Different outcomes in urethral reconstruction using elastin and collagen patches and conduits in rabbits

Mechanical, compositional and morphological characterisation of the human male urethra for the development of a biomimetic tissue engineered urethral scaffold

This study addresses a crucial gap in the literature by characterising the relationship between urethral tissue mechanics, composition and gross structure. We then utilise these data to develop a biomimetic urethral scaffold with physical properties that more accurately mimic the native tissue than existing gold standard scaffolds; small intestinal submucosa (SIS) and urinary bladder matrix (UBM). Nine human urethra samples were mechanically characterised using pressure-diameter and uniaxial extension testing. The composition and gross structure of the tissue was determined using immunohistological staining. A pressure stiffening response is observed during the application of intraluminal pressure. The elastic and viscous tissue responses to extension are free of regional or directional variance. The elastin and collagen content of the tissue correlates significantly with tissue mechanics. Building on these data, a biomimetic urethral scaffold was fabricated from collagen and elastin in a ratio that mimics the composition of the native tissue. The resultant scaffold is comprised of a dense inner layer and a porous outer layer that structurally mimic the submucosa and corpus spongiosum layers of the native tissue, respectively. The porous outer layer facilitated more uniform cell infiltration relative to SIS and UBM when implanted subcutaneously (p < 0.05). The mechanical properties of the biomimetic scaffold better mimic the native tissue compared to SIS and UBM. The tissue characterisation data presented herein paves the way for the development of biomimetic urethral grafts, and the novel scaffold we develop demonstrates positive findings that warrant further in vivo evaluation.

Urethral reconstruction of critical defects in rabbits using molecularly defined tubular type I collagen biomatrices: key issues in growth factor addition

Tubular type I collagen biomatrices with and without growth factors (GFs) were constructed and evaluated in a rabbit model for critical urethral defects. Porous tubular biomatrices with an inner diameter of 3  mm were prepared using highly purified collagen fibrils and were crosslinked with or without heparin. Heparinized biomatrices were supplemented with the heparin-binding GFs vascular endothelial GF, fibroblast GF-2, and heparin-binding epidermal GF. Biomatrices with and without GFs were used to replace a critical 1 cm urethral segment in rabbits (n = 32). All animals showed normal urination without urinary retention. General histology and immunohistology of graft areas (2, 4, 12, and 24 weeks after implantation) indicated that all biomatrices were replaced by urethra-like structures with normal appearing cytokeratin-positive urothelium surrounded by vascularized tissue. The GF-containing biomatrices showed an increase in extracellular matrix deposition, neovascularization, urothelium, glands, granulocytes, and fibroblasts, compared with biomatrices without GF. GFs substantially improved molecular features of healing but failed to be superior in functional outcome. Retrograde urethrography indicated a normal urethral caliber in case of biomatrices without GF, but a relative narrowing of the urethra at 2 weeks postsurgery and diverticula after 4 weeks in case of biomatrices with GF. In conclusion, tubular acellular type I collagen biomatrices were successful in repairing urethral lesions in artificial urethral defects, and inclusion of GF has a profound effect on regenerative processes.