Fast spin-echo MR imaging of the abdomen: contrast optimization and artifact reduction

Quantitative Versus Qualitative Methods in Evaluation of T2 Signal Intensity to Improve Accuracy in Diagnosis of Pheochromocytoma

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to assess T2 signal intensity (SI) of adrenal pheochromocytoma at 1.5 T using the rapid acquisitions with relaxation enhancement (RARE) sequence. We also sought to determine whether quantitative parameters can distinguish pheochromocytoma from other adrenal lesions with better accuracy than conventional qualitative methods.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

MRI examinations of 74 patients (26 with pheochromocytoma, 25 with lipid-poor adenomas, 18 with malignant adrenal lesions, and five with adrenal cysts) were retrospectively reviewed. MRI sequences included single-shot fast spin-echo (n = 38) and fast-recovery fast spin-echo (n = 36) acquisitions. T2 SI of lesions was qualitatively compared with CSF. Quantitative evaluation included applying ROI measurements and calculating SI ratio of each mass to liver, spleen, paraspinal muscle, and CSF. Twoway ANOVA compared SI ratios between different adrenal lesions and between two pulse sequences. ROC analysis determined the optimal threshold SI ratio for distinguishing pheochromocytomas from other adrenal lesions.

RESULTS

Sixty-nine percent of pheochromocytomas displayed isointensity to CSF (p < 0.005), resulting in 81% specificity and 69% sensitivity for differentiation of pheochromocytomas from lipid-poor adenomas and malignant lesions. Adrenal-to-muscle SI ratio was the strongest discriminator for differentiation of pheochromocytomas from other lesions. A threshold of at least 3.95 yielded 88% specificity and 81% sensitivity for distinguishing pheochromocytomas from lipid-poor adenomas and malignant adrenal lesions.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative normalization of T2 SI with reference to muscle improves the sensitivity and specificity profile for differentiation of pheochromocytoma compared with qualitative assessment alone. At 1.5 T field strength, an adrenal-to-muscle SI ratio of at least 3.95 is recommended.

Analysis of endoscopic third ventriculostomy patency by MRI: value of different pulse sequences, the sequence parameters, and the imaging planes for investigation of flow void

PURPOSE

The aim of the study is to evaluate the efficiency of turbo spin-echo (TSE), three-dimensional constructive interference in the steady state (3D CISS) and cine phase contrast (Cine PC) sequences in determining flow through the endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV) fenestration, and to determine the effect of various TSE sequence parameters.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was approved by our institutional review board and informed consent from all patients was obtained. Two groups of patients were included: group I (24 patients with good clinical outcome after ETV) and group II (22 patients with hydrocephalus evaluated preoperatively). The imaging protocol for both groups was identical. TSE T2 with various sequence parameters and imaging planes, and 3D CISS, followed by cine PC were obtained. Flow void was graded as four-point scales. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive and negative predictive values of sequences were calculated.

RESULTS

Bidirectional flow through the fenestration was detected in all group I patients by cine PC. Stroke volumes through the fenestration in group I ranged 10-160.8 ml/min. There was no correlation between the presence of reversed flow and flow void grading. Also, there was no correlation between the stroke volumes and flow void grading. The sensitivity of 3D CISS was low, and 2 mm sagittal TSE T2, nearly equal to cine PC, provided best result.

CONCLUSION

Cine PC and TSE T2 both have high confidence in the assessment of the flow through the fenestration. But, sequence parameters significantly affect the efficiency of TSE T2.

