Myogenic stem cell commitment probability remains constant as a function of organismal and mitotic age

The Satellite Cell at 60: The Foundation Years

The resident stem cell for skeletal muscle is the satellite cell. On the 50th anniversary of its discovery in 1961, we described the history of skeletal muscle research and the seminal findings made during the first 20 years in the life of the satellite cell (Scharner and Zammit 2011, doi: 10.1186/2044-5040-1-28). These studies established the satellite cell as the source of myoblasts for growth and regeneration of skeletal muscle. Now on the 60th anniversary, we highlight breakthroughs in the second phase of satellite cell research from 1980 to 2000. These include technical innovations such as isolation of primary satellite cells and viable muscle fibres complete with satellite cells in their niche, together with generation of many useful reagents including genetically modified organisms and antibodies still in use today. New methodologies were combined with description of endogenous satellite cells markers, notably Pax7. Discovery of the muscle regulatory factors Myf5, MyoD, myogenin, and MRF4 in the late 1980s revolutionized understanding of the control of both developmental and regerenative myogenesis. Emergence of genetic lineage markers facilitated identification of satellite cells in situ, and also empowered transplantation studies to examine satellite cell function. Finally, satellite cell heterogeneity and the supportive role of non-satellite cell types in muscle regeneration were described. These major advances in methodology and in understanding satellite cell biology provided further foundations for the dramatic escalation of work on muscle stem cells in the 21st century.

Pattern of Pax7 expression during myogenesis in the posthatch chicken establishes a model for satellite cell differentiation and renewal

The paired-box transcription factor Pax7 plays a critical role in the specification of satellite cells in mouse skeletal muscle. In the present study, the position and number of Pax7-expressing cells found in muscles of growing and adult chickens confirm the presence of this protein in avian satellite cells. The expression pattern of Pax7 protein, along with the muscle regulatory proteins MyoD and myogenin, was additionally elucidated in myogenic cultures and in whole muscle from posthatch chickens. In cultures progressing from proliferation to differentiation, the expression of Pax7 in MyoD+ cells declined as the cells began expressing myogenin, suggesting Pax7 as an early marker for proliferating myoblasts. At all time points, some Pax7+ cells were negative for MyoD, resembling the reserve cell phenotype. Clonal analysis of muscle cell preparations demonstrated that single progenitors can give rise to both differentiating and reserve cells. In muscle tissues, Pax7 protein expression was the strongest by 1 day posthatch, declining on days 3 and 6 to a similar level. In contrast, myogenin expression peaked on day 3 and then dramatically declined. This finding was accompanied by a robust growth in fiber diameter between day 3 and 6. The distinctions in Pax7 and myogenin expression patterns, both in culture and in vivo, indicate that while some of the myoblasts differentiate and fuse into myofibers during early stages of posthatch growth, others retain their reserve cell capacity.

Cell aging in vivo and in vitro

It has become a staple assumption of biology that there is an intrinsic fixed limit to the number of divisions that normal vertebrate cells can undergo before they senesce, and this limit is in some way related to aging of the organism. The notion of such a limited replicative lifespan arose from the often repeated observation that diploid fibroblasts cannot proliferate indefinitely in monolayer culture, and that the number of divisions before senescence is directly related to the in vivo lifespan of different species. The in vitro evidence is countered by estimates that the number of cell divisions in some organs of rodents and man are one or more orders of magnitude higher than the in vitro limit, with no indication of the degenerative changes seen in culture. Serial transplantation experiments in animals also exhibit many more cell divisions than the in vitro studies, with some indicating an indefinite replicative lifespan. I present evidence that vertebrate cells are severely stressed by enzymatic dispersion and sustain cumulative damage during serial subcultivations. The evidence includes large increases in cell size and its heterogeneity, reductions in replicative efficiency at low seeding densities, appearance of abnormal structures in the cytoplasm, changes in metabolism to a common cell culture type, continuous loss of methyl groups and reiterated sequences from DNA, and a constant rate of decline of growth rate with passage. This evidence is complemented by the reduction induced in the replicative life span of diploid cells by a large array of treatments which have different primary targets in the cells. The most consistent and general observation of cell behavior in aging animals, with only a few exceptions, is a reduction in the rate of cell proliferation. This reduction is perpetuated when the cells are grown in culture, indicating it is an enduring and intrinsic property of the cells rather than a systemic effect of the aging organism. A similar heritable reduction in growth rate can be induced in established cell lines by prolonged incubation at quiescence. The reduction can be exaggerated by subculturing the quiescent cells under suboptimal conditions, just as the effects of age are exaggerated under stress. The constant decline of growth rate that occurs during serial passage of diploid cells may represent a similar decay of cell function. I propose that the limit on replicative lifespan is an artifact that reflects the failure of diploid cells to adapt to the trauma of dissociation and the radically foreign environment of cell culture. It is, however, a useful artifact that has given us much information about cell behavior under stressful conditions. The overall evidence indicates cell in vivo accumulate damage over a lifetime that results in gradual loss of differentiated function and growth rate accompanied by an increased probability for the development of cancer. Such changes are normally held to a minimum by the organized state of the tissues and homeostatic regulation of the organism. The rejection of an intrinsic limit on the number of cell divisions eliminates the need for a cellular clock, such as telomere length, that counts mitoses. I offer a heuristic explanation for the gradual reduction of cell function and growth capacity with age based on a cumulative discoordination of interacting pathways within and between cells and tissues. I also make a case for the use of established cell lines as model systems for studying heritable damage to cell populations that simulates the effects of aging in vivo, and represents a relatively unexplored area of cell biology.

