DIP-STR: highly sensitive markers for the analysis of unbalanced genomic mixtures

Deconvoluting multi-person biological mixtures and accurate characterization and identification of separated contributors using non-targeted single-cell DNA sequencing

The genetic characterization and identification of individuals who contributed to biological mixtures are complex and mostly unresolved tasks. These tasks are relevant in various fields, particularly in forensic investigations, which frequently encounters crime scene stains generated by more than one person. Currently, forensic mixture deconvolution is mostly performed subsequent to forensic DNA profiling at the level of the mixed DNA profiles, which comes with several limitations. Some previous studies attempted at separating single cells prior to forensic DNA profiling. However, these approaches are biased at selection of the cells and, due to their targeted DNA analysis on low template DNA, provide incomplete and unreliable forensic DNA profiles. We recently demonstrated the feasibility of performing mixture deconvolution prior to forensic DNA profiling through the utilization of a non-targeted single-cell transcriptome sequencing (scRNA-seq). In addition to individual-specific mixture deconvolution, this approach also allowed accurate characterisation of biological sex, biogeographic ancestry and individual identification of the separated mixture contributors. However, RNA has the forensic disadvantage of being prone to degradation, and sequencing RNA - focussing on coding regions - limits the number of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) utilized for genetic mixture deconvolution, characterization, and identification. These limitations can be overcome by performing single-cell sequencing on the level of DNA instead of RNA. Here, for the first time, we applied non-targeted single-cell DNA sequencing (scDNA-seq) by applying the scATAC-seq (Assay for Transposase-Accessible Chromatin with sequencing) technique to address the challenges of mixture deconvolution in the forensic context. We demonstrated that scATAC-seq, together with our recently developed De-goulash data analysis pipeline, is capable of deconvoluting complex blood mixtures of five individuals from both sexes with varying biogeographic ancestries. We further showed that our approach achieved correct genetic characterization of the biological sex and the biogeographic ancestry of each of the separated mixture contributors and established their identity. Furthermore, by analysing in-silico generated scATAC-seq data mixtures, we demonstrated successful individual-specific mixture deconvolution of i) highly complex mixtures of 11 individuals, ii) balanced mixtures containing as few as 20 cells (10 per each individual), and iii) imbalanced mixtures with a ratio as low as 1:80. Overall, our proof-of-principle study demonstrates the general feasibility of scDNA-seq in general, and scATAC-seq in particular, for mixture deconvolution, genetic characterization and individual identification of the separated mixture contributors. Furthermore, it shows that compared to scRNA-seq, scDNA-seq detects more SNPs from fewer cells, providing higher sensitivity, that is valuable in forensic genetics.

Development and validation of a new multiplex panel using SNaPshot-based DIP-TriSNP markers for forensic DNA mixtures

Short tandem repeat analysis is challenging when dealing with unbalanced mixtures in forensic cases due to the presence of stutter peaks and large amplicons. In this research, we propose a novel genetic marker called DIP-TriSNP, which combines deletion/insertion polymorphism (DIP) with tri-allelic single nucleotide polymorphism in less than 230 bp length of human genome. Based on multiplex PCR and SNaPShot, a panel, including 14 autosomal DIP-TriSNPs and one Y chromosomal DIP-SNP, had been developed and applied to genotyping 102 unrelated Han Chinese individuals in Sichuan of China and simulated a mixture study. The panel sensitivity can reach as low as 0.1 ng DNA template, and the minor contributor of DNA can be detected with the highest ratio of 19:1, as indicated by the obtained results. In the Sichuan Han population, the cumulative probability of informative genotypes reached 0.997092, with a combined power of discrimination of 0.999999998801. The panel was estimated to detect more than two alleles in at least one locus in 99.69% of mixtures of the Sichuan Han population. In conclusion, DIP-TriSNPs have shown promising as an innovative DNA marker for identifying the minor contributor in unbalanced DNA mixtures, offering advantages such as short amplifications, increased polymorphism, and heightened sensitivity.

Early noninvasive prenatal paternity testing by targeted fetal DNA analysis

Today the challenge in paternity testing is to provide an accurate noninvasive assay that can be performed early during pregnancy. This requires the use of novel analytical methods capable of detecting the low fraction of circulating fetal DNA in maternal blood. We previously showed that forensic compound markers such as deletion/insertion polymorphisms-short tandem repeats (DIP-STR) can efficiently resolve complex mixed biological evidence including the target analysis of paternally inherited fetal alleles. In this study, we describe for the first time the validation of this type of markers in the first trimester of pregnancies, in addition to defining the statistical framework to evaluate paternity. To do so, we studied 47 DIP-STRs in 87 cases, with blood samples collected throughout gestation starting from the seven weeks of amenorrhea. Fetal DNA detection in the first trimester shows a false negative rate as low as 6%. The combined paternity index (CPI) results indicate that seven markers with fully informative genotypes are sufficient to determine the paternity. This study demonstrates that DIP-STR markers can be used from early pregnancy and that a small set of markers (about 40) is sufficient to address the question of paternity. The novel method offers substantial improvements over similar approaches in terms of reduced number of markers, lower costs and increased accuracy.

Identification and characterization of novel DIP-STRs from whole-genome sequencing data

In an attempt to enhance forensic DNA mixture deconvolution several alternative DNA typing approaches have been developed. Among these, DIP-STR compound markers can resolve extremely unbalanced two-source DNA mixtures of same-or-opposite sex donors, up to a 1:1000 minor:major DNA ratio. A forensic set of 10 markers was validated for casework and a larger set of 23 DIP-STRs has proven suitable to biogeographic ancestry inference and for prenatal paternity testing. Yet, to promote the widespread use of this original approach, more markers and multiplex panels need to be developed. To this end, here we describe an extended set of forensic DIP-STRs identified using currently available whole-genome sequencing datasets. Complete lists of Indels and STRs were obtained from reported frequencies of genetic variants of 76,156 genomes. About 3000 identified DIP-STRs candidates were shorter than 200 bp and 500 showed high haplotype variability estimated using the genotypes of individuals homozygous for the DIP or the STR. Here, we present 23 additional DIP-STRs validated for sensitivity, specificity and Swiss population variability. Finally, a set of 30 markers comprising seven previously validated ones is proposed for the prospective development of a forensic DIP-STR multiplex panel.

