Digital mass filter analysis in stability zones A and B

Digital Ion Trap Isolation and Mass Analysis of Macromolecular Analytes with Multiply Charged Ion Attachment

Multiply charged ions produced by electrospray ionization (ESI) of heterogeneous mixtures of macromolecular analytes under native conditions are typically confined to relatively narrow ranges of mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio, often with extensive overlap. This scenario makes charge and mass assignments extremely challenging, particularly when individual charge states are unresolved. An ion/ion reaction strategy involving multiply charged ion attachment (MIA) to the mixture components in a narrow range of m/z can facilitate charge and mass assignment. In MIA operation, multiply charged reagent ions are attached to the analyte ions of opposite polarity to provide large m/z displacements resulting from both large changes in mass and charge. However, charge reduction of the high m/z ions initially generated under native ESI conditions requires the ability to isolate high m/z ions and to analyze even higher m/z product ions. Digital ion trap (DIT) operation offers means for both high m/z ion isolation and high m/z mass analysis, in addition to providing conditions for the reaction of oppositely charged ions. The feasibility of conducting MIA experiments in a DIT that takes advantage of high m/z ion operation is demonstrated here using a tandem 2D-3D DIT instrument. Proof-of-concept MIA experiments with cations derived from β-galactosidase using the 20- charge state of human serum immunoglobulin G (IgG, ∼149 kDa) as the reagent anion are described. MIA experiments involving mixtures of ions derived from the E. coli. ribosome are also described. For example, three components in a mixture of 70S particles (>2.2 MDa) were resolved and assigned with masses and charges following an MIA experiment involving the 20- charge state of human serum IgG.

Single-Frequency Ion Parking in a Digital 3D Quadrupole Ion Trap

Single-frequency ion parking, a useful technique in electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), involves gas-phase charge-reduction ion/ion reactions in an electrodynamic ion trap in conjunction with the application of a supplementary oscillatory voltage to selectively inhibit the reaction rate of an ion of interest. The ion parking process provides a means for limiting the extent of charge reduction in a controlled fashion and allows for ions distributed over a range of charge states to be concentrated into fewer charge states (a single charge state under optimal conditions). As charge reduction inherently leads to an increase in the mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio of the ions, it is important that the means for storing and analyzing ions be able to accommodate ions of high m/z ratios. The so-called 'digital ion trap' (DIT), which uses a digital waveform as the trapping RF, has been demonstrated to be well-suited for the analysis of high m/z ions by taking advantage of its ability to manipulate the waveform frequency. In this study, the feasibility of ion parking in a 3D quadrupole ion trap operated as a DIT using a slow-amplitude single-frequency sine-wave for selective inhibition of an ion/ion reaction is demonstrated. A recently described model that describes ion parking has been adjusted for the DIT case and is used to interpret experimental data for proteins ranging in mass from 8600 Da to 467,000 Da.

Experimental Investigation of a Digital Quadrupole Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer for Elemental Analysis

We describe the development and initial characterization of a digital waveform scanning quadrupole mass filter (digital QMF) used for inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Unlike a conventional voltage scanning QMF, in the digital QMF, the frequency of the digital waveform is scanned to filter ions with different m/z through the quadrupole, and m/z is proportional to 1/f2. In digital QMF, the duty cycle of the digital waveform driving the quadrupole is modified such that stability regions of interest are accessible for mass analysis with no DC voltage applied. Here, we evaluate the performance of our digital ICP-QMS instrument at several duty cycles and corresponding stability zones: from zone 1 to zone 3,2. We demonstrate that, regardless of the stability zone used, frequency vs m/z calibration matches theory. For lower-order stability zones, the mass range of the analyzer is limited by the high-frequency waveform required; however, at zone 3,2, we demonstrate a mass range from at least 40 to 232 Th, which covers most of the elemental mass range. Similar to the conventional QMF, higher stability regions of the digital QMF can yield a higher resolution. We obtained the best resolution for our current instrument at zone 3,2 with a 62.50/37.50 duty cycle. The resolution at full-width at 10% peak height (R10%) was 1200 and 1100 for 115In+ and 232Th+, respectively. Lower pole bias yielded a R10% of 1400 for 40Ar+. Resolution and sensitivity comparisons indicate that higher q values and higher duty cycles lead to enhanced resolution, but lower sensitivity. Our results validate the operation of digital quadrupole ICP-MS and suggest that, with continuous improvement of electronics and instrumentation, a high resolution digital waveform scanning ICP-QMS for elemental analysis is possible.

