Immunohistochemical distribution of enkephalin, substance P, and somatostatin in the brainstem of the leopard frog, Rana pipiens

Organization of enkephalinergic neuronal system in the central nervous system of the gecko Hemidactylus frenatus

Enkephalins are endogenous opioid pentapeptides that play a role in neurotransmission and pain modulation in vertebrates. However, the distribution pattern of enkephalinergic neurons in the brains of reptiles has been understudied. This study reports the organization of the methionine-enkephalin (M-ENK) and leucine-enkephalin (L-ENK) neuronal systems in the central nervous system of the gecko Hemidactylus frenatus using an immunofluorescence labeling method. Although M-ENK and L-ENK-immunoreactive (ir) fibers extended throughout the pallial and subpallial subdivisions, including the olfactory bulbs, M-ENK and L-ENK-ir cells were found only in the dorsal septal nucleus. Enkephalinergic perikarya and fibers were highly concentrated in the periventricular and lateral preoptic areas, as well as in the anterior and lateral subdivisions of the hypothalamus, while enkephalinergic innervation was observed in the hypothalamic periventricular nucleus, infundibular recess nucleus and median eminence. The dense accumulation of enkephalinergic content was noticed in the pars distalis of the hypophysis. In the thalamus, the nucleus rotundus and the dorsolateral, medial, and medial posterior thalamic nuclei contained M-ENK and L-ENK-ir fibers, whereas clusters of M-ENK and L-ENK-ir neurons were observed in the pretectum, mesencephalon, and rhombencephalon. The enkephalinergic fibers were also seen in the area X around the central canal, as well as the dorsal and ventral horns. The widespread distribution of enkephalin-containing neurons within the central nervous system implies that enkephalins regulate a variety of functions in the gecko, including sensory, behavioral, hypophysiotropic, and neuroendocrine functions.

The opioid peptide leucine enkephalin modulates hypothalamic-hypophysial axis in the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus

In vertebrates, opioid peptides are thought to be involved in the regulation of reproduction; however, the significance of enkephalins in testicular function remains unclear. We examined the influence of δ-opioid receptor agonist leucine enkephalin (L-ENK) on the hypophysial-testicular axis of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus. Treatment with a low dose of L-ENK (60 µg) caused a significant increase in the numbers of primary and secondary spermatocytes and early and late spermatids, concomitant with intense immunolabelling of testicular androgen receptors, but did not significantly alter serum luteinizing hormone (LH) and 11-ketotestosterone (11-KT) levels compared to those of controls. Nevertheless, treatment with a high dose of L-ENK (200 µg) caused a significant reduction in the numbers of secondary spermatocytes as well as late spermatids associated with marginal immunolabelling of androgen receptors and significantly lower concentrations of serum 11-KT and LH compared to controls. In addition, the serum cortisol level was not affected in low-dose L-ENK-treated fish, but its level was significantly increased in the high-dose L-ENK-treated group. Together, these findings indicate that a low dose of L-ENK stimulates the germ cells at the meiosis stage and promotes further stages of spermatogenesis, whereas a high concentration of L-ENK inhibits spermatogenesis at the advanced stages. This effect appears to be mediated through the suppression of testicular steroidogenesis and the reduction of LH release in the pituitary gland of tilapia. The findings also suggest that elevated L-ENK levels in teleosts may exert their inhibitory influence on the hypophysial-testicular axis via glucocorticoids.

Neuroanatomical organization of methionine-enkephalinergic system in the brain of the Mozambique tilapia Oreochromis mossambicus

