Early days of quantum crystallography: A personal account

Analytic Construction of One-Electron Reduced Density Matrices from Electron Densities within Finite Basis Sets

We show how to construct analytically all one-electron reduced density matrices (1-RDMs) compatible with a given electron density within a finite basis set, provided that the density is specified as a symmetric quadratic form in terms of the basis functions. Contrary to the current belief, exact linear dependencies in the basis function products assist, rather than hinder, such constructions. By applying the N-representability conditions to the analytically reconstructed 1-RDMs, one can perform a constrained search over physically acceptable 1-RDMs that yield a given finite-basis-set density. The discussion is illustrated with worked-out examples.

An information-theoretic approach to basis-set fitting of electron densities and other non-negative functions

The numerical ill-conditioning associated with approximating an electron density with a convex sum of Gaussian or Slater-type functions is overcome by using the (extended) Kullback-Leibler divergence to measure the deviation between the target and approximate density. The optimized densities are non-negative and normalized, and they are accurate enough to be used in applications related to molecular similarity, the topology of the electron density, and numerical molecular integration. This robust, efficient, and general approach can be used to fit any non-negative normalized functions (e.g., the kinetic energy density and molecular electron density) to a convex sum of non-negative basis functions. We present a fixed-point iteration method for optimizing the Kullback-Leibler divergence and compare it to conventional gradient-based optimization methods. These algorithms are released through the free and open-source BFit package, which also includes a L2-norm squared optimization routine applicable to any square-integrable scalar function.

Extracting Quantitative Information at Quantum Mechanical Level from Noncovalent Interaction Index Analyses

The noncovalent interaction (NCI) index is nowadays a well-known strategy to detect NCIs in molecular systems. Even though it initially provided only qualitative descriptions, the technique has been recently extended to also extract quantitative information. To accomplish this task, integrals of powers of the electron distribution were considered, with the requirement that the overall electron density can be clearly decomposed as sum of distinct fragment contributions to enable the definition of the (noncovalent) integration region. So far, this was done by only exploiting approximate promolecular electron densities, which are given by the sum of spherically averaged atomic electron distributions and thus represent too crude approximations. Therefore, to obtain more quantum mechanically (QM) rigorous results from NCI index analyses, in this work, we propose to use electron densities obtained through the transfer of extremely localized molecular orbitals (ELMOs) or through the recently developed QM/ELMO embedding technique. Although still approximate, the electron distributions resulting from the abovementioned methods are fully QM and, above all, are again partitionable into subunit contributions, which makes them completely suitable for the NCI integral approach. Therefore, we benchmarked the integrals resulting from NCI index analyses (both those based on the promolecular densities and those based on ELMO electron distributions) against interaction energies computed at a high quantum chemical level (in particular, at the coupled cluster level). The performed test calculations have indicated that the NCI integrals based on ELMO electron densities outperform the promolecular ones. Furthermore, it was observed that the novel quantitative NCI-(QM/)ELMO approach can be also profitably exploited both to characterize and evaluate the strength of specific interactions between ligand subunits and protein residues in protein-ligand complexes and to follow the evolution of NCIs along trajectories of molecular dynamics simulations. Although further methodological improvements are still possible, the new quantitative ELMO-based technique could be already exploited in situations in which fast and reliable assessments of NCIs are crucial, such as in computational high-throughput screenings for drug discovery.

A Step toward the Quantification of Noncovalent Interactions in Large Biological Systems: The Independent Gradient Model-Extremely Localized Molecular Orbital Approach

The independent gradient model (IGM) is a recent electron density-based computational method that enables to detect and quantify covalent and noncovalent interactions. When applied to large systems, the original version of the technique still relies on promolecular electron densities given by the sum of spherically averaged atomic electron distributions, which leads to approximate evaluations of the inter- and intramolecular interactions occurring in systems of biological interest. To overcome this drawback and perform IGM analyses based on quantum mechanically rigorous electron densities also for macromolecular systems, we coupled the IGM approach with the recently constructed libraries of extremely localized molecular orbitals (ELMOs) that allow fast and reliable reconstructions of polypeptide and protein electron densities. The validation tests performed on small polypeptides and peptide dimers have shown that the novel IGM-ELMO strategy provides results that are systematically closer to the fully quantum mechanical ones and outperforms the IGM method based on the crude promolecular approximation, but still keeping a quite low computational cost. The results of the test calculations carried out on proteins have also confirmed the trends observed for the IGM analyses conducted on small systems. This makes us envisage the future application of the novel IGM-ELMO approach to unravel complicated noncovalent interaction networks (e.g., in protein-protein contacts) or to rationally design new drugs through molecular docking calculations and virtual high-throughput screenings.

