Extended specificity studies of mRNA assays used to infer human organ tissues and body fluids

mRNA for Body Fluid and Individual Identification

Biological stains are one of the most important pieces of evidence, playing a multifaceted role in forensic investigations. An integral facet of forensic practice involves the identification of body fluids, typically achieved through chemical and enzymatic reactions. In recent decades, the introduction of mRNA markers has been posited as a pivotal advancement to augment the capabilities of body fluid identification (BFID). The mRNA coding region single-nucleotide polymorphisms (cSNPs) also present notable advantages, particularly in the task of individual identification. Here, we review the specificity and stability of mRNA markers in the context of BFID and the prowess of mRNA polymorphism in individual identification. Additionally, innovative methods for mRNA detection are discussed.

Investigative use of human environmental DNA in forensic genetics

Individuals leave behind traces of their DNA wherever they go. DNA can be transferred to surfaces and items upon touch, can be released into the air, and may be deposited in indoor dust. The mere presence of individuals in a location is sufficient to facilitate either direct or indirect DNA transfer into the surrounding environment. In this study, we analyzed samples recovered from commonly touched surfaces such as light switches and door handles in an office environment. We evaluated two different methods to isolate DNA and co-extract DNA and RNA from the samples. DNA profiles were compared to the references of the inhabitants of the different locations and were analyzed taking into consideration the type of sampled surface, sampling location and information about the activities in a room during the sampling day. Results from DNA samples collected from surfaces were also compared to those from air and dust samples collected in parallel from the same areas. We characterized the amount and composition of DNA found on various surfaces and showed that surface DNA sampling can be used to detect occupants of a location. The results also indicate that combining information from environmental samples collected from different DNA sources can improve our understanding of DNA transfer events in an indoor setting. This study further demonstrates the potential of human environmental DNA as an investigative tool in forensic genetics.

An mRNA profiling assay incorporating coding region InDels for body fluid identification and the inference of the donor in mixed samples

Biological traces discovered at crime scenes hold significant significance in forensic investigations. In cases involving mixed body fluid stains, the evidentiary value of DNA profiles depends on the type of body fluid from which the DNA was obtained. Recently, coding region polymorphism analysis has proved to be a promising method for directly linking specific body fluids to their respective DNA contributors in mixtures, which may help to avoid "association fallacy" between separate DNA and RNA evidence. In this study, we present an update on previously reported coding region Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (cSNPs) by exploring the potential application of coding region Insertion/Deletion polymorphisms (cInDels). Nine promising cInDels, selected from 70 mRNA markers based on stringent screening criteria, were integrated into an existing mRNA profiling assay. Subsequently, the body fluid specificity of our cInDel assay and the genotyping consistency between complementary DNA (cDNA) and genomic DNA (gDNA) were examined. Our study demonstrates that cInDels can function as important multifunctional genetic markers, as they provide not only the ability to confirm the presence of forensically relevant body fluids, but also the ability to associate/dissociate specific body fluids with particular donors.

Bloodstain pattern analysis & Bayes: A case report

The findings from a bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) may assist in formulating or falsifying scenarios that are considered in the investigative stages of a criminal investigation. When a case proceeds to trial the bloodstain pattern expert may be asked about the relevance of their findings given scenarios that are proposed by the prosecution and defense counsel. Such opinions provided by an expert are highly relevant to police investigation or legal proceedings, but the reasoning behind the opinion or implicit assumptions made by the expert may not be transparent. A proper framework for the evaluation of forensic findings has been developed since the late twentieth century, based on the hierarchy of propositions, Bayesian reasoning and a model for case assessment and interpretation. This framework, when implemented in casework, mitigates some of the risks of cognitive biases, and makes the reasoning and scientific basis for the opinion transparent. This framework is broadly used across forensic science disciplines. In this paper we describe its application to the field of BPA using a case example from the Netherlands Forensic Institute (NFI).

