, N. C. Electrophoresis 1996, 17, 989-995). The target fragments migrate anomalously slowly in polyacrylamide gels and exhibit birefringence relaxation times that are shorter than those of restriction fragments of the same size, taken from nonbent regions of the same plasmids. Apparent bend angles ranging from 30 degrees to 41 degrees were calculated for the target fragments by tau-ratio method. The bend angles of four of the target fragments were independent of temperature from 4 degrees C to 20 degrees C, but decreased when the temperature was increased to 37 degrees C. The bend angles of the other two target fragments were independent of temperature over the entire range examined, 4 degrees -37 degrees C. Hence, the thermal stability of sequence-dependent bends in random-sequence DNA is variable. The bend angles of five of the six target fragments were independent of the presence or absence of Mg2+ ions in the solution, indicating most of the target fragments were stably bent or curved, rather than anisometrically flexible. Restriction fragments containing 219 and 224 bp, with sequences somewhat offset from the sequence of the 207 bp fragment, were also studied. Comparison of the tau-ratios of these overlapping fragments allowed both the bend angle and bend position to be independently determined. These methods should be useful for analyzing sequence-dependent bending in other random-sequence DNAs.

The use of gel and capillary electrophoresis to investigate some of the fundamental physical properties of DNA

Electrophoresis is a powerful technique which can be used not only for the size-based separation of DNA in slab gels and sieving liquid polymers, but also for the analysis of sequence-dependent variations in DNA conformation and structure. Polyacrylamide gels are useful for conformational analysis, because bent or curved DNA molecules migrate anomalously slowly in this gel medium. Bending is often (but not always) associated with runs of adenine residues (A-tracts) that occur in phase with the helix repeat. The unique structure responsible for DNA bending "melts out" at a temperature considerably below that of strand separation. The circular permutation assay is another polyacrylamide gel-based method of detecting bending. It has usually been applied to small restriction fragments, but can also be used to detect bending in plasmid-sized DNA molecules. The apparent bends in plasmid DNAs tend to be located near biologically important regions of the sequence, such as the origin of replication, the start site of transcription, and the promoters of certain genes. Finally, capillary electrophoresis in free solution (without sieving liquid polymers) can be used to determine the diffusion coefficients of small DNA molecules, detect DNA-buffer interactions, and analyze the sequence dependence of counterion binding. Counterions appear to be preferentially bound to DNA oligomers containing A-tracts, especially the A(n)T(n) sequence motif. Typical examples of these applications of gel and capillary electrophoresis to the study of DNA conformation and structure are described.

Apparent pore size of polyacrylamide gels: comparison of gels cast and run in Tris-acetate-EDTA and Tris-borate-EDTA buffers

The electrophoretic mobilities of DNA molecules in three different molecular weight ladders were measured in polyacrylamide gels containing different acrylamide concentrations (%T) and cross-linker ratios (%C), cast and run in Trisacetate-EDTA (TAE) buffer. The apparent pore radius of each gel was estimated from Ferguson plots of the relative mobilities of each of the DNA molecules, using the mobility of the monomer fragment in each molecular weight ladder as the reference mobility. The effective size of each of the DNA molecules was estimated from its radius of gyration. The apparent gel pore radii calculated in this manner ranged from 21 nm in gels containing 10.5%T, 5%C to 200 nm in gels with 4.6%T, 2%C, similar to the values observed for polyacrylamide gels cast and run in Tris-borate-EDTA (TBE) buffer (Holmes and Stellwagen, Electrophoresis 1991, 12, 612-619). Hence, the effective pore size of polyacrylamide gels is essentially independent of whether the gels are cast and run in TAE or TBE buffer.

