Immunohistochemical localization of beta 1-integrins in anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments of human and rabbit

Basic science of anterior cruciate ligament injury and repair

Injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is one of the most devastating and frequent injuries of the knee. Surgical reconstruction is the current standard of care for treatment of ACL injuries in active patients. The widespread adoption of ACL reconstruction over primary repair was based on early perception of the limited healing capacity of the ACL. Although the majority of ACL reconstruction surgeries successfully restore gross joint stability, post-traumatic osteoarthritis is commonplace following these injuries, even with ACL reconstruction. The development of new techniques to limit the long-term clinical sequelae associated with ACL reconstruction has been the main focus of research over the past decades. The improved knowledge of healing, along with recent advances in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine, has resulted in the discovery of novel biologically augmented ACL-repair techniques that have satisfactory outcomes in preclinical studies. This instructional review provides a summary of the latest advances made in ACL repair. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2014;3:20-31.

Current status and potential of primary ACL repair

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture occurs in hundreds of thousands of active adolescents and young adults each year. Despite current treatment, posttraumatic osteoarthritis following these injuries is common in these young patients. Thus, there is widespread clinical and scientific interest in improving patient outcomes and preventing osteoarthritis. The current emphasis on the removal of the torn ACL and subsequent replacement with a tendon graft (ACL reconstruction) stems from adherence to a long-held and widely accepted doctrine that the ACL has only a limited healing response and, therefore, cannot heal or regenerate with suture repair. Recent work has shown that, despite an active biologic response in the ACL after injury, the two ends of the torn ligament never reconnect. Additional studies have detailed findings after placement of a substitute provisional scaffold in the wound site of the ACL injury to bridge the gap and initiate healing of the ruptured ligament after primary repair. This technique, called enhanced primary repair, has significant potential advantages over current ACL reconstruction techniques, including the preservation of the complex attachment sites and innervation of these structures, thus retaining much of the biomechanical and proprioceptive function of these tissues. This manuscript summarizes the recent in vitro and in vivo studies in the area of enhancing ACL healing using biologic supplementation. Subsequent work in this area may lead to the development of a novel approach to treat this important injury.

Collagen-platelet rich plasma hydrogel enhances primary repair of the porcine anterior cruciate ligament

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) fails to heal after suture repair. One hypothesis for this failure is the premature loss of the fibrin clot, or provisional scaffolding, between the two ligament ends in the joint environment. To test this hypothesis, a substitute provisional scaffold of collagen-platelet rich plasma (PRP) hydrogel was used to fill the ACL wound site at the time of suture repair and the structural properties of the healing ACLs evaluated 4 weeks after surgery. Bilateral ACL transections were performed in five 30-kg Yorkshire pigs and treated with suture repair. In each animal, one of the repairs was augmented with placement of a collagen-PRP hydrogel at the ACL transection site, while the contralateral knee had suture repair alone. In addition, six control knees with intact ACLs from three additional animals were used as a control group. No postoperative immobilization was used. After 4 weeks the animals underwent in vivo magnetic resonance imaging to assess the size of the healing ACL, followed by biomechanical testing to determine tensile properties. The supplementation of suture repair with a collagen-PRP hydrogel resulted in significant improvements in load at yield, maximum load, and linear stiffness at 4 weeks. We conclude that use of a stabilized provisional scaffold, such as a collagen-PRP hydrogel, to supplement primary repair of the ACL can result in improved biomechanical properties at an early time point. Further studies to determine the long-term effect of primary repair enhancement are needed.

Canine ACL fibroblast integrin expression and cell alignment in response to cyclic tensile strain in three-dimensional collagen gels

