In vitro enhancement of the mutagenicity of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine by plant S-9

Evidence for different mechanisms of action behind the mutagenic effects of 4-NOPD and OPD: the role of DNA damage, oxidative stress and an imbalanced nucleotide pool

The mutagenicity of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (4-NOPD) and o-phenylenediamine (OPD) was compared using the Mouse Lymphoma Assay (MLA) with or without metabolic activation (S9). As expected, OPD was found to be a more potent mutagen than 4-NOPD. To evaluate possible mechanisms behind their mutagenic effects, the following end points were also monitored in cells that had been exposed to similar concentrations of the compounds as in the MLA: general DNA damage (using a standard protocol for the Comet assay); oxidative DNA damage (using a modified procedure for the Comet assay in combination with the enzyme hOGG1); reactive oxygen species (ROS; using the CM-H2DCFDA assay); and the balance of the nucleotide pool (measured after conversion to the corresponding nucleosides dC, dT, dG and dA using high-performance liquid chromatography). Both compounds increased the level of general DNA damage. Again, OPD was found to be more potent than 4-NOPD (which only increased the level of general DNA damage in the presence of S9). Although less obvious for OPD, both compounds increased the level of oxidative DNA damage. However, an increase in intracellular ROS was only observed in cells exposed to 4-NOPD, both with and without S9 (which in itself induced oxidative stress). Both compounds decreased the concentrations of dA, dT and dC. A striking effect of OPD was the sharp reduction of dA observed already at very low concentration, both with and without S9 (which in itself affected the precursor pool). Taken together, our results indicate that indirect effects on DNA, possibly related to an unbalanced nucleotide pool, mediate the mutagenicity and DNA-damaging effects of 4-NOPD and OPD to a large extent. Although induction of intracellular oxidative stress seems to be a possible mechanism behind the genotoxicity of 4-NOPD, this pathway seems to be of less importance for the more potent mutagen OPD.

Differential mutagenic response of Salmonella typhimurium to the plant-metabolized organophosphorus insecticides, phoxim and azinphos methyl

The plant cell/microbe coincubation assay was used to analyze organophosphorus insecticide activation. Salmonella typhimurium strains TA98 and TA100 were exposed to several concentrations of the pesticides phoxim and azinphos methyl with and without TX1 cell line of Nicotiana tabacum activation. When the bacterial strains were treated directly with phoxim, mutagenic activity increased significantly. In contrast, no mutagenic activity was detected with plant activation. Azinphos methyl inhibited the growth of Salmonella strains without plant activation. The coincubation with N. tabacum increased mutagenic activity significantly. These findings and those obtained in animals demonstrated that azinphos-methyl was an indirect mutagen or pro-mutagen activated by the plant metabolism.

Metabolic activation of three arylamines and two organophosphorus insecticides by coriander (Coriandrum sativum) a common edible vegetable

Organophosphorus insecticides and arylamines, widely distributed in the environment, can be activated into mutagens by plants. Plant activation of three aromatic amines, 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP), m-phenylenediamine (m-PDA) and 2-aminofluorene (2AF), and two organophosphorus insecticides, dimethoate and methyl parathion has been the focus of this study. The plant cell/microbe coincubation assay was used employing coriander (Coriandrum sativum) suspended cell cultures as the activating system. Interestingly, this vegetable is included in the Mexican diet and ingested generally uncooked and could have epidemiological consequences. As a genetic end point, the Salmonella typhimurium tester strain TA98 was used. Protein contents, as well as peroxidase activity and peroxidase activity inhibited by diethyldithiocarbamate (DEDTC) of coriander cultures were determined after the coculture. Coriander cells highly activated three aromatic amines, NOP, m-PDA and 2-AF to mutagenic products detected in Salmonella. On the other hand, insecticides were only lightly activated, probably because peroxidase activity of coriander cells was inhibited, corroborated by DEDTC peroxidase inhibition. In all the assays, NOP was the more potent mutagenic compound. The results demonstrated that coriander cells were metabolically competent and suitable for a plant cell microbe coincubation assay, developed to analyze the promutagen activation by plant systems and can be used as a indicator of potential genetic effects.

Mechanism of antimutagenic action of (+)-catechin against the plant-activated aromatic amine 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine

Aromatic amines are activated into mutagens by both animal and plant systems. For plant-activated aromatic amines an important step in this process involves peroxidase enzymes. 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP) is a well known direct-acting mutagen that can be enhanced in mutagenic potency by intact plant cells and also by isolated peroxidase enzymes. This activation process is inhibited by several different chemical agents including potassium cyanide (KCn), a known peroxidase inhibitor, and (+)-catechin. In our laboratory both KCn and (+)-catechin inhibited peroxidase-mediated NOP activation into a Salmonella mutagen. However, while KCn demonstrated strong peroxidase enzyme inhibition (as measured biochemically), (+)-catechin showed only minimal inhibition of peroxidase. Experiments comparing NOP direct and plant-activated mutagenic activity to different Salmonella strains (in the presence and absence of (+)-catechin) suggest that (+)-catechin may inhibit the mutagenic process by limiting O-acetyltransferase (OAT) activity in Salmonella. OAT activity in Salmonella is a required process for mutations to be induced following treatment with NOP and other aromatic amines.

