A Comparative13C-NMR. Study on Various Reduced Flavins

Solid-state NMR of flavins and flavoproteins

Why apply solid-state NMR (SSNMR) to flavins and flavoproteins? NMR provides information on an atom-specific basis about chemical functionality, structure, proximity to other groups, and dynamics of the system. Thus, it has become indispensable to the study of chemicals, materials, catalysts, and biomolecules. It is no surprise then that NMR has a great deal to offer in the study of flavins and flavoenzymes. In general, their catalytic or electron-transfer activity resides essentially in the flavin, a molecule eminently accessible by NMR. However, the specific reactivity displayed depends on a host of subtle interactions whereby the protein biases and reshapes the flavin's propensities to activate it for one reaction while suppressing other aspects of this cofactor's prodigious repertoire (Massey et al., J Biol Chem 244:3999-4006, 1969; Müller, Z Naturforsch 27B:1023-1026, 1972; Joosten and van Berkel, Curr Opin Struct Biol 11:195-202, 2007). Thus, we are fascinated to learn about how the flavin cofactor of one enzyme is, and is not, like the flavin cofactor of another. In what follows, we describe how the capabilities of SSNMR can help and are beginning to bear fruit in this exciting endeavor.

NMR spectroscopy on flavins and flavoproteins

(1)H-, (11)B-, (13)C-, (15)N-, (17)O-, (19)F-, and (31)P-NMR chemical shifts of flavocoenzymes and derivatives of it, as well as of alloxazines and isoalloxazinium salts, from NMR experiments performed under various experimental conditions (e.g., dependence of the chemical shifts on temperature, concentration, solvent polarity, and pH) are reported. Also solid-state (13)C- and (15)N-NMR experiments are described revealing the anisotropic values of corresponding chemical shifts. These data, in combination with a number of coupling constants, led to a detailed description of the electronic structure of oxidized and reduced flavins. The data also demonstrate that the structure of oxidized flavin can assume a configuration deviating from coplanarity, depending on substitutions in the isoalloxazine ring, while that of reduced flavin exhibits several configurations, from almost planar to quite bended. The complexes formed between oxidized flavin and metal ions or organic molecules revealed three coordination sites with metal ions (depending on the chemical nature of the ion), and specific interactions between the pyrimidine moiety of flavin and organic molecules, mimicking specific interactions between apoflavoproteins and their coenzymes. Most NMR studies on flavoproteins were performed using (13)C- and (15)N-substituted coenzymes, either specifically enriched in the pterin moiety of flavin or uniformly labeled flavins. The chemical shifts of free flavins are used as a guide in the interpretation of the chemical shifts observed in flavoproteins. Although the hydrogen-bonding pattern in oxidized and reduced flavoproteins varies considerably, no correlation is obvious between these patterns and the corresponding redox potentials. In all reduced flavoproteins the N(1)H group of the flavocoenzyme is deprotonated, an exception is thioredoxin reductase. Three-dimensional structures of only a few flavoproteins, mostly belonging to the family of flavodoxins, have been solved. Also the kinetics of unfolding and refolding of flavodoxins has been investigated by NMR techniques. In addition, (31)P-NMR data of all so far studied flavoproteins and some (19)F-NMR spectra are discussed.

13C-, 15N- and 31P-NMR studies of oxidized and reduced low molecular mass thioredoxin reductase and some mutant proteins