Tissue-engineered ligament substitutes have the potential to become an alternative graft source for ligament reconstruction. If this approach is to become viable, one must first understand and define the mechanisms responsible for creation, maintenance, and remodeling of the native anterior cruciate ligament. It is well accepted that mechanical load alters fibroblast phenotypic expression in a variety of cell sources; however, the mechanosensitive pathways responsible for alteration in matrix production, remodeling, and alignment are unknown. We hypothesize that cell surface integrins play a role in this mechanotransduction process, and as such respond to application of cyclic tensile load. Linear 3D collagen gels containing canine ACL fibroblasts were created in Flexercell Tissue-Train Culture Plates. Gels were untethered (control), tethered without external strain (tethered), or tethered and exposed to 2.5% cyclic strain for 2 h per day for 4 days (strain). Quantitation of alpha1, alpha5, and beta1 integrin subunit was performed using flow cytometry. Cell and matrix alignment was studied using light, polarized light, and fluorescent microscopy. Expression of alpha5 and beta1 integrin subunits was increased significantly in fibroblasts in tethered and strained 3D collagen gels compared with the control, unloaded constructs (p < 0.05). These integrins are known to function as mechanotransducers in other tissues, implicating a similar role in mechanotransduction in ACL fibroblasts. Histologic analysis of the tethered and strained gels demonstrated a linear arrangement of cells and parallel collagen fibril architecture. In contrast, cell distribution and collagen alignment were disorganized in the control, unloaded gels. The alignment of cells and collagen in the 3D gels parallel to applied strain is similar to the in vivo state. These data add to our understanding of the behavior of ACL fibroblasts in vitro. The ability to manipulate signal transduction pathways may enhance our ability to engineer implantable ACL grafts or to modify ACL healing response.

Effect of cyclic strain and plating matrix on cell proliferation and integrin expression by ligament fibroblasts

The role of cell surface integrins in cell migration, proliferation, and attachment to matrix molecules is well known. Integrin-matrix interactions have been implicated in mechanotransduction and load transmission from the outside to the inside of the cell. In this study, the effect of cyclic strain on the cell proliferation, attachment, and expression of integrin subunits beta1, beta3, and alpha5 was determined in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and medial collateral ligament (MCL) fibroblasts grown on polystyrene, Type I collagen, laminin, elastin, and fibronectin. ACL fibroblast proliferation was not affected by growth substrate whereas MCL cells reached confluence more rapidly on fibronectin compared with collagen or polystyrene. Exposure to 5% cyclic strain resulted in a significant decrease in ACL and MCL fibroblast proliferation on fibronectin and Type I collagen. MCL cells showed a greater strain-dependent inhibition of cells grown on a fibronectin substrate than those grown on collagen. This matrix-dependent effect of strain on cell proliferation was not seen with ACL cells. Attachment of ACL and MCL fibroblasts was stronger to fibronectin compared with Type I collagen, laminin, and polystyrene. In the absence of applied load, the expression of beta1, beta3, and alpha5 subunits was not substrate dependent and the expression of beta1 and alpha5 integrin subunits was higher in MCL cells than ACL cells on all substrates. In contrast, the expression of beta3 integrin subunit was higher in ACL cells than MCL cells. In response to 5% strain, beta1, and alpha5 expression increased in all fibroblasts with MCL cells having a higher magnitude of expression. beta3 expression showed a 90% increase in response to load when grown on laminin for both MCL and ACL fibroblasts and demonstrated no change in expression on Type I collagen or fibronectin. The duration of applied strain from 2 versus 22 h had no effect on cell proliferation or integrin expression.

Animal models of tendon and ligament injuries for tissue engineering applications

Animal modeling continues to be an important component to the critical evaluation of new techniques to treat tendon and ligament injuries. Appropriate choice and analysis of these models is essential. Factors that should be considered in assessing a potential model include the tissue type (ligament versus tendon and intrasynovial versus extrasynovial), the type of injury to be modeled, the techniques of measuring the response to treatment, the ease of comparison to previously published models and finally, the ease of translation to human trials and eventually to clinical usage.

Differences in mesenchymal tissue repair

Variations in certain mesenchymal tissue healing processes are not widely recognized. The current review summarizes key differences in healing mechanisms and healing potential after injury to soft tissues having different healing outcomes.

