Impact of oncogene panel results on surgical management of cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules

RAS-Mutant Follicular Thyroid Tumors: A Continuous Challenge for Pathologists

The classification of thyroid nodules, particularly those with a follicular growth pattern, has significantly evolved. These tumors, enriched with RAS or RAS-like mutations, remain challenging for pathologists due to variables such as nuclear atypia, invasion, mitotic activity, and tumor necrosis. This review addresses the histological correlates of benign, low-risk, and malignant RAS-mutant thyroid tumors, as well as some difficult-to-classify follicular nodules with worrisome features. One prototypical RAS-mutant nodule is non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features (NIFTP). The assessment of nuclear characteristics in encapsulated/well-demarcated non-invasive RAS-mutant follicular-patterned tumors helps distinguish between follicular thyroid adenoma (FTA) and NIFTP. Despite this straightforward concept, questions about the degree of nuclear atypia necessary for the diagnosis of NIFTP are common in clinical practice. The nomenclature of follicular nodules lacking clear invasive features with increased mitotic activity, tumor necrosis, and/or high-risk mutations (e.g., TERT promoter or TP53) remains debated. Invasion, particularly angioinvasion, is the current hallmark of malignancy in RAS-mutant follicular-patterned neoplasms, with follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC) as the model. Assessing the tumor interface is critical, though full capsule evaluation can be challenging. Multiple levels and NRASQ61R-specific immunohistochemistry can aid in identifying invasion. Controversies around vascular invasion persist, with ancillary stains like CD31, ERG, and CD61 aiding in its evaluation. Moreover, the review highlights that invasive encapsulated follicular variant papillary thyroid carcinoma (IEFVPTC) is closely associated with FTC, suggesting the need for better nomenclature. The concept of "high-grade" differentiated carcinomas, applicable to FTC or IEFVPTC with necrosis and/or high mitotic activity, is also discussed.

Molecular Pathology of Thyroid Tumors: Old Problems and New Concepts

The molecular signatures of many thyroid tumors have been uncovered. These discoveries have translated into clinical practice and are changing diagnostic and tumor classification paradigms. Here, the findings of recent studies are presented with special emphasis on how molecular insights are impacting the understating of RAS mutant thyroid nodules, Hürthel cell neoplasms, and unusual thyroid tumors, such as hyalinizing trabecular tumor, secretory carcinoma of the thyroid, and sclerosing mucoepidermoid carcinoma with eosinophilia. In addition, the utility of detecting actionable molecular alterations by immunohistochemistry in advanced and aggressive thyroid cancer is also discussed.

Risk of malignancy in cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules harboring thyroid stimulating hormone receptor mutations

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the frequency and risk of malignancy of TSHRpI568T mutations discovered in indeterminate thyroid nodules (ITN) within the Veracyte CLIA laboratory undergoing Afirma^® Genomic Sequencing Classifier (GSC) testing, and to evaluate a broader cohort of TSHR variants and their categorization as Afirma GSC benign (GSC-B) or suspicious (GSC-S). Finally, we seek to assess the risk of malignancy (ROM) of this group of TSHR mutated ITN in the GSC-S category.

METHODS

ITN submitted to Veracyte for Afirma GSC testing between October 2017 and February 2022 were analyzed for TSHR variants and rates of GSC-B and GSC-S were calculated based upon BIII or IV cytology, by TSHR variant codon amino acid (AA) substitution, age, and gender. For GSC-S samples, surgical pathology reports were requested, and the rate of malignancy was calculated.

RESULTS

Five percent of the ITN samples harbored an isolated TSHR variant and 5% of those were classified as GSC-S. Among TSHRpI568T samples, 96% were GSC-B and of the GSC-S samples, 21% were malignant. Among an unselected group of TSHR, absent TSHRpI568T mutations, 16.3% of GSC-S samples were malignant, all but one with codon mutations in the transmembrane subdomains of the TSHR. This prompted a dedicated evaluation of transmembrane codons which revealed a malignancy rate of 10.7% among GSC-S nodules. In total, 13/85 (15.3%) TSHR mutated ITN with Afirma GSC-S results were found to be malignant.

