Morphogenesis of the avian trunk neural crest: use of morphological techniques in elucidating the process

Mechanisms of early neural crest development: from cell specification to migration

The neural crest is a group of embryonic progenitors that forms during the process of neurulation by interactions that take place between the prospective epidermis and the specified neuroectoderm. Although initially an integral part of the neuroepithelium, neural crest cells separate from the central nervous system primordium by a process of epitheliomesenchymal transition and become a motile cell population. These mesenchymal cells then migrate through stereotypic pathways, some of which are common and others unique to various vertebrate species. Furthermore, the availability of distinct migratory pathways also differs according to embryonic stage and axial level. Studies have begun to address the molecular basis of neural crest specification, delamination, and migration. The present review summarizes some major advances in our understanding of the nature of the intercellular interactions and the molecules that mediate them during early phases of neural crest ontogeny.

Inhibition of noggin expression in the dorsal neural tube by somitogenesis: a mechanism for coordinating the timing of neural crest emigration

We have previously shown that axial-dependent delamination of specified neural crest cells is triggered by BMP4 and negatively regulated by noggin. Increasing activity of BMP4 towards the rostral part of the axis is achieved by graded expression of noggin in the dorsal neural tube, the latter being high opposite unsegmented mesoderm, and progressively downregulated facing epithelial and dissociating somites, coinciding in time and axial level with initial delamination of neural crest cells (Sela-Donenfeld, D. and Kalcheim, C. (1999) Development 126, 4749–4762). Here we report that this gradient-like expression of noggin in the neuroepithelium is controlled by the paraxial mesoderm. Deletion of epithelial somites prevented normal downregulation of noggin in the neural tube. Furthermore, partial ablation of either the dorsal half or only the dorsomedial portion of epithelial somites was sufficient to maintain high noggin expression. In contrast, deletion of the segmental plate had no effect. These data suggest that the dorsomedial region of developing somites produces an inhibitor of noggin transcription in the dorsal neural tube. Consistent with this notion, grafting dissociating somites in the place of the unsegmented mesoderm precociously downregulated the expression of noggin and triggered premature emigration of neural crest progenitors from the caudal neural tube. Thus, opposite the unsegmented mesoderm, where noggin expression is high in the neural tube, BMP4 is inactive and neural crest cells fail to delaminate. Upon somitogenesis and further dissociation, the dorsomedial portion of the somite inhibits noggin transcription. Progressive loss of noggin activity releases BMP4 from inhibition, resulting in crest cell emigration. We propose that this inhibitory crosstalk between paraxial mesoderm and neural primordium controls the timing of neural crest delamination to match the development of a suitable mesodermal substrate for subsequent crest migration.

Regulation of the onset of neural crest migration by coordinated activity of BMP4 and Noggin in the dorsal neural tube

For neural crest cells to engage in migration, it is necessary that epithelial premigratory crest cells convert into mesenchyme. The mechanisms that trigger cell delamination from the dorsal neural tube remain poorly understood. We find that, in 15- to 40-somite-stage avian embryos, BMP4 mRNA is homogeneously distributed along the longitudinal extent of the dorsal neural tube, whereas its specific inhibitor noggin exists in a gradient of expression that decreases caudorostrally. This rostralward reduction in signal intensity coincides with the onset of emigration of neural crest cells. Hence, we hypothesized that an interplay between Noggin and BMP4 in the dorsal tube generates graded concentrations of the latter that in turn triggers the delamination of neural crest progenitors. Consistent with this suggestion, disruption of the gradient by grafting Noggin-producing cells dorsal to the neural tube at levels opposite the segmental plate or newly formed somites, inhibited emigration of HNK-1-positive crest cells, which instead accumulated within the dorsal tube. Similar results were obtained with explanted neural tubes from the same somitic levels exposed to Noggin. Exposure to Follistatin, however, had no effect. The Noggin-dependent inhibition was overcome by concomitant treatment with BMP4, which when added alone, also accelerated cell emigration compared to untreated controls. Furthermore, the observed inhibition of neural crest emigration in vivo was preceded by a partial or total reduction in the expression of cadherin-6B and rhoB but not in the expression of slug mRNA or protein. Altogether, these results suggest that a coordinated activity of Noggin and BMP4 in the dorsal neural tube triggers delamination of specified, slug-expressing neural crest cells. Thus, BMPs play multiple and discernible roles at sequential stages of neural crest ontogeny, from specification through delamination and later differentiation of specific neural crest derivatives.

