Development of health risk evaluation data for diagnostic ultrasound: a historical perspective

The use of ultrasound in the investigation of the muscles of mastication

The aim of this article was to review the literature concerning ultrasonography imaging (US) of the muscles of mastication and to discuss its use, advantages and disadvantages and the findings of the authors. A web search was performed using the terms "ultrasound" and "muscles". US has been shown to be a reliable method of great utility in the field of diagnosis of alterations in the muscles of mastication and for the study of changes during growth and aging. It should be preferred in comparison to computerized axial tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) because of its safety and cost advantages since it is as reliable and precise as these other techniques. Although various techniques have been used in ultrasonographic scanning, this article discusses those techniques most commonly adopted by the authors.

Ultrasound-guided drainage of submasseteric space abscesses

PURPOSE

The oral approach for incision and drainage (I and D) in patients presenting with submasseteric space (SMS) abscesses and marked trismus is more difficult and requires a general anesthetic, necessitating an anesthetist experienced in fiberoptic-guided nasal intubation. In such patients, ultrasound-guided drainage (USGD) has been attempted to obviate this need. The purpose of this trial was to report our experience with the surgical management of 11 SMS abscesses, with special reference to their USGD.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seven men and 4 women ranging in age from 18 to 41 years (average age, 25 years) participated in this trial. They were initially examined with US, and their abscesses were subsequently drained under US guidance using a 16-gauge intravenous catheter. An antibiotic regimen was prescribed, and arrangements were made to see the patients daily for 5 days. USGD was repeated after 24 hours, and 24 hours later the infection course was monitored in each patient. Patients with nonresolving infection had their abscesses formally incised and drained extraorally. The source of infection was removed as soon as the acute phase of infection passed and the interincisal opening (IIO) allowed. The catheter or corrugated drain was removed when the discharge ceased or became minimal. Patients were then instructed to continue a 3-day course of an antibiotic and to return after 1 week and then after 1 month.

RESULTS

Resolution of infection was successfully achieved by USGD with no need for I and D in 8 of the 11 patients (73%). In those patients, the average total amount of pus removed was 8.5 mL, and the average IIO was 17.4 mm immediately after an average initial aspirate of 4.5 mL of pus. I and D was required in the remaining 3 patients (27%). In those patients the average total amount of pus removed was 17.5 mL, and the average IIO was 7.7 mm immediately after an average initial aspirate of 9.3 mL of pus.

CONCLUSIONS

Resolution of infection with USGD is more probable if there was an immediate improvement of the IIO to about 1.5 cm or more after an initial aspiration of 5 mL of pus.

Ultrasonography of masseter muscle size in normal young adults

The present study was planned to determine the relationship between linear dimensions of human masseter muscle cross-section and cross-sectional area (CSA), and to assess symmetry between the two sides in normal young adults. Cross-sectional images of the masseter muscle were measured bilaterally by real-time ultrasound imaging in 39 healthy dentate subjects, 19 males and 20 females, aged 21-47. From stored images, CSA and two linear measurements of muscle cross-section were obtained (the shortest and the longest distance through the muscle group). Correlation and regression analyses were performed to examine the relationship between CSA and the linear dimensions (both individually and with the linear dimensions multiplied). Symmetry of CSA between the two sides of the face was examined using the paired t-test. The significance of correlation coefficients (r) and the difference between the slopes of the regression lines were also examined. Masseter CSA was larger in males than in females. All correlation values between CSA and linear measurements were significant but muscle CSA was most accurately predicted when the linear measurements were multiplied (r = 0.97; P < 0.001). Although the correlation in this regard was high, the linear dimensions consistently overestimated the actual CSA by approximately 25%. Males showed more symmetry of CSA than females. The range of values for symmetry of masseter CSA was too large to assess abnormal asymmetry in patients with unilateral symptoms.

Ultrasonographic evaluation of inflammatory changes in the masseter muscle

The ultrasonographic images of 32 patients with inflammatory change in the masseteric region were investigated to clarify the characteristic findings and to evaluate the utility of ultrasonography. Inflamed masseter muscles frequently demonstrated reduction of echo intensity and complete or partial absence of hyperechoic bands. The mean thickness of the masseter muscle on the unaffected side was 8.6 mm, whereas that on the affected side was 12.9 mm. Nine of 10 patients with heterogeneous hypoechoic area, but only 1 of 10 patients with homogeneous hypoechoic area, had received surgical treatment before ultrasonographic examination.

