Distribution of endocytosed molecules to intracellular acidic environments correlates with immunotoxin activity

A novel assay for monitoring internalization of nanocarrier coupled antibodies

Background

Discovery of tumor-selective antibodies or antibody fragments is a promising approach for delivering therapeutic agents to antigen over-expressing cancers. Therefore it is important to develop methods for the identification of target- and function specific antibodies for effective drug delivery. Here we describe a highly selective and sensitive method for characterizing the internalizing potential of multivalently displayed antibodies or ligands conjugated to liposomes into tumor cells. The assay requires minute amounts of histidine-tagged ligand and relies on the non-covalent coupling of these antibodies to fluorescent liposomes containing a metal ion-chelating lipid. Following incubation of cells with antibody-conjugated liposomes, surface bound liposomes are gently removed and the remaining internalized liposomes are quantitated based on fluorescence in a high throughput manner. We have termed this methodology "Chelated Ligand Internalization Assay", or CLIA.

Results

The specificity of the assay was demonstrated with different antibodies to the ErbB-2 and EGF receptors. Antibody-uptake correlated with receptor expression levels in tumor cell lines with a range of receptor expression. Furthermore, Ni-NTA liposomes containing doxorubicin were used to screen for the ability of antibodies to confer target-specific cytotoxicity. Using an anti-ErbB2 single chain Fv (scFv) (F5) antibody, cytotoxicity could be conferred to ErbB2-overexpressing cells; however, a poly(ethylene glycol)-linked lipid (DSPE-PEG-NTA-Ni) was necessary to allow for efficient loading of the drug and to reduce nonspecific drug leakage during the course of the assay.

Conclusion

The CLIA method we describe here represents a rapid, sensitive and robust assay for the identification and characterization of tumor-specific antibodies capable of high drug-delivery efficiency when conjugated to liposomal nanocarriers.

Studies on the joint cytotoxicity of Wheat Germ Agglutinin and monensin

Wheat Germ Agglutinin (WGA) cytotoxicity has been studied using two human leukemia cell lines, Molt3 and K562, and human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). In spite of similar binding at the cell surface, WGA was found to promote cell death to a different extent in Molt3, K562 and PBMC and to induce different death events leading to apoptosis in Molt3 and either apoptosis and necrosis in K562 cells and PBMC. In Molt3 but not in K562 cells, WGA cytotoxicity could be potentiated 66-200 fold by 50 nM monensin, a carboxylic ionophore that perturbs the intracellular trafficking of endocytosed molecules. Synergism between the cytotoxic activities of WGA and monensin was demonstrated in Molt3 cells by comparing non toxic, or slightly toxic, doses of WGA and monensin alone or in combination. These results show that the cytotoxic effect of WGA is dependent on internalisation events which may differ among the cell lines used. WGA and monensin can enter the human diet being a component of wheat germ and an antibiotic used for zootechnic reasons in the bioindustry, respectively. These data reveal the synergistic effect between two dietary molecules, otherwise per se toxic at much higher concentrations, with possible implications for human and animal health.

Identification of ricin A-chain HLA class II-restricted epitopes by human T-cell clones

The identification of ricin toxin A-chain (RTA) epitopes and the molecular context in which they are recognized will allow strategies to be devised that prevent/suppress an anti-RTA immune response in patients treated with RTA-based immunotoxins. RTA-specific human T-cell lines and T-cell clones were produced by in vitro priming of PBMC. The T-cell clones used a limited set of Vbeta chains (Vbeta1, Vbeta2 and Vbeta8) to recognize RTA epitopes. The use of RTA deletion mutants demonstrated that T-cell lines and T-cell clones from three out of four donors responded to RTA epitopes within the domain D124-Q223, whereas one donor recognized the region I1-D124. The response to RTA peptides of T-cell lines and T-cell clones from two donors allowed the identification of immunogenic segments (D124-G140 and L161-T190) recognized in the context of different HLA-DRB1 alleles (HLA-DRB1*0801, and HLA-DRB1*11011 and B1*03011, respectively). The response to L161-T190 was investigated in greater detail. We found that the HLA-DRB1*03011 allele presents a minimal epitope represented by the sequence I175-Y183 of RTA, whereas the HLA-DRB1*11011 allele presents the minimal epitope M174-I184. RTA peptides and an I175A RTA point mutant allowed us to identify I175 as a crucial residue for the epitope(s) recognized by the two HLA-DRB1 alleles. Failure of T-cell clones to recognize ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) showing sequences similar but not identical to RTA further confirmed the role of I175 as a key residue for the epitope recognized in the context of HLA-DRB1*11011/03011 alleles.