CONCLUSIONS

TSHR variants are rare in ITN, and most are categorized as benign under Afirma GSC testing which carries a < 4% risk of malignancy. For GSC-S ITN with TSHR mutations, the risk of malignancy is ≥= 15%, which is clinically meaningful and may alter treatment or monitoring recommendations for patients.

Development of a Molecular Assay for Detection and Quantification of the BRAF Variation in Residual Tissue From Thyroid Nodule Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy Specimens

Importance

Thyroid cancer, predominantly papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), is common, but an estimated 30% of ultrasonography-guided fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of thyroid nodules are indeterminate. BRAF variation, associated with poor clinicopathological characteristics, is a useful molecular marker for diagnostics.

Objective

To develop a sensitive molecular assay for BRAF V600E detection in remaining tissue of thyroid FNA biopsies to identify patients with cancer carrying a BRAF variation.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This diagnostic study used tumor tissue from surgical formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimens and residual tissue from thyroid FNA biopsies for genomic DNA extraction. FFPE specimens served as the validation set, and residual tissue from FNA biopsies served as the test set. A molecular assay was developed for accurate detection of BRAF V600E variation using locked nucleic acid (LNA) probe-based droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (dPCR), and the assay was validated by BRAF V600E immunohistochemical staining (IHC). The study was conducted between February 2019 and May 2021.

Results

A total of 271 specimens, including 77 FFPE specimens (with a follow-up of 48 matched surgical specimens) and 146 residual FNA samples, were collected from 223 patients (mean [SD] age, 53.8 [15.3] years; 174 [78.0%] women; 49 [22.0%] men). The molecular assay by dPCR was first established to specifically and accurately detect and quantify wild-type BRAF and variant BRAF in DNA from human follicular thyroid carcinoma-derived FTC-133 and papillary thyroid carcinoma-derived BCPAP cells. The linearity of quantification of BRAF V600E was calculated (y = 0.7339x; R2 = 0.9996) with sensitivity at 0.02 copies/μL and reproducibility in detecting variant DNA at various dilutions(coefficient of variance in 0.3% DNA, 9.63%; coefficient of variance in 1.0% DNA, 7.41%). In validation testing, the dPCR assay and IHC staining exhibited 100% specificity in concordantly identifying BRAF V600E in PTCs (κ = 0.873; P < .001) and sensitivity of 32.0% (95% CI, 19.1% to 44.9%) in dPCR and 26.0% (95% CI, 13.1% to 38.9%) in IHC staining, with an improvement by 23.08% in dPCR compared with the IHC staining. The dPCR assay further detected BRAF V600E in 39 of 146 residual FNA specimens (26.7%). At short-term follow-up, 48 patients, including 14 of 39 patients with BRAF variation and 34 of 107 patients without BRAF variation on residual FNA specimens, underwent resection. The dPCR assay of BRAF status in the matched surgical specimens showed BRAF V600E variations in 12 patients and wild-type BRAF in 36 patients, with a high agreement to that in residual tissue of FNA specimens (κ = 0.789; P < .001). Among 14 patients with BRAF variations on residual FNA, 13 were diagnosed with PTC and 1 was diagnosed with anaplastic thyroid cancer at the thyroidectomy.

Conclusions and Relevance

This diagnostic study developed a sensitive molecular assay for detection and quantification of BRAF V600E variation in residual tissue from thyroid FNA biopsies to identify patients with cancer harboring BRAF V600E in a cost-effective manner, highlighting the clinical value of molecular assay of the remaining FNA tissue in the management of thyroid nodules.

