Improving autofluorescent proteins: Comparative studies of the effective brightness of Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) mutants

Characterization of Fluorescent Proteins with Intramolecular Photostabilization*

Genetically encodable fluorescent proteins have revolutionized biological imaging in vivo and in vitro. Despite their importance, their photophysical properties, i. e., brightness, count-rate and photostability, are relatively poor compared to synthetic organic fluorophores or quantum dots. Intramolecular photostabilizers were recently rediscovered as an effective approach to improve photophysical properties of organic fluorophores. Here, direct conjugation of triplet-state quenchers or redox-active substances creates high local concentrations of photostabilizer around the fluorophore. In this paper, we screen for effects of covalently linked photostabilizers on fluorescent proteins. We produced a double cysteine mutant (A206C/L221C) of α-GFP for attachment of photostabilizer-maleimides on the β-barrel near the chromophore. Whereas labelling with photostabilizers such as trolox, a nitrophenyl group, and cyclooctatetraene, which are often used for organic fluorophores, had no effect on α-GFP-photostability, a substantial increase of photostability was found upon conjugation to azobenzene. Although the mechanism of the photostabilizing effects remains to be elucidated, we speculate that the higher triplet-energy of azobenzene might be crucial for triplet-quenching of fluorophores in the blue spectral range. Our study paves the way for the development of fluorescent proteins with photostabilizers in the protein barrel by methods such as unnatural amino acid incorporation.

Emission shaping in fluorescent proteins: role of electrostatics and π-stacking

We obtained the fluorescence spectrum of the GFP with trajectory simulations, and revealed the role of the protein sidechains in emission shifts.

Optimization of flow cytometric detection and cell sorting of transgenic Plasmodium parasites using interchangeable optical filters

Background

Malaria remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Flow cytometry-based assays that take advantage of fluorescent protein (FP)-expressing malaria parasites have proven to be valuable tools for quantification and sorting of specific subpopulations of parasite-infected red blood cells. However, identification of rare subpopulations of parasites using green fluorescent protein (GFP) labelling is complicated by autofluorescence (AF) of red blood cells and low signal from transgenic parasites. It has been suggested that cell sorting yield could be improved by using filters that precisely match the emission spectrum of GFP.

Methods

Detection of transgenic Plasmodium falciparum parasites expressing either tdTomato or GFP was performed using a flow cytometer with interchangeable optical filters. Parasitaemia was evaluated using different optical filters and, after optimization of optics, the GFP-expressing parasites were sorted and analysed by microscopy after cytospin preparation and by imaging cytometry.

Results

A new approach to evaluate filter performance in flow cytometry using two-dimensional dot blot was developed. By selecting optical filters with narrow bandpass (BP) and maximum position of filter emission close to GFP maximum emission in the FL1 channel (510/20, 512/20 and 517/20; dichroics 502LP and 466LP), AF was markedly decreased and signal-background improve dramatically. Sorting of GFP-expressing parasite populations in infected red blood cells at 90 or 95% purity with these filters resulted in 50-150% increased yield when compared to the standard filter set-up. The purity of the sorted population was confirmed using imaging cytometry and microscopy of cytospin preparations of sorted red blood cells infected with transgenic malaria parasites.

Discussion

Filter optimization is particularly important for applications where the FP signal and percentage of positive events are relatively low, such as analysis of parasite-infected samples with in the intention of gene-expression profiling and analysis. The approach outlined here results in substantially improved yield of GFP-expressing parasites, and requires decreased sorting time in comparison to standard methods. It is anticipated that this protocol will be useful for a wide range of applications involving rare events.

