Miniature endplate potentials induced by ammonium chloride, hypertonic shock, and botulinum toxin

Presynaptic quantal plasticity: Katz's original hypothesis revisited

Changes in the amplitudes of signals conveyed at synaptic contacts between neurons underlie many brain functions and pathologies. Here we review the possible determinants of the amplitude and plasticity of the elementary postsynaptic signal, the miniature. In the absence of a definite understanding of the molecular mechanism releasing transmitters, we investigated a possible alternative interpretation. Classically, both the quantal theory and the vesicle theory predict that the amount of transmitter producing a miniature is determined presynaptically prior to release and that rapid changes in miniature amplitude reflect essentially postsynaptic alterations. However, recent data indicates that short-term and long-lasting changes in miniature amplitude are in large part due to changes in the amount of transmitter in individual released packets that show no evidence of preformation. Current representations of transmitter release derive from basic properties of neuromuscular transmission and endocrine secretion. Reexamination of overlooked properties of these two systems indicate that the amplitude of miniatures may depend as much, if not more, on the Ca(2+) signals in the presynaptic terminal than on the number of postsynaptic receptors available or on vesicle's contents. Rapid recycling of transmitter and its possible adsorption at plasma and vesicle lumenal membrane surfaces suggest that exocytosis may reflect membrane traffic rather than actual transmitter release. This led us to reconsider the disregarded hypothesis introduced by Fatt and Katz (1952; J Physiol 117:109-128) that the excitability of the release site may account for the "quantal effect" in fast synaptic transmission. In this case, changes in excitability of release sites would contribute to the presynaptic quantal plasticity that is often recorded.

Porocytosis: a new approach to synaptic function

We propose a new approach to address the question of how a single quantum of neurotransmitter is secreted from a presynaptic terminal whose clustered secretory vesicles are locally bathed in high levels of calcium ions [Proceedings of the Symposium on Bioelectrogenesis (1961) 297-309; The Physiology of Synapses (1964) Chapters 1, 4, 5, 6; How the Self Controls its Brain (1994) Chapters 1, 4, 5, 6; Science 256 (1992) 677-679]. This hypothesis, which we term 'porocytosis', posits that the post-synaptic quantal response results from transmitter secreted through an array of docked vesicle/secretory pore complexes. The transient increase in calcium ions, which results from the voltage activated calcium channels, stimulates the array of secretory pores to simultaneously flicker open to pulse transmitter. Porocytosis is consistent with the quantal nature of presynaptic secretion and transmission, and with available biochemical, morphological and physiological evidence. It explains the frequency dependency of quantal size as a function of the secretion process. It permits a signature amount of transmitter release for different frequencies allowing a given synapse to be employed in different behavioral responses. The porocytosis hypothesis permits fidelity of secretion and the seemingly apposed characteristic of synaptic plasticity. The dynamics inherent in an array insure a constant quantal size as a function of the number of units within the array. In this hypothesis, plasticity is a consequence of concurrent pre- and post-synaptic changes due to a change in array size. Changes in the number of docked vesicle-secretory pore complexes composing the array can explain facilitation, depletion, graded excitation-secretion and long term plasticity.

Surface-accessible GABA supports tonic and quantal synaptic transmission

Exocytosis is commonly viewed as the only secretory process able to account for quantal forms of fast synaptic transmission. However, the demonstrated variability and composite properties of miniature postsynaptic signals are not easily explained by all-or-none exocytotic discharge of transmitter in solution from inside vesicles. Recent studies of endocrine secretion have shown that hormone release does not coincide with exocytosis due to its trapping in the core matrix of the granule. Thus, we tested whether the synaptic transmitter GABA could also be held in a matrix before being released. Using confocal microscopy and flow cytometry of embryonic rat hippocampal neurons, we found a GABA immunoreaction at the surface of live cell bodies and growth cones that coincided spatially and quantitatively with the binding of tetanus toxin fragment C (TTFC). TTFC binds predominantly at membrane sites containing the trisialoglycosphingolipid GT1b. Using flow cytometry, GT1b-containing liposomes preincubated in 100 nM GABA exhibited the same relationship between GABA and TTFC surface binding as found on neurons and growth cones. Embryonic neurons differentiated in culture expressed initially a tonic, and after 3-5 days, transient, postsynaptic signals mediated by GABA acting at GABA(A) receptor/Cl(-) channels. A stream of saline applied to the neuronal surface rapidly and reversibly suppressed both tonic and transient signals. A brief application of the GABAmimetic isoguvacine immediately transformed both tonic and transient GABAergic signals into tonic and transient isoguvacinergic signals. These results and those in the literature are consistent with an immediately releasable compartment of transmitter accessible from the presynaptic surface.

