Dominant-negative SOX9 mutations in campomelic dysplasia

Variants in the SOX9 transactivation middle domain induce axial skeleton dysplasia and scoliosis

SOX9 is an essential transcriptional regulator of cartilage development and homeostasis. In humans, dysregulation of SOX9 is associated with a wide spectrum of skeletal disorders, including campomelic and acampomelic dysplasia, and scoliosis. The mechanism of how SOX9 variants contribute to the spectrum of axial skeletal disorders is not well understood. Here, we report four novel pathogenic variants of SOX9 identified in a large cohort of patients with congenital vertebral malformations. Three of these heterozygous variants are in the HMG and DIM domains, and for the first time, we report a pathogenic variant within the transactivation middle (TAM) domain of SOX9 . Probands with these variants exhibit variable skeletal dysplasia, ranging from isolated vertebral malformation to acampomelic dysplasia. We also generated a Sox9 hypomorphic mutant mouse model bearing a microdeletion within the TAM domain ( Sox9 ^Asp272del ). We demonstrated that disturbance of the TAM domain with missense mutation or microdeletion results in reduced protein stability but does not affect the transcriptional activity of SOX9. Homozygous Sox9 ^Asp272del mice exhibited axial skeletal dysplasia including kinked tails, ribcage anomalies, and scoliosis, recapitulating phenotypes observed in human, while heterozygous mutants display a milder phenotype. Analysis of primary chondrocytes and the intervertebral discs in Sox9 ^Asp272del mutant mice revealed dysregulation of a panel of genes with major contributions of the extracellular matrix, angiogenesis, and ossification-related processes. In summary, our work identified the first pathologic variant of SOX9 within the TAM domain and demonstrated that this variant is associated with reduced SOX9 protein stability. Our finding suggests that reduced SOX9 stability caused by variants in the TAM domain may be responsible for the milder forms of axial skeleton dysplasia in humans.

Hypomorphic and dominant-negative impact of truncated SOX9 dysregulates Hedgehog-Wnt signaling, causing campomelia

Haploinsufficiency for SOX9, the master chondrogenesis transcription factor, can underlie campomelic dysplasia (CD), an autosomal dominant skeletal malformation syndrome, because heterozygous Sox9 null mice recapitulate the bent limb (campomelia) and some other phenotypes associated with CD. However, in vitro cell assays suggest haploinsufficiency may not apply for certain mutations, notably those that truncate the protein, but in these cases in vivo evidence is lacking and underlying mechanisms are unknown. Here, using conditional mouse mutants, we compared the impact of a heterozygous Sox9 null mutation (Sox9+/-) with the Sox9+/Y440X CD mutation that truncates the C-terminal transactivation domain but spares the DNA-binding domain. While some Sox9+/Y440X mice survived, all Sox9+/- mice died perinatally. However, the skeletal defects were more severe and IHH signaling in developing limb cartilage was significantly enhanced in Sox9+/Y440X compared with Sox9+/-. Activating Sox9Y440X specifically in the chondrocyte-osteoblast lineage caused milder campomelia, and revealed cell- and noncell autonomous mechanisms acting on chondrocyte differentiation and osteogenesis in the perichondrium. Transcriptome analyses of developing Sox9+/Y440X limbs revealed dysregulated expression of genes for the extracellular matrix, as well as changes consistent with aberrant WNT and HH signaling. SOX9Y440X failed to interact with β-catenin and was unable to suppress transactivation of Ihh in cell-based assays. We propose enhanced HH signaling in the adjacent perichondrium induces asymmetrically localized excessive perichondrial osteogenesis resulting in campomelia. Our study implicates combined haploinsufficiency/hypomorphic and dominant-negative actions of SOX9Y440X, cell-autonomous and noncell autonomous mechanisms, and dysregulated WNT and HH signaling, as the cause of human campomelia.

SOX9 and SOX10 control fluid homeostasis in the inner ear for hearing through independent and cooperative mechanisms