Determination of copper(II) ion concentration by lifetime measurements of green fluorescent protein

The understanding of cellular processes and functions and the elucidation of their physiological mechanisms is an important aim in the life sciences. One important aspect is the uptake and the release of essential substances as well as their interactions with the cellular environment. As green fluorescent protein (GFP) can be genetically encoded in cells it can be used as an internal sensor giving a deeper insight into biochemical pathways. Here we report that the presence of copper(II) ions leads to a decrease of the fluorescence lifetime (τ(fl)) of GFP and provide evidence for Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) as the responsible quenching mechanism. We identify the His(6)-tag as the responsible binding site for Cu(2+) with a dissociation constant K(d) = 9 ± 2 μM and a Förster radius R(0) = 2.1 ± 0.1 nm. The extent of the lifetime quenching depends on [Cu(2+)] which is comprehended by a mathematical titration model. We envision that Cu(2+) can be quantified noninvasively and in real-time by measuring τ(fl) of GFP.

Quenched substrates for live-cell labeling of SNAP-tagged fusion proteins with improved fluorescent background

Recent developments in fluorescence microscopy raise the demands for bright and photostable fluorescent tags for specific and background free labeling in living cells. Aside from fluorescent proteins and other tagging methods, labeling of SNAP-tagged proteins has become available thereby increasing the pool of potentially applicable fluorescent dyes for specific labeling of proteins. Here, we report on novel conjugates of benzylguanine (BG) which are quenched in their fluorescence and become highly fluorescent upon labeling of the SNAP-tag, the commercial variant of the human O(6)-alkylguanosyltransferase (hAGT). We identified four conjugates showing a strong increase, i.e., >10-fold, in fluorescence intensity upon labeling of SNAP-tag in vitro. Moreover, we screened a subset of nine BG-dye conjugates in living Escherichia coli and found them all suited for labeling of the SNAP-tag. Here, quenched BG-dye conjugates yield a higher specificity due to reduced contribution from excess conjugate to the fluorescence signal. We further extended the application of these conjugates by labeling a SNAP-tag fusion of the Tar chemoreceptor in live E. coli cells and the eukaryotic transcription factor STAT5b in NIH 3T3 mouse fibroblast cells. Aside from the labeling efficiency and specificity in living cells, we discuss possible mechanisms that might be responsible for the changes in fluorescence emission upon labeling of the SNAP-tag, as well as problems we encountered with nonspecific labeling with certain conjugates in eukaryotic cells.

Photoswitching of E222Q GFP mutants: "concerted" mechanism of chromophore isomerization and protonation

Photochromic (i.e. reversibly photoswitchable) fluorescent proteins increasingly find applications as biomarkers for advanced bioimaging applications. From a mechanistic point of view, photochromicity usually stems from the reversible cis-trans photoisomerization of the chromophore. We demonstrated experimentally that cis-trans photoisomerization constitutes a very efficient deactivation pathway of isolated chromophores upon visible light excitation. Nonetheless, this intrinsic property is seldom displayed by chromophores in the folded protein structure. We found that the E222Q amino acid replacement restores efficient photochromicity in otherwise poorly switchable green fluorescent protein variants of different optical properties. Glutamic acid 222 is known to play a pivotal role in the inner proton wires that involve the GFP chromophore and the surrounding residues. Hence its substitution with an isosteric but non-ionizable residue presumably leads to a extensive rewiring of proton pathways around the chromophore, which has a deep effect also on the photochromic properties. In this work, we review and discuss the main photophysical properties of photochromic E222Q GFP mutants. Additionally we show, by means of flash-photolysis experiments, that chromophore cis to trans photoswitching involves a molecular mechanism where stereochemical isomerization and chromophore protonation occur in a coordinated way. Such a "concerted" mechanism is, in our opinion, at the basis of efficient photochromic behavior and might be activated by the E222Q mutation.