Comparison between MACSprep™ forensic sperm microbead kit and Erase Sperm Isolation kit for the enrichment of sperm fractions recovered from sexual assault samples

Sexual assault samples often contain mixtures of cells coming from at least two donors. Ideally, one would need to separate the cells into two cellular fractions: one consisting of the alleged aggressor's spermatozoa (the sperm fraction) and the other containing the victim's epithelial cells (the non-sperm fraction). This separation increases the probability of obtaining the alleged offender's autosomal DNA profile. However, spermatozoa are often collected along with an excess of biological material originating from the victim, and with unfavorable male:female biological material ratios, the absence of separation could result in the PCR amplification of the victim's DNA profile only. Several approaches are available to enrich/purify the spermatozoa present on sexual assault samples. In this paper, we compare a new method, the MACSprep™ Forensic Sperm MicroBead Kit (MACSprep, based on microbeads conjugated with antibodies bound to spermatozoa and their retention within a magnetic column) with the Erase Sperm Isolation Kit (Erase, a standard differential lysis separation procedure combined with a specific removal of free DNA) routinely used in our lab. The performance of both kits was tested using sets of vaginal and buccal swabs loaded with different dilutions of sperm, or azoospermic semen, representing a total of 120 independent samples. For the samples containing undiluted sperm, an average recovery of 58% was observed for the MACSprep's sperm fractions and 43% for Erase's. Significantly better recovery of azoospermic semen was observed in MACSprep's non-sperm fractions (~ 85%) compared to Erase (~ 28%). Erase performed significantly better than MACSprep in terms of recovery for diluted sperm samples (1:10 to 1:800 sperm dilutions) in the presence of vaginal cells, while the purities of the achieved sperm fractions were in favor of MACSprep for the highest sperm dilutions tested. Similar trends were observed with buccal swabs loaded with 1:200 sperm dilutions. Increased sperm dilutions on vaginal swabs resulted in higher variability in the male material recovered, whatever the separation method used. Both methods were easy to perform and resulted in male DNA extracts ready to use in less than 2 h. Both kits showed their specificities in terms of recovery efficiency and purity of the sperm fractions. Ideally, additional experiments should be performed in different laboratories, using workflow and chemistries different than ours, to better define the peculiarities observed with MACSprep for high dilutions. Improving the recovery of MACSprep for diluted samples, in addition to its better purity observed in the experiments performed, could make it a method of choice for laboratory workflow, despite MACSprep's current price per sample being about twice the price of Erase's.

Set of 15 SNP-SNP Markers for Detection of Unbalanced Degraded DNA Mixtures and Noninvasive Prenatal Paternity Testing

Unbalanced and degraded mixtures (UDM) are very common in forensic DNA analysis. For example, DNA signals from criminal suspects are masked by a large amount of DNA from victims, or cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA) in maternal plasma is masked by a high background of maternal DNA. Currently, detecting minor DNA in these mixtures is complex and challenging. We developed a new set of SNP-SNP microhaplotypes with short amplicons, and we successfully genotyped them using the new method of amplification-refractory mutation system PCR (ARMS-PCR) combined with SNaPshot technology based on a capillary electrophoresis (CE) platform. This panel reflects a high polymorphism in the Southwest Chinese Han population and thus has excellent potential for mixture studies. We evaluated the feasibility of this panel for UDM detection and noninvasive prenatal paternity testing (NIPPT). Fifteen SNP-SNPs detected minor DNA of homemade DNA mixtures, with a sensitivity of 0.025-0.05 ng and a specificity of 1:1,000. In addition, the panel successfully genotyped degraded DNA from single and mixed samples. Finally, 15 SNP-SNPs were applied to 26 trios. All samples displayed positive results with at least one marker to detect cffDNA. Besides, all fetal alleles in maternal plasma were confirmed by genotyping fetal genomic DNA from amniocentesis and paternal genomic DNA from peripheral blood. The results indicated that the SNP-SNP strategy based on the CE platform was useful for UDM detection and NIPPT.

Evaluation of microfluidics-based droplet PCR combined with multiplex STR system in forensic science

Because of its excellent monodispersity, high throughput, and low volume, microfluidics-based droplet PCR has become the core technology of digital PCR, next-generation sequencing, and other technology platforms. This study constructed a microfluidic water-in-oil droplet PCR system and amplified a commercially available forensic 22-plex short tandem repeat detection system. We analyzed the sensitivity, concordance, amplification efficiency of the droplet PCR, and influence factors of the above aspects. The droplet PCR showed high concordance with conventional bulk PCR and had high sensitivity as 0.125 ng. Furthermore, we observed the performance of droplet PCR in high-order mixed DNA. As the mixture ratios from 10:1 to 30:1, droplet PCR presented more mixture proportion (Mx) increased loci from 11 (57.89%) to 17 (89.47%). In the mixture ratios 20:1, 25:1, and 30:1, significant Mx differences between droplet PCR and bulk PCR were observed (p < 0.05). The results showed that the droplet PCR could improve the identification of the minor contributor's DNA in a two-person mixture and alleviate the imbalanced amplification problem. This study provides a reference and basis for the wide application of droplet PCR in forensic science.

