Delineation of brain tumor margins using intraoperative sononavigation: implications for tumor resection

Clinical, histopathological and molecular risk factors for recurrence of pilocytic astrocytomas: brainstem/spinal location, nestin expression and gain of 7q and 19 are associated with early tumor recurrence

Pilocytic astrocytomas (PAs) are benign tumors. However, clinically aggressive PAs despite benign histology have been reported, and histological and molecular risk factors for prognosis have not been elucidated. 38 PAs were studied for clinical, histological, and molecular factors, including tumor location, extent of resection, post-operative treatment, glioma-associated molecules (IDH1/2, ATRX, BRAF, FGFR1, PIK3CA, H3F3A, p53, VEGF, Nestin, PD-1/PD-L1), CDKN2A/B deletion, and chromosomal number aberrations, to see if there is any correlation with patient's progression-free survival (PFS). Brainstem/spinal location, extent of resection and post-operative treatment, and VEGF-A, Nestin and PD-L1 expression, copy number gain of chromosome 7q or 19, TP53 mutation were significantly associated with shorter PFS. None of the histological parameters was associated with PFS. Multivariate analyses demonstrated that high Nestin expression, gain of 7q or 19, and extent of removal were independently predictive for early tumor recurrence. The brainstem/spinal PAs appeared distinct from those in the other sites in terms of molecular characteristics. Clinically aggressive PAs despite benign histology exhibited high Nestin expression. Brainstem/spinal location, extent of resection and some molecular factors including Nestin expression and gains of 7q and 19, rather than histological parameters, may be associated with early tumor recurrence in PAs.

Clinical Application of Shear Wave Elastography for Assisting Brain Tumor Resection

Background

The clinical outcomes for brain tumor resection have been shown to be significantly improved with increased extent of resection. To achieve this, neurosurgeons employ different intra-operative tools to improve the extent of resection of brain tumors, including ultrasound, CT, and MRI. Young’s modulus (YM) of brain tumors have been shown to be different from normal brain but the accuracy of SWE in assisting brain tumor resection has not been reported.

Aims

To determine the accuracy of SWE in detecting brain tumor residual using post-operative MRI scan as “gold standard”.

Methods

Thirty-four patients (aged 1–62 years, M:F = 15:20) with brain tumors were recruited into the study. The intraoperative SWE scans were performed using Aixplorer^® (SuperSonic Imagine, France) using a sector transducer (SE12-3) and a linear transducer (SL15-4) with a bandwidth of 3 to 12 MHz and 4 to 15 MHz, respectively, using the SWE mode. The scans were performed prior, during and after brain tumor resection. The presence of residual tumor was determined by the surgeon, ultrasound (US) B-mode and SWE. This was compared with the presence of residual tumor on post-operative MRI scan.

Results

The YM of the brain tumors correlated significantly with surgeons’ findings (ρ = 0.845, p < 0.001). The sensitivities of residual tumor detection by the surgeon, US B-mode and SWE were 36%, 73%, and 94%, respectively, while their specificities were 100%, 63%, and 77%, respectively. There was no significant difference between detection of residual tumor by SWE, US B-mode, and MRI. SWE and MRI were significantly better than the surgeon’s detection of residual tumor (p = 0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively).

Conclusions

SWE had a higher sensitivity in detecting residual tumor than the surgeons (94% vs. 36%). However, the surgeons had a higher specificity than SWE (100% vs. 77%). Therefore, using SWE in combination with surgeon’s opinion may optimize the detection of residual tumor, and hence improve the extent of brain tumor resection.

Ultrasound-guided brain surgery: echographic visibility of different pathologies and surgical applications in neurosurgical routine

BACKGROUND

The use of intraoperative ultrasound (iUS) has increased in the last 15 years becoming a standard tool in many neurosurgical centers. Our aim was to assess the utility of routine use of iUS during various types of intracranial surgery. We reviewed our series to assess ultrasound visibility of different pathologies and iUS applications during the course of surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This is a retrospective review of 162 patients who underwent intracranial surgery with assistance of the iUS guidance system (SonoWand). Pathologic categories were neoplastic (135), vascular (20), infectious (2), and CSF related (5). Ultrasound visibility was assessed using the Mair classification, a four-tiered grading system that considers the echogenicity of the lesion and its border visibility (from 0 to 3; grade 0, pathology not visible; grade 3, visible with clear border with normal tissue). iUS applications included lesion localization, approach planning to deep-seated lesions, and lesion removal.