Photoinduced millisecond switching kinetics in the GFPMut2 E222Q mutant

New probes for kinetic intracellular measurements in the millisecond range are desirable to monitor protein biochemical dynamics essential for catalysis, allosteric regulation, and signaling. Good candidates to this aim are the photoswitchable mutants of the green fluorescent protein, whose anionic fluorescence, primed by blue light, is markedly enhanced under an additional excitation at a shorter wavelength and relaxes within a few milliseconds. The aim of this report is to study how the brightness enhancement kinetics depends on the physical-chemical and spectroscopic parameters and to provide proof-of-concept experiments for the use of the fluorescence enhancement in conditions in which the protein diffusion is hindered and thereby photobleaching can be a limiting critical issue. Future, direct applications of photochromic mutants for modulated excitation imaging would in fact require such a detailed knowledge. We present here an extensive study of the photoswitching mechanism of the E222Q mutant of GFPMut2 (Mut2Q), pumped by visible 488 nm light and probed at 400-420 nm, as a function of pH, viscosity, temperature, and light intensity. In solution, two characteristic photoswitching times are found by means of modulated double beam fluorescence correlation spectroscopy in the 1-30 ms range, depending on the solution pH. The photoswitching kinetics is solved in terms of the eigenvalues and the eigenvectors of a specific energy diagram and used directly to fit the data, suggesting that the observed photoswitching amplitudes and kinetics are related to a single three-level transition loop. Finally, we give in vitro examples of the use of modulated excitation microscopy, based on fluorescence enhancement amplitude and kinetics detection, on Mut2Q protein samples immobilized in acrylamide gels.

Manipulation of the local density of photonic states to elucidate fluorescent protein emission rates

We present experiments to determine the quantum efficiency and emission oscillator strength of exclusively the emitting states of the widely used enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP). We positioned the emitters at precisely defined distances from a mirror to control the local density of optical states, resulting in characteristic changes in the fluorescence decay rate that we monitored by fluorescence lifetime microscopy. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first emission lifetime control of a biological emitter. From the oscillation of the observed emission lifetimes as a function of the emitter to mirror distance, we determined the radiative and nonradiative decay rates of the fluorophore. Since only the emitting species contribute to the change in emission lifetimes, the rates determined characterize specifically the quantum efficiency and oscillator strength of the on-states of the emitter, in contrast to other methods that do not differentiate between emitting and dark states. The method reported is especially interesting for photophysically complex systems like fluorescent proteins, where a range of emitting and dark forms has been observed. We have validated the analysis method using Rhodamine 6G dye, obtaining results in very good agreement with the literature. For EGFP we determine the quantum efficiency of the on-states to be 72%. As expected for this complex system, our value is higher than that determined by methods that average over on- and off-states.

Efficient photoconversion distorts the fluorescence lifetime of GFP in confocal microscopy: a model kinetic study on mutant Thr203Val

Phototransformations of autofluorescent proteins are applied in high-resolution microscopy and in studying cellular transport, but they are detrimental when accidentally occurring in blinking or photobleaching (BL). Here, we investigate the kinetics of phototransformations of a photoactivatable green fluorescent protein (GFP) in confocal microscopy. Photoconversion (PC) is achieved by excitation of the barely present anionic chromophore state R(eq) (-) in the GFP mutant Thr203Val. Besides the shift of the equilibrium between the neutral chromophore state RH and R(eq) (-), the photoconverted anionic chromophore R(PC) (-) exhibits a reduced fluorescence lifetime tau(fl)=2.2 ns. In fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy, tau(fl) is found to depend, however, on the excitation conditions and history. The underlying photochemistry is described by the kinetic scheme of consecutive reactions, R(eq) (-)-->R(PC) (-)-->P(dark), in which the anionic chromophore species and the dark protein P(dark) are coupled by PC and BL. Time-correlated single-photon-counting detection in a confocal geometry of freely diffusing species is used to compute the quantum yields for PC and BL, Phi(PC) and Phi(BL). The assessed values are Phi(PC)=5.5 x 10(-4) and Phi(BL)>1 x 10(-5). Based on these values, PC provokes misinterpretation in fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments and is responsible for spectroscopic peculiarities in single-molecule detection.