Transfer, persistence and recovery of DNA and mRNA vaginal mucosa markers after intimate and social contact with Bayesian network analysis for activity level reporting

In sexual assault cases, it can be challenging to identify the type of body fluids/ cell types present in a crime scene sample, especially the origin of epithelial cells. Therefore, more labs are applying mRNA body fluid analysis for saliva, skin and vaginal mucosa markers. To address activity level propositions, it is necessary to assign probabilities of transfer, persistence, prevalence and recovery of DNA and mRNA markers. In this study we analysed 158 samples (fingernail swabs, penile swabs and boxershorts) from 12 couples collected at different time points post intimate contact and after non-intimate contact in order to detect DNA from the person of interest (POI) and mRNA vaginal mucosa markers. Samples were DNA and RNA co-extracted and analysed with PowerPlex®Fusion 6C System and 19-plex mRNA primer mix respectively, using Endpoint PCR and the CE platform. Vaginal mucosa was detected up to 36 h post intimate contact, but also detected in one non-intimate contact sample. In 94% of intimate contact and 50 % of non-intimate contact samples the DNA results support the proposition that POI is the donor (LR ≥ 10,000). There was a strong association between the detection of vaginal mucosa and the average RFU value of the POI. The data were used to instantiate a comprehensive Bayesian network to evaluate the evidence at activity level, given alternate propositions conditioned upon indirect or direct transfer events. It is shown that the value of the evidence is mainly affected by the high DNA quantity (measured as mean RFU) that is recovered from the POI. The detection of vaginal mucosa had low impact upon the resultant likelihood ratio.

Schwere sexualisierte Gewalt – Aufklärung eines Falls durch Kombination aus DNA- und mRNA-Analyse

Mithilfe der Analyse von mRNA-Expressionsmustern durch Einsatz der PCR-Amplifikation von zellspezifischen cDNA-Transkripten und Nachweis der Amplifikate mittels Kapillarelektrophorese (CE) lässt sich die Frage klären, aus welchen Zelltypen (Blut, Speichel, Sperma, Vaginalschleimhaut, Menstrual- und Nasensekret) sich eine biologische Spur zusammensetzt. Durch Verwendung der DNA-RNA-Koextraktion kann dieses Verfahren unabhängig von der STR-Typisierung durchgeführt werden. Am Beispiel des hier dargestellten Falles, bei dem Vaginalsekret der verletzten Frau am Mittelfinger des Beschuldigten nachgewiesen wurde, wird gezeigt, dass der Einsatz dieser Methode besonders bei Fällen von sexualisierter Gewalt sinnvoll ist.

On the Identification of Body Fluids and Tissues: A Crucial Link in the Investigation and Solution of Crime

Body fluid and body tissue identification are important in forensic science as they can provide key evidence in a criminal investigation and may assist the court in reaching conclusions. Establishing a link between identifying the fluid or tissue and the DNA profile adds further weight to this evidence. Many forensic laboratories retain techniques for the identification of biological fluids that have been widely used for some time. More recently, many different biomarkers and technologies have been proposed for identification of body fluids and tissues of forensic relevance some of which are now used in forensic casework. Here, we summarize the role of body fluid/ tissue identification in the evaluation of forensic evidence, describe how such evidence is detected at the crime scene and in the laboratory, elaborate different technologies available to do this, and reflect real life experiences. We explain how, by including this information, crucial links can be made to aid in the investigation and solution of crime.

Cell survival and DNA damage repair are promoted in the human blood thanatotranscriptome shortly after death

RNA analysis of post-mortem tissues, or thanatotranscriptomics, has become a topic of interest in forensic science due to the essential information it can provide in forensic investigations. Several studies have previously investigated the effect of death on gene transcription, but it has never been conducted with samples of the same individual. For the first time, a longitudinal mRNA expression analysis study was performed with post-mortem human blood samples from individuals with a known time of death. The results reveal that, after death, two clearly differentiated groups of up- and down-regulated genes can be detected. Pathway analysis suggests active processes that promote cell survival and DNA damage repair, rather than passive degradation, are the source of early post-mortem changes of gene expression in blood. In addition, a generalized linear model with an elastic net restriction predicted post-mortem interval with a root mean square error of 4.75 h. In conclusion, we demonstrate that post-mortem gene expression data can be used as biomarkers to estimate the post-mortem interval though further validation using independent sample sets is required before use in forensic casework.