RESULTS

All pathologies were visible on iUS except one aneurysm. On average, extra-axial tumors were identified more easily and had clearer limits compared to intra-axial tumors (extra-axial 17% grade 2, 83% grade 3; intra-axial 5.5% grade 1, 46.5% grade 2, 48% grade 3). iUS provided precise and safe transcortical trajectories to deep-seated lesions (71 patients; tumors, hemangiomas, ICHs); iUS was judged to be less useful to approach skull base tumors and aneurysms. iUS was used to judge extent of resection in 152 cases; surgical artifacts reduced sonographic visibility in 25 cases: extent of resection was correctly checked in 127 patients (53 gliomas, 15 metastases, 39 meningiomas, 4 schwannomas, 4 sellar region tumors, 6 hemangiomas, 3 AVMs, 2 abscesses).

CONCLUSIONS

iUS was highly sensitive in detecting all types of pathology, was safe and precise in planning trajectories to intraparenchymal lesions (including minimally mini-invasive approaches), and was accurate in checking extent of resection in more than 80% of cases. iUS is a versatile and feasible tool; it could improve safety and its use may be considered in routine intracranial surgery.

The Diagnostic Properties of Intraoperative Ultrasound in Glioma Surgery and Factors Associated with Gross Total Tumor Resection

OBJECTIVE

In glioma operations, we sought to analyze sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values of intraoperative 3-dimensional ultrasound (US) for detecting residual tumor compared with early postoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Factors possibly associated with radiologic complete resection were also explored.

METHODS

One hundred forty-four operations for diffuse supratentorial gliomas were included prospectively in an unselected, population-based, single-institution series. Operating surgeons answered a questionnaire immediately after surgery, stating whether residual tumor was seen with US at the end of resection and rated US image quality (e.g., good, medium, poor). Extent of surgical resection was estimated from preoperative and postoperative MRI.

RESULTS

Overall specificity was 85% for "no tumor remnant" seen in US images at the end of resection compared with postoperative MRI findings. Sensitivity was 46%, but tumor remnants seen on MRI were usually small (median, 1.05 mL) in operations with false-negative US findings. Specificity was highest in low-grade glioma operations (94%) and lowest in patients who had undergone prior radiotherapy (50%). Smaller tumor volume and superficial location were factors significantly associated with gross total resection in a multivariable logistic regression analysis, whereas good ultrasound image quality did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.061).

CONCLUSIONS

The specificity of intraoperative US is good, but sensitivity for detecting the last milliliter is low compared with postoperative MRI. Tumor volume and tumor depth are the predictors of achieving gross total resection, although ultrasound image quality was not.

Recent technological advances in pediatric brain tumor surgery

X-rays and ventriculograms were the first imaging modalities used to localize intracranial lesions including brain tumors as far back as the 1880s. Subsequent advances in preoperative radiological localization included computed tomography (CT; 1971) and MRI (1977). Since then, other imaging modalities have been developed for clinical application although none as pivotal as CT and MRI. Intraoperative technological advances include the microscope, which has allowed precise surgery under magnification and improved lighting, and the endoscope, which has improved the treatment of hydrocephalus and allowed biopsy and complete resection of intraventricular, pituitary and pineal region tumors through a minimally invasive approach. Neuronavigation, intraoperative MRI, CT and ultrasound have increased the ability of the neurosurgeon to perform safe and maximal tumor resection. This may be facilitated by the use of fluorescing agents, which help define the tumor margin, and intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring, which helps identify and protect eloquent brain.