Magnetic resonance imaging of the upper abdomen using a free-breathing T2-weighted turbo spin echo sequence with navigator triggered prospective acquisition correction

PURPOSE

To evaluate a free-breathing navigator triggered T2-weighted turbo spin-echo sequence with prospective acquisition correction (T2w-PACE-TSE) for MRI of the upper abdomen in comparison to a conventional T2-weighted TSE (T2w-CTSE), a single-shot TSE (T2w-HASTE), and a T1-weighted gradient-echo sequence (T1w-FLASH).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 40 consecutive patients were examined at 1.5 T using free-breathing T2w-PACE-TSE, free-breathing T2w-CTSE, and breath-hold T2w-HASTE and T1w-FLASH acquisition. Images were evaluated qualitatively by three radiologists regarding motion artifacts, liver-spleen contrast, depiction of intrahepatic vessels, the pancreas and the adrenal glands, and overall image quality on a four-point scale. Quantitative analysis of the liver-spleen contrast was performed.

RESULTS

Depiction and sharpness of intrahepatic vessels were rated significantly better (P < 0.01) using T2w-PACE-TSE compared to T2w-CTSE and T2w-HASTE sequences. Significantly higher contrast values were measured for T2w-PACE-TSE images compared to T2w-CTSE, T2w-HASTE, and T1w-FLASH images (P < 0.01). Mean examination time of the T2w-PACE-TSE was 7.91 minutes, acquisition time of the T2w-CTSE sequence was 4.52 minutes.

CONCLUSION

Prospective acquisition correction is an efficient method for reducing respiratory movement artifacts in T2w-TSE imaging of the upper abdomen. Compared to T2w-CTSE and T2w-HASTE sequences recognition of anatomical details and contrast can be significantly improved.

Extent and time course of morphological changes of bone marrow induced by granulocyte-colony stimulating factor as assessed by magnetic resonance imaging of healthy blood stem cell donors

The aim of this study was to assess the time course and extent of signal alterations of red bone marrow after short-term stimulation by recombinant human granulocyte-colony stimulating factor (rHuG-CSF) in healthy peripheral blood stem cell donors using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at low-field strength. Twelve healthy blood stem cell donors without evidence of bone marrow disorders were prospectively investigated and underwent four MRI studies of their lumbar spine. Sagittal T1- and T2-weighted spin-echo sequences and a gradient-echo (GE) sequence with an echo time for out-of-phase imaging were performed prior to rHuG-CSF application (baseline MRI), on the day of first stem cell harvest (after 70 microg/kg body weight rHuG-CSF, second MRI) followed by two studies 9-18 days (median 14.5 days, third MRI) and 26-48 days (median 39.5 days, fourth MRI) after discontinuation of rHuG-CSF application. Baseline MRI showed normal marrow signal in all patients. The second MRI revealed a decrease of quantified bone marrow signal relative to nucleus pulposus in T1- and T2-weighted images and an increase of relative signal in out-of-phase GE sequences. The greatest changes of relative marrow signal were observed at the third MRI. Compared to baseline MRI, relative marrow signal was diminished by 12% in T1-weighted images and increased by 59% in GE sequences, consistent with a rise in marrow cellularity simulating diffuse marrow disease. At the fourth MRI quantified relative marrow signal returned to baseline levels in all sequences. In healthy individuals rHuG-CSF application leads to significant signal changes of bone marrow in lumbar vertebra that are maximal about 2 weeks after discontinuation of rHuG-CSF application. In patients with underlying marrow disorders who receive hematopoietic growth factors during treatment, these changes should not be confused with disease progression.

Liver lesion conspicuity: T2-weighted breath-hold fast spin-echo MR imaging before and after gadolinium enhancement--initial experience

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effect of a gadolinium chelate on T2-weighted breath-hold fast spin-echo magnetic resonance images of focal hepatic lesions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In 21 patients with focal hepatic lesions, identical T2-weighted breath-hold fast spin-echo images were obtained before and after gadolinium enhancement and were compared regarding lesion-to-liver contrast-to-noise ratio, signal-to-noise ratio, lesion conspicuity, and vascular pulsation artifact. Image review was performed independently, in random order, by two experienced radiologists.