Quantum Mechanics/Extremely Localized Molecular Orbital Embedding Strategy for Excited States: Coupling to Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory and Equation-of-Motion Coupled Cluster

The QM/ELMO (quantum mechanics/extremely localized molecular orbital) method is a recently developed embedding technique in which the most important region of the system under examination is treated at fully quantum mechanical level, while the rest is described by means of transferred and frozen extremely localized molecular orbitals. In this paper, we propose the first application of the QM/ELMO approach to the investigation of excited states, and, in particular, we present the coupling of the QM/ELMO philosophy with Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TDDFT) and Equation-of-Motion Coupled Cluster with single and double substitutions (EOM-CCSD). The proposed TDDFT/ELMO and EOM-CCSD/ELMO strategies underwent a series of preliminary tests that were already considered for the validation of other embedding methods for excited states. The obtained results showed that the novel techniques allow the accurate description of localized excitations in large systems by only including a relatively small number of atoms in the region treated at fully quantum chemical level. Furthermore, for TDDFT/ELMO, it was also observed that (i) the method enables to avoid the presence of artificial low-lying charge-transfer states that may affect traditional TDDFT calculations, even using functionals that do not take into account long-range corrections, and (ii) the novel approach can be also successfully exploited to investigate local electronic transitions in quite large systems (e.g., reduced model of the Green Fluorescent Protein), and the accuracy of the results can be improved by including a sufficient number of chemically crucial fragments/residues in the quantum mechanical region. Finally, concerning EOM-CCSD/ELMO, it was also seen that, despite the quite crude approximation of an embedding potential given by frozen extremely localized molecular orbitals, the new strategy is able to satisfactorily account for the effects of the environment. This work paves the way to further extensions of the QM/ELMO philosophy for the study of local excitations in extended systems, suggesting the coupling of the QM/ELMO approach with other quantum chemical strategies for excited states, from the simplest ΔSCF techniques to the most advanced and computationally expensive multireferences methods.

Orbital-free quantum crystallography: view on forces in crystals

Quantum theory of atoms in molecules and the orbital-free density functional theory (DFT) are combined in this work to study the spatial distribution of electrostatic and quantum electronic forces acting in stable crystals. The electron distribution is determined by electrostatic electron mutual repulsion corrected for exchange and correlation, their attraction to nuclei and by electron kinetic energy. The latter defines the spread of permissible variations in the electron momentum resulting from the de Broglie relationship and uncertainty principle, as far as the limitations of Pauli principle and the presence of atomic nuclei and other electrons allow. All forces are expressed via kinetic and DFT potentials and then defined in terms of the experimental electron density and its derivatives; hence, this approach may be considered as orbital-free quantum crystallography. The net force acting on an electron in a crystal at equilibrium is zero everywhere, presenting a balance of the kinetic F kin( r ) and potential forces F ( r ). The critical points of both potentials are analyzed and they are recognized as the points at which forces F kin( r ) and F ( r ) individually are zero (the Lagrange points). The positions of these points in a crystal are described according to Wyckoff notations, while their types depend on the considered scalar field. It was found that F ( r ) force pushes electrons to the atomic nuclei, while the kinetic force F kin( r ) draws electrons from nuclei. This favors formation of electron concentration bridges between some of the nearest atoms. However, in a crystal at equilibrium, only kinetic potential v kin( r ) and corresponding force exhibit the electronic shells and atomic-like zero-flux basins around the nuclear attractors. The force-field approach and quantum topological theory of atoms in molecules are compared and their distinctions are clarified.

