Mutagenesis and human genetic disease: dominant mutation frequencies and a characterization of mutational events in mice and humans

Developmental genetics in ophthalmology

Much of our knowledge about the function of genes in mammalian development has been derived from the molecular analysis of spontaneous or induced mutations in the mouse. Since mutations affecting the mouse eye can be easily identified, a remarkable number of mutant lines provide animal models for congenital anomalies in man. To understand the mechanisms of lens development in detail, the isolation of the corresponding genes and the characterization of the mutations at the molecular level are important. A prerequisite for molecular analysis is the chromosomal localization of the gene. In this review, some mutants from our institute will be discussed according to the embryological time scale of the expression of the affected genes, reflecting also their genetic hierarchy. (1) In the aphakia mouse mutant, two deletions in the promoter of the homeobox transcription factor Pitx3 lead to a loss of its function and to an arrest of eye development at the lens stalk stage. Mutations in the homologous human PITX3 gene have been demonstrated to be causative of cataracts and the dysmorphology of the anterior segment of the eye. (2) Connexin50 is present in the lens vesicle. Later on, it becomes abundant in the anterior part of the fiber cells and in the lens epithelial cells. Mutations in the connexin50-encoding gene Gja8 lead to dominant cataracts. (3) alphaA-crystallin is present in the mouse lens cup, in the posterior half of the lens vesicle, and later in a high concentration in the lens fiber cells. Mutations in the alphaA-crystallin-encoding gene Cryaa lead to recessive and dominant cataracts. (4) Mutations in the gamma-crystallin -encoding genes (Cryg) are the most frequent cause of congenital, dominant nuclear, or total cataracts in the mouse. Indications from our first studies in congenital human cataracts support these data. (5) Some postnatal, progressive cataracts have been characterized by mutations in the beta-crystallin -encoding genes (Cryb). Since at least one of them is also expressed in the retina and the brain, effects on these tissues have to be considered, too.

Mouse models of congenital cataract

Mouse mutants affecting lens development are excellent models for corresponding human disorders. The mutant aphakia has been characterised by bilaterally aphakic eyes (Varnum and Stevens, J Hered 1968;59:147-50); the corresponding gene was mapped to chromosome 19 (Varnum and Stevens, Mouse News Lett 1975;53:35). Recent investigations in our laboratory refined the linkage of 0.6 cM proximal to the marker D19Mit10. Several candidate genes have been excluded (Chuk1, Fgf8, Lbp1, Npm3, Pax2, Pitx3). The Cat3 mutations are characterised by vacuolated lenses caused by alterations in the initial secondary lens fibre cell differentiation. Secondary malformations develop at the cornea and iris, but the retina remains unaffected. The mutation has been mapped to chromosome 10 close to the markers D10Mit41 and D10Mit95. Several candidate genes have been excluded (Dcn, Elk3, Ldc, Mell8, Tr2-11). The series of Cat2 mutations have been mapped close to the gamma-crystallin genes (Cryg; Löster et al., Genomics 1994;23:240-2). The Cat2nop mutation is characterised by a mutation in the third exon of Crygb leading to a truncated gamma B-crystallin and the termination of lens fibre cell differentiation. The Cat2 mutants are interesting models for human cataracts caused by mutations in the human CRYG genes at chromosome 2q32-35.

Cataract mutations and lens development

The lens plays an essential role for proper eye development. Mouse mutants affecting lens development are excellent models for corresponding human disorders. Moreover, using mutations in particular genes the process of eye and lens development can be dissected into distinct steps. Therefore, three mouse mutants will be described in detail and discussed affecting three essential stages: formation of the lens vesicle, initiation of secondary lens fiber cell formation, and terminal differentiation of the secondary fiber cells. The mutant aphakia (ak) has been characterized by bilaterally apakic eyes [Varnum and Stevens (1968) J. Hered. 59, 147-150], and the corresponding gene was mapped to chromosome 19 [Varnum and Stevens (1975) Mouse News Letters 53, 35]. Recent investigations in our laboratory refined the linkage 0.6 +/- 0.3 N cm proximal to the microsatellite marker D19Mit10. The linked gene Pax2, responsible for proper development of the posterior part of the eye and the optic nerve, was excluded as candidate gene by sequence analysis. Histological analysis of the homozygous ak mutants revealed a persisting lens stalk and subsequently the formation of lens rudiments. The lens defects led to irregular iris development and retinal folding. Congenital aphakia is known as a rare human anomaly. Besides a corneal dystrophy (CDTB), no corresponding disease is localized at the homologous region of human chromosome 10q23. The Cat3 mutations are characterized by vacuolated lenses caused by alterations in the beginning of secondary lens fiber cell differentiation at embryonic day 12.5. Secondary malformations develop at the cornea and the iris, but the retina remains unaffected. Two mutant alleles of the Cat3 locus have been mapped to mouse chromosome 10 very close to the microsatellite markers D10Mit41 and D10Mit95 (less than 0.3 cM). Since Cat3 is mapped to a position, which is homologous to human chromosome 12q21-24, the disorder cornea plana congenita can be considered as a candidate disease. The series of Cat2 mutations have been mapped close to the locus encoding the gamma-crystallin gene cluster Cryg [Löster et al. (1994) Genomics 23, 240-242]. The Cat2nop mutation is characterized by a deletion of 11 bp and an insertion of 4 bp in the 3rd exon of Crygh leading to a truncated gamma B-crystallin. The defect in the Crygh gene is causative for the stop of lens fiber cell differentiation from embryonic day 15.5 onward. Besides the lens, no further ocular tissue is affected. The Cat2 mouse mutants are interesting models for human cataracts caused by mutations in the gamma-crystallin genes at human chromosome 2q32-35. The ak, Cat3 and Cat2 mutants are discussed in the context of other mutants affecting early eye and lens development. Additionally, human congenital cataracts are discussed, which have been characterized similar to the mouse models. The overview of the three types of mutants demonstrates that genes, which affect the early eye development, e.g. at the lens vesicle stage, have consequences for the development of the whole eye. In contrast, if the mutation influences later steps of lens differentiation, the consequences are restricted to the lens only. These data indicate a decreasing effect of the lens for the regulation of eye development during embryogenesis.