Enkephalins are a class of opioid peptides implicated in several physiological and neuroendocrine responses in vertebrates. In this study, using immunocytochemical or immunofluorescence technique, we examined the neuroanatomical distribution of methionine enkephalin (M-ENK) immunoreactivity in the central nervous system (CNS) of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus. In the telencephalon, no M-ENK-like-immunoreactive (M-ENK-L-ir) perikarya, but sparsely distributed fibres were detected in the glomerular layer and the granule cell layer of the olfactory bulb. Although intensely labeled M-ENK-L-ir cells and fibres were found in the pallium, no M-ENK immunoreactivity was observed in the subpallium. The preoptic area showed a few M-ENK-L-ir somata and dense innervations of fibres. In the hypothalamic area, M-ENK-L-ir cells and fibres were located in magnocellular and parvocellular subdivisions of the nucleus preopticus, and medial and lateral subdivisions of the nucleus lateralis tuberis. Surrounding the recessus lateralis of the third ventricle, several intensely stained and packed M-ENK-L-ir cells and fibres were seen in dorsal, lateral and ventral subdivisions of the nucleus recessus lateralis. In the diencephalon, M-ENK immunoreactivity was restricted to the habenula, the thalamus, the pretectal area and the nucleus posterior tuberis. Dense aggregations of M-ENK-L-ir fibres were seen in the mesencephalic subdivisions, the optic tectum and the torus semicircularis, whereas a few fusiform M-ENK-L-ir cells and fibres were scattered in the midbrain tegmentum. In the rhombencephalon, different populations of ovoid or spindle shaped M-ENK-L-ir cells were observed in the secondary gustatory nucleus, the sensory trigeminal nerve nucleus, the nucleus reticularis medialis and the vagal motor nucleus, whereas bands of fibres were seen in the rostral spinal cord. Collectively, the widespread distribution of M-ENK immunoreactivity in the CNS suggests a role for this opioid peptide in regulation of neuroendocrine control of reproduction and modulation of sensorimotor functions in fish.

Leucine-enkephalin-immunoreactive neurons in the brain of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus

Enkephalins are the pentapeptides involved in pain relief and neuroendocrine responses with high affinity for delta opioid receptors in vertebrates. In the present investigation, we studied the distribution of leucine-enkephalin-immunoreactive (L-ENK-ir) neurons in the brain of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus. Application of the antisera against L-ENK revealed the presence of numerous L-ENK-ir perikarya and fibres in subdivisions of the dorsal and the ventral telencephalon, the medial olfactory tract and the nucleus entopeduncularis, whereas intensely labelled L-ENK-ir fibres were noticed in the olfactory bulb. Furthermore, the presence of L-ENK-ir cells and dense accumulations of fibres in the preoptic area and its subdivisions, the nucleus preopticus pars magnocellularis and the nucleus preopticus pars parvocellularis suggested a role for this peptide in regulation of reproduction. While intensely labelled cells and fibres were found in the nucleus lateralis tuberis pars lateralis as well as the nucleus lateralis tuberis pars medialis, some L-ENK-ir fibres were seen at the hypothalamo-hypophyseal tract indicating the possible hypophysiotrophic role for this peptide. Numerous L-ENK-ir cells and dense network of fibres were observed in the subdivisions of the nucleus recess lateralis and the pretectal area, whereas intensely labelled thick network of L-ENK- fibres were found in the ventromedial thalamic nucleus, the sub-layers of the optic tectum and the rostral spinal cord. The widespread distribution of L-ENK-immunoreactivity in the olfactory bulb, the telencephalon, the diencephalon and the mesencephalon regions of the brain as well as the spinal cord suggests the possible involvement of this peptide in the regulation of diverse functions such as neuroendocrine, antinociceptive, visual and olfactory responses in O. mossambicus.

Experience-Dependent Bimodal Plasticity of Inhibitory Neurons in Early Development

Inhibitory neurons are heterogeneous in the mature brain. It is unclear when and how inhibitory neurons express distinct structural and functional profiles. Using in vivo time-lapse imaging of tectal neuron structure and visually evoked Ca(2+) responses in tadpoles, we found that inhibitory neurons cluster into two groups with opposite valence of plasticity after 4 hr of dark and visual stimulation. Half decreased dendritic arbor size and Ca(2+) responses after dark and increased them after visual stimulation, matching plasticity in excitatory neurons. Half increased dendrite arbor size and Ca(2+) responses following dark and decreased them after stimulation. At the circuit level, visually evoked excitatory and inhibitory synaptic inputs were potentiated by visual experience and E/I remained constant. Our results indicate that developing inhibitory neurons fall into distinct functional groups with opposite experience-dependent plasticity and as such, are well positioned to foster experience-dependent synaptic plasticity and maintain circuit stability during labile periods of circuit development.