Thioredoxin reductase (TrxR) from Escherichia coli, the mutant proteins E159Y and C138S, and the mutant protein C138S treated with phenylmercuric acetate were reconstituted with [U-(13)C(17),U-(15)N(4)]FAD and analysed, in their oxidized and reduced states, by (13)C-, (15)N- and (31)P-NMR spectroscopy. The enzymes studied showed very similar (31)P-NMR spectra in the oxidized state, consisting of two peaks at -9.8 and -11.5 p.p.m. In the reduced state, the two peaks merge into one apparent peak (at -9.8 p.p.m.). The data are compared with published (31)P-NMR data of enzymes closely related to TrxR. (13)C and (15)N-NMR chemical shifts of TrxR and the mutant proteins in the oxidized state provided information about the electronic structure of the protein-bound cofactor and its interactions with the apoproteins. Strong hydrogen bonds exist between protein-bound flavin and the apoproteins at C(2)O, C(4)O, N(1) and N(5). The N(10) atoms in the enzymes are slightly out of the molecular plane of the flavin. Of the ribityl carbon atoms C(10alpha,gamma,delta) are the most affected upon binding to the apoprotein and the large downfield shift of the C(10gamma) atom indicates strong hydrogen bonding with the apoprotein. The hydrogen bonding pattern observed is in excellent agreement with X-ray data, except for the N(1) and the N(3) atoms where a reversed situation was observed. Some chemical shifts observed in C138S deviate considerably from those of the other enzymes. From this it is concluded that C138S is in the FO conformation and the others are in the FR conformation, supporting published data. In the reduced state, strong hydrogen bonding interactions are observed between C(2)O and C(4)O and the apoprotein. As revealed by the (15)N chemical shifts and the N(5)H coupling constant the N(5) and the N(10) atom are highly sp(3) hybridized. The calculation of the endocyclic angles for the N(5) and the N(10) atoms shows the angles to be approximately 109 degrees, in perfect agreement with X-ray data showing that the flavin assumes a bent conformation along the N(10)/N(5) axis of the flavin. In contrast, the N(1) is highly sp(2) hybridized and is protonated, i.e. in the neutral state. Upon reduction of the enzymes, the (13)C chemical shifts of some atoms of the ribityl side chain undergo considerable changes also indicating conformational rearrangements of the side-chain interactions with the apoproteins. The chemical shifts between native TrxR and C138S are now rather similar and differ from those of the two other mutant proteins. This strongly indicates that the former enzymes are in the FO conformation and the other two are in the FR conformation. The data are discussed briefly in the context of published NMR data obtained with a variety of flavoproteins.

Carbon-13 nuclear magnetic resonance study on the dynamics of the conformation of reduced flavin

Several flavin model compounds in the reduced state have been investigated by 13C NMR techniques. The NMR spectra were recorded in dependence of temperature, in the range of 30 to -100 degrees C. The results show that the activation barrier for the ring inversion ("butterfly" motion) is too low to be observed directly. In order to be able to detect the barrier of the ring inversion, it was coupled with a side-chain rotation. In this way, the intrinsic barrier for the ring inversion is increased by the barrier of the side-chain rotation, which allowed detection of the former barrier. It is shown that the intrinsic barrier for the ring inversion is less than 20 kJ/mol. Moreover, it is shown that previous results of Tauscher et al. [Tauscher, L., Ghisla, S., & Hemmerich, P. (1973) Helv. Chim. Acta 56, 630-649] are incorrect and nitrogen inversion is not observed. Symmetry arguments in the dynamic processes are discussed. From the low activation barrier for the ring inversion, it can be concluded that the conformation of the reduced flavin can be easily influenced upon binding to apoflavoproteins. This aspect might be of importance in the regulation of the function of the flavin prosthetic group in biological systems.

An optomechanical transducer in the blue light receptor phototropin from Avena sativa

The PHOT1 (NPH1) gene from Avena sativa specifies the blue light receptor for phototropism, phototropin, which comprises two FMN-binding LOV domains and a serine/threonine protein kinase domain. Light exposure is conducive to autophosphorylation of the protein kinase domain. We have reconstituted a recombinant LOV2 domain of A. sativa phototropin with various (13)C/(15)N-labeled isotopomers of the cofactor, FMN. The reconstituted protein samples were analyzed by NMR spectroscopy under dark and light conditions. Blue light irradiation is shown to result in the addition of a thiol group (cysteine 450) to the 4a position of the FMN chromophore. The adduct reverts spontaneously in the dark by elimination. The light-driven flavin adduct formation results in conformational modification, which was diagnosed by (1)H and (31)P NMR spectroscopy. This conformational change is proposed to initiate the transmission of the light signal via conformational modulation of the protein kinase domain conducive to autophosphorylation of NPH1.