RESULTS

For solid lesions, the lesion-to-liver contrast-to-noise ratio on enhanced images was significantly higher (P <.05) than that on nonenhanced images. For nonsolid lesions, however, there was no significant difference (P =.07). For both readers, lesion conspicuity for solid lesions on enhanced images was significantly higher than on nonenhanced images (P <.05). Severity of vascular pulsation artifact was not significantly different.

CONCLUSION

Solid-lesion contrast on T2-weighted breath-hold fast spin-echo images improves after administration of a gadolinium chelate. These images should be obtained after, rather than before, gadolinium enhancement.

A prospective assessment of breath-hold fast spin echo and inversion recovery fast spin echo techniques for detection and characterization of focal hepatic lesions

The purpose of this study was to prospectively assess two breath-hold T(2)-weighted fast spin-echo sequences and two breath-hold inversion recovery fast spin-echo sequences to determine their relative ability to detect and characterize focal hepatic lesions. Fourteen patients with a total of nineteen proven focal hepatic lesions were imaged with two breath-hold T(2)-weighted (T2W) fast spin echo sequences (HASTE TE = 66 and HASTE TE = 120), two breath-hold inversion recovery fast spin echo sequences (IRFSE TE = 64 and IRFSE TE = 95), and a nonbreath-hold T(2)-weighted fast-spin echo sequence (FSE TE = 96-120). Contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) were measured for all proven lesions on all sequences. Both IRFSE sequences and the HASTE sequence with TE = 66 showed an improvement in lesion-liver and liver-spleen CNRs compared to the nonbreath-hold T2W sequence. The mean difference in CNR between benign and malignant lesions was largest for the HASTE TE = 120 sequence. These preliminary results suggest that a breath-hold IRFSE sequence (TE = 64 or 95) has an equal ability to detect focal hepatic lesions as a nonbreath-hold T2W FSE sequence (TE = 96-120). The HASTE TE = 120 showed the greatest ability to discriminate between benign and malignant lesions.

T2-weighted breathold imaging of the liver: a quantitative and qualitative comparison of fast spin echo and half Fourier single shot fast spin echo imaging

The imaging characteristics of two EPI-hybrid breath-hold sequences, T2-weighted fast spin-echo [FSE, effective echo time (TEeff) 138 ms] and half Fourier single shot turbo spin-echo (HASTE, TEeff 60 ms), were compared in hepatic imaging. A total of 111 patients with suspected hepatic disease were studied at 1.5 Tesla using a body phase-array coil. The signal-to-noise (S/N) and contrast-to-noise (C/N) ratios for organs and lesions were calculated and quantitatively compared. Organ delineation, visualization of anatomical structures and pathological lesions, artifacts, and total image quality were qualitatively assessed and statistically compared. The final diagnoses were metastases from colorectal, breast, and pancreatic cancer in 23/111, hepatocellular carcinoma in 15/111, cysts in 19/111, hemangiomas in 9/111, several other lesions in 7/111, and no lesions in 38/111 of the cases. A total of 139 lesion in 73% of the patients were seen while 85% of the lesions were at least 1.5 cm in size. Regarding S/Ns HASTE was significantly (P < 0.03) superior to FSE with only minor (P > 0.05) differences in C/Ns between the two sequences for anatomical and pathological structures. HASTE demonstrated in almost all (97.3%) of the cases no artifacts, while on fast SE imaging moderate to minor artifacts were present in 23.5-51.7% of the cases. The overall image quality and diagnostic confidence was rated significantly higher (good 43.2%, excellent 53.2%) for HASTE than for fast SE imaging (good 44.8%, excellent 17.6%). Providing comparable C/Ns for anatomical and pathological structures, breatheld HASTE imaging proved to be superior to fast SE in T2-weighted imaging of the upper abdomen regarding general image quality, and, with adequate technical prerequisites, may be a suitable substitute of fast T2-imaging techniques.