Lung respiratory rhythm and pattern generation in the bullfrog: role of neurokinin-1 and mu-opioid receptors

Location of the lung respiratory rhythm generator (RRG) in the bullfrog brainstem was investigated by examining neurokinin-1 and mu-opioid receptor (NK1R, muOR) colocalization by immunohistochemistry and characterizing the role of these receptors in lung rhythm and episodic pattern generation. NK1R and muOR occurred in brainstems from all developmental stages. In juvenile bullfrogs a distinct area of colocalization was coincident with high-intensity fluorescent labeling of muOR; high-intensity labeling of muOR was not distinctly and consistently localized in tadpole brainstems. NK1R labeling intensity did not change with development. Similarity in colocalization is consistent with similarity in responses to substance P (SP, NK1R agonist) and DAMGO (muOR agonist) when bath applied to bullfrog brainstems of different developmental stages. In early stage tadpoles and juvenile bullfrogs, SP increased and DAMGO decreased lung burst frequency. In juvenile bullfrogs, SP increased lung burst frequency, episode frequency, but decreased number of lung bursts per episode and lung burst duration. In contrast, DAMGO decreased lung burst frequency and burst cycle frequency, episode frequency, and number of lung bursts per episode but increased all other lung burst parameters. Based on these results, we hypothesize that NK1R and muOR colocalization together with a metamorphosis-related increase in muOR intensity marks the location of the lung RRG but not necessarily the lung episodic pattern generator.

Role of glutamate and substance P in the amphibian respiratory network during development

This study tested the hypothesis that glutamatergic ionotropic (AMPA/kainate) receptors and neurokinin receptors (NKR) are important in the regulation of respiratory motor output during development in the bullfrog. The roles of these receptors were studied with in vitro brainstem preparations from pre-metamorphic tadpoles and post-metamorphic frogs. Brainstems were superfused with an artificial cerebrospinal fluid at 20-22 degrees C containing CNQX, a selective non-NMDA antagonist, or with substance P (SP), an agonist of NKR. Blockade of glutamate receptors with CNQX in both groups caused a reduction of lung burst frequency that was reversibly abolished at 5 microM (P<0.01). CNQX, but not SP, application produced a significant increase (P<0.05) in gill and buccal frequency in tadpoles and frogs, respectively. SP caused a significant increase (P<0.05) in lung burst frequency at 5 microM in both groups. These results suggest that glutamatergic activation of AMPA/kainate receptors is necessary for generation of lung burst activity and that SP is an excitatory neurotransmitter for lung burst frequency generation. Both glutamate and SP provide excitatory input for lung burst generation throughout the aquatic to terrestrial developmental transition in bullfrogs.

Distribution of somatostatin-like immunoreactivity in the brain of the caecilian Dermophis mexicanus (Amphibia: Gymnophiona): comparative aspects in amphibians

The organization of the somatostatin-like-immunoreactive (SOM-ir) structures in the brain of anuran and urodele amphibians has been well documented, and significant differences were noted between the two amphibian orders. However, comparable data are not available for the third order of amphibians, the gymnophionans (caecilians). In the present study, we analyzed the anatomical distribution of SOM-ir cells and fibers in the brain of the gymnophionan Dermophis mexicanus. In addition, because of its known relationship with catecholamines in other vertebrates, double immunostaining for SOM and tyrosine hydroxylase was used to investigate this situation in the gymnophionan. Abundant SOM-ir cell bodies and fibers were widely distributed throughout the brain. In the telencephalon, pallial and subpallial cells were labeled, being most numerous in the medial pallium and amygdaloid region. Most of the SOM-ir neurons were found in the preoptic area and hypothalamus and showed a clear projection to the median eminence. Less conspicuously, SOM-ir structures were found in the thalamus, tectum, tegmentum, and reticular formation. Both SOM-ir cells and fibers were demonstrated in the spinal cord. The double-immunohistofluorescence technique revealed that catecholaminergic neurons and SOM-ir cells are largely intermingled in many brain regions but form totally separated populations. Many differences were found between the distribution of SOM-ir structures in Dermophis and that in anurans or urodeles. Some features were shared only with anurans, such as the abundant pallial SOM-ir cells, whereas others were common only to urodeles, such as the organization of the hypothalamohypophysial SOM-ir system. In addition, some characteristics were found only in Dermophis, such as the localization of the SOM-ir spinal cells and the lack of colocalization of catecholamines and SOM throughout the brain. Therefore, any conclusions concerning the SOM system in amphibians are incomplete without considering evidence for gymnophionans.