Flavin-protein interactions in flavocytochrome b2 as studied by NMR after reconstitution of the enzyme with 13C- and 15N-labelled flavin

A new procedure was devised for reversibly removing the flavin from flavocytochrome b2. It allowed reconstitution with selectively enriched 13C- and 15N-labelled FMN for an NMR analysis of the chemical shifts of the enriched positions as well as that of 31P. From these measurements, it was possible to deduce information about the hydrogen-bonding pattern of FMN in the protein, the hybridization states of the nitrogen atoms and (in part) the pi-electron distribution. The carbonyl groups at C(2) and C(4) and the nitrogen atoms N(1) and N(5) form hydrogen bonds to the apoenzyme in both redox states. Nevertheless, according to 15N-chemical shifts, the bond from the protein to N(3) is very weak in both redox states, whereas that to N(5) is strong for the oxidized state, and is weakened upon flavin reduction. On the other hand, the 13C-NMR results indicate that the C(2) and C(4) carbonyl oxygens form stronger hydrogen bonds with the enzyme than most other flavoproteins in both redox states. From coupling constant measurements it is shown that the N(3) proton is not solvent accessible. Although no N-H coupling constant could be measured for N(5) in the reduced state due to lack of resolution, N(5) is clearly protonated in flavocytochrome b2 as in all other known flavoproteins. With respect to N(10), it is more sp3-hybridized in the oxidized state than in free FMN, whereas the other nitrogen atoms show a nearly planar structure. In the reduced state, N(5) and N(10) in bound FMN are both more sp3-hybridized than in free FMN, but N(5) exhibits a higher degree of sp3-hybridization than N(10), which is only slightly shifted out of the isoalloxazine plane. In addition, two-electron reduction of the enzyme leads to anion formation on N(1), as indicated by its 15N-chemical shift of N(1) and characteristic upfield shifts of the resonances of C(2), C(4) and C(4a) compared to the oxidized state, as observed for most flavoproteins. 31P-NMR measurements show that the phosphate geometry has changed in enzyme bound FMN compared to the free flavin in water, indicating a strong interaction of the phosphate group with the apoenzyme.

A comparative carbon-13, nitrogen-15, and phosphorus-31 nuclear magnetic resonance study on the flavodoxins from Clostridium MP, Megasphaera elsdenii, and Azotobacter vinelandii

The flavodoxins from Megasphaera elsdenii, Clostridium MP, and Azotobacter vinelandii were studied by 13C, 15N, and 31P NMR techniques by using various selectivity enriched oxidized riboflavin 5'-phosphate (FMN) derivatives. It is shown that the pi electron distribution in protein-bound flavin differs from that of free flavin and depends also on the apoflavoprotein used. In the oxidized state Clostridium MP and M. elsdenii flavodoxins are very similar with respect to specific hydrogen bond interaction between FMN and the apoprotein and the electronic structure of flavin. A. vinelandii flavodoxin differs from these flavodoxins in both respects, but it also differs from Desulfovibrio vulgaris flavodoxin. The similarities between A. vinelandii and D. vulgaris flavodoxins are greater than the similarities with the other two flavodoxins. The differences in the pi electron distribution in the FMN of reduced flavodoxins from A. vinelandii and D. vulgaris are even greater, but the hydrogen bond patterns between the reduced flavins and the apoflavodoxins are very similar. In the reduced state all flavodoxins studied contain an ionized prosthetic group and the isoalloxazine ring is in a planar conformation. The results are compared with existing three-dimensional data and discussed with respect to the various possible mesomeric structures in protein-bound FMN. The results are also discussed in light of the proposed hypothesis that specific hydrogen bonding to the protein-bound flavin determines the specific biological activity of a particular flavoprotein.

Carbon-13 and nitrogen-15 nuclear-magnetic-resonance investigation on Desulfovibrio vulgaris flavodoxin

