Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy via retroperitoneal approach in a patient with horseshoe kidney

Robot-assisted Partial Nephrectomy With Selective Artery Clamping for Renal Cell Carcinoma in Horseshoe Kidney

BACKGROUND

Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy (RAPN) has become the standard treatment for small renal tumors, including highly complex cases. However, applying RAPN to renal tumors in the horseshoe kidney (HSK) is clinically challenging due to malformations and complex blood supply. Herein, we present two cases of RAPN in patients with HSK treated using selective artery clamping methods.

CASE REPORTS

A 61-year-old male with a 15 mm renal tumor located on the upper pole of the right HSK was referred to our Department. The patient underwent RAPN via the transperitoneal approach, following a three-dimensional computed tomography (3D-CT) assessment. Additionally, before surgery, we confirmed which renal arteries would be clamped in surgery by examining the kidney regions supplied by each renal artery. The second patient referred to our Department, a 45-year-old male, had a 46 mm renal tumor located on the isthmus of the HSK. His tumor received blood supply from two renal arteries, with the bilateral collecting systems converging and forming a ureter on 3D-CT. The patient underwent RAPN through an intraperitoneal approach in the semi-lateral position, with port placement lower than in standard RAPN. Pathological examinations revealed clear-cell renal cell carcinoma with negative surgical margins in both cases. Both patients had no recurrences or metastases at 53 and 13 months post-surgery, respectively.

CONCLUSION

We present cases successfully treated with RAPN with selective artery clamping methods for HSK using 3D-CT without encountering complications, even in isthmus tumors.

How far has robot-assisted partial nephrectomy reached?

Nephron-sparing surgery is the standard treatment for small renal mass (SRM). Nephron-sparing surgery has evolved from an open to a minimally invasive technique. Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy (RAPN) is the latest technique in this field and is reported to be safe and feasible, showing oncologically and functionally superior or compatible results compared with open and laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for SRM. This is not limited to only SRM but also applies to large and complex renal masses and other challenging situations. RAPN showed good oncological and functional outcomes for ≥clinical T2 renal tumors, complex renal masses (PADUA score ≥10, RENAL score ≥10), hilar renal tumors, and multiple renal tumors. In addition, the outcomes of RAPN in these challenging cases were not inferior to those in conventional cases. RAPN could also be applied to a number of challenging cases in which the open technique was considered first. RAPN showed good results in patients with a solitary kidney, horseshoe kidney, and in repeat surgeries. Furthermore, RAPN could be safely performed on obese, elderly, and pediatric patients. Finally, this review evaluates efficiency and utility of RAPN based on the results of challenging cases of renal masses and to project the future of RAPN.

Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma in the isthmus of horseshoe kidney

The anatomic features of a horseshoe kidney are unique—the kidney is fixed and poorly mobile, with many arterial and venous blood supplies, thereby complicating minimally invasive surgery for renal cancer in this setting. Several reports have described robot-assisted partial nephrectomy (RAPN) to treat renal cancer in a horseshoe kidney, but no reports of RAPN for renal cancer in the isthmus of a horseshoe kidney have been published to date. This case report describes the technique and usefulness of RAPN for treatment of renal cancer located in the isthmus of a horseshoe kidney.

•

Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy for a horseshoe kidney is technically difficult.

•

The problem is poor kidney mobility and complex blood vessels.

•

This describes the technique and the benefit of RAPN for a tumor in the isthmus.

•

The key is to create an appropriate and safe surgical view for each scene.