Experimental Evaluation of Higher Order Stability Zones Using a Digitally Operated Quadrupole Mass Filter

Recent improvements to the comparison-based method of digital waveform generation increased the reproducibility of the waveforms so that the higher-order Mathieu stability zones can be accessed reliably. Digitally driven quadrupole mass filters access these zones using a fixed AC voltage and rectangular waveforms that are defined by a duty cycle. In this context, the duty cycle is the fraction of the waveform period where the waveform remains in the high state. Because digitally driven quadrupoles navigate stability using a duty cycle, there is no need to apply a resolving DC offset between electrode pairs. Accessing the higher stability zones using a conventional resonantly tuned RF requires the use of thousands of AC and DC voltages making the mode of operation less accessible with these devices. Stability zones higher than (1,1) and (2,1) have theoretical resolving powers that are on the order 1,140 and 3,447 at fwhm which drives efforts to practically access these operational conditions. Accessing these zones digitally requires the use of extremely precise waveforms. In a previous effort, waveform generation produced waveforms to reliably access the (1,1) and (2,1) zones without impacting performance. However, recent work found more improvement was needed to reliably access neighboring higher stability zones. Derived from that work, it was determined that a waveform resolution of ∼10 ppm or less was needed to reliably access the (3,1) and (3,2) zones. The present work utilized digital waveforms that achieve this level of precision to experimentally access and characterize attributes of the (3,1) and (3,2) zones. This work dives into the investigation of different beam energies to overcome the destabilizing fringing fields, improve transmission, and their overall effect on the experimental resolving power and signal-to-noise. In addition, the AC voltage of the driving RF was varied to understand the effects on the initial ion beam energy that is needed to achieve balanced separation and how the overall signal-to-noise is affected. Lastly, an assessment was made on the effects of the temporal parameters of a digital mass scan on peak sensitivity, peak fidelity, and overall duration for a scan.

Portable Instrumentation for Ambient Ionization and Miniature Mass Spectrometers

We critically evaluate the current status of portable mass spectrometry (pMS), particularly where this aligns with ambient ionization. Assessing the field of pMS can be quite subjective, especially in relation to the portable aspects of design, deployment, and operation. In this review, we discuss what it means to be portable and introduce a set of criteria by which pMS and ambient ionization sources can be assessed. Moreover, we consider the recent literature in terms of the most popular and significant advances in portable instrumentation for ambient ionization and miniature mass spectrometers. Finally, emerging trends and exciting future prospects are discussed and some recommendations are offered.

Increasing Isolation Efficiency Using a Segmented Quadrupole Mass Filter Operated with Rectangular Waveforms

The performance of a segmented quadrupole mass filter operated with rectangular waveforms and capacitively coupled rectangular waveforms applied to the prefilters was examined on a home-built quadrupole-Orbitrap platform. For peak widths of 50 m/z, 100% isolation efficiency was achieved, which fell to approximately 20% for 5 m/z peak width for a rectangular waveform of 150 V0-p. Due to a small exit aperture following the mass filter, peak structure was observed in both experimental peak shapes and those simulated using SIMION. A larger radius quadrupole was examined and achieved similar performance. While the segmented quadrupole does remove the defocusing effects of the fringing fields, the ion beam is only slightly refocused due to the low RF voltage which limits achievable gains in isolation efficiency.