Adult anaplastic pilocytic astrocytoma - a diagnostic challenge? A case series and literature review

INTRODUCTION

Anaplastic pilocytic astrocytoma (APA) is an exceptionally rare type of high-grade glioma in adults. Establishing histopathological diagnosis is challenging and its clinical and radiological appearance insidious. By this case series and first literature review we investigated the various clinical, neuroradiological, and histopathological features of APA in adults.

METHODS

An in hospital screening of the database from the Institute of Pathology was conducted to identify cases of APA. Further, we performed a literature review in PubMed using the keywords "anaplastic/malignant/atypical AND pilocytic astrocytoma" and "anaplastic astrocytoma/glioblastoma AND Rosenthal fibers" and summarized the current knowledge about APA in adults.

RESULTS

Over the last decade we were able to identify 3 adult patients with APA in our hospital. According to the pertinent literature, the prognosis of APA in adults (documented survival of up to 10 years) appears to be better than in other high-grade gliomas. Few cases were associated with neurofibromatosis type 1, which seems to predispose for development of APA. Although molecular genetics is still of limited value for differentiation of APA from other high-grade glioma, advanced neuroimaging techniques such as magnetic resonance perfusion imaging and spectroscopy allow improved differential work-up. In particular, APA in adults has the ability to mimic various neurological diseases such as tumefactive demyelinating lesions, low-, or high-grade gliomas.

CONCLUSIONS

Although currently not explicitly recognized as a distinct clinico-pathologic entity it seems that adult APA behaves differently from conventional high-grade glioma and should be included in differential diagnostics to enable adequate patient care. However, further studies are needed to better understand this extremely rare disease.

Intraoperative ultrasound in pediatric brain tumors: does the surgeon get it right?

PURPOSE

Intraoperative ultrasound (iUS) is a valuable tool-inexpensive, adds minimal surgical time, and involves minimal risk. The diagnostic predictive value of iUS is not fully characterized in Pediatric Neurosurgery. Our objective is to determine if surgeon-completed iUS has good concordance with post-operative MRI in estimating extent of surgical resection (EOR) of pediatric brain tumors.

METHODS

We reviewed charts of all pediatric brain tumor resections (single institution 2006-2013). Those with iUS and postoperative imaging (<1 week) were included. The surgeon's estimation of the EOR based on iUS and the post-operative neuroimaging results (gold standard) were collected, as well as information about the patients/tumors.

RESULTS

Two hundred two resections were reviewed and 58 cases were included. Twenty-six of the excluded cases utilized iUS but did not have EOR indicated. The concordance of interpretation between iUS and post-operative MRI was 98.3%. Of 43 cases where iUS suggested gross total resection, 42 were confirmed on MRI (negative predictive value (NPV), 98%). All 15 cases where iUS suggested subtotal resection were confirmed on MRI (positive predictive value (PPV), 100 %). Agreement between iUS and post-operative imaging had an overall Kappa score of 0.956, signifying almost perfect agreement.

CONCLUSION

The results from this study suggest that iUS is reliable with both residual tumor (PPV-100%) and when it suggests no residual (NPV-98%) in tumors that are easily identifiable on iUS. However, tumors that were difficult to visualize on iUS were potentially excluded, and therefore, these results should not be extrapolated for all brain tumor types.

Transcranial ultrasound imaging with speed of sound-based phase correction: a numerical study

This paper presents a numerical study for ultrasound transcranial imaging. To correct for the phase aberration from the skull, two critical steps are needed prior to brain imaging. In the first step, the skull shape and speed of sound are acquired by either CT scans or ultrasound scans. In the ultrasound scan approach, phased array and double focusing technique are utilized, which are able to estimate the thickness of the skull with a maximum error of around 10% and the average speed of sound in the skull is underestimated by less than 2%. In the second step, the fast marching method is used to compute the phase delay based on the known skull shape and sound speed from the first step, and the computation can be completed in seconds for 2D problems. The computed phase delays are then used in combination with the conventional delay-and-sum algorithm for generating B-mode images. Images of wire phantoms with CT or ultrasound scan-based phase correction are shown to have much less artifact than the ones without correction. Errors of deducing speed of sound from CT scans are also discussed regarding its effect on the transcranial ultrasound images. Assuming the speed of sound grows linearly with the density, this study shows that, the CT-based phase correction approach can provide clear images of wire phantoms even if the speed of sound is overestimated by 400 m s(-1), or the linear coefficient is overestimated by 40%. While in this study, ultrasound scan-based phase correction performs almost equally well with the CT-based approach, potential problems are identified and discussed.