Hepatic T2-weighted MRI: a prospective comparison of sequences, including breath-hold, half-Fourier turbo spin echo (HASTE)

The purpose of this study was to quantitatively compare the hepatic contrast characteristics of conventional spin-echo (CSE) and fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences with breath-hold T2-weighted images acquired with half-Fourier turbo spin echo (HASTE). Forty-five patients were examined with a phased-array surface coil. Nineteen patients had focal hepatic lesions, including eight malignant tumors, 10 cavernous hemangiomas, and one hepatic adenoma. Twenty-six patients had no focal hepatic lesions. T2-weighted images with comparable TE were acquired with CSE, FSE, and HASTE pulse sequences. Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) for liver, spleen, and lesions were measured. FSE demonstrated significantly better quantitative performance than CSE for liver-spleen CNR (P .0084). No statistically significant difference was demonstrated between FSE and CSE for liver or spleen SNR. FSE demonstrated clear scan time and resolution advantages over CSE. HASTE performed significantly poorer than CSE and FSE for liver-spleen CNR (P < .0001), liver SNR (P = .0002 for CSE and P < .0001 for FSE), and spleen SNR (P < .0001). Optimized FSE images with a short echo train length performed comparably to CSE images of equivalent TE. Liver-lesion CNR was suppressed on HASTE images, suggesting that long echo train length FSE sequences could diminish solid lesion detection compared to CSE and short echo train length FSE.

Comparison of phased-array and body coils for MR imaging of liver

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES

To compare liver lesion conspicuity using torso phased-array (TPA) and body coils with two pulse sequences.

METHODS

Sixty patients with 125 focal hepatic lesions underwent T2-weighted fast spin-echo (T2-FSE) and fast multiplanar inversion recovery (FMPIR) imaging with a standard body coil and with a TPA coil. The first 30 patients were scanned identically in both coils with four acquisitions; the second 30 were scanned with four acquisitions in the body coil and two in the TPA coil.

RESULTS

Liver-lesion contrast-to-noise (C/N) was significantly higher for the TPA coil both with four acquisitions (P< 0.001) and with two acquisitions (P < 0.002) using FMPIR, compared to with four acquisitions in the body coil. Liver-lesion C/N for T2-FSE was equivalent in both coils. Liver-lesion C/N was significantly higher (P<0.01) for FMPIR than T2-FSE both in the body coil and in the TPA coil.

CONCLUSION

Liver-lesion C/N was significantly higher using the TPA coil rather than the body coil. Imaging time can be reduced by decreasing the number of acquisitions with the TPA coil.

Motion artifact in T2-weighted fast spin-echo images of the liver: effect on image contrast and reduction of artifact using respiratory triggering in normal volunteers

The purpose of our study was to evaluate the effect of respiratory motion on the image contrast of T2-weighted fast spin-echo (FSE) images of the liver as well as the reduction of motion artifact using respiratory triggering of the data acquisition. We imaged the livers of 10 healthy volunteers using a fast spin-echo T2-weighted sequence. Images were obtained both without and with patient triggering. Triggered images were acquired in a segmented fashion during multiple sequential breath-holds using an echo train of 8 or 16, both with and without flow compensation (gradient moment nulling). Ratios of signal difference to noise (SD/N) of the liver and gallbladder as well as the liver and spleen were compared for all sequences. All of the triggered images showed statistically significant improvement of SD/N for the liver and gallbladder as well as for the liver and spleen when compared with the nontriggered images. Triggered images obtained with an echo train length of 8 and, with flow compensation, showed the highest SD/N ratios. In one volunteer whose liver contained multiple small cysts, the triggered images showed improved visualization of individual cysts and identified a larger number of cysts. Respiratory motion causes a significant loss of contrast on T2-weighted fast spin-echo images of the liver. This can be reduced by using a segmented data acquisition triggered by the respiratory cycle obtained during sequential breath-holds.