Miniature EPSPs and sensory encoding in the primary afferents of the vestibular lagena of the toadfish, Opsanus tau

The synaptic activity transmitted from vestibular hair cells of the lagena to primary afferent neurons was recorded in vitro using sharp, intracellular microelectrodes. At rest, the activity was composed of miniature excitatory postsynaptic potentials (mEPSPs) at frequencies from 5 to 20/s and action potentials (APs) at frequencies betwen 0 and 10/s. mEPSPs recorded from a single fiber displayed a large variability. For mEPSPs not triggering APs, amplitudes exhibited an average coefficient of variance (CV) of 0.323 and rise times an average CV of 0.516. APs were only triggered by mEPSPs with larger amplitudes (estimated 4-6 mV) and/or steeper maximum rate of rise (10.9 mV/ms, +/- 3.7 SD, n=4 experiments) compared to (3.50 mV/ms, +/-0.07 SD, n=6 experiments) for nontriggering mEPSPs. The smallest mEPSPs showed a fast rise time (0.99 ms between 10% and 90% of peak amplitude) and limited variability across fibers (CV:0.18) confirming that they were not attenuated signals, but rather represented single-transmitter discharges (TDs). The mEPSP amplitude and rise-time relationship suggests that many mEPSPs represented several, rather than a single pulse of secretion of TDs. According to the estimated overall TD frequency, the coincidence of TDs contributing to the same mEPSP were not statistically independent, indicating a positive interaction between TDs that is reminiscent of the way subminiature signals group to form miniature signals at the neuromuscular junction. Depending on the duration and intensity of efferent stimulation, a complete block of AP initiation occurred either immediately or after a delay of a few seconds. Efferent stimulation did not significantly change AP threshold level, but abruptly decreased mEPSP frequency to a near-complete block that followed the block of APs. Maximum mEPSP rate of rise decreased during, and recovered progressively after, efferent stimulation. After termination of efferent stimulation, mEPSP amplitude did not recover instantly and for a few seconds the amplitude distribution of synaptic events showed fewer large-amplitude events than during the control period. This confirms that mEPSP amplitude and rate of rise properties, which are critical for triggering afferent APs, are modified by efferent activity. The depression of afferent AP firing during efferent stimulation corresponded to a decrease in mEPSP frequency and, to a lesser extent, a decrease in mEPSP amplitude and rate of rise, suggesting, a decrease in the level of interaction among TDs contibuting to a mEPSP.

Constitutive secretion of exogenous neurotransmitter by nonneuronal cells: implications for neuronal secretion

Fibroblasts in cell culture were loaded with exogenous neurotransmitter acetylcholine (ACh). ACh secretion from loaded cells was detected by whole-cell patch clamp recordings from Xenopus myocytes manipulated into contact with ACh-loaded cells. Two different approaches were used for ACh loading. In the first approach, fibroblasts were incubated in the culture medium containing ACh. Recordings from myocytes revealed fast inward currents that resemble miniature endplate currents found at neuromuscular synapses. The currents observed in recordings from myocytes were due to exocytosis of ACh-containing vesicles. Although exogenous ACh penetrated through the plasma membrane of fibroblasts during incubation and was present in the cytoplasm at detectable levels, cytoplasmic ACh did not contribute to the quantal ACh secretion. In the second approach, exogenous ACh was loaded into the cytoplasm of fibroblasts by microinjection. Under these experimental conditions, fibroblasts also exhibited spontaneous quantal ACh secretion. Analysis of the exocytotic events in fibroblasts following two different protocols of ACh loading revealed that the vesicular compartments responsible for uptake of exogenous ACh are associated with the endocytic recycling pathway. Extrapolation of our results to neuronal cells suggest that in cholinergic neurons, in addition to genuine synaptic vesicles, ACh can be secreted by the vesicles participating in endosomal membrane recycling.