Spatiotemporal sequence of appearance of NPFF-immunoreactive structures in the developing central nervous system of Xenopus laevis

Neuropeptide FF-like immunoreactive (NPFFir) cells and fibers were analyzed through development of Xenopus laevis. The first NPFFir cells appeared in the embryonic hypothalamus, which projected to the intermediate lobe of the hypophysis, the brainstem and spinal cord. Slightly later, scattered NPFFir cells were present in the olfactory bulbs and ventral telencephalon. In the caudal medulla, NPFFir cells were observed in the nucleus of the solitary tract only at embryonic and early larval stages. Abundant NPFFir cells and fibers were demonstrated in the spinal cord. The sequence of appearance observed in Xenopus shares many developmental features with mammals although notable differences were observed in the telencephalon and hypothalamus. In general, NPFF immunoreactivity developed earlier in amphibians than in mammals.

Distribution of Neuropeptide FF-Like Immunoreactivity in the Brain of Dermophis mexicanus (Amphibia; Gymnophiona): Comparison with FMRFamide Immunoreactivity

Neuropeptide FF (NPFF) is an FMRFamide-related peptide widely distributed in the mammalian brain. NPFF immunohistochemistry labeled cell bodies in a few locations and dense fiber networks throughout the brain. Recently, the distribution of NPFF immunoreactive (NPFF-ir) cells and fibers in the brain of anuran and urodele amphibians was studied and, as in mammals, significant species differences were noted. To further assess general and derived features of the NPFF-containing neuron system in amphibians, we have investigated the distribution of NPFF-ir cell bodies and fibers in the brain of the gymnophionan Dermophis mexicanus by means of an antiserum against bovine NPFF. This distribution was compared to that of FMRFamide immunoreactivity. Major traits shared with anurans and urodeles were the abundant fiber labeling in the ventral telencephalon, hypothalamus, isthmus, ventrolateral medulla and dorsal spinal cord. In addition, in the three amphibian orders the majority of the NPFF-ir cells were located in the preoptic-hypothalamic region. However, distinct particular features were present in the gymnophionan such as the lack of NPFF-ir cells in the telencephalon, brainstem and spinal cord and the absence of NPFF-ir fibers in the hypophysis and the olfactory bulbs. This pattern was distinct from that observed for FMRFamide distribution. Striking differences were noted in the pallium, caudal hypothalamus and midbrain tegmentum where FMRFamide-containing cells were localized. The present results in Dermophis support the idea that data from gymnophionans must be included when stating the amphibian condition of a given system because important variations are obvious when gymnophionans are compared with anurans and urodeles.

Neuroanatomical Distribution of Cannabinoid Receptor Gene Expression in the Brain of the Rough-Skinned Newt, Taricha granulosa

Type I cannabinoid receptor (CB1) is a G-protein coupled receptor with a widespread distribution in the central nervous system in mammals. In a urodele amphibian, the rough-skinned newt (Taricha granulosa), recent evidence indicates that endogenous cannabinoids (endocannabinoids) mediate behavioral responses to acute stress and electrophysiological responses to corticosterone. To identify possible sites of action for endocannabinoids, in situ hybridization using a gene and species specific cRNA probe was used to label CB1 mRNA in brains of male T. granulosa. Labeling of CB1 mRNA in the telencephalon was observed in the olfactory bulb and all areas of the pallium, as well as the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis and nucleus amygdalae dorsolateralis. The labeling of CB1 mRNA was also found in regions of the preoptic area, thalamus, midbrain tegmentum and tectum, cerebellum, and the stratum griseum of the hindbrain. A notable difference in CB1 labeling between this amphibian and mammals is the abundance of labeling in areas associated with olfaction (anterior olfactory nuclei, nucleus amygdalae dorsolateralis, and lateral pallium), which hints that endocannabinoids might modulate responses to odors as well as pheromones. This widespread distribution of CB1 labeling, particularly in sensory and motor control centers, fits with prior results showing that endocannabinoids modulate sensorimotor processing and behavioral output in this species. The distribution of CB1 in the brain of T. granulosa was in many of the same sites previously observed in the brain of the anuran amphibian, Xenopus laevis, as well as those of different species of mammals, suggesting that endocannabinoid signaling pathways are conserved.