Objective assessment of utility of intraoperative ultrasound in resection of central nervous system tumors: A cost-effective tool for intraoperative navigation in neurosurgery

Background:

Localization and delineation of extent of lesions is critical for safe maximal resection of brain and spinal cord tumors. Frame-based and frameless stereotaxy and intraoperative MRI are costly and not freely available especially in economically constrained nations. Intraoperative ultrasound has been around for a while but has been relegated to the background. Lack of objective evidence for its usefulness and the perceived “user unfriendliness” of US are probably responsible for this. We recount our experience with this “forgotten” tool and propose an objective assessment score of its utility in an attempt to revive this practice.

Materials and Methods:

Seventy seven intraoperative ultrasound (IOUS) studies were carried out in patients with brain and spinal cord tumors. Seven parameters were identified to measure the “utility” of the IOUS and a “utility score” was devised (minimum 0 and maximum 7). Individual parameter and overall scores were calculated for each case.

Results:

IOUS was found to be useful in many ways. The median overall score was 6 (mean score 5.65). There were no scores less than 4 with the majority demonstrating usefulness in 5 or more parameters (91%). The use of the IOUS significantly influenced the performance of the surgery in these cases without significantly prolonging surgery.

Conclusions:

The IOUS is a very useful tool in intraoperative localization and delineation of lesions and planning various stages of tumor resection. It is easy, convenient, reliable, widely available, and above all a cost-effective tool. It should be increasingly used by neurosurgeons in the developing world where costlier intraoperative localization and imaging is not available freely.

Ultrasound-guided operations in unselected high-grade gliomas--overall results, impact of image quality and patient selection

BACKGROUND

A number of tools, including intraoperative ultrasound, are reported to facilitate surgical resection of high-grade gliomas. However, results from selected surgical series do not necessarily reflect the effectiveness in common neurosurgical practice. Delineation of seemingly similar brain tumours vary in different ultrasound-guided operations, perhaps limiting usefulness in certain patients.

METHODS

We explore and describe the results associated with use of the SonoWand system with intraoperative ultrasound in a population-based, unselected, high-grade glioma series. Surgeons filled out questionnaires about presumed extent of resection, use of ultrasound and ultrasound image quality just after surgery. We evaluate the impact of ultrasound image quality. We also explore the importance of patient selection for surgical results.

RESULTS

Of 156 consecutive malignant glioma operations, 142 (91%) were resections whilst 14 (9%) were only biopsies. We achieved gross total resection (GTR) in 37% of all high-grade glioma resections, whilst worsening of functional status was seen in 13%. The risk of getting worse was significantly higher in reoperations, resections in eloquent locations, resections in cases with poor ultrasound image quality, resection when surgeons' resection grade estimates were inaccurate and in cases with surgery-related complications. Aiming for GTR, unifocality of lesion, non-eloquent location and medium or good ultrasound image quality were identified as independent factors associated with achieving GTR.

CONCLUSION

We report good overall results, both in terms of resection grades and functional outcome in consecutive malignant glioma resections, in which intraoperative ultrasound was used in 95%. We observed a seeming dose-response relationship between ultrasound image quality and clinical and radiological results. This may suggest that better ultrasound facilitates better surgery. The study also clearly demonstrates that, in terms of surgical results, the selection of patients seems to be much more important than the selection of surgical tools.