Hypertonic treatment reversibly increases the ratio of giant skew-miniature endplate potentials to bell-miniature endplate potentials

Miniature endplate potentials were recorded from single frog muscle fibers before, during and after treatment with hypertonic saline (200-500 mM NaCl or Na gluconate added to frog saline). Miniature endplate potential amplitude distributions were plotted from small muscle fibers so that the modes and ratios of the skew-miniature endplate potential to bell-miniature endplate potential classes could be defined. Muscle fibers were voltage clamped with two electrodes to determine the input resistance before, during and after treatment. Input resistance increased from two to 100 times during treatment and rapidly fell towards control values (no more than 30% greater) when preparations were returned to normal frog saline. Short duration treatments with 200-300 mM hypertonic salines immediately increased frequencies (100-fold) of both skew-miniature endplate potential and bell-miniature endplate potential classes. Preparations when returned to normal frog saline after a few minutes of treatment showed control miniature endplate potential distributions within minutes. One to two hour treatments left only the skew-miniature endplate potential class and with hour-long recovery periods bell-miniature endplate potentials reappeared and ratios of skew-miniature endplate potential to bell-miniature endplate potential classes returned to control values. Treatment with 500 mM NaCl added to frog saline immediately increased the percentage of skew-miniature endplate potentials (from 2 to 50%) with little or no increase in overall miniature endplate potential frequencies. The mode of the skew-miniature endplate potential class was unchanged after hypertonic treatment, whereas that of the bell-miniature end plate potential class either remained about the same size or decreased depending on the duration of treatment. The number and percentage of giant-miniature endplate potentials belonging to the skew-miniature endplate potential class increased as a function of the duration of 200-300 mM hypertonic saline treatments. Most giant-miniature endplate potentials had a slow rising phase with a foot and/or breaks demonstrating a composite structure. Sequentially recorded giant-miniature endplate potentials had similar initial slopes indicating either repetitive releases from single sites or releases from cooperative sites. After hypertonic treatment the bell-miniature endplate potential size was never more than that expected with the increase (under 30%) in input resistance. The results presented here are completely different from those of Yu and Van der Kloot [(1991) J. Physiol. 433, 677-704] who reported that the bell-miniature endplate potential amplitude was increased two- to four-fold after hypertonic treatment. The wide range of results in the ratio of skew-miniature endplate potential to bell-miniature endplate potential classes is discussed in regards to the quantal hypothesis which is based on a single class of immutable amounts of transmitter; and, a hypothesis based on a dynamical process that meters transmitter in subunit amounts to control miniature endplate potential size and class during release.

How can exocytosis account for the actual properties of miniature synaptic signals?

It is broadly accepted that a postsynaptic "miniature" is the most elementary chemically transmitted signal and results from the all-or-none release of transmitter packaged in a single presynaptic vesicle. Hitherto, it has not been possible to directly verify this renowned representation, although it is consistent with evidence of vesicle traffic and, following an intense period of release, vesicle depletion. However, vesicle traffic involving molecular components similar to those implicated in transmitter release has been attributed to other functions including membrane repair. Furthermore, as a number of investigators have recently proposed, miniature signals recorded at peripheral and central synapses may actually reflect several rather than a single discharge of transmitter. It is not clear whether such putative multiple-discharge miniatures represent near-synchronous exocytoses of several vesicles or a burst of openings in a pore that couples a vesicle with the outer membrane. In any case, despite the popularity of the vesicular hypothesis, the molecular mechanism involved in synchronizing fast elementary secretion has not yet been elucidated. Interdependencies among subminiature discharges composing a miniature have suggested that the underlying process is a regenerative signal restricted to a presynaptic terminal unit, confirming Fatt and Katz's first speculation on miniatures, which was not vesicular exocytosis [Fatt and Katz (1952), J. Physiol., 117:109-128]. Here we discuss the possibility that this regenerative signal might be a localized cytosolic Ca2+ transient and attempt to reconcile this hypothesis with the exocytotic models proposed to explain fast transmitter release.