Enhanced mixture interpretation with macrohaplotypes based on long-read DNA sequencing

Deconvoluting mixture samples is one of the most challenging problems confronting DNA forensic laboratories. Efforts have been made to provide solutions regarding mixture interpretation. The probabilistic interpretation of Short Tandem Repeat (STR) profiles has increased the number of complex mixtures that can be analyzed. A portion of complex mixture profiles, particularly for mixtures with a high number of contributors, are still being deemed uninterpretable. Novel forensic markers, such as Single Nucleotide Variants (SNV) and microhaplotypes, also have been proposed to allow for better mixture interpretation. However, these markers have both a lower discrimination power compared with STRs and are not compatible with CODIS or other national DNA databanks worldwide. The short-read sequencing (SRS) technologies can facilitate mixture interpretation by identifying intra-allelic variations within STRs. Unfortunately, the short size of the amplicons containing STR markers and sequence reads limit the alleles that can be attained per STR. The latest long-read sequencing (LRS) technologies can overcome this limitation in some samples in which larger DNA fragments (including both STRs and SNVs) with definitive phasing are available. Based on the LRS technologies, this study developed a novel CODIS compatible forensic marker, called a macrohaplotype, which combines a CODIS STR and flanking variants to offer extremely high number of haplotypes and hence very high discrimination power per marker. The macrohaplotype will substantially improve mixture interpretation capabilities. Based on publicly accessible data, a panel of 20 macrohaplotypes with sizes of ~ 8 k bp and the maximum high discrimination powers were designed. The statistical evaluation demonstrates that these macrohaplotypes substantially outperform CODIS STRs for mixture interpretation, particularly for mixtures with a high number of contributors, as well as other forensic applications. Based on these results, efforts should be undertaken to build a complete workflow, both wet-lab and bioinformatics, to precisely call the variants and generate the macrohaplotypes based on the LRS technologies.

Development of a multiplex methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme-based SNP typing system for deconvolution of semen-containing mixtures

The identification of mixed stains has always been a difficult problem in personal identification in the forensic field. In recent years, tissue-specific methylation sites have proven to be very stable biomarkers for distinguishing tissue origin. However, it is still challenging to perform tissue source identification and individual identification simultaneously. In this study, we developed a method that uses tissue-specific methylation markers combined with single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers to detect semen from mixed biofluids and to identify individuals simultaneously. Semen-specific CpG markers were chosen from the literature and further validated utilizing methylation-sensitive restriction endonuclease (MSRE) combined with PCR technology. The neighboring SNP markers were searched in the flanking sequence of the target CpG within 400 bp, and SNP typing was then carried out through a single-base extension reaction followed by capillary electrophoresis. Eventually, a method of MSRE combined with SNaPshot that could detect 12 compound CpG-SNP markers was developed. Using this system, 10 ng of total DNA and DNA mixture with semen content up to 25% could be typed successfully. Moreover, the cumulative discrimination power of the system in the northern Chinese Han population is 0.9998. This study provides a valuable strategy for forensic practice to perform tissue origin and individual identification from mixed stains simultaneously.

Comparison of single nucleotide polymorphisms and short tandem repeats as markers for differentiating between donors and recipients in solid organ transplantation

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Useful autosomal STR marker sets for forensic and paternity applications in the Central Indian population

BACKGROUND

Many countries have developed their core set of STR loci for forensic application and database generation, which India lacks.

AIM

To assess the usefulness of various combinations of autosomal STR marker sets for their superior use in the central Indian population for forensic and paternity applications.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

19 STR marker sets were analysed on 200 central Indian populations and 20 paternity cases to assess their usefulness.

RESULTS

Two marker sets each comprising 19 STR markers are found to be superior to 20 expanded CODIS loci in the studied population. These marker sets also showed their effectiveness in 20 paternity cases having CPI values of 7.62 × 10¹¹ and 7.16 × 10¹¹. Three non-CODIS STR markers Penta E, Penta D, and SE33 showed amplification in 50 challenging samples with >0.80 heterozygosity.

CONCLUSION

Population-specific STR marker sets are useful in forensic and paternity applications, as well as database generation, and it is envisioned that Penta E, Penta D, and SE33 markers will be included in the list of core STR loci in the central Indian population.

Detection of cell-free fetal DNA in maternal plasma using two types of compound markers

With the discovery of circulating cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA) in maternal plasma, noninvasive prenatal testing became possible. However, analysis of low-level cffDNA against high background maternal DNA remains complicated and challenging. To circumvent this limitation, selective amplification of cffDNA was used in this study. Two kinds of compound markers (namely DIP-STR and SNP-STR), both based on selective amplification, were used here for targeting fetal DNA. By designing two allele-specific forward primers for DIP-STR and SNP-STR, DNA fragments with different DIP/SNP alleles can be selectively amplified. When analyzing maternal plasma DNA, these markers can selectively target paternally inherited fetal alleles whose DIP/SNP allele was not shared with the mother. In this study, 21 families were studied with six DIP-STRs and 11 SNP-STRs. Fetal DNA was successfully detected across plasma samples for at least one marker. Detection rate varied between DIP-STR and SNP-STR markers, and DIP-STR outperforms SNP-STR. Fetal alleles obtained from maternal plasma were double confirmed by genotyping paternal genomic DNA and fetal genomic DNA from amniocentesis. This study demonstrated that selective amplification strategy can be used to target cffDNA in maternal plasma, which will be a promising method for noninvasive prenatal paternity testing.