Tandem Mass-Selective Cryogenic Digital Ion Traps for Enhanced Cluster Formation

We present the implementation of tandem mass-selective cryogenic ion traps, designed to enhance the range of ion processing capabilities that can be performed prior to spectroscopic interrogation. We show that both the formation of ion clusters and mass filtering steps can be combined in a single cryogenic linear quadrupole ion trap driven by RF square waves. Mass filtering and mass isolation can be achieved by manipulation of the RF frequency and duty cycle. Very importantly, this scheme circumvents the need for high-amplitude RF voltages that can be incompatible with typical cryogenic ion processing conditions. In addition, proper adjustment of the stability boundaries during the clustering process allows for the preferential formation of a specific cluster size rather than a broad distribution of sizes. Lastly, we show that a specific cluster size can be formed, mass-selected, and then transferred to another ion trap for a second completely separate ion processing step. The instrumentation and modular design developed here expand the scope of ionic species and clusters that can be accessed by processing electrosprayed ions.

Digital Quadrupole Isolation and Electron Capture Dissociation on an Extended Mass Range Q-TOF Provides Sequence and Structure Information on Proteins and Protein Complexes

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) is now a well-established method for sequencing peptides and performing top-down analysis on proteins of less than 30 kDa, and there is growing interest in using this approach for studies of larger proteins and protein complexes. Although much progress on ECD has been made over the past few decades, establishing methods for obtaining informative spectra still poses a significant challenge. Here we describe how digital quadrupole (DigiQ) ion isolation can be used for the mass selection of single charge states of proteins and protein complexes prior to undergoing ECD and/or charge reduction. First, we demonstrate that the DigiQ can isolate single charge states of monomeric proteins such as ubiquitin (8.6 kDa) and charge states of large protein complexes such as pyruvate kinase (234 kDa) using a hybrid quadrupole-TOF-MS (Agilent extended m/z range 6545XT). Next, we demonstrate that fragment ions resulting from ECD can be utilized to provide information about the sequence and structure of the cytochrome c/heme complex and the ubiquitin monomer. Lastly, an especially interesting result for DigiQ isolation and electron capture (EC) was noted; namely, the 16+ charge state of the streptavidin/biotin complex reveals different electron capture patterns for the biotinylated proteoforms of streptavidin. This result is consistent with previous reports that apo streptavidin exists in multiple conformations and that biotin binding shifts the conformational dynamics of the complex (Quintyn, R. Chem. Biol. 2015, 22 (55), 583-592).

Optimization of a Digital Mass Filter for the Isolation of Intact Protein Complexes in Stability Zone 1,1

Digital mass filters are advantageous for the analysis of large molecules due to the ability to perform ion isolation of high-m/z ions without the generation of very high radio frequency (RF) and DC voltages. Experimentally determined Mathieu stability diagrams of stability zone 1,1 for capacitively coupled digital waveforms show a voltage offset between the quadrupole rod pairs is introduced by the capacitors which is dependent on the voltage magnitude of the waveform and the duty cycle. This changes the ion's a value from a = 0 to a < 0. These effects are illustrated for isolation for single-charge states for various protein complexes up to 800 kDa (GroEL) for stability zone 1,1. Isolation resolving power (m/Δm) of approximately 280 was achieved for an ion of m/z 12,315 (z = 65+ for 800.5 kDa GroEL D398A), which corresponds to an m/z window of 44.

Experimental Validation of the Digital Tandem Mass Filter

This work presents the experimental evaluation of a digital tandem mass filter that is composed of two digitally operated low-resolution mass filters in series whose mass windows are shifted with respect to each other. The overlap of the mass windows allows the resolution (Δm) of ions to be narrowed to provide better resolving power, while the acceptance of the tandem mass filter is defined by the acceptance of the first low-resolution quadrupole. Our experiments show that digital operation fulfills the promise of the tandem mass filter for providing better ion transmission at the same or better resolving power as a single quadrupole mass filter. It allows the user to continuously adjust the resolving power and sensitivity to meet current needs. Most importantly, the observed resolving power/sensitivity characteristics are the same at any mass and m/z.