Production of anti-CD3 and anti-CD7 ricin A-immunotoxins for a clinical pilot study

This report describes the preparation of an immunotoxin-combination, consisting of an anti-CD3 and anti-CD7 monoclonal antibody (MoAb) both conjugated to the A-chain of plant toxin ricin, for the experimental treatment of graft-versus-host disease. MoAbs and toxin were conjugated by conventional biochemical and chromatographic techniques. Raw materials, intermediate and final products were evaluated in accordance with the relevant 'points to consider' of the FDA. Yields, purity and sterility of the two final products were all satisfactory. Preservation of MoAb-affinity and toxin-activity were confirmed in biological assays. The LD50, 25-45 mg immunotoxin-combination/kg mouse, equalled that of similar immunotoxins already in clinical use. Because in vitro cross-reactivity screening revealed an unexpected binding of the CD3-MoAb to the esophagus epithelium, human doses of immunotoxin-combination were administered to two cynomolgus monkeys. Clinically relevant serum concentrations were obtained without irreversible toxicities occurring. The T(1/2) varied between approximately 6 and 9 h and the C(max) ranged from 1.8 to 3.9 microg/ml. The main side effect was a transient rise of serum creatine kinase. Importantly, neither damage nor binding of the CD3-immunotoxin to the monkey esophagus epithelium could be demonstrated. It was concluded that sufficient material of proper quality and with an acceptable toxicity profile was produced, warranting the evaluation in a clinical pilot-study.

Genetic grafting of membrane-acting peptides to the cytotoxin dianthin augments its ability to de-stabilize lipid bilayers and enhances its cytotoxic potential as the component of transferrin-toxin conjugates

Three chimeric proteins were obtained by fusing together the dianthin gene and DNA fragments encoding for the following membrane-acting peptides: the N-terminus of protein G of the vesicular stomatitis virus (KFT25), the N terminus of the HA2 hemagglutinin of influenza virus (pHA2), and a membrane-acting peptide (pJVE). Chimeric dianthins (KFT25DIA, pHA2DIA and pJVEDIA) retained full enzymatic activity in cell-free assays and showed increased ability to induce pH-dependent calcein release from large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs). pHA2DIA and pJVEDIA also showed faster kinetics of interaction with LUVs, while KFT25DIA and pHA2DIA displayed a reduced cytotoxicity as compared to wild-type dianthin. Conjugates made by chemically cross-linking KFT25DIA or pJVEDIA and human transferrin (Tfn) showed greater cell-killing efficiency than conjugates of Tfn and wild-type dianthin. As a consequence, by fusion of membrane-acting peptides to the dianthin sequence the specificity factor (i.e., the ratio between non-specific and specific toxicity) of Tfn-KFT25DIA, Tfn-pHA2DIA and Tfn-pJVEDIA was increased with respect to that of Tfn-based conjugates made with wild-type dianthin. Taken together, our results suggest that genetic fusion of membrane-acting peptides to enzymatic cytotoxins results in the acquisition of new physico-chemical properties exploitable for designing new recombinant cytotoxins and to tackle cell-intoxication mechanisms.

Enhancement of ricin toxin A chain immunotoxin activity: synthesis, ionophoretic ability, and in vitro activity of monensin derivatives

Site-selective toxin delivery was achieved by coupling monoclonal antibody to the A chain subunit of ricin (RTA-IT). The cell-killing potency of RTA-IT can be drastically increased in vitro by using ionophores such as monensin. To reduce the intrinsic toxicity of monensin and to enhance its in vitro and in vivo activity, we synthesized 7 derivatives characterized by different lipophilicities. These derivatives were also analyzed for ionophoretic activity on intact cells, toxicity, and RTA-IT-enhancing activity. Two different RTA-IT were assayed on a human leukemia cell line. A correlation between lipophilicity, ionophoretic activity, and RTA-IT enhancement was observed. The compounds with the highest polar charge showed low intrinsic toxicity, revealed moderate ionophoretic activity, and were able to enhance RTA-IT only at high concentrations, whereas more lipophilic compounds (with a C28 tail or a phenyl group) showed significant ionophoretic activity and good enhancing properties.