Thyroid nodules: diagnostic evaluation based on thyroid cancer risk assessment

Thyroid nodules are extremely common and can be detected by sensitive imaging in more than 60% of the general population. They are often identified in patients without symptoms who are undergoing evaluation for other medical complaints. Indiscriminate evaluation of thyroid nodules with thyroid biopsy could cause a harmful epidemic of diagnoses of thyroid cancer, but inadequate selection of thyroid nodules for biopsy can lead to missed diagnoses of clinically relevant thyroid cancer. Recent clinical guidelines advocate a more conservative approach in the evaluation of thyroid nodules based on risk assessment for thyroid cancer, as determined by clinical and ultrasound features to guide the need for biopsy. Moreover, newer evidence suggests that for patients with indeterminate thyroid biopsy results, a combined assessment including the initial ultrasound risk stratification or other ancillary testing (molecular markers, second opinion on thyroid cytology) can further clarify the risk of thyroid cancer and the management strategies. This review summarizes the clinical importance of adequate evaluation of thyroid nodules, focuses on the clinical evidence for diagnostic tests that can clarify the risk of thyroid cancer, and highlights the importance of considering the patient's values and preferences when deciding on management strategies in the setting of uncertainty about the risk of thyroid cancer.

Thyroid follicular microcarcinoma

Differentiated thyroid cancers are the most common malignancies arising in thyroid gland. Papillary thyroid cancer presents a very favorable prognosis, while follicular type is slightly more aggressive, mainly for its attitude to hematogenous spreading with distant metastases. Papillary microcarcinoma (10 mm or less) has an excellent prognosis, largely demonstrated, and its management is changed in the last few years, reducing surgical procedure, role of radio iodine ablation (RAI) and TSH suppression. But no effective data are available for follicular thyroid microcarcinoma (mFTC); very few reports and studies are present in literature about mFTC, mainly for its low incidence. Aim of this paper is to review current literature to reach, in absence of evidence, some suggestion in managing mFTC.

Molecular Variants and Their Risks for Malignancy in Cytologically Indeterminate Thyroid Nodules

Background: Gene panels are routinely used to assess predisposition to hereditary cancers by simultaneously testing multiple susceptibility genes and/or variants. More recently, genetic panels have been implemented as part of solid tumor malignancy testing assessing somatic alterations. One example is targeted variant panels for thyroid nodules that are not conclusively malignant or benign upon fine-needle aspiration (FNA). We systematically reviewed published studies from 2009 to 2018 that contained genetic data from preoperative FNA specimens on cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules (ITNs) that subsequently underwent surgical resection. Pooled prevalence estimates per gene and variant, along with their respective positive predictive values (PPVs) for malignancy, were calculated. Summary: Our systematic search identified 540 studies that were supplemented by 18 studies from bibliographies or personal files. Sixty-one studies met all inclusion criteria and included >4600 ITNs. Overall, 26% of nodules contained at least 1 variant or fusion. However, half of them did not include details on the specific gene, variant, and/or complete fusion pair reported for inclusion toward PPV calculations. The PPVs of genomic alterations reported at least 10 times were limited to BRAF^V600E (98%, 95% confidence interval [CI 96-99%]), PAX8/PPARG (55% [CI 34-78%]), HRAS^Q61R (45% [CI 22-72%]), BRAF^K601E (42% [CI 19-68%]), and NRAS^Q61R (38% [CI 23-55%]). Excluding BRAF^V600E, the pooled PPV for all other specified variants and fusions was 47%. Multiple variants within the same nodule were identified in ∼1% of ITN and carried a cumulative PPV of 77%. Conclusions: The chance that a genomic alteration predicts malignancy depends on the individual variant or fusion detected. Only five alterations were reported at least 10 times; BRAF^V600E had a PPV of 98%, while the remaining four had individual PPVs ranging from 38% to 55%. The small sample size of most variants and fusion pairs found among ITNs, however, limits confidence in their individual PPV point estimates. Better specific reporting of genomic alterations with cytological category, histological subtype, and cancer staging would facilitate better understanding of cancer prediction, and the independent contribution of the genomic profile to prognosis.