Analysis of interactions of signaling proteins with phage-displayed ligands by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescent correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was used to measure binding affinities of ligands to ligates that are expressed by phage-display technology. Using this method we have quantified the binding of the 14-3-3 signaling protein to artificial peptide ligand. As a ligand we used the R18 artificial peptide expressed as a fusion in the cpIII coat protein that is present in 3 to 5 copies in an M13 phage. Comparisons of binding affinities were made with free R18 ligands using FCS. The result showed a relatively high binding affinity for the phage-displayed R18 peptide compared with binding to free fluorescently labeled R18. Quantification was supported by titration of the phage numbers using atomic force microscopy (AFM). AFM was shown to accurately determine phage numbers in solution as a good alternative for electron microscopy. It was shown to give reliable data that correlated perfectly with those of the viable phage numbers determined by classical bacterial infection studies. In conclusion, a very fast and sensitive method for the selection of new peptide ligands or ligates based on a quantitative assay in solution has been developed.

Protonation and conformational dynamics of GFP mutants by two-photon excitation fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

GFP mutants are known to display fluorescence flickering, a process that occurs in a wide time range. Because serine 65, threonine 203, glutamate 222, and histidine 148 have been indicated as key residues in determining the GFP fluorescence photodynamics, we have focused here on the role of histidine 148 and glutamate 222 by studying the fluorescence dynamics of GFPmut2 (S65A, V68L, and S72A GFP) and its H148G (Mut2G) and E222Q (Mut2Q) mutants. Two relaxation components are found in the fluorescence autocorrelation functions of GFPmut2: a 10-100 micros pH-dependent component and a 100-500 micros laser-power-dependent component. The comparison of these three mutants shows that the mutation of histidine 148 to glycine induces a 3-fold increase in the protonation rate, thereby indicating that the protonation-deprotonation of the chromophore occurs via a proton exchange with the solution mediated by the histidine 148 residue. The power-dependent but pH-independent relaxation mode, which is not affected by the E222Q and H148G mutations, is due to an excited-state process that is probably related to conformational rearrangements of the chromophore after the photoexcitation, more than to the chromophore excited-state proton transfer.

New insights into the photophysics of DsRed by multiparameter spectroscopy on single proteins

The red fluorescent protein from DsRed from Discosoma reef coral exhibits complex photophysics. One key reason for this is that DsRed forms obligate tetrameric units containing green and red emitting monomers in random composition. Experimental investigations have proven that these different chromophores within one tetramer are coupled by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and that the observed strong red emission is due to a nonradiative energy transfer from the green to the red chromophore when the green chromophore is exclusively excited. Ensemble studies can only provide averaged data on statistical mixtures of tetramers with different compositions, since it is impossible to separate the tetramers into functional monomers containing only red or green emitting chromophores. We present here the results of DsRed multiparameter single molecule spectroscopy. By combination of spectral and time domain spectroscopy, we were able to isolate single tetramers containing only green chromophores and thus record the fluorescence lifetime of the green emitting species without interference from FRET to the red chromophore for the first time. The fluorescence lifetime for the green chromophore of DsRed is remarkably longer than for the green fluorescent protein, which is a chemical analogue to the green chromophore in DsRed. On the basis of our single protein experiments, we can derive a complete set of spectroscopic parameters to describe Forster energy transfer in the DsRed system without any further assumptions. Hence in combination with X-ray studies our data allow for an accurate quantitative description of the radiative and nonradiative relaxation processes in DsRed proteins.

Fluorescent proteins for single-molecule fluorescence applications

We present single-molecule fluorescence data of fluorescent proteins GFP, YFP, DsRed, and mCherry, a new derivative of DsRed. Ensemble and single-molecule fluorescence experiments proved mCherry as an ideally suited fluorophore for single-molecule applications, demonstrated by high photostability and rare fluorescence-intensity fluctuations. Although mCherry exhibits the lowest fluorescence quantum yield among the fluorescent proteins investigated, its superior photophysical characteristics suggest mCherry as an ideal alternative in single-molecule fluorescence experiments. Due to its spectral characteristics and short fluorescence lifetime of 1.46 ns, mCherry complements other existing fluorescent proteins and is recommended for tracking and localization of target molecules with high accuracy, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM), or multicolor applications.