Distribution of GABA, glycine, and glutamate in neurons of the medulla oblongata and their projections to the midbrain tectum in plethodontid salamanders

In the medulla oblongata of plethodontid salamanders, GABA-, glycine-, and glutamate-like immunoreactivity (ir) of neurons was studied. Combined tracing and immunohistochemical experiments were performed to analyze the transmitter content of medullary nuclei with reciprocal connections with the tectum mesencephali. The distribution of transmitters differed significantly between rostral and caudal medulla; dual or triple localization of transmitters was present in somata throughout the rostrocaudal extent of the medulla. Regarding the rostral medulla, the largest number of GABA- and gly-ir neurons was found in the medial zone. Neurons of the nucleus reticularis medius (NRM) retrogradely labeled by tracer application into the tectum revealed predominantly gly-ir, often colocalized with glu-ir. The NRM appears to be homologous to the mammalian gigantocellular reticular nucleus, and its glycinergic projection is most likely part of a negative feedback loop between medulla and tectum. Neurons of the dorsal and vestibular nucleus projecting to the tectum were glu-ir and often revealed additional GABA- and/or gly-ir in the vestibular nucleus. Regarding the caudal medulla, the highest density of GABA- and gly-ir cells was found in the lateral zone. Differences in the neurochemistry of the rostral versus caudal medulla appear to result from the transmitter content of projection nuclei in the rostral medulla and support the idea that the rostral medulla is involved in tecto-reticular interaction. Our results likewise underline the role of the NRM in visual object selection and orientation as suggested by behavioral studies and recordings from tectal neurons.

Distribution of GABA-Like Immunoreactive Cell Bodies in the Brains of Two Amphibians, Rana catesbeiana and Xenopus laevis

The distribution of the neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) is not well understood for non-mammalian vertebrates. We thus used immunocytochemistry to locate putative GABAergic cells in the brains of male bullfrogs (Rana catesbeiana) and South African clawed frogs (Xenopus laevis). GABA-immunoreactive cell bodies were broadly distributed throughout the brains of both species with similar general patterns. In both, the greatest numbers of GABA-positive cells were found in the olfactory bulb, thalamus, and optic tectum, but virtually no major brain region lacked GABAergic cells. Species differences were also apparent. The density of GABA-immunoreactive cells was substantially higher in many areas of the bullfrog brain, compared to Xenopus. Bullfrogs possessed extensive cell populations in the medial pallium, preoptic area, optic tectum, torus semicircularis and tegmentum but cells were fewer in these locations in Xenopus. In the bullfrog hindbrain, GABA-immunoreactive cell bodies were restricted to very narrow and distinct populations. In Xenopus, however, cells in a similar position were fewer and spread more extensively. The distribution of GABA cells in the brain of these two species supports the hypotheses that GABA is involved in control of olfaction, audition, vision and vocalization. However, differences in the distribution of GABA between the bullfrog and Xenopus suggest that the extent of the GABAergic influence might vary between species.

Somatostatin in the brain of the cave salamander,Hydromantes genei (Amphibia, Plethodontidae): Immunohistochemical localization and biochemical characterization

The distribution of somatostatin-like immunoreactivity in the brain of the cave salamander Hydromantes genei (Amphibia, Plethodontidae) was investigated by using two distinct antisera raised against somatostatin-14. Most somatostatin-positive cells were detected in the ependymal cell layer surrounding the ventricles. These cells possessed the typical morphological characteristics of tanycytes or radial glial cells. Double-labeling with an antiserum against somatostatin and a monoclonal antibody against glial fibrillary acidic protein showed that somatostatin-immunoreactive cells lining the ventricles also exhibited GFAP-like immunoreactivity. Injection of the neurotracer biocytin into the lateral ventricle revealed that neurons lining the ventricles did not contain somatostatin-like immunoreactivity. In the telencephalon, somatostatin-like immunoreactivity was confined to radial glial cells. In the diencephalon, in addition to somatostatin-immunoreactive cells in the ependyma, positive cell bodies were also found in the periventricular preoptic nucleus, the infundibular nucleus, the epiphysis, and the subcommissural organ. In the metencephalon, positive cell bodies were found in the auricula cerebelli, whereas in the rhombencephalon numerous somatostatin-immunoreactive cells were seen lining the ventricular cavity. Immunoreactive nerve fibers were observed in the hypothalamus-median eminence complex. In the pituitary, a discrete group of somatostatin-positive cells was found in the pars distalis. High-performance liquid chromatography analysis of brain extracts revealed that the immunoreactive material coeluted with somatostatin-14. The present results show that the somatostatin peptidergic system in the brain of the cave salamander has a more simple organization than those described in the brain of frog and other vertebrates. This feature is probably related to the expression of high pedomorphic characters in plethodontids. The distribution of somatostatin-like immunoreactivity suggests that, in the cave salamander, somatostatin may act as a neurotransmitter and/or neuromodulator, a central regulator of fluid homeostasis, and a hypophysiotropic neurohormone.