Human fibroblast commitment to a senescence-like state in response to histone deacetylase inhibitors is cell cycle dependent

Human diploid fibroblasts (HDF) complete a limited number of cell divisions before entering a growth arrest state that is termed replicative senescence. Two histone deacetylase inhibitors, sodium butyrate and trichostatin A, dramatically reduce the HDF proliferative life span in a manner that is dependent on one or more cell doublings in the presence of these agents. Cells arrested and subsequently released from histone deacetylase inhibitors display markers of senescence and exhibit a persistent G1 block but remain competent to initiate a round of DNA synthesis in response to simian virus 40 T antigen. Average telomere length in prematurely arrested cells is greater than in senescent cells, reflecting a lower number of population doublings completed by the former. Taken together, these results support the view that one component of HDF senescence mimics a cell cycle-dependent drift in differentiation state and that propagation of HDF in histone deacetylase inhibitors accentuates this component.

Overexpression of the type-1 insulin-like growth factor receptor increases ligand-dependent proliferation and differentiation in bovine skeletal myogenic cultures

Previous studies demonstrated that overexpression of the type-1 insulin-like growth factor (IGF) receptor (IGF-1R) in skeletal myogenic cell lines increased proliferation and differentiation responses to IGF. However, it was unclear if such manipulations in primary, untransformed skeletal myogenic cells would result in modulation of these responses, which may be more stringently regulated in primary cells than in myogenic cell lines. In this study, low passage untransformed fetal bovine myogenic cultures were infected with a replication-deficient retroviral expression vector (LISN) coding for the human IGF-1R or with a control retroviral vector (LNL6). Bovine myogenic cultures infected with the LISN vector (Bov-LISN) displayed ten times more IGF-1Rs than controls (Bov-LNL6). Bov-LISN myogenic cultures exhibited elevated rates of IGF-I-stimulated proliferation and increased rates of terminal differentiation which were reduced to control levels by the anti-human IGF-1R antibody alpha IR3. These findings indicate overexpression of the IGF-1R can enhance IGF sensitivity and thereby modify the proliferation and differentiation behavior of untransformed low passage myoblasts. Such manipulations may be useful to increase muscle mass in clinical or agricultural applications.

Identification of self-renewing myoblasts in the progeny of single human muscle satellite cells

We demonstrate that self-renewing myoblasts can be identified in the progeny of single human muscle satellite cells (HMSC) in culture. We show, using cytoskeletal proteins and cell size as markers, that self-renewing myoblasts are phenotypically different from other myoblasts, but similar to native HMSC. Native desmin-positive HMSC, cultured as single cells, yielded two major populations of myoblasts, alpha-sarcomeric (alpha-SR)-actin-positive myoblasts and desmin-positive myoblasts. In appropriate culture conditions, alpha-SR-actin-positive myoblasts fused into myotubes, whereas a population of desmin-positive non-fusing myoblasts (NFMB) persisted for weeks among the myotubes. Upon isolation from myotubes, some of the NFMB resumed proliferation and their progeny included fusing and non-fusing myoblasts, with the same cytoskeletal phenotypes as the progeny of native HMSC. This self-renewal cycle could be repeated, yielding four cohorts of myoblasts. The yield of self-renewing cells appeared to decrease with the number of cycles. These results suggest that stem cells are present among NFMB. Moreover, we find that these presumptive stem cells are already segregated during myoblast proliferation. They are small, phenotypically similar to native HMSC, and do not divide unless they are isolated from their sister progeny and cultured alone. Enriched preparations of cells with stem cell-like properties can be obtained from proliferating myoblasts by flow cytometry on the basis of size and nucleocytoplasmic ratio.