A Novel SNP-STR System Based on a Capillary Electrophoresis Platform

Various compound markers encompassing two or more variants within a small region can be regarded as generalized microhaplotypes. Many of these markers have been investigated for various forensic purposes, such as individual identification, deconvolution of DNA mixtures, or forensic ancestry inference. SNP-STR is a compound biomarker composed of a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) and a closely linked short tandem repeat polymorphism (STR), and possess the advantages of both SNPs and STRs. In addition, in conjunction with a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique based on the amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS), SNP-STRs can be used for forensic unbalanced DNA mixture analysis based on capillary electrophoresis (CE), which is the most commonly used platform in worldwide forensic laboratories. Our previous research reported 11 SNP-STRs, but few of them are derived from the commonly used STR loci, for which existing STR databases can be used as a reference. For maximum compatibility with existing DNA databases, in this study, we screened 18 SNP-STR loci, of which 14 were derived from the expanded CODIS core loci set. Stable and sensitive SNP-STR multiplex PCR panels based on the CE platform were established. Assays on simulated two-person DNA mixtures showed that all allele-specific primers could detect minor DNA components in 1:500 mixtures. Population data based on 113 unrelated Chengdu Han individuals were investigated. A Bayesian framework was developed for the likelihood ratio (LR) evaluation of SNP-STR profiling results obtained from two-person mixtures. Furthermore, we report on the first use of SNP-STRs in casework to show the advantages and limitations for use in practice. Compared to 2.86 × 10³ for autosomal STR kits, the combined LR reached 7.14 × 10⁷ using the SNP-STR method in this casework example.

Multi-Indel: A Microhaplotype Marker Can Be Typed Using Capillary Electrophoresis Platforms

Since the concept of microhaplotypes was proposed by Kidd in 2013, various microhaplotype markers have been investigated for various forensic purposes, such as individual identification, deconvolution of DNA mixtures, or forensic ancestry inference. In our opinion, various compound markers are also regarded as generalized microhaplotypes, encompassing two or more variants in a short segment of DNA (e.g., 200 bp). That is, a set of variants (referred to herein as multi-variants) within a certain length includes single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP), insertion/deletion polymorphisms (Indels), or short tandem repeat polymorphisms (STRs). At present, multi-variant is mainly aimed at multi-SNPs. However, the haplotype genotyping of multi-variants relies on single-strand analysis, mainly using massively parallel sequencing (MPS). Here, we describe a method based on a capillary electrophoresis (CE) platform that can directly obtain haplotypes of individuals. Several microhaplotypes consisting of three or more Indels with different insertion or deletion lengths in the range of less than 200 bp were screened out, each of which had at least three haplotypes. As a result, the haplotype of an individual was reflected by the length of its polymorphism. Finally, we established a multiplex amplification system containing 18 multi-Indel markers that could identify haplotypes on each chromosome of an individual. The combined power of discrimination (CPD) and the cumulative probability of exclusion (CPE) were 0.999999999997234 and 0.9984, respectively.

DIP-microhaplotypes: new markers for detection of unbalanced DNA mixtures

The identification of a suspect in a degraded and unbalanced DNA mixture has been a challenge for the standard short tandem repeat polymorphisms (STR) typing. Several methods have been introduced to solve this problem, such as DIP-STR, DIP-SNP, and SNP-STR markers. In this study, we proposed DIP-microhaplotype (deletion/insertion linked a chain of SNPs) as a kind of new genetic marker to type the unbalanced and degraded DNA mixture. We established the detection method with ten DIP-microhaplotype markers including 26 SNPs using allele-specific multiplex PCR followed by SNaPshot assay. This novel compound marker allows us to detect the minor DNA with a sensitivity of 1:100 to 1:1000 in a DNA mixture of any gender. Most of the DIP-microhaplotype markers had a relatively high probability of informative alleles with an average informative value (I value) of 0.308. In all, we proposed DIP-microhaplotype as a novel type of DNA marker for the detection of minor contributor from unbalanced DNA mixtures. Due to their inherent shorter length, higher polymorphism, and sensitivity, DIP-microhaplotypes are promising markers for the examination of the degraded and unbalanced mixtures in forensic stains or clinical chimeras.

Human Leukocyte Antigen alleles as an aid to STR in complex forensic DNA samples

Human biological samples with multiple contributors remain one of the most challenging aspects of DNA typing within a forensic science context. With the increasing sensitivity of commercially available kits allowing detection of low template DNA, complex mixtures are now a standard component of forensic DNA evidence. Over the years, various methods and techniques have been developed to try to resolve the issue of mixed profiles. However, forensic DNA analysis has relied on the same markers to generate DNA profiles for the past 30 years causing considerable challenges in the deconvolution of complex mixed samples. The future of resolving complicated DNA mixtures may rely on utilising markers that have been previously applied to gene typing of non-forensic relevance. With Massively Parallel Sequencing (MPS), techniques becoming more popular and accessible even epigenetic markers have become a source of interest for forensic scientists. The aim of this review is to consider the potential of alleles from the Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) complex as effective forensic markers. While Massively Parallel Sequencing of HLA is routinely used in clinical laboratories in fields such as transplantation, pharmacology or population studies, there have not been any studies testing its suitability for forensic casework samples.