Navigate Flying Molecular Elephants Safely to the Ground: Mass-Selective Soft Landing up to the Mega-Dalton Range by Electrospray Controlled Ion-Beam Deposition

The prototype of a highly versatile and efficient preparative mass spectrometry system used for the deposition of molecules in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) is presented, along with encouraging performance data obtained using four model species that are thermolabile or not sublimable. The test panel comprises two small organic compounds, a small and very large protein, and a large DNA species covering a 4-log mass range up to 1.7 MDa as part of a broad spectrum of analyte species evaluated to date. Three designs of innovative ion guides, a novel digital mass-selective quadrupole (dQMF), and a standard electrospray ionization (ESI) source are combined to an integrated device, abbreviated electrospray controlled ion-beam deposition (ES-CIBD). Full control is achieved by (i) the square-wave-driven radiofrequency (RF) ion guides with steadily tunable frequencies, including a dQMF allowing for investigation, purification, and deposition of a virtually unlimited m/z range, (ii) the adjustable landing energy of ions down to ∼2 eV/z enabling integrity-preserving soft landing, (iii) the deposition in UHV with high ion beam intensity (up to 3 nA) limiting contaminations and deposition time, and (iv) direct coverage control via the deposited charge. The maximum resolution of R = 650 and overall efficiency up to T_total = 4.4% calculated from the solution to UHV deposition are advantageous, whereby the latter can be further enhanced by optimizing ionization performance. In the setup presented, a scanning tunneling microscope (STM) is attached for in situ UHV investigations of deposited species, demonstrating a selective, structure-preserving process and atomically clean layers.

Implementing Digital-Waveform Technology for Extended m/z Range Operation on a Native Dual-Quadrupole FT-IM-Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

Here, we describe a digital-waveform dual-quadrupole mass spectrometer that enhances the performance of our drift tube FT-IMS high-resolution Orbitrap mass spectrometer (MS). The dual-quadrupole analyzer enhances the instrument capabilities for studies of large protein and protein complexes. The first quadrupole (q) provides a means for performing low-energy collisional activation of ions to reduce or eliminate noncovalent adducts, viz., salts, buffers, detergents, and/or endogenous ligands. The second quadrupole (Q) is used to mass-select ions of interest for further interrogation by ion mobility spectrometry and/or collision-induced dissociation (CID). Q is operated using digital-waveform technology (DWT) to improve the mass selection compared to that achieved using traditional sinusoidal waveforms at floated DC potentials (>500 V DC). DWT allows for increased precision of the waveform for a fraction of the cost of conventional RF drivers and with readily programmable operation and precision (Hoffman, N. M. . A comparison-based digital-waveform generator for high-resolution duty cycle. Review of Scientific Instruments 2018, 89, 084101).

Will the Digital Mass Filter Be the Next High-Resolution High-Mass Analyzer?

Mass filter operation in higher stability zones is known to provide better resolution. Unfortunately, for sine driven instruments, higher stability zone operation reduces the accessible mass range and increases the degenerative effects of fringe fields. Conversely, digitally driven mass filters do not suffer from loss of mass range, and the fringe field effects do not increase significantly by switching stability zones because the AC voltage is always constant and the DC voltage is always zero. This work catalogues 12 stability zones that are accessible with the new digital waveform generation technology. These zones have theoretical baseline resolving powers that range from 22 to 1 300 000 with pseudopotential well depths that range from 3.5 to 43 V. Operation in higher stability zones also has the advantage of aligned axial stability wells. That alignment maximizes the pseudopotential well depth for each higher stability zone, making them more than an order of magnitude greater than the standard ∼0.2 V well of a sine filter operating in the first stability zone at unit resolution. Increased pseudopotential well depth correlates with better ion transmission and sensitivity. Our theoretical examination suggests that the digital mass filter can obtain both high resolution and high sensitivity with essentially unlimited mass range.