Localized Molecular Orbital-Based Embedding Scheme for Correlated Methods

Embedding strategies currently provide the best compromise between accuracy and computational cost in modeling chemical properties and processes of large and complex systems. In this framework, different methods have been proposed all over the years, from the very popular QM/MM approaches to the more recent and very promising density matrix and density functional embedding techniques. Here, we present a further development of the quantum mechanics/extremely localized molecular orbital technique (QM/ELMO) method, a recently proposed multiscale embedding strategy in which the chemically active region of the investigated system is treated at a fully quantum mechanical level, while the rest is described by frozen extremely localized molecular orbitals previously transferred from proper libraries or tailor-made model molecules. In particular, in this work we discuss and assess in detail the extension of the QM/ELMO approach to density functional theory and post-Hartree-Fock techniques by evaluating its performances when it is used to describe chemical reactions, bond dissociations, and intermolecular interactions. The preliminary test calculations have shown that, in the investigated cases, the new embedding strategy enables the results of the corresponding fully quantum mechanical computations to be reproduced within chemical accuracy in almost all the cases but with a significantly reduced computational cost, especially when correlated post-Hartree-Fock strategies are used to describe the quantum mechanical subsystem. In light of the obtained results, we already envisage the future application of the new correlated QM/ELMO techniques to the investigation of more challenging problems, such as the modeling of enzyme catalysis, the study of excited states of biomolecules, and the refinement of macromolecular X-ray crystal structures.

On the use of the Obara–Saika recurrence relations for the calculation of structure factors in quantum crystallography

Modern methods of quantum crystallography are techniques firmly rooted in quantum chemistry and, as in many quantum chemical strategies, electron densities are expressed as two-centre expansions that involve basis functions centred on atomic nuclei. Therefore, the computation of the necessary structure factors requires the evaluation of Fourier transform integrals of basis function products. Since these functions are usually Cartesian Gaussians, in this communication it is shown that the Fourier integrals can be efficiently calculated by exploiting an extension of the Obara–Saika recurrence formulas, which are successfully used by quantum chemists in the computation of molecular integrals. Implementation and future perspectives of the technique are also discussed.

Quantum Mechanics/Extremely Localized Molecular Orbital Method: A Fully Quantum Mechanical Embedding Approach for Macromolecules

The development of methods for the quantum mechanical study of macromolecules has always been an important challenge in theoretical chemistry. Nowadays, the techniques proposed in this context can be used to investigate very large systems and can be subdivided into two main categories: fragmentation and embedding strategies. In this paper, by modifying and improving the local self-consistent field approach originally proposed for quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics techniques, we introduce the new multiscale embedding quantum mechanics/extremely localized molecular orbital (QM/ELMO) method. The new strategy enables treatment of chemically relevant regions of large biological molecules through usual methods of quantum chemistry while describing the remaining parts of the systems by means of frozen extremely localized molecular orbitals transferred from properly constructed libraries. Test calculations have shown the correct functioning and the high reliability of the new approach, thus anticipating its possible applications to different fields of physical chemistry, such as rational drug design and structural refinements of proteins.

X-ray constrained spin-coupled technique: theoretical details and further assessment of the method

One of the well-established methods of modern quantum crystallography is undoubtedly the X-ray constrained wavefunction (XCW) approach, a technique that enables the determination of wavefunctions which not only minimize the energy of the system under examination, but also reproduce experimental X-ray diffraction data within the limit of the experimental errors. Initially proposed in the framework of the Hartree–Fock method, the strategy has been gradually extended to other techniques of quantum chemistry, but always remaining limited to a single-determinant ansatz for the wavefunction to extract. This limitation has been recently overcome through the development of the novel X-ray constrained spin-coupled (XCSC) approach [Genoni et al. (2018). Chem. Eur. J. 24, 15507–15511] which merges the XCW philosophy with the traditional spin-coupled strategy of valence bond theory. The main advantage of this new technique is the possibility of extracting traditional chemical descriptors (e.g. resonance structure weights) compatible with the experimental diffraction measurements, without the need to introduce information a priori or perform analyses a posteriori. This paper provides a detailed theoretical derivation of the fundamental equations at the basis of the XCSC method and also introduces a further advancement of its original version, mainly consisting in the use of molecular orbitals resulting from XCW calculations at the Hartree–Fock level to describe the inactive electrons in the XCSC computations. Furthermore, extensive test calculations, which have been performed by exploiting high-resolution X-ray diffraction data for salicylic acid and by adopting different basis sets, are presented and discussed. The computational tests have shown that the new technique does not suffer from particular convergence problems. Moreover, all the XCSC calculations provided resonance structure weights, spin-coupled orbitals and global electron densities slightly different from those resulting from the corresponding unconstrained computations. These discrepancies can be ascribed to the capability of the novel strategy to capture the information intrinsically contained in the experimental data used as external constraints.