Degradation of human mRNA transcripts over time as an indicator of the time since deposition (TsD) in biological crime scene traces

Knowledge about the age of a stain, also termed as time since deposition (TsD), would provide law-enforcing authorities with valuable information for the prosecution of criminal offenses. Yet, there is no reliable method for the inference / assessment of TsD available. The aim of this study was to gain further insight into the RNA degradation pattern of forensically relevant body fluids and to find candidate markers for TsD estimation. Blood, menstrual blood, saliva, semen and vaginal secretion samples were exposed to indoor (dark, room temperature) and outdoor (exposed to sun, wind, etc. but protected from rain) conditions for up to 1.5 years. Based on expression and degradation analyses, we were able to identify body fluid specific signatures and RNA degradation patterns. The indoor samples showed a marked drop in RNA integrity after 6 months, while the outdoor samples were difficult to interpret and therefore excluded for some of the analyses. Up to 4 weeks, indoor samples showed more stable and less degrading transcripts than outdoor samples. Stable transcripts tended to be significantly shorter than degrading ones or transcripts, which are neither degrading nor stable. We reinforced the body fluid specific and the housekeeping gene nature of previously reported markers. With an unbiased approach, we selected stable and degrading genes for each body fluid in the short term and assessed their integrity during extended storage. We identified several stable and degrading gene transcripts, which could be tested in a targeted assay to assess the TsD interval e.g. by analyzing the ratio of degrading vs stable transcripts. In conclusion, we were able to detect RNA degradation patterns in samples being aged up to 1.5 years and identified several candidate markers, which could be evaluated for TsD estimation.

Forensic transcriptome analysis using massively parallel sequencing

The application of transcriptome analyses in forensic genetics has experienced tremendous growth and development in the past decade. The earliest studies and main applications were body fluid and tissue identification, using targeted RNA transcripts and a reverse transcription endpoint PCR method. A number of markers have been identified for the forensically most relevant body fluids and tissues and the method has been successfully used in casework. The introduction of Massively Parallel Sequencing (MPS) opened up new perspectives and opportunities to advance the field. Contrary to genomic DNA where two copies of an autosomal DNA segment are present in a cell, abundant RNA species are expressed in high copy numbers. Even whole transcriptome sequencing (RNA-Seq) of forensically relevant body fluids and of postmortem material was shown to be possible. This review gives an overview on forensic transcriptome analyses and applications. The methods cover whole transcriptome as well as targeted MPS approaches. High resolution forensic transcriptome analyses using MPS are being applied to body fluid/ tissue identification, determination of the age of stains and the age of the donor, the estimation of the post-mortem interval and to post mortem death investigations.

Parameters for Successful PCR Primer Design

Primers are critical components of any PCR assay, as they are the main determinants of its specificity, sensitivity, and robustness. Despite the publication of numerous guidelines, the actual design of many published assays is often unsound: primers lack the claimed specificity, they may have to compete with secondary structures at their binding sites, primer dimer formation may affect the assay's sensitivity or they may bind only within a narrow temperature range. This chapter provides simple guidance to avoid these most common issues.

Interpol review of forensic biology and forensic DNA typing 2016-2019

This review paper covers the forensic-relevant literature in biological sciences from 2016 to 2019 as a part of the 19th Interpol International Forensic Science Managers Symposium. The review papers are also available at the Interpol website at: https://www.interpol.int/content/download/14458/file/Interpol%20Review%20Papers%202019.pdf.

Potential applications of microRNA profiling to forensic investigations

Within the forensic science community, there is a continued push to develop novel tools to aid in criminal investigations. microRNA (miRNA) analysis has been the focus of many researcher's attention in the biomedical field since its discovery in 1993; however, the forensic application of miRNA analysis has only been suggested within the last 10 years and has been gaining considerable traction recently. The primary focus of the forensic application of miRNA analysis has been on body fluid identification to provide confirmatory universal analysis of unknown biological stains obtained from crime scenes or evidence items. There are, however, other forensic applications of miRNA profiling that have shown potential, yet are largely understudied, and warrant further investigation such as organ tissue identification, donor age estimation, and more. This review paper aims to evaluate the current literature and future potential of miRNA analysis within the forensic science field.