Desulfovibrio vulgaris apoflavodoxin has been reconstituted with 15N and 13C-enriched riboflavin 5'-phosphate. For the first time all carbon atoms of the isoalloxazine ring of the protein-bound prosthetic group have been investigated. The reconstituted protein was studied in the oxidized and in the two-electron-reduced state. The results are interpreted in terms of specific interactions between the apoprotein and the prosthetic group, and the chemical structure of protein-bound FMN. In the oxidized state weak hydrogen bonds exist between the apoprotein and the N(5), N(3) and O(4 alpha) atoms of FMN. The N(1) and O(2 alpha) atoms of FMN form strong hydrogen bonds. The isoalloxazine ring of FMN is strongly polarized and the N(10) atom shows an increased sp2 hybridisation compared to that of free FMN in aqueous solution. The N(3)-H group is not accessible to bulk solvent, as deduced from the coupling constant of the N(3)-H group. In the reduced state the hydrogen bond pattern is similar to that in the oxidized state and in addition a strong hydrogen bond is observed between the N(5)-H group of FMN and the apoprotein. The reduced prosthetic group possesses a coplanar structure and is ionized. The N(3)-H and N(5)-H groups are not accessible to solvent water. Two-electron reduction of the protein leads to a large electron density increase in the benzene subnucleus of bound FMN compared to that in free FMN. The results are discussed in relation to the published crystallographic data on the protein.

Reinvestigation of the structure of oxidized and reduced flavin: carbon-13 and nitrogen-15 nuclear magnetic resonance study

Several chemically substituted flavins are investigated in the oxidized and the reduced state by 13C and 15N NMR techniques. The dependence on the polarity of the solvent and on the concentration is studied. In combination with already published results, a semiempirical theory is developed to interpret the chemical shifts in terms of the solution structure of flavins. Where possible, the results are compared with crystallographic and light absorption data. In contrast to common ideas, the solution structure of the oxidized state is not fully coplanar, but the N(10) atom is situated out of plane to a certain degree. Polarizing the flavin by hydrogen bonds in a high dielectric medium moves the N(10) atom into the molecular plane, and the flavin molecule becomes coplanar. In the coplanar molecule, pi electrons are delocalized from the N(10) atom mainly to O(2 alpha) and O(4 alpha). The NMR results show that the solution structure of reduced flavin is mainly governed by sterical hindrance and hydrogen bonds. The findings are in contrast to commonly accepted ideas that reduced flavin is strongly bent. In an apolar solvent, the reduced neutral isoalloxazine is only slightly bent. The formation of hydrogen bonds in a protic solvent of a high dielectric constant decreases the bend. The N(10) atom is now almost fully sp2 hybridized, and the N(5) atom has an endocyclic angle of 115-117 degrees, indicating its predominant sp2 character. The results have several important implications for flavin catalysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance investigation of 15N-labeled flavins, free and bound to Megasphaera elsdenii apoflavodoxin

Flavin derivatives, enriched with 15N (approximately equal to 95%) at the four nitrogen atoms of the isoalloxazine ring, have been investigated in the oxidized and the two-electron reduced state by the 15N nuclear magnetic resonance technique. The measurements were conducted with aqueous and chloroform solutions of flavin. A comparison of the chemical shifts of the N(1) and N(5) atoms of oxidized flavin in the two solvents revealed that these atoms are sensitive indicators for possible hydrogen-bridge formation to these atoms. The N(5) atom of oxidized flavin resonates at low field and shifts about 300 ppm upfield upon reduction. A pKa of 6.8 was determined from pH-dependent 15N NMR measurements of the two-electron reduced flavin molecule. In addition it is also shown that reduced flavin in aqueous solution possesses a more coplanar structure than in chloroform solution. The 15N chemical shifts of flavin bound to Megasphaera elsdenii apoflavodoxin indicate that various hydrogen bridges are formed between the prosthetic group and the apoprotein. Especially the N(1) atom of the prosthetic group in the oxidized state seems to form a strong hydrogen bond with the apoprotein. In the reduced state the prosthetic group is bound in the anionic form and possesses an almost coplanar structure. These results are in agreement with published crystallographic data on the related flavodoxin from Clostridium MP. Where possible 15N-1H, 15N-15N and 13C-15N coupling constants were determined. Some of the coupling constants are useful parameters for the elucidation of the planarity of free and protein-bound flavin and for the evaluation of the interaction between flavin and apoprotein. Spin-lattice relaxation measurements show that the relaxation of the 15N(3)H group of flavin is predominantly determined by dipole-dipole interaction. The calculated rotational correlation times of flavin in two different solvents were determined and are in good agreement with published results.