Aspherical scattering factors for SHELXL - model, implementation and application

A new aspherical scattering factor formalism has been implemented in the crystallographic least-squares refinement program SHELXL. The formalism relies on Gaussian functions and can optionally complement the independent atom model to take into account the deformation of electron-density distribution due to chemical bonding and lone pairs. Asphericity contributions were derived from the electron density obtained from quantum-chemical density functional theory computations of suitable model compounds that contain particular chemical environments, as defined by the invariom formalism. Thanks to a new algorithm, invariom assignment for refinement in SHELXL is automated. A suitable parameterization for each chemical environment within the new model was achieved by metaheuristics. Figures of merit, precision and accuracy of crystallographic least-squares refinements improve significantly upon using the new model.

Libraries of Extremely Localized Molecular Orbitals. 3. Construction and Preliminary Assessment of the New Databanks

The fast and reliable determination of wave functions and electron densities of macromolecules has been one of the goals of theoretical chemistry for a long time, and in this context, several linear scaling techniques have been successfully devised over the years. Different approaches have been adopted to tackle this problem, and one of them exploits the fact that, according to the traditional chemical perception, molecules can be seen as constituted of recurring units (e.g., functional groups) with well-defined chemical features. This has led to the development of methods in which the global wave functions or electron densities of macromolecules are obtained by simply transferring density matrices or fuzzy electron densities associated with molecular fragments. In this context, we propose an alternative strategy that aims at quickly reconstructing wave functions and electron densities of proteins through the transfer of extremely localized molecular orbitals (ELMOs), which are orbitals strictly localized on small molecular units and, for this reason, easily transferable from molecule to molecule. To accomplish this task we have constructed original libraries of ELMOs that cover all the possible elementary fragments of the 20 natural amino acids in all their possible protonation states and forms. Our preliminary test calculations have shown that, compared to more traditional methods of quantum chemistry, the transfers from the novel ELMO databanks allow to obtain wave function and electron densities of large polypeptides and proteins at a significantly reduced computational cost. Furthermore, notwithstanding expected discrepancies, the obtained electron distributions and electrostatic potentials are in very good agreement with those obtained at Hartree-Fock and density functional theory (DFT) levels. Therefore, the results encourage to use the new libraries as alternatives to the popular pseudoatom-databases of crystallography in the refinement of crystallographic structures of macromolecules. In particular, in this context, we have already envisaged the coupling of the ELMO databanks with the promising Hirshfeld atom refinement technique to extend the applicability of the latter to very large systems.

Quantum Crystallography: Current Developments and Future Perspectives

Crystallography and quantum mechanics have always been tightly connected because reliable quantum mechanical models are needed to determine crystal structures. Due to this natural synergy, nowadays accurate distributions of electrons in space can be obtained from diffraction and scattering experiments. In the original definition of quantum crystallography (QCr) given by Massa, Karle and Huang, direct extraction of wavefunctions or density matrices from measured intensities of reflections or, conversely, ad hoc quantum mechanical calculations to enhance the accuracy of the crystallographic refinement are implicated. Nevertheless, many other active and emerging research areas involving quantum mechanics and scattering experiments are not covered by the original definition although they enable to observe and explain quantum phenomena as accurately and successfully as the original strategies. Therefore, we give an overview over current research that is related to a broader notion of QCr, and discuss options how QCr can evolve to become a complete and independent domain of natural sciences. The goal of this paper is to initiate discussions around QCr, but not to find a final definition of the field.