Somatostatin-like immunoreactivity in the brain of the urodele amphibian Pleurodeles waltl. Colocalization with catecholamines and nitric oxide

The neuronal structures with somatostatin-like immunoreactivity have been studied in the brain of the urodele amphibian Pleurodeles waltl. Intense immunoreactivity was observed in neurons and fibers distributed throughout the brain. Within the telencephalon, the subpallial regions were densely labeled containing both cells and fibers, primarily in the striatum and amygdala. The majority of the somatostatin immunoreactive neurons were located in the preoptic area and hypothalamus, although less numerous cells were also found in the thalamus. A conspicuous innervation of the median eminence was revealed, which arises from the hypothalamic cell populations. In the brainstem, intense fiber labeling was present in the tectum and tegmentum, whereas cell bodies were located only in the tegmentum of the mesencephalon and in the interpeduncular, raphe and reticular nuclei of the rhombencephalon. Longitudinal fiber tracts throughout the brainstem were observed and they continued into the spinal cord in the laterodorsal funiculus. The localization of somatostatin in catecholaminergic and nitrergic neurons was studied by double labeling techniques with antisera against tyrosine hydroxylase and nitric oxide synthase. Catecholamines and somatostatin only colocalized in a cell population in the ventral preoptic area. In turn, the striatum and amygdala contained neurons with somatostatin and nitric oxide synthase. Our results demonstrated that the somatostatin neuronal system in the brain of Pleurodeles waltl is consistent with that observed in anuran amphibians and shares many characteristics with those of amniotes. Colocalization of somatostatin with catecholamines and nitric oxide is very restricted in the urodele brain, but in places that can be easily compared to those reported for mammals, suggesting that interactions between these neurotransmitter systems are a primitive feature shared by tetrapod vertebrates.

The effects of nicotinic and muscarinic receptor activation on patch-clamped cells in the optic tectum of Rana pipiens

Both nicotinic and muscarinic cholinergic receptors are present in the optic tectum. To begin to understand how the activation of these receptors affects visual activity patterns, we have determined the types of physiological responses induced by their activation. Using tectal brain slices from the leopard frog, we found that application of nicotine (100 microM) evoked long-lasting responses in 60% of patch-clamped tectal cells. Thirty percent of these responses consisted of an increase in spontaneous postsynaptic currents (sPSCs) and had both a glutamatergic and GABAergic component as determined by the use of 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (50 microM) and bicuculline (25 microM), respectively. Remaining response types consisted of an inward membrane current (16%) and an increase in sPSCs combined with an inward membrane current (14%). All responses could be elicited in the presence of tetrodotoxin (0.5 microM). Muscarinic receptor-mediated responses, induced by carbachol (100 microM) application after nicotinic receptor desensitization, produced responses in 70% of tectal cells. In contrast to responses elicited by nicotine, carbachol-induced responses could be evoked multiple times without significant decrement. Responses consisted of either an outward current (57%), a decrease in sPSCs (5%) or an increase in sPSCs, with (almost 6%) or without (almost 3%) an outward current. The response elicited by carbachol was not predicted by the response of the cell to nicotine. Our results suggest that nicotinic receptors are found predominantly at presynaptic locations in the optic tectum while muscarinic receptors are most often present at postsynaptic sites. We conclude that both of these receptor types could substantially modulate visual activity by changing either the input to tectal neurons or the level of their response to that input.