Preparing to read the ubiquitin code: characterization of ubiquitin trimers by top-down mass spectrometry

Characterization of Unbranched Ubiquitin Tetramers by Combining Ultraviolet Photodissociation with Proton Transfer Charge Reduction Reactions

Polyubiquitination is an important post-translational modification (PTM) that regulates various biological functions. The linkage sites and topologies of polyubiquitination chains are important factors in determining the fate of polyubiquitinated proteins. Characterization of polyubiquitin chains is the first step in understanding the biological functions of protein ubiquitination, but it is challenging owing to the repeating nature of the ubiquitin chains and the difficulty in deciphering linkage positions. Here, we combine ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) mass spectrometry and gas-phase proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR) to facilitate the assignment of product ions generated from Lys6-, Lys11-, Lys29-, Lys33-, Lys48-, and Lys63-linked ubiquitin tetramers. UVPD results in extensive fragmentation of intact proteins in a manner that allows the localization of PTMs. However, UVPD mass spectra of large proteins (>30 kDa) are often congested due to the overlapping isotopic distribution of highly charged fragment ions. UVPD + PTCR improved the identification of PTM-containing fragment ions, allowing the localization of linkage sites in all six tetramers analyzed. UVPD + PTCR also increased the sequence coverage obtained from the PTM-containing fragment ions in each of the four chains of each tetramer by 7 to 44% when compared to UVPD alone.

Analysis of the topology of ubiquitin chains

The small protein ubiquitin and its multiple polymers are encountered free in cells and as post-translational modifications on all proteins. Different polyubiquitin three dimensional structures are shown to correlate uniquely with different cellular functions as part of the diverse ubiquitin signaling. At the same time, this multiplicity of structures provides serious challenges to the analytical biochemist. Globally applicable strategies are presented here for the analyses of polyubiquitins and of ubiquitinated proteins, which take advantage of the speed, specificity and sensitivity of top-down tandem mass spectrometry. Particular attention is given to the supervised interpretation of fragmentation as revealed in the MS/MS spectra of these branched proteins. The strategy is compatible with any MS activation technology, is applicable to all polyubiquitin linkage and chain types, can be extended to ubiquitin-like proteins, and will be compatible with and enhanced by continuing advances in LC-MS/MS instrumentation and interpretation software.

Top-down analysis of novel synthetic branched proteins

A strategy for top-down analysis of branched proteins has been reported earlier, which relies on electron transfer dissociation assisted by collisional activation, and software designed for graphic interpretation of tandem mass spectra and adapted for branched proteins. In the present study, the strategy is applied to identify unknown and novel products of reactions in which rationally mutated proteoforms of Rub1 are used to probe the selectivity of E1 and E2 enzymes normally active in ubiquitination. To test and demonstrate this application, components and attachment sites of three branched dimers are deduced and the mutations are confirmed.

Top-Down Analysis of Branched Proteins Using Mass Spectrometry

Post-translational modifications by the covalent attachment of Rub1 (NEDD8), ubiquitin, SUMO, and other small signaling proteins have profound impacts on the functions and fates of cellular proteins. Investigations of the relationship of these bioactive structures and their functions are limited by analytical methods that are scarce and tedious. A novel strategy is reported here for the analysis of branched proteins by top-down mass spectrometry and illustrated by application to four recombinant proteins and one synthetic peptide modified by covalent bonds with ubiquitin or Rub1. The approach allows an analyte to be recognized as a branched protein; the participating proteins to be identified; the site of conjugation to be defined; and other chemical, native, and recombinant modifications to be characterized. In addition to the high resolution and high accuracy provided by the mass spectrometer, success is based on sample fragmentation by electron-transfer dissociation assisted by collisional activation and on software designed for graphic interpretation and adapted for branched proteins. The strategy allows for structures of unknown, two-component branched proteins to be elucidated directly the first time and can potentially be extended to more complex systems.