Genotyping of STR and DIP-STR Markers in Plasma Cell-Free DNA for Simple and Rapid Noninvasive Prenatal Diagnosis of Zygosity of Twin Pregnancies

Due to the high rate of complications, special medical care must be provided especially for monozygotic twin pregnancies, which are characterized as having 2.5 times higher mortality of fetuses. In recent years, examination of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) circulating in maternal plasma has become a useful noninvasive method of prenatal diagnosis. However, fetal DNA constitutes only 3-20% of plasma cfDNA during pregnancy. Short tandem repeats (STRs) are routinely used in forensic examination of DNA mixtures and are able to identify 5% minority components. Haplotypes of deletion/insertion polymorphisms and STRs (DIP-STRs) are able to detect even 0.1% minority components of DNA mixtures. Thus, STRs and DIP-STRs seem to be a perfect tool for detection of fetal alleles in DNA isolated from maternal plasma. Here, we present a novel noninvasive prenatal diagnosis technique of determination of pregnancy zygosity based on examination of feto-maternal microchimerism of plasma cfDNA with the use of STRs and DIP-STRs. Our preliminary results based on 22 STR loci showed 67% sensitivity, 100% specificity and 82% accuracy for prenatal detection of twin dizygosity. The corresponding values for seven DIP-STRs were 13%, 100% and 54%, respectively. Owing to assay performance, low DNA input requirements, low costs (below 10 USD per patient) and simplicity of analysis, genotyping of STR/DIP-STR markers in maternal plasma cfDNA may become a useful supplementary test for noninvasive prenatal diagnosis of twin zygosity in cases when chorionicity and zygosity cannot be reliably determined by ultrasound examination and prognostic value may be provided by a DNA test determining pregnancy zygosity.

A new set of DIP-SNP markers for detection of unbalanced and degraded DNA mixtures

Unbalanced and degraded mixtures (UDM) are frequently encountered during forensic DNA analysis. For example, forensic DNA units regularly encounter DNA mixture signal where the DNA signal from the alleged offender is masked or swamped by high quantities of DNA from the victim. Our previous data presented a new kind of DNA markers that composed of a deletion/insertion polymorphism (DIP) and a SNP and we termed this new kind of microhaplotypes DIP-SNP (combination of DIP and SNP). Since such markers could be designed short enough for degraded DNA amplification, we hypothesized that DIP-SNP markers are applicable for typing of UDM. In this study, we developed a new set of DIP-SNPs with short amplicons which were complement to our prior developed system. The multiplex PCR and SNaPshot assay were established for 20 DIP-SNPs in a Chinese Han population. The DIP-SNPs were capable of detecting the minor contributor's allele in home-made DNA mixture with sensitivities from 1:100 to 1:1000 with a total of 1 -10 ng input DNA. Moreover, this system successfully typed the degraded DNA whether it came from the single source or mixture samples. In Chinese population, the system showed an average informative value of 0.293 and combined informative value of 0.998363862. Our results demonstrated that DIP-SNPs may serve as a valuable tool in detection of UDM in forensic medicine.

The advances in DNA mixture interpretation

In forensic genetics, the analysis of DNA in biological samples is a valuable tool for personal identification. There is an increasing demand in analyzing of the mixed DNA which may provide insightful investigative instructions. With the continuous effort for the improvement of individual identification, complicated mixed stains represent a growing fraction of the samples processed by forensic laboratories. Recent technological advances have enabled quantitative analysis of DNA mixture and emerging sequencing approaches to decipher the complicated DNA mixture. Here, we describe the use of different genetic markers, typing approaches and analytical methods in mixture analysis, and how useful information can be obtained from complicated DNA mixture.

Analysis and interpretation of mixture DNA using AS-PCR of mtDNA

Semi-nested PCR with allele-specific (AS) primers and sequencing of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) were performed to analyze and interpret DNA mixtures, especially when biological materials were degraded or contained a limited amount of DNA. SNP-STR markers were available to identify the minor DNA component using AS-PCR; moreover, SNPs in mtDNA could be used when the degraded or limited amounts of DNA mixtures were not successful with SNP-STR markers. Five pairs of allele-specific primers were designed based on three SNPs (G15043A, T16362C, and T16519C). The sequence of mtDNA control region of minor components was obtained using AS-PCR and sequencing. Sequences of the amplification fragments were aligned and compared with the sequences of known suspects or databases. When this assay was used with the T16362C and T16519C SNPs, we found it to be highly sensitive for detecting small amounts of DNA (∼30 pg) and analyzing DNA mixtures of two contributors, even at an approximately 1‰ ratio of minor and major components. An exception was tests based on the SNP G15043A, which required approximately 300 pg of a 1% DNA mixture. In simulated three contributor DNA mixtures (at rate of 1:1:1), control region fragments from each contributor were detected and interpreted. AS-PCR combined with semi-nested PCR was successfully used to identify the mtDNA control region of each contributor, providing biological evidence for excluding suspects in forensic cases, especially when biological materials were degraded or had a limited amount of DNA.

Inferring biogeographic ancestry with compound markers of slow and fast evolving polymorphisms

Bio-geographic ancestry is an area of considerable interest in the medical genetics, anthropology and forensics. Although genome-wide panels are ideal as they provide dense genotyping data, small sets of ancestry informative marker provide a cost-effective way to investigate genetic ancestry and population structure. Here, we investigate the performance of a reduced marker set that combine different types of autosomal markers through haplotype analysis. In particular, recently described DIP-STR markers should offer the advantage of comprising both, low mutation rate Indels (DIPs), to study human history over longer time scale; and high mutation rate STRs, to trace relatively recent demographic events. In this study, we assessed the ability of an initial set of 23 DIP-STRs to distinguish major population groups using the HGDP-CEPH reference samples. The results obtained applying the STRUCTURE algorithm show that the discrimination capacity of the DIP-STRs is comparable to currently used small-scale ancestry informative markers by approaching seven major demographic groups. Yet, the DIP-STRs show an improved success rate in assigning individuals to populations of Europe and Middle East. These data show a remarkable ability of a preliminary set of 23 DIP-STR markers to infer major biogeographic origins. A novel set of DIP-STRs preselected to contain ancestry information should lead to further improvements.

Analysis of fetal DNA in maternal plasma with markers designed for forensic DNA mixture resolution

PURPOSE

With the description of circulating fetal DNA in maternal blood, noninvasive prenatal diagnostics became theoretically possible. As the presence of background maternal DNA interferes with the detection of fetal DNA, analytical methods require genetic markers capable of distinguishing by quantitative or targeted approaches the minor population of DNA molecules of the fetus. Here we evaluate the feasibility of analyzing fetal DNA with novel DIP-STR genetic markers, designed for the investigation of forensic mixed biological evidence.