Role of intraoperative ultrasound in resection of pediatric brain tumors

PURPOSE

In neurosurgery, ultrasound is useful in determination of the tumor location, differentiation between solid tumors and cystic components, as well as definition of the shortest and safest access to the mass. This study aims to evaluate the role of the intraoperative ultrasound in resection of pediatric brain tumors.

METHODS

Intraoperative ultrasonography (conventional B-Mode) was performed in 25 pediatric patients with brain tumors pre-, during, and post-resection, in whom eight patients were supratentorial and 17 were infratentorial. Post-op Grayscale images of the brain tumors on conventional ultrasound were compared with the results of immediate postoperative magnetic resonance imaging.

RESULTS

The border of the tumor and post-resection residual tumor were more distinguishable from healthy brain on ultrasound during the operation. Improved definition of the tumor tissue from normal brain with ultrasound was demonstrated in all cases aiding in tumor resection.

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative ultrasound is suggested to be a useful imaging technique in defining the border between the tumor and healthy brain tissue pre-resection, in detecting residual tumor tissues after the resection of the mass, and in guiding to the shortest and safest access to the tumor during neurosurgery.

The impact of workflow and volumetric feedback on frameless image-guided neurosurgery

OBJECTIVE

During image-guided neurosurgery, if the surgeon is not fully orientated to the surgical position, he or she will briefly shift attention toward the visualization interface of an image guidance station, receiving only momentary "point-in-space" information. The aim of this study was to develop a novel visual interface for neuronavigation during brain tumor surgery, enabling intraoperative feedback on the entire progress of surgery relative to the anatomy of the brain and its pathology, regardless of the interval at which the surgeon chooses to look.

METHODS

New software written in Java (Sun Microsystems, Inc., Santa Clara, CA) was developed to visualize the cumulative recorded instrument positions intraoperatively. This allowed surgeons to see all previous instrument positions during the elapsed surgery. This new interactive interface was then used in 17 frameless image-guided neurosurgical procedures. The purpose of the first 11 cases was to obtain clinical experience with this new interface. In these cases, workflow and volumetric feedback (WVF) were available at the surgeons' discretion (Protocol A). In the next 6 cases, WVF was provided only after a complete resection was claimed (Protocol B).

RESULTS

With the novel interactive interface, dynamics of surgical resection, displacement of cortical anatomy, and digitized functional data could be visualized intraoperatively. In the first group (Protocol A), surgeons expressed the view that WVF had affected their decision making and aided resection (10 of 11 cases). In 3 of 6 cases in the second group (Protocol B), tumor resections were extended after evaluation of WVF. By digitizing the cortical surface, an impression of the cortical shift could be acquired in all 17 cases. The maximal cortical shift measured 20 mm, but it typically varied between 0 and 10 mm.

CONCLUSION

Our first clinical results suggest that the embedding of WVF contributes to improvement of surgical awareness and tumor resection in image-guided neurosurgery in a swift and simple manner.

Meningioma

Meningiomas are mostly benign tumours originating from the arachnoid cap cells, represent 13-26% of all intracranial tumours. They are more common in older age and in females. Deletion in NF2 gene and exposure to ionizing radiation are established risk factors, while the role of sex hormones is yet not clarified. Five-year survival for typical meningiomas exceeds 80%, but is poorer (5-year survival <60%) in malignant and atypical meningiomas. Papillary and haemangiopericytic morphology, large tumour size, high mitotic index, absence of progesterone receptors, deletions and loss of heterozygosity are poor prognostic factors. Complete surgical excision is the standard treatment. Radiotherapy is currently used in the clinical practice in atypical, malignant or recurrent meningioma at a total dose of 45-60Gy. However, the role of adjuvant irradiation is still controversial and has to be compared in a randomised prospective setting with a policy of watchful waiting. Radiosurgery has gained more and more importance in the management of meningiomas, especially in meningiomas that cannot be completely resected as for many skull base meningiomas. Medical therapy for patients with recurrent, progressive and symptomatic disease after repeated surgery, radiosurgery and radiotherapy is investigational. Hormonal therapy with progesterone antagonists has shown modest results, while chemotherapy with hydroxyurea appears moderately active.