Skeletal muscle satellite cells

Evidence now suggests that satellite cells constitute a class of myogenic cells that differ distinctly from other embryonic myoblasts. Satellite cells arise from somites and first appear as a distinct myoblast type well before birth. Satellite cells from different muscles cannot be functionally distinguished from one another and are able to provide nuclei to all fibers without regard to phenotype. Thus, it is difficult to ascribe any significant function to establishing or stabilizing fiber type, even during regeneration. Within a muscle, satellite cells exhibit marked heterogeneity with respect to their proliferative behavior. The satellite cell population on a fiber can be partitioned into those that function as stem cells and those which are readily available for fusion. Recent studies have shown that the cells are not simply spindle shaped, but are very diverse in their morphology and have multiple branches emanating from the poles of the cells. This finding is consistent with other studies indicating that the cells have the capacity for extensive migration within, and perhaps between, muscles. Complexity of cell shape usually reflects increased cytoplasmic volume and organelles including a well developed Golgi, and is usually associated with growing postnatal muscle or muscles undergoing some form of induced adaptive change or repair. The appearance of activated satellite cells suggests some function of the cells in the adaptive process through elaboration and secretion of a product. Significant advances have been made in determining the potential secretion products that satellite cells make. The manner in which satellite cell proliferative and fusion behavior is controlled has also been studied. There seems to be little doubt that cellcell coupling is not how satellite cells and myofibers communicate. Rather satellite cell regulation is through a number of potential growth factors that arise from a number of sources. Critical to the understanding of this form of control is to determine which of the many growth factors that can alter satellite cell behavior in vitro are at work in vivo. Little work has been done to determine what controls are at work after a regeneration response has been initiated. It seems likely that, after injury, growth factors are liberated through proteolytic activity and initiate an activation process whereby cells enter into a proliferative phase. After myofibers are formed, it also seems likely that satellite cell behavior is regulated through diffusible factors arising from the fibers rather than continuous control by circulating factors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Myogenic cell lineages

For many years the mechanisms by which skeletal muscles in higher vertebrates come to be composed of diverse fiber types distributed in distinctive patterns has interested cell and developmental biologists. The fiber composition of skeletal muscles varies from class to class and from muscle to muscle within the vertebrates. The developmental basis for these events is the subject of this review. Because an individual multinucleate vertebrate skeletal muscle fiber is formed by the fusion of many individual myoblasts, more attention, in recent times, has been directed toward the origins and differences among myoblasts, and more emphasis has been placed on the lineal relationship of myoblasts to fibers. This is a review of studies related to the concepts of myogenic cell lineage in higher vertebrate development with emphases on some of the most challenging problems of myogenesis including the embryonic origins of myogenic precursor cells, the mechanisms of fiber type diversity and patterning, the distinctions among myoblasts during myogenesis, and the current hypotheses of how a variety of factors, intrinsic and extrinsic to the myoblast, determine the definitive phenotype of a muscle fiber.

Differential response among cells in the chick embryo myogenic lineage to photosensitization by Merocyanine 540

Primary cultures of myogenic cells from progressively older embryonic and adult chickens were incubated in medium containing Merocyanine 540 (MC540) and were exposed to white light during the incubation period. After exposure, the cultures were followed to determine cell survival and differentiation. MC540 attached to the surface membranes of all cells. In cultures from 10-day embryos (E10 cells), concentrations of MC540 greater than or equal to 60 micrograms/ml resulted in death of nearly all myogenic cells upon exposure to light, but non-myogenic cells survived and replicated. Below 60 micrograms/ml, there was a dose-dependent reduction in muscle differentiation. At concentrations less than 40 micrograms/ml, there was no effect on myogenesis. Cultures of cells from 18-day (E18) embryos (myogenic stem cells) and from adult muscle (satellite cells) were resistant to doses of MC540 that killed E10 cells. E14 myogenic cell populations contained both resistant and sensitive sub-populations. Terminally differentiated muscle cells were more sensitive to MC540 than precursor cells from any age embryo. Progeny of E18 cells acquired sensitivity to MC540 as differentiation proceeded. In clonal cultures, cells that normally give rise to small muscle clones (committed cells) were selectively destroyed by exposure to the dye. These observations demonstrate that an MC540-resistant myogenic population is present in low numbers in 10-day embryonic pectoral muscle. As development proceeds, this population increases such that, by 18 days of gestation, most of the myogenic cells are resistant to MC540. The results also suggest that embryonic chick myogenic stem cells and adult satellite cells have surface membrane properties which differ from those of their committed progeny.

Myogenic cells of regenerating adult chicken muscle can fuse into myotubes after a single cell division in vivo

Autoradiographic studies were carried out on regenerating muscles of adult chickens. Three different muscles of hens were injured, and tritiated thymidine (1 microCi/g) was injected at various times after injury to label replicating muscle precursors. Detailed comparisons of grain counts over premitotic nuclei in samples removed one hour after injection of tritiated thymidine, and of postmitotic myotube nuclei in samples removed 10 days after injury (when labeled precursors had fused to form myotubes), revealed how many times some labeled precursors had divided before fusing into myotubes. DNA synthesis in muscle precursors was initiated 30 h after injury. Grain counts of myotube nuclei indicated that many muscle precursors labeled at the onset of myogenic cell proliferation had divided only once, or twice, before fusing into myotubes. The relationship of these in vivo results to the cell lineage model of myogenesis is discussed.