Self-potentiation of ligand-toxin conjugates containing ricin A chain fused with viral structures

A chimeric protein was obtained by fusing together the ricin toxin A chain (RTA) gene and a DNA fragment encoding the N terminus of protein G of the vesicular stomatitis virus. Chimeric RTA (cRTA) retained full enzymic activity in a cell-free assay, but was 10-fold less toxic against human leukemic cells than either native RTA (nRTA) or unmodified recombinant RTA (rRTA). However, conjugates made with cRTA and human transferrin (Tfn) showed 10-20-fold greater cell killing efficacy than Tfn-nRTA or Tfn-rRTA conjugates despite equivalent binding of the three conjugates to target tumor cells. As a consequence, by fusion of the KFT25 peptide to the RTA sequence, the specificity factor (i.e. the ratio between nonspecific and specific cytotoxicity) of Tfn-cRTA was increased 90-240 times with respect to those of Tfn-nRTA and Tfn-rRTA. cRTA interacted with phospholipid vesicles with 15-fold faster kinetics than nRTA at acidic pH. Taken together, our results suggest that the ability of vesicular stomatitis virus protein G to interact with cell membranes can be transferred to RTA to facilitate its translocation to the cell cytosol. Our strategy may serve as a general approach for potentiating the cytotoxic efficacy of antitumor immunotoxins.

Effects of cellular pharmacology on drug distribution in tissues

The efficacy of targeted therapeutics such as immunotoxins is directly related to both the extent of distribution achievable and the degree of drug internalization by individual cells in the tissue of interest. The factors that influence the tissue distribution of such drugs include drug transport; receptor/drug binding; and cellular pharmacology, the processing and routing of the drug within cells. To examine the importance of cellular pharmacology, previously treated only superficially, we have developed a mathematical model for drug transport in tissues that includes drug and receptor internalization, recycling, and degradation, as well as drug diffusion in the extracellular space and binding to cell surface receptors. We have applied this "cellular pharmacology model" to a model drug/cell system, specifically, transferrin and the well-defined transferrin cycle in CHO cells. We compare simulation results to models with extracellular diffusion only or diffusion with binding to cell surface receptors and present a parameter sensitivity analysis. The comparison of models illustrates that inclusion of intracellular trafficking significantly increases the total transferrin concentration throughout much of the tissue while decreasing the penetration depth. Increasing receptor affinity or tissue receptor density reduces permeation of extracellular drug while increasing the peak value of the intracellular drug concentration, resulting in "internal trapping" of transferrin near the source; this could account for heterogeneity of drug distributions observed in experimental systems. Other results indicate that the degree of drug internalization is not predicted by the total drug profile. Hence, when intracellular drug is required for a therapeutic effect, the optimal treatment may not result from conditions that produce the maximal total drug distribution. Examination of models that include cellular pharmacology may help guide rational drug design and provide useful information for whole body pharmacokinetic studies.

Escape mechanisms of human leukemic cells to long-term immunotoxin treatment in an in vitro experimental model

In kinetic assays, an anti-CD5-ricin A chain (ST.I-RTA) immunoconjugate (immunotoxins, IT) specifically inhibited up to 40% the protein synthesis of Jurkat target cells within the first 40 hr. Longer exposures of leukemia cells to ST.I-RTA resulted in a progressively higher number of target cells escaping IT treatment and becoming resistant to further treatment with ST.I-RTA even in the presence of the RTA-IT enhancer monensin. Resistant Jurkat cells proliferated at the same rate as control untreated cells, and were as sensitive as control cells to a transferrin-RTA IT, indicating that the ST.I-RTA-resistant tumor-cell population did not become insensitive to the enzymatic activity of RTA. Binding studies revealed that the anti-CD5 IT treatment induced a transient modulation of CD5 antigens but not of the functionally related CD3 antigens. The CD5 antigens were re-expressed at the cell surface following removal of the IT molecules from the culture medium with 1.1% of the total CD5 Ag being re-expressed per hr. When our experimental data on the kinetics of cell intoxication by the IT were corrected for the proliferative potential of the resistant and of the sensitive tumor-cell populations, it appeared that the effect of ST.I-RTA treatment on Jurkat cells was only to delay cell growth for a limited time period (20 hr) without reducing effectively the tumor-cell burden. Our results may have implications for the long-term treatment of target tumor cells with IT.