Association of Tumor Size With Histologic and Clinical Outcomes Among Patients With Cytologically Indeterminate Thyroid Nodules

Importance

Tens of thousands of unnecessary operations are performed each year for diagnostic purposes among patients with cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules. Whereas a diagnostic lobectomy is recommended for most patients with solitary indeterminate thyroid nodules, a total thyroidectomy is preferred for nodules larger than 4 cm.

Objective

To determine whether histologic or clinical outcomes of indeterminate thyroid nodules 4 cm or larger are worse than those for nodules smaller than 4 cm, thus justifying a more aggressive initial surgical approach.

Design, Setting, and Participants

In this retrospective cohort study, 652 indeterminate thyroid nodules (546 nodules <4 cm and 106 nodules ≥4 cm) with surgical follow-up were consecutively evaluated at an academic cancer center from October 1, 2008, through April 30, 2016.

Exposure

Tumor size.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Differences in cancer rates, rates of invasive features, cancer aggressiveness, and response to therapy between indeterminate thyroid nodules smaller than 4 cm and 4 cm or larger.

Results

A total of 652 indeterminate thyroid nodules (546 nodules <4 cm and 106 nodules ≥4 cm) from 589 patients (mean [SD] age, 53.1 [13.8] years; 453 [76.9%] female) were studied. No differences were found in the baseline characteristics of patients or nodules between the 2 size groups. Tumor size was not associated with the cancer rate as a categorical (140 of 546 [25.6%] for nodules <4 cm and 33 of 106 [31.1%] for nodules ≥4 cm; effect size, 0.05; 95% CI, 0.002-0.12) or continuous (odds ratio [OR], 1.03; 95% CI, 0.92-1.15) variable. No association was found between nodule size and prevalence of extrathyroidal extension, positive margins, lymphovascular invasion, lymph node metastasis, or distant metastasis. Most malignant tumors were low risk in both size groups (70% in the nodules <4 cm and 72% in the nodules ≥4 cm), and tumor size was not associated with tumor aggressiveness as a categorical (effect size, 0.10; 95% CI, 0.03-0.31) or continuous variable (OR for intermediate-risk cancer, 0.91; 95% CI, 0.72-1.14; OR for high-risk cancer, 1.43; 95% CI, 0.96-2.15). At the last follow-up visit, 88 of 105 patients (83.8%) with malignant tumors in the smaller than 4 cm group and 21 of 25 (84.0%) in the 4 cm or greater group had no evidence of disease, and tumor size was not associated with response to therapy (effect size, 0.13; 95% CI, 0.07-0.33).

Conclusions and Relevance

Most indeterminate thyroid nodules are benign or low-risk malignant tumors regardless of tumor size. In the absence of other indications for total thyroidectomy, this study suggests that a thyroid lobectomy is sufficient initial treatment for most solitary cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules independent of the tumor size.

Role of Ancillary Techniques in Thyroid Cytology Specimens

Ancillary molecular testing has emerged as a promising way to refine the preoperative risk stratification of thyroid nodules with indeterminate fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy results. Commercially available molecular tests for thyroid FNAs include those that analyze samples for mutations and gene fusions, gene expression alterations, microRNA expression alterations, chromosomal copy number alterations, or a combination thereof. This review summarizes the performance characteristics of the most current iterations of three tests currently marketed for cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules: ThyroSeq v3, ThyGeNEXT/ThyraMIR, and Afirma Gene Sequencing Classifier.