Computational evaluation of a new digital tandem quadrupole mass filter

A tandem mass filter consists of two low-resolution mass filters arranged in series that operate with a small offset between their mass windows. In principle, the overlap of the two individual mass windows defines the tandem window. Tandem operation provides improved resolution and transmission compared to a single mass filter operated with the same mass window. The improvement in transmission is owed to the larger acceptance of the low-resolution quadrupoles. The tandem filter resolution and transmission are adjusted by changing the amount of offset separating the mass windows of the individual filters. Sine wave systems create this offset through voltage changes. Digital tandem mass filters depart from convention because they do not change voltage. The tandem mass window is created when the individual filters are operated with two slightly different duty cycles. Both quadrupoles operate at the same frequency, phase, and voltage. When the frequency, phase, and voltage of each quadrupole are identical, there theoretically are no changes to the Mathieu parameters to cause ion excitation and loss during transition between the quadrupole pair. The work presented here shows that a fixed AC voltage digital tandem mass filter can only operate in higher stability zones. However, unlike sine mass filters, the mass range of a digital system is not limited. This makes the digital tandem mass filter feasible as a commercial product. For the tandem digital mode to be successful, the duty cycles of each quadrupole must be precisely controlled because the duty cycle differences required to shift the mass windows are small. The creation of these mass window offsets requires waveform generation that can obtain high duty cycle resolution. Our method of generating waveforms can meet this demand; however, modifications to our current printed circuit board must be made. These modifications are minor and will be discussed.

Computational evaluation of mass filter acceptance and transmittance influenced by developing fields: An application of the plane method to investigate prefilter efficacy for rectangular wave operated mass filters

The acceptance of quadrupole mass filters is improved when the alternating current (AC) and direct current (DC) fields are developed separately. Physically, this is achieved when a short RF only quadrupole (prefilter) is situated directly ahead of the mass filter. The acceptance gained by a system operating with a prefilter can be observed as an increase in sensitivity over conventional operation. Frequency dynamic duty cycle based rectangular waveform driven (rectangular wave) mass filters, a recent development, currently do not operate with prefilters. Little is known about the influence of duty cycle changes on the acceptance of rectangular wave mass filters. The sensitivity gain seen by conventional systems operating with prefilters indicates that the sensitivity of duty cycle based rectangular wave systems should increase comparably. The objective of this work was to determine prefilter efficacy for nonspecific rectangular wave mass filter systems. In this work, the plane method of acceptance was used to model the change to the acceptance and transmittance of sine and rectangular waveform driven mass filters under different modes of field development. Both systems indicated a fourfold increase in sensitivity when the mass filtering DC or duty cycle was delayed.

Stable X-islands of quadrupole mass filter

Quadrupole mass filters are normally operated as narrow band pass filters by appropriate choices of rf and DC voltages corresponding to Mathieu a and q values near the apex of the first stability region. We add an auxiliary quadrupole excitation potential to the main drive voltage. As a result, stability islands appear on the (a,q) plane. The method of the islands mapping on the (a,q) plane is discussed in detail. The DC electric field's effect responsible for removing "shadowing" islands has been studied using a combination of analytic theory and computer modeling. We call a narrow stability region elongated along an iso-βx line an X-island. Two such stability islands were found where operation is possible without mass spectra interference when the DC potential is used. Those islands are formed by quadrupole potentials with relative excitation frequencies ν=β,ν=1±β and ν=2±β, where β << 1. Many other stability X-islands are presented in detail and illustrated by their transmission contours. This data is necessary for experimental testing of the separation mode at those islands. The study demonstrates how to use X-islands to achieve relatively high resolution 4000-12,000 at the transmission of about 28-15%, respectively.

Tutorial and comprehensive computational study of acceptance and transmission of sinusoidal and digital ion guides

A quadrupoles acceptance is a measure of its ability to catch ions with certain trajectories. One way to calculate acceptance is the method of ellipses. The method arose partly from a simplification that trajectories could be calculated for an electrode axis independently of others. It has been used to calculate the acceptance and transmission of sine-driven quadrupole mass filters for over 50 years. Although the method is straightforward, it is generally described with little detail or presented as a confusing string of equations. As such, it may not be decipherable by all practitioners. For this reason, the first half of this paper presents a practical explanation of the method of ellipses and the concepts that make it work. Only equations necessary to describe the method are introduced. The tutorial also prepares the reader for the second half, which presents an alternative approach for calculating acceptance based on an array of initial trajectories. The alternative approach is used to compare the acceptance of simplified sinusoidal and digital ion guides. The method of ellipses was applied to validate results of the new approach for calculation of acceptance.