METHODS

The DIP-STR molecular approach is based on sequence-specific analysis of paternally inherited fetal alleles. These sequences are biallelic deletion/insertion polymorphisms (DIPs) located very close to short tandem repeat (STR) markers, for combined analysis. In this study, 48 women were tested with 28 DIP-STRs during the first, second, and third trimester of pregnancy.

RESULTS

Positive results were obtained across markers, including longer ones (386 base-pairs) and with blood samples collected during early pregnancy, such as 10 weeks of gestational age.

CONCLUSION

These data show that DIP-STR markers can be used to amplify specific genomic regions of circulating fetal DNA to obtain targeted genetic information. This method may contribute to developments in noninvasive prenatal paternity testing and diagnosis of certain genetic diseases.

Two-person DNA mixture interpretation based on a novel set of SNP-STR markers

Autosomal short tandem repeats (STR) markers analysed by PCR and capillary electrophoresis (CE) represent the gold-standard for forensic DNA analysis. With the improved sensitivity of detection equipment, a larger number of mixed DNA profiles can be obtained from trace amounts of DNA that conventionally used to appear as a single source. More specifically, two-source DNA mixtures, comprising the victim's and the perpetrator's DNAs, are often encountered in forensic casework, where the victim's DNA represents a major component of the mixture. Unfortunately, unbalanced two-person DNA mixtures with a ratio larger than 20:1 (here we have named this kind of mixture extremely unbalanced DNA mixture) provide limited information on the minor component. Although the development of probabilistic software has made interpretation of results from mixed DNA easier, high mixture ratios lead to an uninformative likelihood ratio (LR), considering the minor component. Therefore, a technique that can be performed on the conventional CE platform, while enhancing the ability to detect minor DNA in extremely unbalanced DNA mixtures, may be very useful in forensic casework. Our previous research has reported that SNP-STRs, in conjunction with a PCR technique based on amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS), can be used to resolve extremely unbalanced two-person DNA mixtures. To further explore the capacity of SNP-STR markers to help analyse such DNA mixtures, we developed 11 novel SNP-STR markers. The ARMS-based PCR was then used to design allele-specific primers, where each primer targeted one SNP allele located in the flanking region of the tandem repeats. This method allowed primers to specifically and selectively amplify minor DNA without interference from DNA of the major component because the selected SNP allele was not shared with the major contributor. A survey of the selected 11 SNP-STRs in a southwest Chinese Han population showed high levels of polymorphism. Assays on two-person DNA mixtures showed that all the allele-specific primers could target minor DNA even when the amount of major DNA was a 100-fold higher. Therefore, this novel set of SNP-STR markers provides an alternative method for the analysis of extremely unbalanced two-person DNA mixtures.

A novel multiplex assay of SNP-STR markers for forensic purpose

Like DIP-STR markers (deletion/insertion polymorphism-short tandem repeat combinations), SNP-STR markers (single nucleotide polymorphism-STR combinations) are also valuable in forensic DNA mixture analysis. In this study, eight SNP-STRs were selected, and a stable and sensitive multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay was developed for amplifying these SNP-STRs and the Amelogenin gender marker according to the principle of amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS). This novel multiplex set allows detection of the minor DNA contributor in a DNA mixture of any gender and cellular origin with high resolution (beyond a DNA ratio of 1:20). In addition, SNP-STR haplotype frequencies were estimated based on a survey of 350 unrelated individuals from Chinese Han population, and the combined power of discrimination (PD) and power of exclusion (PE) of the eight SNP-STRs were calculated as 0.99999999965 and 0.9996, which were obviously higher than that of the eight STR loci: 0.9999999954 and 0.9989 respectively. The results indicated that the SNP-STR compound markers have higher application value in forensic identification compared to standard autosomal STRs, especially in the analysis of imbalanced DNA mixtures.

Separation/extraction, detection, and interpretation of DNA mixtures in forensic science (review)

Interpreting mixed DNA samples containing material from multiple contributors has long been considered a major challenge in forensic casework, especially when encountering low-template DNA (LT-DNA) or high-order mixtures that may involve missing alleles (dropout) and unrelated alleles (drop-in), among others. In the last decades, extraordinary progress has been made in the analysis of mixed DNA samples, which has led to increasing attention to this research field. The advent of new methods for the separation and extraction of DNA from mixtures, novel or jointly applied genetic markers for detection and reliable interpretation approaches for estimating the weight of evidence, as well as the powerful massively parallel sequencing (MPS) technology, has greatly extended the range of mixed samples that can be correctly analyzed. Here, we summarized the investigative approaches and progress in the field of forensic DNA mixture analysis, hoping to provide some assistance to forensic practitioners and to promote further development involving this issue.

A set of 14 DIP-SNP markers to detect unbalanced DNA mixtures

Unbalanced DNA mixture is still a difficult problem for forensic practice. DIP-STRs are useful markers for detection of minor DNA but they are not widespread in the human genome and having long amplicons. In this study, we proposed a novel type of genetic marker, termed DIP-SNP. DIP-SNP refers to the combination of INDEL and SNP in less than 300bp length of human genome. The multiplex PCR and SNaPshot assay were established for 14 DIP-SNP markers in a Chinese Han population from Shanxi, China. This novel compound marker allows detection of the minor DNA contributor with sensitivity from 1:50 to 1:1000 in a DNA mixture of any gender with 1 ng-10 ng DNA template. Most of the DIP-SNP markers had a relatively high probability of informative alleles with an average I value of 0.33. In all, we proposed DIP-SNP as a novel kind of genetic marker for detection of minor contributor from unbalanced DNA mixture and established the detection method by associating the multiplex PCR and SNaPshot assay. DIP-SNP polymorphisms are promising markers for forensic or clinical mixture examination because they are shorter, widespread and higher sensitive.