Factors governing the appearance of small-mode miniature endplate currents at the snake neuromuscular junction

At the snake neuromuscular junction, following a short period of high frequency motor nerve stimulation, a population of 'small-mode' miniature endplate currents (MEPCs) is seen. These small-mode MEPCs are believed to be due to the release of acetylcholine from incompletely refilled recycling synaptic vesicles [Searl et al., Neuroscience, 35 (1991) 145-156]. This study determines the role of the trans-vesicular membrane proton gradient in the generation of small-mode MEPCs. Preserving the trans-vesicular membrane proton gradient during synaptic vesicle exocytosis by exposure of snake nerve/muscle preparations to an extracellular pH approximately equal to the intravesicular pH, leads to an augmentation of the amplitude of the stimulation-induced small-mode MEPCs. Conversely, pretreatment of snake neuromuscular preparations with 10 mM ammonium ions, to buffer intravesicular protons and hence dissipate the trans-vesicular membrane proton gradient, leads to an inhibition of the stimulation-induced appearance of small-mode MEPCs. The data are consistent with the theory that the reduced acetylcholine content of recycled synaptic vesicles in the snake is a consequence of an incomplete restoration of the trans-vesicular membrane proton gradient following synaptic vesicle exocytosis. Thus, in recycling synaptic vesicles the limiting step in the refilling process appears to be generation of the trans-membrane proton gradient and not the transport of acetylcholine into the vesicle.

Botulinum A toxin stimulates neurite branching in nerve-muscle cocultures

In addition to skeletal muscle paralysis, type A botulinum toxin commonly causes sprouting of motor axons in various experimental whole-animal systems. The use of type A botulinum toxin in clinical treatment of muscle spasm disorders is becoming increasingly popular. The eventual, unwanted return of involuntary activity in the treated muscles may be a consequence of such axon sprouting. We have developed a coculture model allowing the quantification of botulinum toxin-induced sprouting that shows promise for future studies on its mechanism and control. Chick embryo ciliary ganglion motor neurons were cocultured with chick leg muscle cells. The presence of type A botulinum toxin in the coculture medium was correlated with significantly increased branching frequency of neurites. Toxin-increased branching frequency occurred even when the neurons and muscle cells were separated from each other on the culture dishes, suggesting a presynaptic effect of toxin. Cocultures incubated in the presence of curare, a post-synaptic blocker, had control levels of neurite branching, ruling out the possibility that simple synaptic blockade causes sprouting but again supporting the hypothesis of a pre-synaptic activity of botulinum toxin.

Quantal and subquantal GABAergic transmissions in cultured rat hippocampal neurons

At the neuromuscular junction, spontaneous miniature excitatory synaptic currents mediated by acetylcholine are considered elementary, "quantal" transmissions. These miniature conductances can be quantitatively dichotomized into a large-mode class whose mode is the mean of a normal, bell-shaped distribution and a small-mode class whose distribution is skewed to lower values with its mode being a fraction of the large-mode class. The large-mode class constitutes the population of synaptic signals originally utilized to formulate tenets of "quantal" transmission, which have been tacitly adopted in more recent studies of fast transmission at central synapses. Large- and small-mode conductance classes of inhibitory synaptic elementary conductances mediated by GABA have now been recorded in cultured hippocampal neurons (Vautrin J, Schaffner AE, Barker JL, 1991, Neurosci Lett 138:67). Pairs of hippocampal neurons were patch-recorded at optimal signal-to-noise and, using time course analysis, two elementary fluctuations (0.1-0.3 nS and 1-2 nS) were found within synaptic conductances evoked either by presynaptic action potentials or by presynaptic terminal stimulation. These results were interpreted with a simple model that shows how different frequencies of unitary GABA release can generate either small-mode, skew-distributed conductance (0.5-3 kHz) or large-mode, normally-distributed conductances (> or = 10 kHz). Only the latter satisfies the original tenets of the classic quantal theory.