Genetic activity profiles of anticancer drugs

The results from short-term tests for genetic and related effects, abstracted from the open literature for 36 anticancer drugs, are examined in this review. Data for 27 of these agents are available in the EPA/IARC Genetic Activity Profile (GAP) database. Data summaries, including data listings and activity profiles, are presented for nine anticancer drugs added to the GAP database for this analysis. Genetic toxicity data from the recent literature are included for the additional agents to provide a broader representation of the categories of drugs being evaluated. These categories, based on the chemical mode of action, are covalent and noncovalent DNA-binding drugs, topoisomerase II inhibitors, antimetabolites, mitotic spindle inhibitors, and drugs which affect endocrine function. The qualitative data for all 36 drugs are summarized in this report and findings are presented from pair-wise matching of genetic activity profiles, based on test results in common, for some chemical analogs. The significance of germ cell test results for some of these drugs and their implication in assessing risk of heritable genetic disease are discussed.

Genetic aspects of embryonic eye development in vertebrates

The vertebrate eye comprises tissues from different embryonic origins, e.g., iris and ciliary body are derived from the wall of the diencephalon via optic vesicle and optic cup. Lens and cornea, on the other hand, come from the overlying surface ectoderm. The timely action of transcription factors and inductive signals ensure the correct development of the different eye components. Establishing the genetic basis of eye defects has been an important tool for the detailed analysis of this complex process. One of the main control genes for eye development was discovered by the analysis of the allelic series of the Small eye mouse mutants and characterized as Pax6. It is involved in the interaction between the optic cup and the overlaying ectoderm. The central role for Pax6 in eye development is conserved throughout the animal kingdom as the murine Pax6 gene induces ectopic eyes in transgenic Drosophila despite the obvious diverse organization of the eye in the fruit fly compared to vertebrates. In human, mutations in the PAX6 gene are responsible for aniridia and Peter's anomaly. In addition to Pax6, other mutations affecting the interaction of the optic cup and the lens placode have been documented in the mouse. For the differentiation of the retina from the optic cup several genes are responsible: Mi leads to microphthalmia, if mutated, and encodes for a transcription factor, which is expressed in the melanocytes of the pigmented layer of the retina. In addition, further genes are implicated in the correct development of the retina, e.g., Chx10, Dlx1, GH6, Msx1 and -2, Otx1 and -2, or Wnt7b. Mutations within the retinoblastoma gene (RB1) are responsible for retinal tumors. Knock-out mutants of RB1 exhibit a block of lens differentiation prior to the retinal defect. Besides the influence of Rb1, the lens differentiates under the influence of growth factors (e.g., FGF, IGF, PDGF, TGF), and specific genes become activated encoding cytoskeletal proteins (e.g., filensin, phakinin, vimentin), structural proteins (e.g., crystallins) or membrane proteins (e.g., Mip). The optic nerve originates from the neural retina; ganglion cells grow to the optic stalk, forming the optic nerve. Its retrograde walk to the brain through the rudiment of the optic stalk depends on the correct Pax2 expression.

Mutagenesis and human genetic disease: an introduction

This special issue attempts to provide a fresh perspective on the importance of germ-cell mutagenesis studies and restate the questions and challenges inherent in efforts to minimize the incidence of human genetic diseases. We are working in a time when rapidly advancing molecular technologies provide the tools that permit a more detailed understanding of germ-cell mutagenesis and genetic disease. Meanwhile, discoveries of new genetic disease phenomena challenge our abilities to conceive and develop research models for their study. It is hoped that the collection of articles in this issue will serve to stimulate interest in scientists of varied disciplines and help focus those interests on the issues surrounding the relationship between environmental mutagens and human genetic disease.