Different cytotoxic activity and intracellular fate of an anti-CD5-momordin immunotoxin in normal compared to tumour cells

We investigated the different sensitivity of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and human T cell leukaemias (Jurkat and CEM) to an anti-CD5-momordin immunotoxin. In a short-term assay, the immunotoxin displayed different cytotoxic activity on normal and tumour cells: for leukaemic cell lines an incubation time of 72 h was necessary for the immunotoxin to reach the IC50 of 41-53 pM, compared to the 1 h sufficient for 6 pM immunotoxin to inhibit 50% of PBMC protein synthesis. In a long-term clonogenic assay (15 days), the immunotoxin demonstrated a comparable efficacy of clonogenic cell killing for both cell types. We investigated the immunotoxin internalization pathway by a flow-cytometric method and our data seem to indicate that the molecules meet a different intracellular fate in the two cell populations. It may be assumed that the low cytotoxic activity of immunotoxins on tumour cells, detected in the short-term assay, is due to inefficient delivery to their cytoplasmatic target, while a longer exposure of the cells to the immunotoxin promotes adequate intracellular distribution.

A critical comparison of three internalization assays applied to the evaluation of a given mAb as a toxin-carrier candidate

In the attempt to define a strategy for screening new monoclonal antibodies (mAb) that could be appropriate for clinical application in oncology, we evaluated the suitability of three methods: a direct internalization assay (DIA), an indirect internalization assay (IIA) and an indirect cytotoxicity assay (ICA), by applying them to already selected mAb. The latter were directed against three antigenic systems [38-kDa glycoprotein (gp38), epidermal growth factor receptor, and the neu oncogene product], which, according to their tumor selectivity, could be considered suitable for mAb-guided therapy. The dose-dependent and time-dependent binding, as well as the low intra-assay variability, demonstrated the reliability of the three tests. However, a certain degree of inter-assay variability was observed in each one, the highest value being that found when IIA was applied. Furthermore, the degree of variability, as well as the predictability, seemed to be more related to the mAb/antigen (Ag) combination used rather than to the test applied. From the overall data we suggest a procedure to be applied for screening purposes. As a first approach applied to the raw material, ICA is only suitable for screening in the case of an already selected toxin whereas IIA may be helpful to eliminate the true negative mAb. After purification of the relevant mAb a repeated analysis using DIA could allow the selection of true internalizing mAb. However, this second screening should be followed by a further analysis of the fate of the Ag-Ab complex after internalization.

Rapid cellular removal of a membrane-inserted foreign polypeptide

We have developed a system that makes it possible to study the fate of a foreign polypeptide that is inserted in the plasma membrane. Diphtheria toxin is a bacterial protein toxin that, upon acidification, has the ability to insert into the plasma membrane from the outside of eukaryotic cells. We present results that indicate endocytic uptake and degradation of the diphtheria toxin B-fragment after insertion into the membrane of Vero cells. The degradation rate of the fragment was found to be very high (t1/2 = 6 min) and dependent on cleavage of the extracellular part of the polypeptide with protease. Degradation was strongly inhibited in ATP-depleted cells, as well as at temperatures below 18 degrees C, and it was partially inhibited when the cytosol was acidified to block endocytosis from clathrin-coated pits. Degradation was also reduced in the presence of NH4Cl. The results indicate that the inserted and cleaved B-fragment is degraded by a process requiring endocytosis and transport to late endosomes or to lysosomes.

Rationale for the clinical use of immunotoxins: monoclonal antibodies conjugated to ribosome-inactivating proteins

The use of chemotherapeutic drugs in combination with bone marrow transplantation to treat cancer patients has markedly improved the disease-free survival and cure rate. Part of the tumor cells, however, can escape from therapy due to resistance. Tumor-specific delivery of toxins that do not interfere with conventional drugs and are not cell cycle dependent seems to be a reasonable approach to overcome this problem. Natural ribosome-inhibiting-proteins (RIPs) from plants, bacteria and fungi which are extremely toxic inhibitors of protein synthesis are isolated and coupled to monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) and receptor-specific ligands, immunotoxins (ITs), to fulfil this purpose. ITs are very suitable to eliminate malignant cells in vitro and in vivo. RIPs contain two or three active sites: a binding site which can be absent in a part of the RIPs and can be replaced by the MoAb; a translocation site that facilitates transport into the cytosol after internalization, and a cytotoxic site that enzymatically inhibits protein synthesis. Binding site containing toxins induce strong nonspecific cytotoxicity when coupled to MoAbs. Recent developments in recombinant DNA techniques enable genetic elimination of the binding site to reduce nonspecific cytotoxicity of these toxins. In this review the structures and mechanisms of action of RIPs as well as factors that influence cytotoxicity of immunotoxins are discussed. Moreover the problems dealing with in vivo application of ITs such as blood clearance by instability of the IT and hepatic entrapment, and production of antibodies directed against MoAb and toxin are reviewed.