Lessons from a study of DNA contaminations from police services and forensic laboratories in Switzerland

In Switzerland, the DNA profiles of police officers collecting crime scene traces as well as forensic genetic laboratories employees are stored in the staff index of the national DNA database to detect potential contaminations. Our study aimed at making a national inventory of contaminations to better understand their origin and to make recommendations in order to decrease their occurrence. For this purpose, a retrospective questionnaire was sent to both police services and forensic genetic laboratories for each case where there was a contamination. Between 2011 and 2015, a total of 709 contaminations were detected. This represents a mean of 11.5 (9.6-13.4) contaminations per year per 1'000 profiles sent to the Swiss DNA database. Feedbacks were obtained from the police, the laboratory or both for 552/709 (78%) of the contaminations. Approximately 86% of these contaminations originated from police officers whereas only 11% were from genetic laboratories employees and 3% were associated to other sources (e.g. positive controls, stain-stain contaminations). Interestingly, a direct contact between the stain and the contaminant person occurred in only 51% of the laboratory contaminations whereas this number increased to 91% for police collaborators. The high level of indirect DNA transfer in laboratories might be explained by the presence of "DNA reservoirs" suggesting that cleaning procedures should be improved. At the police level, most contaminations originated from the person who collected the trace and likely occurred directly at the crime scene. Improving sampling practices could be beneficial to reduce these contaminations.

A solution for the rare type match problem when using the DIP-STR marker system

The rare type match problem is an evaluative challenging situation in which the analysis of a DNA profile reveals the presence of (at least) one allele which is not contained in the reference database. This situation is challenging because an estimate for the frequency of occurrence of the profile in a given population needs sophisticated evaluative procedures. The rare type match problem is very common when the DIP-STR marker system, which has proven itself very useful for dealing with unbalanced DNA mixtures, is used, essentially due to the limited size of the available database. The object-oriented Bayesian network proposed in Cereda et al. [7] to assess the value of the evidence for general scenarios, was not designed to deal with this particular situation. In this paper, the model is extended and partially modified to be able to calculate the full Bayesian likelihood ratio in presence of any (observed and not yet observed) allele of a given profile. The method is based on the approach developed in Cereda [5] for Y-STR data. Alternative solutions, such as the plug-in approximation and an empirical Bayesian methodology are also proposed and compared with the results obtained with the full Bayesian approach.

An investigation of a set of DIP-STR markers to detect unbalanced DNA mixtures among the southwest Chinese Han population

The resolution of DNA mixtures is still a difficult problem that is worthy of further study. A common method applied for analysing mixtures is the use of autosomal STR markers as well as related calculation software based on genotypes; however, these markers have a limitation in detecting minor DNA in unbalanced mixtures if major DNA constitutes over 95% of the stain. Novel biomarkers, such as Y-STR, DIP-STR and SNP-STR, have been shown to perform well in distinguishing DNA donors in this type of mixture. DIP-STR can successfully target minor DNA in 1000-fold background DNA using two separate allele-specific primers. However, whether this method can successfully detect minor DNA primarily depends on the distribution of the DIPs in a population. Until now, only Swiss population data have been reported; therefore in this study, we selected 10 DIP-STR markers that performed well in the Swiss population and investigated whether these markers were also useful among the southwest Chinese Han population. The allele frequencies were estimated based on 152 samples, and six of the ten DIP-STR makers had a relatively high probability of informative markers (I value), which indicated their potential usefulness in the southwest Chinese Han population. A comparative study of DIP-STR markers and autosomal STR markers demonstrated that DIP-STR markers detected minor DNA at a ratio of 1:1000, while autosomal STR markers often failed to genotype minor DNA because of strong background noises caused by large amount of major DNA. However, the discrimination power was not high enough using these six DIPs alone. Therefore, we suggest that development of a panel with more loci is imperative and that a panel combined with DIP-STR and SNP-STR markers may be a possible way to achieve better discrimination power.

STRait Razor v2s: Advancing sequence-based STR allele reporting and beyond to other marker systems

STRait Razor has provided the forensic community a free-to-use, open-source tool for short tandem repeat (STR) analysis of massively parallel sequencing (MPS) data. STRait Razor v2s (SRv2s) allows users to capture physically phased haplotypes within the full amplicon of both commercial (ForenSeq) and "early access" panels (PowerSeq, Mixture ID). STRait Razor v2s may be run in batch mode to facilitate population-level analysis and is supported by all Unix distributions (including MAC OS). Data are reported in tables in string (haplotype), length-based (e.g., vWA allele 14), and International Society of Forensic Genetics (ISFG)-recommended (vWA [CE 14]-GRCh38-chr12:5983950-5984049 (TAGA)₁₀ (CAGA)₃ TAGA) formats. STRait Razor v2s currently contains a database of ∼2500 unique sequences. This database is used by SRv2s to match strings to the appropriate allele in ISFG-recommended format. In addition to STRs, SRv2s has configuration files necessary to capture and report haplotypes from all marker types included in these multiplexes (e.g., SNPs, InDels, and microhaplotypes). To facilitate mixture interpretation, data may be displayed from all markers in a format similar to that of electropherograms displayed by traditional forensic software. The download package for SRv2s may be found at https://www.unthsc.edu/graduate-school-of-biomedical-sciences/molecular-and-medical-genetics/laboratory-faculty-and-staff/strait-razor.