Development and validation of alternative metabolic systems for mutagenicity testing in short-term assays

We present here the results obtained within the framework of an EU funded project aimed to develop and validate alternative metabolic activating systems to be used in short-term mutagenicity assays, in order to reduce the use of laboratory animals for toxicology testing. The activating systems studied were established cell lines (Hep G2, CHEL), genetically engineered V79 cell lines expressing specific rat cytochromes P450, erythrocyte-derived systems, CYP-mimetic chemical systems and plant homogenates. The metabolically competent cell lines were used as indicator cells for genotoxic effects as well as for the preparation of external activating systems using other indicator cells. The following endpoints were used: micronuclei, chromosomal aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges, mutations at the hprt locus, gene mutations in bacteria (Ames test), unscheduled DNA synthesis and DNA breaks detected in the comet assay. All metabolic systems employed activated some promutagens. With some of them, promutagens belonging to many different classes of chemicals were activated to genotoxicants, including carcinogens negative in liver S9-mediated assays. In other cases, the use of the new activating systems allowed the detection of mutagens at much lower substrate concentrations than in liver S9-mediated assays. Therefore, the alternative metabolizing systems, which do not require the use of laboratory animals, have a substantial potential in in vitro toxicology, in the basic genotoxicity testing as well as in the elucidation of activation mechanisms. However, since the data basis is much smaller for the new systems than for the activating systems produced from subcellular liver preparations, the overlapping use of both systems is recommended for the present and near future. For example, liver S9 preparations may be used with some indicator systems (e.g., bacterial mutagenicity), and metabolically competent mammalian cell lines may be used with other indicator systems (e.g., a cytogenetic endpoint) in a battery of basic tests.

Activation of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine by the S2 fraction of Zea mays to mutagenic product(s)

Studies on plant metabolic activation with the S2 fraction from Zea mays have been developed. The 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP) activation by S2 has been analyzed with the Ames test as a short-term assay. The NOP mutagenic potency was increased two-fold by S2, while rat liver S9 produced the contrary effect. The presence of a NADPH-generating system and the treatment of S2 with CO do not modify S2 activation of NOP. In this fraction, neither cytochrome P450 nor some enzymatic activities depending on cyt-P450 (aniline hydroxylase and aminopyrine demethylase) were detected. Therefore, the enhancement of NOP mutagenic potency by S2 is independent of the mixed-function oxidase system. On the other hand, inhibitors of the peroxidase activity such as N-acetyl-p-aminophenol caused a partial inhibition of S2 activation of NOP. Likewise, diethyldithiocarbamate produced both a reduction of the S2 peroxidase activity in biochemical assays and a partial inhibition of S2 activation of NOP. Moreover, it was possible to find a direct correlation between the activity of peroxidase per plate of both the S2 fraction and horseradish peroxidase and the number of revertants induced by NOP in the TA98 strain. On the basis of these results, we report that a HRP-like peroxidase activity must be the main pathway of NOP activation by the plant metabolic activation system studied in this work.

The metabolic activation of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine by chlorophyll-containing plant extracts: the relationship between mutagenicity and antimutagenicity

Chlorophyllin, the sodium and copper salt of chlorophyll, chlorophyll a, and chlorophyll b were tested for their ability to inhibit the mutagenic activity of the direct-acting mutagen 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP) and its plant-activated mutagenic enhancement. All three forms of chlorophyll were antimutagenic against both NOP and its plant-activated product, with chlorophyllin proving most effective. Chlorophyll-containing plant extracts, however, proved very efficient at activating NOP into a mutagen of greater potency. When these extracts were assayed for total chlorophyll content it was found that they contained far less chlorophyll than was required for an antimutagenic effect to occur. Thus, the balance between chemical mutagen activation and/or enhancement by chlorophyll-containing plant extracts and the potential antimutagenicity of these plant extracts is a function of chlorophyll concentration. The data presented here indicate that this balance must be taken into consideration in future studies investigating the efficacy of complex natural plant extracts as antimutagenic substances.

Activation of two environmental mixtures by plant S9

Nitrated and ozonized pyrene mixtures were assayed for their mutagenic activity in the presence or absence of pea S9 using Salmonella typhimurium TA98 as the indicator organism. The plant enzymes increased the mutagenic response of these mixtures above that obtained in the absence of S9. The optimum S9 protein concentration for the activation of the nitrated pyrene mixture at 0.1 microgram was 3.9 mg/plate whereas that for the ozonized pyrene mixture at 33.3 micrograms was 3.2 mg protein/plate. BSA could not replace S9, and NADPH was a required co-factor in the activation of both mixtures by pea S9. Although the nitrated pyrene mixture was determined to consist of approximately 90% 1-nitropyrene, the mutagenic response due to this compound ranged from 30 to 50% of that of the mixture.