T2-weighted MR imaging of the liver: optimization of hybrid-RARE sequences

The objectives of this study were to optimize T2-weighted hybrid-RARE pulse sequences for clinical MR imaging of the liver, and to compare them to the conventional spin-echo (CSE) sequence. Specifically, the ranges of the echo train length (ETL) and the effective echo time (TEeff) were investigated to optimize image quality and liver-spleen contrast, in healthy volunteers. A total of thirteen volunteers were scanned at 1.5 Tesla with an extensive array of hybrid-RARE scans. The images were analyzed quantitatively with respect to CNR (contrast-to-noise ratio of spleen vs. liver), SNR (signal to noise ratio of the spleen), SIR (signal intensity ratio of liver and spleen) and CDR (contrast difference ratio between the spleen and liver). The images were also analyzed qualitatively with respect to image sharpness, vascular artifacts, ghosting, chemical shift, and truncations. Results of quantitative analysis indicated that CDR and SIR of hybrid-RARE at higher ETL (> 13) were consistently better than both the reference CSE and the lower ETL sequences (p < 0.05) at all TEeff. SNR was slightly inferior for all hybrid-RARE sequences than for the CSE sequence. Image quality for hybrid-RARE sequences with ETL > 13 proved to be consistently better than that for the CSE (TE = 90 ms) with respect to imaging sharpness, vascular artifacts and ghosting artifacts (p < 0.05). In conclusion, the optimized hybrid-RARE sequences with ETL greater than or equal to 13 are capable of producing sharp and relatively artifact free images with the advantage of a much greater acquisition time efficiency.

Multisection T1-weighted hybrid-RARE: a pulse sequence for MR imaging of the entire liver during suspended respiration

It is shown that the maximum average-data-collection-speed (ADCS) of multisection 2D hybrid-RARE sequences is independent of TR and TEeff, and a monotonically increasing function of echo-train-length (ETL). This result was used in the design of an optimized T1-weighted hybrid-RARE sequence that produces 20 images of the abdomen in 31 s divided into four breath-hold periods. The resulting ADCS is 58 lines in k-space per second. Twenty-four subjects (2 healthy volunteers and 22 patients) were imaged with a protocol that also included: (a) breath-hold T1-weighted FLASH which acquires data at 34 lines in k-space per second (49 s scan time), and (b) T1-weighted conventional spin-echo (9:44 minutes scan time) with respiratory compensation. The experiments show that this T1-weighted-hybrid-RARE sequence has: (1) a level of T1 weighting that is comparable with the conventional sequences, (2) very low vulnerability to susceptibility artifacts, (3) high data acquisition efficiency, and (4) higher SNR than T1-weighted-FLASH. In conclusion, the T1-weighted-hybrid-RARE sequence described herein is an efficacious and reproducible technique for rapid imaging of the upper abdomen during suspended respiration.

Hepatic MR imaging: comparison of RARE derived sequences with conventional sequences for detection and characterization of focal liver lesions

BACKGROUND

We compared two T2-weighted turbo spin echo (TSE) sequences with a T2-weighted conventional SE (CSE) sequence to determine whether sequences derived from rapid acquisition with relaxation enhancement such as TSE could replace CSE for the detection and subsequent characterization of focal liver lesions.

METHODS

A total of 55 consecutive patients with 107 liver lesions underwent magnetic resonance imaging examinations at 1.5 Tesla, with a constant imaging protocol. TSE pulse sequences were acquired with eight echo trains (repetition time [TR], 4718 ms; echo time [TE], 90 ms; acquisition time [TA], 4.03 min; and a symmetric k-space ordering scheme) and 11 echo trains (TR, 4200 ms; TE, 140 ms; TA, 4.40 min; and an asymmetric k-space ordering scheme) and compared with CSE (TR, 2300 ms; TE, 45/90 ms; TA, 9.53 min). Images were analyzed qualitatively by scoring image quality and artifacts and counting focal liver lesions by independent reading with consensus obtained for discrepancies. Quantitative analysis was performed by measuring signal-to-noise (S/N), contrast-to-noise (C/N), and tumor-liver signal intensity (T/L) ratios.