Frequency modulation of transmitter release

In 1952 Fatt and Katz recorded at a frog neuromuscular junction while stimulating the nerve and found "... that successive endplate potential responses varied in a step-like manner, corresponding to units of miniature endplate potentials" (J Physiol 117, 109-128). This led them to propose that fast neuromuscular transmission is 'quantal'. Quantal release is now commonly ascribed to a vesicular form of neurosecretion since vesicles have routinely been visualized in presynaptic terminals. The vesicular hypothesis (Del Castillo and Katz, 1955) assumes that quanta, or 'transmitter packets of standard size', are assembled and stored in the numerous vesicles routinely identified in micrographs of virtually all central and peripheral presynaptic nerve terminals. Simply stated, this model predicts that each one of the miniature synaptic signals (MSSs) follows from the exocytosis of one vesicle's contents. However, the time required for membrane fusion preceding exocytosis (Almers and Tse, 1990) and the variability in MSS amplitude and time course (Vautrin et al, 1992a,b) cannot readily be reconciled by a simple, exocytotic model of quantal release from preloaded vesicles. These difficulties with the original model have led us to re-evaluate MSSs generated at the classical peripheral synapse, the cholinergic neuromuscular junction of the mouse diaphragm, as well as at central synapses between embryonic hippocampal neurons mediated by gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA). At these synapses, the release of GABA is also assumed to have classical quantal properties like peripheral acetylcholine release (Edwards et al, 1990). Our results show that at both synapses, progressive alterations in elementary signal properties can be induced in a remarkably rapid manner. The original report of preferred amplitudes and intervals in the spontaneous miniature signals (Fatt and Katz, 1952) has repeatedly been confirmed and is here incorporated into a dynamic model of fast synaptic transmission. Although MSSs exhibit variable rise-times and peak amplitudes, they can both be described in terms of synchronization of transmitter release. We have reviewed many experimental findings, which together strongly suggest that the original interpretation of Fatt and Katz (1952) regarding MSSs as reflecting the non-propagated 'neurogenic' activity of 'terminal spots' may be a useful concept to pursue since it may help to explain part of the underlying molecular basis of quantal release.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Further evidence for the dynamic formation of transmitter quanta at the neuromuscular junction

Fatt and Katz (Nature 166:597-598, 1950; J Physiol 117:109-128, 1952) attributed miniature endplate potentials (MEPPs) to the action of a standard quantity of transmitter, the quantum (Del Castillo and Katz, J Physiol 124:560-573, 1954). Quantal packets of transmitter were proposed to be preformed (Del Castillo and Katz, In CNRS Paris (Ed): "Microphysiologie comparée des éléments excitables" 67:245-258, 1957) and stored in large numbers in the motor nerve terminal. Statistical analyses of intervals between MEPPs and numbers of quanta composing small endplate potentials indicated that quantal release was a random process and that release sites functioned independently of each other. With the discovery of synaptic vesicles it was proposed that each contained one quantum of transmitter. The quantal-vesicular hypothesis (Del Castillo and Katz, as cited above) fails, however, to explain amplitude distributions of MEPPs that are skewed and/or that show multiple peaks (Kriebel et al., Brain Res Review 15:167-178, 1990). The drop formation process (Shaw, "The Dripping Faucet as a Model Chaotic System," Santa Cruz, CA: Aerial Press, Inc., 1984) was shown to generate amplitude classes of drops that were similar to classes of MEPPs which suggested that rapid changes in quantal size and ratios of skew- to bell-MEPPs could be explained with a simple dynamic process which determines quantal size at the moment of release (Kriebel et al., as cited above, 1990). Further similarities between miniature endplate currents (MEPCs) and the formation of drops are reported here. We found that rapid changes in MEPC amplitudes and time courses, which accompany an increase in frequency, mimic changes in drop sizes that accompany increases in flow rate. MEPC intervals have a minimum and their distributions are comparable to those of drop intervals. During an increased rate of transmitter release, MEPP amplitudes and intervals were positively correlated. The results suggest that spontaneously released transmitter "packets" are formed at the moment of release and that transmitter supply to the process that forms packets is continuous.

Focal, extracellular recording of slow miniature junctional potentials at the mouse neuromuscular junction

Miniature endplate potentials (MEPPs) with slow rising phase can be attributed either to burst of transmitter releases or to distortion of conduction from remote releasing sites. The spontaneous activity of neuromuscular junctions recorded extracellularly at mouse diaphragms using sharp electrodes was analyzed to test these two hypotheses. The miniature junctional potentials (MEJPs) frequencies observed intracellularly as compared to MEPP frequency measured intracellularly in controls indicate that most events recorded extracellularly are induced by the presence of the electrode. All types of MEPPs (bell-MEPPs, skew-MEPPs, slow-, and giant MEPPs) previously described with intracellular recording methods (Vautrin and Kriebel, Neuroscience 41:71-88, 1991) were observed extracellularly and showed similar characteristics. This means that the presynaptic and postsynaptic zones that generate these synaptic events are restricted within areas of a few micrometers squared of synaptic contact. Long rise times of extracellularly recorded synaptic spontaneous events may be explained by multiple transmitter releases at intervals shorter than the rise time of individual events, which postsynaptic responses fuse into a single peak.