Distinct spectrum of microRNA expression in forensically relevant body fluids and probabilistic discriminant approach

MicroRNA is attracting worldwide attention as a new marker for the identification of forensically relevant body fluids. A probabilistic discriminant model was constructed to identify venous blood, saliva, semen, and vaginal secretion, based on microRNA expression assessed via RT-qPCR. We quantified 15 candidate microRNAs in four types of body fluids by RT-qPCR and found that miR-144-3p, miR-451a-5p, miR-888-5p, miR-891a-5p, miR-203a-3p, miR-223-3p and miR-1260b were helpful to discriminate body fluids. Using the relative expression of seven candidate microRNAs in each body fluid, we implemented a partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) as a probabilistic discriminant model and distinguished four types of body fluids. Of 14 testing samples, 13 samples were correctly identified with >90% posterior probability. We also investigated the effects of microRNA expression in skin, semen infertility, and vaginal secretion during different menstrual phases. Semen infertility and menstrual phases did not affect our body fluid identification system. Therefore, the selected microRNAs were effective in identifying the four types of body fluids, indicating that probabilistic evaluation may be practical in forensic casework.

The expression of 10 candidate specific microRNA markers for human body fluid identification in animal buccal swabs

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) have been of interest in forensic science for body fluid identification with recent years. However, there is no study investigating the species specificity of miRNA markers by the SYBR Green method. Due to the conservation of miRNAs across species, miRNA markers maybe less species-specific than mRNA markers, and in forensic cases, animal buccal swabs are more likely to appear. Therefore, in this study we addressed the influence of 8 kinds of animal buccal swabs on human saliva, semen, vaginal secretion swabs and blood identification with 10 candidate specific miRNA markers by the SYBR Green quantitative PCR. Our data showed that the expression levels of the candidate specific miRNA markers miR-124a and 372 in the cat, dog, mouse and rabbit buccal swabs were in the same range as the human vaginal secretion swabs; buccal swabs from these animals also showed similar expression levels to human saliva for the candidate specific miRNA markers miR-200c, 205 and 658. These results indicated that biomaterials of buccal swabs from cats, dogs, mice and rabbits may be mistaken for human saliva or human vaginal secretion swabs, both of which could result in false positives for human body fluids. Thus, the interpretation of these miRNA profiles for human body fluid identification can be inaccurate in the presence of these animal buccal swabs. Therefore, we suggested performing species tests before human body identification with miRNA markers.

Optimal small-molecular reference RNA for RT-qPCR-based body fluid identification

MicroRNA (miRNA) -based body fluid identification (BFID) plays a prominent role in a forensic practice, and the selected reference RNA is indispensable for a robust normalization in BFID performed using reverse transcription-quantitative PCR. In this study, we first examined sample quality using RNA integrity number, then evaluated the consistency of expression of candidate reference RNAs in 4 forensically relevant body fluids using NormFinder and BestKeeper, and lastly used each rank and index output from these tools for selecting the optimal reference RNA and the combination of the multiple RNAs using the RankAggreg package of R. We found that RNA integrity number was small in our samples, despite the use of pristine body fluids; 5S-rRNA was the optimal reference RNA for the identification of forensically relevant body fluids; and the combination of 5S-rRNA and miR-92a-3p and/or miR-484 enhanced the normalization quality. Our findings enable us to perform stringent normalization of the expression of body fluid-specific RNAs, and thus, can contribute to the development of small RNA-based BFID systems.

A SNP panel for identification of DNA and RNA specimens

BACKGROUND

SNP panels that uniquely identify an individual are useful for genetic and forensic research. Previously recommended SNP panels are based on DNA profiles and mostly contain intragenic SNPs. With the increasing interest in RNA expression profiles, we aimed for establishing a SNP panel for both DNA and RNA-based genotyping.

RESULTS

To determine a small set of SNPs with maximally discriminative power, genotype calls were obtained from DNA and blood-derived RNA sequencing data belonging to healthy, geographically dispersed, Dutch individuals. SNPs were selected based on different criteria like genotype call rate, minor allele frequency, Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium and linkage disequilibrium. A panel of 50 SNPs was sufficient to identify an individual uniquely: the probability of identity was 6.9 × 10^- 20 when assuming no family relations and 1.2 × 10^- 10 when accounting for the presence of full sibs. The ability of the SNP panel to uniquely identify individuals on DNA and RNA level was validated in an independent population dataset. The panel is applicable to individuals from European descent, with slightly lower power in non-Europeans. Whereas most of the genes containing the 50 SNPs are expressed in various tissues, our SNP panel needs optimization for other tissues than blood.

CONCLUSIONS

This first DNA/RNA SNP panel will be useful to identify sample mix-ups in biomedical research and for assigning DNA and RNA stains in crime scenes to unique individuals.