The Ups and Downs of Repeated Cleavage and Internal Fragment Production in Top-Down Proteomics

Analysis of whole proteins by mass spectrometry, or top-down proteomics, has several advantages over methods relying on proteolysis. For example, proteoforms can be unambiguously identified and examined. However, from a gas-phase ion-chemistry perspective, proteins are enormous molecules that present novel challenges relative to peptide analysis. Herein, the statistics of cleaving the peptide backbone multiple times are examined to evaluate the inherent propensity for generating internal versus terminal ions. The raw statistics reveal an inherent bias favoring production of terminal ions, which holds true regardless of protein size. Importantly, even if the full suite of internal ions is generated by statistical dissociation, terminal ions are predicted to account for at least 50% of the total ion current, regardless of protein size, if there are three backbone dissociations or fewer. Top-down analysis should therefore be a viable approach for examining proteins of significant size. Comparison of the purely statistical analysis with actual top-down data derived from ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) and higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) reveals that terminal ions account for much of the total ion current in both experiments. Terminal ion production is more favored in UVPD relative to HCD, which is likely due to differences in the mechanisms controlling fragmentation. Importantly, internal ions are not found to dominate from either the theoretical or experimental point of view. Graphical abstract ᅟ.

Ubiquitin Chain Enrichment Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry Enables Characterization of Branched Ubiquitin Chains in Cellulo

Ubiquitin (Ub) has a broad functional range that has been ascribed to the formation of an array of polymeric ubiquitin chains. Understanding the precise roles of ubiquitin chains, however, is difficult due to their complex chain topologies. Branched ubiquitin chains are particularly challenging, as multiple modifications on a single ubiquitin preclude the use of standard bottom-up proteomic approaches. Developing methods to overcome these challenges is crucial considering evidence suggesting branched chains regulate the stability of proteins. In this study, we employ Ubiquitin Chain Enrichment Middle-down Mass Spectrometry (UbiChEM-MS) to identify branched chains that cannot be detected using bottom-up proteomic methods. Specifically, we employ tandem ubiquitin binding entities (TUBEs) and the K29-selective Npl4 Zinc Finger 1 (NZF1) domain from the deubiquitinase TRABID to enrich for chains from human cells. Minimal trypsinolysis followed by high resolution mass spectrometric analysis reveals that Ub chain branching can indeed be detected using both Ub binding domains (UBDs) tested at endogenous levels. We find that ∼1% of chains isolated with TUBEs contain Ub branch points, with this value rising to ∼4% after proteasome inhibition. Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) analysis indicates the presence of K48 in these branched chains. The use of the NZF1 domain reveals that ∼4% of the isolated chains contain branch points with no apparent dependence on proteasome inhibition. Our results demonstrate an effective strategy for detecting and characterizing the dynamics of branched conjugates under different cellular conditions.

Seven perspectives on GPCR H/D-exchange proteomics methods

Recent research shows surging interest to visualize human G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) dynamic structures using the bottom-up H/D-exchange (HDX) proteomics technology. This opinion article clarifies critical technical nuances and logical thinking behind the GPCR HDX proteomics method, to help scientists overcome cross-discipline pitfalls, and understand and reproduce the protocol at high quality. The 2010 89% HDX structural coverage of GPCR was achieved with both structural and analytical rigor. This article emphasizes systematically considering membrane protein structure stability and compatibility with chromatography and mass spectrometry (MS) throughout the pipeline, including the effects of metal ions, zero-detergent shock, and freeze-thaws on HDX result rigor. This article proposes to view bottom-up HDX as two steps to guide choices of detergent buffers and chromatography settings: (I) protein HDX labeling in native buffers, and (II) peptide-centric analysis of HDX labels, which applies (a) bottom-up MS/MS to construct peptide matrix and (b) HDX MS to locate and quantify H/D labels. The detergent-low-TCEP digestion method demystified the challenge of HDX-grade GPCR digestion. GPCR HDX proteomics is a structural approach, thus its choice of experimental conditions should let structure lead and digestion follow, not the opposite.

Preparing to read the ubiquitin code: top-down analysis of unanchored ubiquitin tetramers

The characterization of polyubiquitin chains has been an analytical challenge for several decades. It has been shown that anchored and unanchored polyubiquitin chains with different isopeptide linkages and lengths exhibit a wide range of profoundly different cellular functions. However, structure function studies have been hindered by the difficulty of characterizing these complex chain structures. This report presents a broadly applicable workflow to characterize ubiquitin tetramers without the need for genetic mutations or reiterative immunoprecipitations. We use a top-down proteomic strategy that exploits ETciD activation on an orbitrap Fusion Lumos and manual interpretation aided by graphical interpretation of mass shifts to facilitate characterization of chain topography and lysine linkage sites. Our workflow differentiates all topological features of the numerous isomers of tetraubiquitin, which have molecular masses in excess of 34 000 Da and identifies linkage sites in these branched proteins. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.