A mixture detection method based on separate amplification using primer specific alleles of INDELs-a study based on two person's DNA mixture

Samples containing unbalanced DNA mixtures from individuals often occur in forensic DNA examination and clinical detection. Because of the PCR amplification bias, the minor contributor DNA is often masked by the major contributor DNA when using traditional STR or SNP typing techniques. Here we propose a method based in allele-specific Insertion/Deletion (INDEL) genotyping to detect DNA mixtures in forensic samples. Fourteen INDELs were surveyed in the Chinese Han population of Shanxi Province. The INDELs were amplified using two separate primer-specific reactions by real-time PCR. The difference Ct value of the 2 reactions (D-value) were used for determination of the single source DNA. INDELs types and further confirmed by electrophoresis separation. The minor allele frequency (MAF) was above 0.2 in 10 INDELs. The detection limit was 0.3125 ng-1.25 ng template DNA for real-time PCR in all 14 INDEL markers. For single source 10 ng DNA, the average D-value was 0.31 ± 0.14 for LS type, 6.96 ± 1.05 for LL type and 7.20 ± 1.09 for SS type. For the series of simulated DNA mixture, the Ct value varied between the ranges of single source DNA, depending on their INDEL typing and mixture ratios. This method can detect the specific allele of the minor DNA contributor as little as 1:50 in rs397782455 and rs397696936; 1:100 in rs397832665, rs397822382 and rs397897230; the detection limit of the minor DNA contributor was as little as 1:500-1:1000 in the rest INDEL markers, a much higher sensitivity compared with traditional STR typing. The D-value variation depended on the alternation of dilution ratio and INDEL types. When the dilution was 1:1000, the maximum and minimum D-values were 8.84 ± 0.11 in rs397897230 and 4.27 ± 0.19 in rs397897239 for LL and SS type mixture, the maximum and minimum D-values were 9.32 ± 0.54 in rs397897230 and 4.38 ± 0.26 in rs 397897239 for LL(SS) and LS type mixture, separately. Any D-value between 0.86 and 5.11 in the 14 INDELs indicated the presence of mixture. The separate amplification strategy based on real-time PCR provides a promising and convenient method for detection of unbalanced DNA mixture for Chinese Han population.

Evaluation of blood, buccal swabs, and hair follicles for DNA profiling technique using STR markers

AIM

To study the short tandem repeat (STR) pattern of DNA from the blood, buccal swabs, and hair follicles of the recipients of allogenic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation to examine whether these tissues contain donor derived cells.

METHODS

The study enrolled 25 patients who sustained engraftment. Peripheral blood, buccal swabs, and hair follicles were collected on days 21-30, 90, and 180 after transplantation and the chimeric status of the recipients was evaluated.

RESULTS

Donor derived cells existed in the blood and buccal swabs, but not in hair follicles, which can be used to obtain the pre-transplant sample of the recipient after transplant.

CONCLUSION

Peripheral blood and buccal swab do not serve as a reliable source of recipient's origin for DNA analysis of individuals who underwent allogenic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation at least within 6 months after transplant.

A novel set of DIP-STR markers for improved analysis of challenging DNA mixtures

Currently available molecular biology tools allow forensic scientists to characterize DNA evidence found at crime scenes for a large variety of samples, including those of limited quantity and quality, and achieve high levels of individualization. Yet, standard forensic markers provide limited or no results when applied to mixed DNA samples where the contributors are present in very different proportions (unbalanced DNA mixtures). This becomes an issue mostly for the analysis of trace samples collected on the victim or from touched objects. To this end, we recently proposed an innovative type of genetic marker, named DIP-STR that relies on pairing deletion/insertion polymorphisms (DIP) with standard short tandem repeats (STR). This novel compound marker allows detection of the minor DNA contributor in a DNA mixture of any gender and cellular origin with unprecedented resolution (beyond a DNA ratio of 1:1000). To provide a novel analytical tool useful in practice to common forensic laboratories, this article describes the first set of 10 DIP-STR markers selected according to forensic technical standards. The novel DIP-STR regions are short (between 146 and 271 bp), include only highly polymorphic tri-, tetra- and pentanucleotide tandem repeats and are located on different chromosomes or chromosomal arms to provide statistically independent results. This novel set of DIP-STR can target the amplification of 0.03-0.1 ng of DNA when mixed with a 1000-fold excess of major DNA. DIP-STR relative allele frequencies are estimated based on a survey of 103 Swiss individuals. Finally, this study provides an estimate of the occurrence of informative alleles and a calculation of the corresponding random match probability of the detected minor DIP-STR genotype assessed across 10,506 pairwise conceptual mixtures.

Sequence-based definition of eight short tandem repeat loci located within the HLA-region in an Austrian population

Sequenced allelic ladders are a prerequisite for reliable genotyping of short tandem repeat (STR) polymorphisms and consistent results across instrument platforms. For eight STR-loci located on the short arm of chromosome 6 (6p21.3), a sequenced based nomenclature was established according to international recommendations. Publicly available reference DNA samples were sequenced enabling interested laboratories to construct their own allelic ladders. Three tetrameric (D6S2691, D6S2678, DQIV), one trimeric (D6S2906) and four dimeric repeat loci (D6S2972, D6S2792, D6S2789, D6S273) were investigated. Apart from the very complex sequence structure at the DQIV locus, three loci showed a compound and four loci a simple repeat pattern. In the flanking regions of some loci additional single nucleotide and insertion/deletion polymorphisms occurred as well as sequence polymorphisms within the repeat region of alleles with the same length. In an Austrian Caucasoid population sample (n=293) between eight and 22 alleles were found. No significant deviation from Hardy-Weinberg expectations was observed, the power of discrimination ranged from 0.826 to 0.978. The loci cover the HLA-coding region from HLA-A to HLA-DQB1 and can be used for a better definition of HLA haplotypes for population and disease association studies, recombination point mapping, haematopoietic stem cell transplantation as well as for identity and relationship testing.