Neural crest development: the interplay between morphogenesis and cell differentiation

The final pattern of tissues established during embryogenesis reflects the outcome of two developmental processes: differentiation and morphogenesis. Avian neural crest cells are an excellent system in which to study this interaction. In the first phase of neural crest cell migration, neural crest cells separate from the neural epithelium via an epithelial-mesenchymal transformation. We present three models to account for this process: (1) separation by asymmetric mitosis, (2) separation by generating tractional force in order to rupture cell adhesions and (3) loss of expression or function of cell-cell adhesion molecules that keep the presumptive neural crest cells tethered to the neural epithelium. Evidence is presented that the segregation of the neural crest lineage apart from the neural epithelium is caused by the epithelial-mesenchymal transformation. Once they have detached from the neural tube, neural crest cells take two pathways in the trunk of the chick embryo: (1) the ventral path between the neural tube and somite, where neural crest cells give rise to neurons and glial cells of the peripheral nervous systems, and (2) the dorsolateral path between the ectoderm and dermamyotome of the somite, where they differentiate into pigment cells of the skin. We present data to suggest that the migration and differentiation along the ventral path is controlled primarily by environmental cues, which we refer to as the environment-directed model of neural crest morphogenesis. Conversely, only melanoblasts can migrate into the dorsolateral space, and the ability to invade that path is dependent upon their early specification as melanoblasts. We call this the phenotype-directed model for neural crest cell migration and suggest that this latter model for the positioning of neural crest derivatives in the embryo may be more common than previously suspected. These observations invite a re-examination of patterning of other crest derivates, which previously were believed to be controlled by environmental cues.

Cell death in the avian sclerotome

In this study the occurrence of apoptotic cells in chick embryo trunk somites, between 2.5 and 4 days of development, has been examined using an in situ nick-end-labeling method (TUNEL) to identify nuclei in which DNA is undergoing fragmentation. At 2.5 days of development, apoptotic cells were found in the sclerotome with a distribution that depended on the rostrocaudal level in the trunk. At the most rostral levels (somites 1-18), dying cells were present primarily in the rostral half of the ventral sclerotome; at midlevels (somites 19-26), they were present throughout the ventral sclerotome; and at caudal levels (somites 27-32), no dying cells were present. By 4 days of development, the number of dying cells in the sclerotome was sharply reduced, and those present were primarily distributed to the caudal side of the intrasclerotomal fissure. Double labeling of cells for both TUNEL and the HNK-1 epitope, at 2.5 days, indicated that the majority of the dying cells were not neural crest cells. Further, dying cells in the rostral somite half were present largely in regions of the sclerotome that labeled poorly for HNK-1. It was confirmed that apoptotic neural crest cells retain the HNK-1 epitope and therefore would have been observed if present. Neural crest cells only appeared to be apoptotic in relatively small numbers and only at the ventral border of the sclerotome. Examination of DiI-labeled neural crest cells confirmed that the dying cells in the body of the somite were not primarily neural crest cells. Two hypotheses regarding the TUNEL-positive cells in the sclerotome were experimentally tested. First, that they originate from the somitocoel compartment of the somite, because their distribution patterns at 4 days were similar to those of somitocoel cells. To test this, somitocoel cells were labeled with carboxyfluorescein and grafted into host embryos in ovo. Results showed that these cells did not become apoptotic and that the dying cells were therefore not derived from the somitocoel. Second, the hypothesis was tested that the distribution patterns of the dying cells in the sclerotome are determined by factors outside the somite itself. Somites and segmental plates were transplanted into hosts in ovo with reversed orientation, after which the patterns of dying cells were examined using nile blue sulfate staining. The results indicated that the patterns were unchanged after a further 2 days incubation, suggesting that the patterns of cell death in the sclerotome are not determined solely from within the somite. The distribution of the cell death-associated gene products, bcl-2, bax, and interleukin-1 beta converting enzyme, indicates that although these proteins are segmentally distributed in the dermomyotome and in the rostrodorsal quadrant of the sclerotome, their patterns are not directly correlated with the distribution of dying cells.