DNA mobility anomalies are determined primarily by polyacrylamide gel concentration, not gel pore size

The dependence of DNA mobility anomalies on gel pore size has been studied in polyacrylamide gels with a wide variety of compositions, using molecular weight ladders containing multiple copies of normal (12B) and anomalously slowly migrating (12A) 147-base pair restriction fragments from plasmid pBR322 as the migrating probe molecules. If the gel pore size is increased by decreasing the total acrylamide concentration (%T) at constant cross-linker ratio (%C), the usual method of increasing gel pore size, the mobility anomalies decrease with increasing gel pore radius as though the 12A multimers were retarded by a sieving mechanism. However, the decrease in the mobility anomalies is independent of whether the apparent gel pore radius is larger or smaller than the DNA radius of gyration, suggesting that gel pore size is not the controlling variable. If the acrylamide concentration is held constant and the gel pore size is increased by decreasing %C at constant %T, the mobility anomalies of the largest 12A multimers (6 mers and higher) decrease with increasing gel pore radius, because of sieving effects, until the effective gel pore radius becomes approximately equal to the DNA radius of gyration, after which the mobility anomalies level off and become independent of gel pore size. The mobility anomalies exhibited by 5-mers and smaller multimers of fragment 12A are independent of gel pore radius in all gels with constant %T. Similar results are observed with a molecular weight ladder containing phased A-tracts from the kinetoplast bending locus. Since the anomalous electrophoretic mobilities depend primarily on the total acrylamide concentration in the gel, and not on the apparent gel pore radius, increases in the magnitude of the mobility anomalies with increasing gel concentration (and decreasing gel pore radius) cannot be taken as evidence for DNA curvature.

Intrinsic curvature of plasmid DNAs analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

The electrophoretic mobility of two small DNA plasmids, pUC19 and Litmus 28, linerarized by digestion with a variety of single-cut restriction enzymes, has been studied. The permuted sequence isomers migrate with identical mobilities in agarose gels, as expected, but exhibit different mobilities in large-pore polyacrylamide gels, suggesting that the parent plasmids contain sequence-specific sites of curvature and/or anisotropic flexibility. Both plasmids contain apparent bend centers near their origin(s) of replication; pUC19 also has a major apparent bend center near the promoter of the ampicillin resistance gene. These apparent bend centers are observed under a variety of experimental conditions, suggesting that they correspond to sites of stable curvature in the parent plasmids. Both plasmids also contain minor bend centers that are observed under a sub-set of electrophoretic conditions and disappear when divalent cations are added to the solution, suggesting that these apparent bend centers may correspond to localized regions of variable flexibility.

Influence of optical probing with YOYO on the electrophoretic behavior of the DNA molecule

The influence of the fluorescent dye YOYO (1,1'-(4,4,8,8,-tetramethyl- 4,8-diazaundecamethylene)bis[4-[[3-methyl-benzo-1,3-oxazol-2 -yl] methylidene]-1,4-dihydroquinolinium] tetraiodide) on the electrophoretic behavior of the DNA molecule was investigated. This is important when using YOYO as a probe in capillary electrophoresis or in fluorescence microscopy studies of DNA with the purpose of studying the migration mechanism of DNA on the molecular level. We have measured the mobility and orientation dynamics (using the linear dichroism technique) for both pure DNA and the YOYO-DNA complex in agarose gel in order to compare their electrophoretic properties. Mobility decreases, the degree of orientation becomes lower, and the orientational dynamics slower, when YOYO binds to DNA. However, the dependence on field strength of the mobility, orientation and orientational dynamics, are similar for DNA and YOYO-DNA, indicating that the mode of migration does not change significantly upon binding YOYO to DNA. Furthermore, since our results show that the effect of YOYO on both the degree of orientation and orientational dynamics of the DNA can be measured and therefore be compensated for, it can be concluded that YOYO is an excellent optical probe for the study of the migrational behavior of DNA.

Electric birefringence of kilobase-sized DNA molecules

Transient electric birefringence has been used to characterize the rotational diffusion of linear, circularly permuted pBR322 and SV40 DNA molecules. The birefringence relaxation times vary with the site of linearization, suggesting that the circularly permuted DNAs have different conformations in solution. The longest relaxation times are observed for DNA sequence isomers linearized at the major bend centers identified by gel electrophoresis. SV40 sequence isomers linearized at other locations have faster, but approximately equal, terminal relaxation times, suggesting that their free solution conformations are relatively independent of the location of the bend center within the sequence. By contrast, the terminal relaxation times of the various pBR322 sequence isomers vary approximately in accord with their electrophoretic mobilities in large-pore polyacrylamide gels, suggesting that the different mobilities may reflect real conformational differences between the sequence isomers.