RESULTS

T2-weighted TSE sequences provided better subjective image quality and reduced artifacts as compared with the T2-weighted CSE sequence. CSE and TSE sequences exhibited no statistically significant differences in liver S/N, lesion-liver C/N (CSE TE, 90 ms: 18.6 +/- 14.0; TSE TE, 90 ms: 16.5 +/- 12.9) and the detectability of focal liver lesions. Heavily T2-weighted TSE with a TE of 140 ms allowed correct characterization of focal liver lesions based on a T/L ratio of 3.0 in 84% of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

T2-weighted TSE sequences are as suited as CSE for the detection (TE, 90 ms), and appear to be superior for the characterization (TE, 140 ms), of focal hepatic lesions. Whether a single sequence, such as a double-echo TSE or a single-echo TSE sequence with a TE between 110 and 120 ms, might perform both functions as well or better than CSE is unknown. However, because of time savings, TSE eventually may be preferred over CSE.

Comparison of single-breath-hold fast spin-echo sequences with routine non-breath-hold techniques: application to MRI of renal masses

In 24 patients presenting with 55 renal lesions (mean size, 20.8 mm), single-breath-hold (SBH) fast spin-echo (FSE) techniques allowing T1 and T2 images to be produced within 20 and 23 sec, respectively, were compared with routine non-breath-hold (NBH) spin-echo (SE) T1 and NBH-FSE T2 sequences. Contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) measured from SBH-FSE T1 images were an average of 97% higher than their NBH counterparts (P = .0001) and allowed an improved lesion conspicuity in 80% of the cases (P = 0.0001). For T2 imaging, SBH-FSE and NBH-FSE sequences were not statistically different with respect to lesion conspicuity (P = .55) and CNR values (P = .19). This was observed despite a 35% average decrease in CNR of SBH-FSE compared to NBH-FSE images. By reducing respiratory motion artifacts while preserving SE-like image contrast, SBH-FSE techniques have the potential to replace routine NBH sequences for an optimal diagnosis of renal masses.

MRI in characterization of focal liver lesions: comparison of T2 weighting by conventional spin-echo and turbo spin-echo sequences

Forty-one patients with 61 proved focal liver lesions underwent MRI of the liver at 1.0 T, with the aim of evaluating the usefulness of turbo spin-echo (TSE) sequences in characterizing focal liver lesions, by comparing them with conventional spin-echo (CSE) sequences. Two different TSE protocols were employed. with constant echo time and varying repetition time: TSE-S (3000 msec) and TSE-L (5100 msec). All images were evaluated quantitatively (signal-to-noise ration 'SNR') and qualitatively: because benign lesions were all liquid (12 cysts and 10 hemangiomas), they were well characterized morphologically on the basis of signal intensity. Mean SNR was significantly different between metastases and benign lesions (P < .0001) with all T2 sequences. Among the single T2 sequences tested, logistic regression analysis showed TSE-L to have the best predictive ability of the nature of focal lesions, with a G value of 42.02, compared to 29.87 of TSE-S and 25.55 of CSE second echo (SE II). The combination of TSE-L with TSE-S did not modify these results, whereas the combination of TSE-L with CSE only resulted in slight improvement (G = 46.95). Comparison of the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves showed only SE II (area under the ROC curve of .8312) to be significantly inferior to the best single sequence, or TSE-L (area under the ROC curve of .9176; P = .027). All sequences were equivalent in qualitative evaluation with good reproducibility, sensitivity ranging from .94 to 1.0 and specificity ranging from .86 to .93. This study confirms the value of TSE sequences in characterization of focal liver lesions. Time of acquisition is strongly reduced with these sequences, whereas results are fairly similar to those obtained with CSE. TSE sequences could therefore replace CSE for the study of focal liver lesions.