Mutagenic activity of promutagens in plants: indirect evidence of their activation

This review summarizes data concerning mutagenic activity of promutagens in various plant in vivo assays. These data are compared with the present knowledge about the metabolism of xenobiotics and activation of promutagens in plants obtained by biochemical studies and by the separation of the activation process from the genetic endpoints assayed for the mutagenicity. The article documents a differential response of plant species in the endogenous transforming of various classes of promutagens into mutagens. Attention is devoted to the following types of promutagens: nitrosamines, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and aromatic amines, aflatoxins, pyrrolizidine alkaloids, diallate, styrene, vinylchloride, ethanol, cycasin, nitrofurans, sodium azide, s-triazine herbicides, 1,2-dibromoethane and maleic hydrazide.

Studies on the use of plant extracts in assessing the effects of plant metabolism on the mutagenicity and toxicity of pesticides

We have carried out studies on the effects of plant metabolism on the mutagenicity of agricultural chemicals. Our approach is to use a cell-free plant extract, as a source of metabolic enzymes, in a standard Ames test. Using a number of test compounds, we observe that plant metabolism can alter the mutagenicity of several pesticides, and can in some instances give rise to metabolites apparently unique from those which are formed in animal cells. A number of parameters of the assay have been examined, and we find that the assay temperature and preincubation of the pesticide with the extract can significantly alter the outcome of the test. We also have devised a method of controlling for the effects that natural extracts can have on the spontaneous reversion rate of the Salmonella tester strains, in an effort to distinguish slight mutagenic responses from the effects of nutrients (e.g. histidine for his- bacteria) in the assay.

Mutagenicity of selected aniline derivatives to Salmonella following plant activation and mammalian hepatic activation

We compared several phenylenediamines (4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine, NOP; 2-nitro-p-phenylenediamine, NPD; o-phenylenediamine, OPD; p-phenylenediamine, PPD; m-phenylenediamine, MPD) and aniline (ANL) for mutagenicity to Salmonella directly and following activation by plant and mammalian hepatic S9 using plate incorporation and preincubation protocols. In addition, we assayed each chemical for activation by intact plant cells using the plant cell/microbe coincubation protocol. At the concentrations tested, NOP, NPD, OPD, MPD and ANL were active in one or more assays. NPD, OPD and MPD were activated by mammalian hepatic S9 in one or more assay and each was activated by plant S9 or intact plant cells. ANL was mutagenic only in the presence of plant S9. PPD was not active under any of the test conditions.

Plant cells at different stages in their growth curve differentially activate promutagens

Mutagenic activity of the promutagens 2-aminofluorene (2AF) and a contaminant of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP-X) was followed in Ames Salmonella strain TA98 following metabolism by cotton and carrot cell suspension cultures using the plant cell/microbe coincubation assay. Both cell lines were capable of activating each chemical. However, activation capacities of the cell lines differed relative to their respective stage of growth when used. For 2AF activation early-log phase cotton cells and mid-log phase carrot cells proved superior while mid-log phase cotton cells and stationary phase carrot cells proved superior for NOP-X activation. These data indicate that the phase of the growth cycle at which plant cells are harvested can significantly affect their promutagen activation potential.

Tulipa gesneriana bulb extracts activate promutagenic 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene in the salmonella/ames assay

Crude extracts from Tulipa gesneriana bulbs have been tested for their ability to activate 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA) in the Salmonella mutagenicity assay. Bacteria of strain TA98 were incubated for 30 min at 37 degrees C with the mixture of the promutagen and bulb extracts prior to plating. The frequency of his+ revertants increased in relation to both the promutagenic dose and the amount of bulb extract in the mixture, and under optimal conditions, was more than 50 times higher than the value found after the action of the promutagen alone. Addition of NADP and glucose 6-phosphate to the incubation mixture did not seem to be obligatory.

In vitro activation of chemicals by plants: a comparison of techniques

We have studied the ability of two in vitro plant activation techniques to enhance the mutagenicity of 4-nitro-o-phenylenediamine (NOP) and to activate 2-aminofluorene (2AF). Mutagenic activities of NOP and 2AF were both increased by plant S9 in the Salmonella plate-incorporation and preincubation assays. They were also increased during preincubation with intact plant cells. NOP mutagenic activity was enhanced to a similar extent by plant S9 and by intact plant cells in Salmonella assay, whereas 2AF was activated more extensively by the plant cells than by plant S9. NOP was not enhanced by mammalian hepatic S9 in any assay, whereas 2AF was activated by hepatic S9 under all conditions tested.