The in vivo mechanisms underlying dominant syndromes caused by mutations in SRY-Box Transcription Factor 9 (SOX9) and SOX10 (SOXE) transcription factors, when they either are expressed alone or are coexpressed, are ill-defined. We created a mouse model for the campomelic dysplasia SOX9Y440X mutation, which truncates the transactivation domain but leaves DNA binding and dimerization intact. Here, we find that SOX9Y440X causes deafness via distinct mechanisms in the endolymphatic sac (ES)/duct and cochlea. By contrast, conditional heterozygous Sox9-null mice are normal. During the ES development of Sox9Y440X/+ heterozygotes, Sox10 and genes important for ionic homeostasis are down-regulated, and there is developmental persistence of progenitors, resulting in fewer mature cells. Sox10 heterozygous null mutants also display persistence of ES/duct progenitors. By contrast, SOX10 retains its expression in the early Sox9Y440X/+ mutant cochlea. Later, in the postnatal stria vascularis, dominant interference by SOX9Y440X is implicated in impairing the normal cooperation of SOX9 and SOX10 in repressing the expression of the water channel Aquaporin 3, thereby contributing to endolymphatic hydrops. Our study shows that for a functioning endolymphatic system in the inner ear, SOX9 regulates Sox10, and depending on the cell type and target gene, it works either independently of or cooperatively with SOX10. SOX9Y440X can interfere with the activity of both SOXE factors, exerting effects that can be classified as haploinsufficient/hypomorphic or dominant negative depending on the cell/gene context. This model of disruption of transcription factor partnerships may be applicable to congenital deafness, which affects ∼0.3% of newborns, and other syndromic disorders.

Case report: Cystic hygroma accompanied with campomelic dysplasia in the first trimester caused by haploinsufficiency with SOX9 deletion

Introduction: Campomelic dysplasia (CD) is a rare autosomal dominant skeletal malformation syndrome characterized by shortness and bowing of the lower extremities with or without XY sex reversal. Diagnosis using ultrasonography is most often made in the latter half of pregnancy. Intragenic heterozygous mutations in SOX9 are responsible for most cases of CD. CD caused by SOX9 deletion is a rare condition.

Case presentation: We present a single case report of an individual with cystic hygroma accompanied by CD, which was detected by ultrasound in the first trimester. Chromosomal microarray analysis (CMA) was performed to determine copy number variants, whereas whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed to elucidate single-nucleotide variants. Chorionic villus sampling was performed to enable such analyses. Ultimately, CMA detected a 606 kb deletion in the 17q24.3 region with only one protein-coding gene (SOX9). However, no mutation in the SOX9 protein-coding sequence was detected by WES.

Conclusion: When cystic hygroma is detected, prenatal diagnoses for skeletal dysplasia by ultrasound are likely to be confirmed in the first trimester. We propose a comprehensive prenatal diagnostic strategy that combines CMA and WES to diagnose fetuses with cystic hygroma accompanied by skeletal dysplasia.

Nsun4 and Mettl3 mediated translational reprogramming of Sox9 promotes BMSC chondrogenic differentiation

The chondrogenic differentiation of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) has been used in the treatment and repair of cartilage defects; however, the in-depth regulatory mechanisms by which RNA modifications are involved in this process are still poorly understood. Here, we found that Sox9, a critical transcription factor that mediates chondrogenic differentiation, exhibited enhanced translation by ribosome sequencing in chondrogenic pellets, which was accompanied by increased 5-methylcytosine (m⁵C) and N6-methyladenosine (m⁶A) levels. Nsun4-mediated m⁵C and Mettl3-mediated m⁶A modifications were required for Sox9-regulated chondrogenic differentiation. Interestingly, we showed that in the 3’UTR of Sox9 mRNA, Nsun4 catalyzed the m⁵C modification and Mettl3 catalyzed the m⁶A modification. Furthermore, we found that Nsun4 and Mettl3 co-regulated the translational reprogramming of Sox9 via the formation of a complex. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) assays showed that this complex was assembled along with the recruitment of Ythdf2 and eEF1α-1. Moreover, BMSCs overexpressing Mettl3 and Nsun4 can promote the repair of cartilage defects in vivo. Taken together, our study demonstrates that m⁵C and m⁶A co-regulate the translation of Sox9 during the chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs, which provides a therapeutic target for clinical implications.

Nsun4-mediated m5C and Mettl3-mediated m6A are found to be required for Sox9-regulated chondrogenic differentiation, whereby Nsun4 and Mettl3 interact with each other and recruit Ythdf2 and eEF1a-1 to form a complex at the 3’UTR of Sox9.