Measurement of anterior tibial muscle size using real-time ultrasound imaging

Cross-sectional images of the anterior tibial muscle group were obtained using real-time ultrasound scanning in 17 normal women. From photographs taken of the images, the cross-sectional area (CSA) and two linear measurements of muscle cross-section were determined. A measurement of the shortest distance of the muscle depth was termed DS, and a measurement of the longest distance through the muscle group was termed DL. Both linear dimensions showed a positive correlation with CSA and the best correlations were obtained when the dimensions were squared or combined (DS x DL). The correlation values were: CSA vs DS2, r = 0.9; CSA vs DL2, r = 0.75 and CSA vs DS x DL, r = 0.88. An approximate value for CSA could be calculated from DS2 by the equation 2 x DS2 + 1. A shape ratio, obtained by dividing DL by DS, was consistent within the group [mean 2.1 (SD 0.2)] and characterised the muscle geometrically. The CSA of repeated scans was assessed for repeatability between-days and between-scans by analysis of variance and the coefficient of variation (CV) calculated. Areas were repeatable between-days (CV 6.5%) and between-scans (CV 3.6%). Linear dimensions of the anterior tibial muscle group reflected CSA and their potential for assessing changes in muscle size with atrophy and hypertrophy have yet to be established.

Masseter muscle thickness measured by ultrasonography and its relation to facial morphology

The aims of this study were to evaluate ultrasonography as a method for measuring masseter muscle thickness, to quantitate the normal range of the ultrasonically measured thickness of the masseter in adults, and to test whether the variation in the thickness of the muscle is related to the variation in the facial morphology in different individuals. In 40 healthy, fully-dentate young adults, 20 men and 20 women, the masseter thickness was measured bilaterally by a real-time ultrasound imaging technique. The measurements were performed under both relaxed conditions and with maximal clenching. Standardized facial photos of the subjects were taken so that their facial morphology could be determined. The measurement error of the thickness of the masseter was found to be small, not exceeding 0.49 mm. Under relaxed conditions, the mean thickness (+/- S.D.) of the muscle in men was 9.7 (+/- 1.5) mm, and under contracted conditions, 15.1 (+/- 1.9) mm. In women, the respective measurements were 8.7 (+/- 1.6) mm and 13.0 (+/- 1.8) mm. The thickness of the masseter muscle was found to be related to the facial morphology, mainly in women, but not in men; the women with a thin masseter had a proportionally longer face. Ultrasonography was found to be a reliable and accurate method for study of the thickness of the masseter muscle. There was a large variation in the thickness of the muscle between individuals, and the thickness of the masseter was related to facial morphology in women.

Medical sonography: reproductive effects and risks

While it is clear that the levels and types of medical sonography that have been used in the past have no measurable risks, it would be inaccurate to label the modality of ultrasound as totally safe regardless of exposure. Most agents have reproductive risks and even teratogenic risks if the exposure is raised sufficiently. Thus the prudent use of sonography means that clinicians and designers of equipment have to maintain exposures far below the risks that have been demonstrated in animal studies and from the knowledge obtained about the physical changes that can be produced in humans as the absorbed dose is elevated. The reproductive risks were evaluated using five criteria: 1) human epidemiology, 2) secular trend data, 3) animal experiments, 4) dose response relationships, and 5) biologic plausibility. The analysis reveals that the human epidemiology does not indicate that diagnostic ultrasound presents a measurable risk to the developing embryo or fetus. Animal studies also indicate that diagnostic levels of ultrasound are safe and do not elevate the fetal temperature into the region where deleterious embryonic and fetal effects will occur. Because higher exposures of ultrasound can elevate the temperature of the embryo, the use of diagnostic procedures and the design of sonographic equipment should take into consideration the hyperthermic potential of higher exposures of ultrasound and the hypothetical additional risk of performing sonography on pregnant patients who are febrile. It would appear that if the embryonic temperature never exceeds 39 degrees C, then there is no measurable risk. We suggest that sonography (the field) and sonogram (the procedure) are the most appropriate and least anxiety provoking terms.

Acute response of fetal rat telencephalon to ultrasound exposure in utero

Pregnant rats were exposed to ultrasound or microwaves from transducers located over one uterine horn. Ultrasound intensity (SPTA) was 0.78 W/cm2 for 30 min at a frequency of 2.5 MHz. Microwave exposure was used to reproduce approximately the rate of rise of uterine temperature of the rats exposed to ultrasound. The average peak temperature was 40.1 degrees C for ultrasound exposure and 42.2 degrees C for microwave exposure. On Gestational Day 16, 24 h after exposure, fetuses were removed and prepared for morphological examination of the developing cerebral cortical mantle. Morphometric measurements were made of nuclear area of subventricular zone cells, number of mitoses per mm in the ventricular zone, number of pyknotic cells in the mantle per mm, and number of ventricular macrophages per mm. Both exposures increased nuclear size and numbers of pyknotic cells and macrophages, and decreased the number of mitotic figures. The data from the four measurements were evidence of damage from ultrasound similar to the effects produced by microwave heating. The thermal effects of ultrasound, even at relatively low levels of rise in temperature, may have been the cause of the damage to the fetal cortex in these experiments or may have interacted with other effects of ultrasound energies to produce damage to developing neurons.