Optimization and Validation of a Custom-Designed Perfusion Bioreactor for Bone Tissue Engineering: Flow Assessment and Optimal Culture Environmental Conditions

Various perfusion bioreactor systems have been designed to improve cell culture with three-dimensional porous scaffolds, and there is some evidence that fluid force improves the osteogenic commitment of the progenitors. However, because of the unique design concept and operational configuration of each study, the experimental setups of perfusion bioreactor systems are not always compatible with other systems. To reconcile results from different systems, the thorough optimization and validation of experimental configuration are required in each system. In this study, optimal experimental conditions for a perfusion bioreactor were explored in three steps. First, an in silico modeling was performed using a scaffold geometry obtained by microCT and an expedient geometry parameterized with porosity and permeability to assess the accuracy of calculated fluid shear stress and computational time. Then, environmental factors for cell culture were optimized, including the volume of the medium, bubble suppression, and medium evaporation. Further, by combining the findings, it was possible to determine the optimal flow rate at which cell growth was supported while osteogenic differentiation was triggered. Here, we demonstrated that fluid shear stress up to 15 mPa was sufficient to induce osteogenesis, but cell growth was severely impacted by the volume of perfused medium, the presence of air bubbles, and medium evaporation, all of which are common concerns in perfusion bioreactor systems. This study emphasizes the necessity of optimization of experimental variables, which may often be underreported or overlooked, and indicates steps which can be taken to address issues common to perfusion bioreactors for bone tissue engineering.

Osteogenic induction of human mesenchymal stem cells in multilayered electrospun scaffolds at different flow rates and configurations in a perfusion bioreactor

Electrospun scaffolds are potentially interesting in bone tissue engineering due to a strong structural similarity to the natural bone matrix. To investigate the osteogenic behavior of cells on the scaffolds, dynamic culture of cells is essential to simulate the biological environment. In the present study, human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) were cultured on multilayer nanohydroxyapatite-polycaprolactone electrospun scaffolds at different configurations (horizontal with or without pressure and parallel with the medium flow) and flow rates in a perfusion bioreactor. Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, cell viability, Ca deposition and RUNX2 expression were determined in three different dynamic states, and compared with static culture after 1, 3, 7, and 14 days. Among dynamic groups, RUNX2 gene expression upregulated more in a horizontal state at a low flow rate without mechanical pressure (LF) and parallel flow (PF), than static group on day 7. At a high flow rate with mechanical pressure, Ca deposition and ALP activity increased 2.34 and 1.7 folds more than in static culture over 7 days, respectively. Furthermore, ALP activity, Ca deposition and RUNX2 gene expression increased in PF samples. PF provided longer culture time with higher cell differentiation. Therefore, high flow rate with mechanical pressure and PF are suggested for producing differentiated cell structure for bone tissue engineering.