Hedgehog signalling in bone and osteoarthritis: the role of Smoothened and cholesterol

Hedgehog signalling is essential for development, crucial for normal anatomical arrangement and activated during tissue damage repair. Dysregulation of hedgehog signalling is associated with cancer, developmental disorders and other diseases including osteoarthritis (OA). The hedgehog gene was first discovered in Drosophila melanogaster, and the pathway is evolutionarily conserved in most animals. Although there are several hedgehog ligands with different protein expression patterns, they share a common plasma membrane receptor, Patched1 and hedgehog signalling pathway activation is transduced through the G-protein-coupled receptor-like protein Smoothened (SMO) and downstream effectors. Functional assays revealed that activation of SMO is dependent on sterol binding, and cholesterol was observed bound to SMO in crystallography experiments. In vertebrates, hedgehog signalling coordinates endochondral ossification and balances osteoblast and osteoclast activation to maintain homeostasis. A recently discovered mutation of SMO in humans (SMO^R173C ) is predicted to alter cholesterol binding and is associated with a higher risk of hip OA. Functional studies in mice and human tissue analysis provide evidence that hedgehog signalling is pathologically activated in chondrocytes of osteoarthritic cartilage.

SOX9 and SATB2 Immunohistochemistry Cannot Reliably Distinguish Between Osteosarcoma and Chondrosarcoma on Biopsy Material

INTRODUCTION

Limited tissue in biopsies of malignant bone lesions can preclude definitive subclassification, especially when cellular or matrix elements are sparse, absent, or confounding. It is uncertain whether IHC for SOX9 (marker of chondrogenesis) and SATB2 (marker of osteoblastic differentiation) may be discriminatory tools towards osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma.

METHODS

This study interrogated the pre-resection biopsies of a cohort of osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma with SATB2 and SOX9 in tandem, to assess their value as diagnostic adjuncts as well as their concordance with final resection diagnoses.

RESULTS

SATB2 was expressed more frequently in osteosarcoma (46/53, 86%) compared to chondrosarcoma (9/18, 50%); SOX9 was expressed in high frequencies in both osteosarcoma (52/53, 98%) and chondrosarcoma (17/18, 94%), and SATB2 and SOX9 were co-expressed in both osteosarcoma (46/53, 89%) and chondrosarcoma (8/18, 44%).

CONCLUSIONS

There exists significant overlap in expression of SATB2 and SOX9 in osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma. These markers are not expressed in a distribution that is unique enough for application towards this particular diagnostic differential.

Novel SRY-box transcription factor 9 variant in campomelic dysplasia and the location of missense and nonsense variants along the protein domains: A case report

BACKGROUND

Campomelic dysplasia (CD) is a rare disorder that involves the skeletal and genital systems. This condition has been associated with a diverse set of mutations in the SRY-box transcription factor 9 (SOX9) gene.

CASE PRESENTATION

We herein report a case involving a 4-year-old female patient with CD, female sex reversal, type 1 Arnold-Chiari malformation, and bilateral conductive hearing loss and investigate the causal mutation. Whole-exome sequencing analysis detected a novel Trp115X* variant in the SOX9 gene. We performed a literature review of the reported cases and demonstrated that the missense variants were located only in the self-dimerization domain (DIM) and high-mobility group box domains. We also reported that variants in the DIM domain do not cause sex reversal and identified that the amino acid sequences that were mutated in the patients with campomelic dysplasia are evolutionarily conserved among primates.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that missense variants cannot be located in the K2, PQA, and PQS given that these domains function critically for transcriptional activation or repression of target genes and evolve under purifying selection.

Case report: A de novo Non-sense SOX9 mutation (p.Q417*) located in transactivation domain is Responsible for Campomelic Dysplasia

BACKGROUND

Campomelic dysplasia (CD) is an autosomal dominant skeletal dysplasia syndrome characterized by shortness and bowing of lower extremities, and often accompanied by XY sex reversal. Heterozygous pathogenic variants of SOX9 or rearrangement involving the long arm of chromosome 17 are the causes of disease. However, evidence for pathogenesis of SOX9 haploinsufficiency is insufficient.

METHODS

We enrolled a Chinese family where the fetus was diagnosed with CD. The affected fetus was selected for whole-exome sequencing to identify the pathogenic mutations in this family.

RESULTS

After data filtering, a novel non-sense SOX9 variant (NM_000346.3; c.1249C > T; p.Q417*) was identified as the pathogenic lesion in the fetus. Further co-segregation analysis using Sanger sequencing confirmed that this novel SOX9 mutation (c.1249C > T; p.Q417*) was a de novo mutation in the affected fetus. This terminated codon mutation identified by bioinformatics was located at an evolutionarily conserved site of SOX9. The bioinformatics-based analysis predicted this variant was pathogenic and affected SOX9 transactivation activity.

CONCLUSION

CD is a rare condition, which connected with SOX9 tightly. We identified a novel heterozygous SOX9 variant (p.Q417*) in a Chinese CD family. Our study supports the putative reduced transactivation of SOX9 variants in the pathogenicity of CD.