Analytical and Clinical Validation of Expressed Variants and Fusions From the Whole Transcriptome of Thyroid FNA Samples

Introduction: The Afirma® Xpression Atlas (XA) detects gene variants and fusions in thyroid nodule FNA samples from a curated panel of 511 genes using whole-transcriptome RNA-sequencing. Its intended use is among cytologically indeterminate nodules that are Afirma GSC suspicious, Bethesda V/VI nodules, or known thyroid metastases. Here we report its analytical and clinical validation. Methods: DNA and RNA were purified from the same sample across 943 blinded FNAs and compared by multiple methodologies, including whole-transcriptome RNA-seq, targeted RNA-seq, and targeted DNA-seq. An additional 695 blinded FNAs were used to define performance for fusions between whole-transcriptome RNA-seq and targeted RNA-seq. We quantified the reproducibility of the whole-transcriptome RNA-seq assay across laboratories and reagent lots. Finally, variants and fusions were compared to histopathology results. Results: Of variants detected in DNA at 5 or 20% variant allele frequency, 74 and 88% were also detected by XA, respectively. XA variant detection was 89% when compared to an alternative RNA-based detection method. Low levels of expression of the DNA allele carrying the variant, compared with the wild-type allele, was found in some variants not detected by XA. 82% of gene fusions detected in a targeted RNA fusion assay were detected by XA. Conversely, nearly all variants or fusions detected by XA were confirmed by an alternative method. Analytical validation studies demonstrated high intra-plate reproducibility (89%-94%), inter-plate reproducibility (86-91%), and inter-lab accuracy (90%). Multiple variants and fusions previously described across the spectrum of thyroid cancers were identified by XA, including some with approved or investigational targeted therapies. Among 190 Bethesda III/IV nodules, the sensitivity of XA as a standalone test was 49%. Conclusion: When the Afirma Genomic Sequencing Classifier (GSC) is used first among Bethesda III/IV nodules as a rule-out test, XA supplements genomic insight among those that are GSC suspicious. Our data clinically and analytically validate XA for use among GSC suspicious, or Bethesda V/VI nodules. Genomic information provided by XA may inform clinical decision-making with precision medicine insights across a broad range of FNA sample types encountered in the care of patients with thyroid nodules and thyroid cancer.

Thyroid Nodules with Indeterminate Cytology: Utility of the American Thyroid Association Sonographic Patterns for Cancer Risk Stratification

BACKGROUND

The 2015 American Thyroid Association (ATA) guidelines recommend using a classification based on sonographic patterns to set the size threshold for biopsies. Each pattern is associated with a distinct estimated rate of malignancy that it was hypothesized should stratify the risk of malignancy of cytologically indeterminate thyroid nodules (ITNs).

METHODS

Ultrasound images of 463 ITNs (38% atypia/follicular lesions of undetermined significance; 62% follicular neoplasms) with histological follow-up consecutively evaluated between October 2008 and June 2015 at the authors' academic cancer center were independently evaluated by three observers and classified into one of the five sonographic patterns proposed by the ATA. Nodules with sonographic patterns not defined in the classification were grouped into a non-ATA pattern category. Differences in clinical and histological findings between the sonographic patterns were assessed. The prevalence of malignancy and odds ratio for malignancy were calculated for each sonographic pattern (low and intermediate patterns were collapsed for the analysis).

RESULTS

The distribution of size and cytological diagnosis was significantly different between sonographic patterns (p < 0.001). The overall rate of malignancy was 27%. The rate of malignancy for the very low, low/intermediate, high, and non-ATA patterns were 0%, 19%, 56%, and 36%, respectively, and were all significantly different. Compared to the low/intermediate suspicion patterns, the odds ratios for malignancy were 2.35 for the non-ATA and 5.18 for the high suspicion patterns (p < 0.001). The odds ratio of the non-ATA pattern was 0.45 over the high suspicion pattern (p = 0.04). Results were similar in both cytological categories and for each observer separately. Sonographic patterns were associated with distinct histopathological profiles (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

ATA sonographic patterns are associated with distinct clinical features and pathological outcomes, and effectively stratify the cancer risk in ITNs. Thus, the ATA sonographic patterns should be used not only to set the size threshold for biopsy, but also to personalize management after the biopsy.