A dominant-negative SOX18 mutant disrupts multiple regulatory layers essential to transcription factor activity

Few genetically dominant mutations involved in human disease have been fully explained at the molecular level. In cases where the mutant gene encodes a transcription factor, the dominant-negative mode of action of the mutant protein is particularly poorly understood. Here, we studied the genome-wide mechanism underlying a dominant-negative form of the SOX18 transcription factor (SOX18^RaOp) responsible for both the classical mouse mutant Ragged Opossum and the human genetic disorder Hypotrichosis-lymphedema-telangiectasia-renal defect syndrome. Combining three single-molecule imaging assays in living cells together with genomics and proteomics analysis, we found that SOX18^RaOp disrupts the system through an accumulation of molecular interferences which impair several functional properties of the wild-type SOX18 protein, including its target gene selection process. The dominant-negative effect is further amplified by poisoning the interactome of its wild-type counterpart, which perturbs regulatory nodes such as SOX7 and MEF2C. Our findings explain in unprecedented detail the multi-layered process that underpins the molecular aetiology of dominant-negative transcription factor function.

Signaling Pathways in Bone Development and Their Related Skeletal Dysplasia

Bone development is a tightly regulated process. Several integrated signaling pathways including HH, PTHrP, WNT, NOTCH, TGF-β, BMP, FGF and the transcription factors SOX9, RUNX2 and OSX are essential for proper skeletal development. Misregulation of these signaling pathways can cause a large spectrum of congenital conditions categorized as skeletal dysplasia. Since the signaling pathways involved in skeletal dysplasia interact at multiple levels and have a different role depending on the time of action (early or late in chondrogenesis and osteoblastogenesis), it is still difficult to precisely explain the physiopathological mechanisms of skeletal disorders. However, in recent years, significant progress has been made in elucidating the mechanisms of these signaling pathways and genotype–phenotype correlations have helped to elucidate their role in skeletogenesis. Here, we review the principal signaling pathways involved in bone development and their associated skeletal dysplasia.

Control of the Autophagy Pathway in Osteoarthritis: Key Regulators, Therapeutic Targets and Therapeutic Strategies

Autophagy is involved in different degenerative diseases and it may control epigenetic modifications, metabolic processes, stem cells differentiation as well as apoptosis. Autophagy plays a key role in maintaining the homeostasis of cartilage, the tissue produced by chondrocytes; its impairment has been associated to cartilage dysfunctions such as osteoarthritis (OA). Due to their location in a reduced oxygen context, both differentiating and mature chondrocytes are at risk of premature apoptosis, which can be prevented by autophagy. AutophagomiRNAs, which regulate the autophagic process, have been found differentially expressed in OA. AutophagomiRNAs, as well as other regulatory molecules, may also be useful as therapeutic targets. In this review, we describe and discuss the role of autophagy in OA, focusing mainly on the control of autophagomiRNAs in OA pathogenesis and their potential therapeutic applications.

Sorting Sox: Diverse Roles for Sox Transcription Factors During Neural Crest and Craniofacial Development

Sox transcription factors play many diverse roles during development, including regulating stem cell states, directing differentiation, and influencing the local chromatin landscape. Of the twenty vertebrate Sox factors, several play critical roles in the development the neural crest, a key vertebrate innovation, and the subsequent formation of neural crest-derived structures, including the craniofacial complex. Herein, we review the specific roles for individual Sox factors during neural crest cell formation and discuss how some factors may have been essential for the evolution of the neural crest. Additionally, we describe how Sox factors direct neural crest cell differentiation into diverse lineages such as melanocytes, glia, and cartilage and detail their involvement in the development of specific craniofacial structures. Finally, we highlight several SOXopathies associated with craniofacial phenotypes.

Transcription Factors in Cartilage Homeostasis and Osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common degenerative joint disease, and it is characterized by articular cartilage loss. In part, OA is caused by aberrant anabolic and catabolic activities of the chondrocyte, the only cell type present in cartilage. These chondrocyte activities depend on the intra- and extracellular signals that the cell receives and integrates into gene expression. The key proteins for this integration are transcription factors. A large number of transcription factors exist, and a better understanding of the transcription factors activated by the various signaling pathways active during OA can help us to better understand the complex etiology of OA. In addition, establishing such a profile can help to stratify patients in different subtypes, which can be a very useful approach towards personalized therapy. In this review, we discuss crucial transcription factors for extracellular matrix metabolism, chondrocyte hypertrophy, chondrocyte senescence, and autophagy in chondrocytes. In addition, we discuss how insight into these factors can be used for treatment purposes.