Differential expression of integrin subunits in canine knee ligament fibroblasts

A method for measuring the expression of integrin subunits on the cell surface of knee ligament fibroblasts was developed with use of flow cytometry and immunofluorescence. The ligament cells exhibited uniform size and density, as shown by forward and side-scatter properties, and showed minimal nonspecific binding of isotype control antibodies compared with unstained cells. All cells expressed the alpha5 integrin subunit; lateral collateral ligament cells stained with antibody to alpha5 showed a mean fluorescence intensity 2-fold higher than that of medial collateral ligament cells, 1.5-fold higher than that of posterior cruciate ligament cells, and 3-fold higher than that of anterior cruciate ligament cells, indicating a greater expression of the alpha5 subunit by lateral collateral ligament cells than by medial collateral, posterior cruciate, and anterior cruciate ligament cells. All cells expressed the beta1 integrin subunit; the expression by posterior cruciate ligament cells was 3-fold higher than that by medial collateral ligament or lateral collateral ligament cells and 5-fold higher than that by anterior cruciate ligament cells. All cells expressed the beta3 integrin subunit; the expression by posterior cruciate ligament cells was 1.5, 3, and 4.5-fold greater than that by lateral collateral, anterior cruciate, and medial collateral ligament cells, respectively. Our data suggest there is a differential expression of integrin subunits in knee ligament fibroblasts, and this in part may explain differences in their attachment and adherence to extracellular matrix molecules.

Increased expression of the beta 1, alpha 5, and alpha v integrin adhesion receptor subunits occurs coincident with remodeling of stress-deprived rabbit anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments

The biomechanical, biochemical, and morphological properties of the anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments are dramatically altered in response to deprivation of normal physical forces and joint motion. Integrin adhesion receptors are known to play important roles in the tissue remodeling that occurs in the course of normal wound repair. We propose that integrins play a similar role in the remodeling of the extracellular matrix in stress-deprived periarticular ligaments. This study tests the hypothesis that altered expression of integrins on ligament fibroblasts accompanies this remodeling. The left knees of 15 New Zealand White rabbits were surgically immobilized in acute flexion and the right knees served as controls (no operation). The anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments were harvested at 1, 3, 5, 9, or 12 weeks after immobilization. Sections from the ligaments were immunostained with monoclonal antibodies specific for the integrin subunits beta 1, alpha 5, alpha 6, and alpha v, as well as with a negative control antibody. Fibroblasts within both the stress-deprived anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments demonstrated markedly increased staining for the beta 1, alpha 5, and alpha v subunits, as compared with the controls. The increased staining was greatest at 9 weeks in the anterior cruciate ligament and at 12 weeks in the medial collateral ligament. Western blot study of ligament proteins extracted with sodium dodecyl sulfate demonstrated an increased amount of beta 1 subunit protein in both ligaments from knees that were stress deprived for 9 and 12 weeks, as compared with the control ligaments.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adhesiveness of human ligament fibroblasts to laminin

The adhesiveness of fibroblasts from the human anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments to the laminin molecule was studied, with particular emphasis on the intrinsic differences between fibroblasts from the two ligaments. Cellular adhesion strength, adhesion area, laminin concentration, and seeding time were examined. Cell adhesion to laminin anchored with poly-D-lysine to a cleaned cover glass was measured with a micropipette micromanipulation system after seeding. The adhesion strength of fibroblasts from the anterior cruciate ligament to laminin was greater than and significantly different from that of fibroblasts from the medial collateral ligament, depending on the laminin concentration. Fibroblasts from the anterior cruciate ligament also exhibited an increase in adhesion strength, dependent on laminin concentration of as much as 30 micrograms/ml, at which the laminin receptors were thought to be saturated. Fibroblasts from the medial collateral ligament did not show such an increase except at laminin concentrations of 5-10 micrograms/ml. There was no significant difference in adhesion area between fibroblasts from the two ligaments except after 45 minutes at a laminin concentration of 40 micrograms/ml. For both, the adhesion to laminin showed little correlation to seeding time during periods of as long as 60 minutes. Measurements of adhesion area also failed to show a significant correlation to seeding time for fibroblasts from either ligament at laminin concentrations of 20 and 40 micrograms/ml. Adhesion strength normalized by adhesion area had no correlation to seeding time.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Integrin display increases in the wounded rabbit medial collateral ligament but not the wounded anterior cruciate ligament

The differential capacities of the anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments to heal may be related to differences in cellular function. This study tested the hypothesis that differential expression of integrins occurs in these ligaments after injury. The integrins are a family of cell surface receptors that mediate adhesion, migration, and other cellular functions critical to the healing of a wound. A similar complement and amount of the beta 1 subfamily of integrins are known to be present on the unperturbed anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments in humans and rabbits. A partial laceration was surgically created in these two ligaments in 12 anesthetized New Zealand White rabbits. Immunohistochemistry was performed on sections from the ligaments at 1, 3, 7, and 10 days after injury, using monoclonal antibodies directed against the integrin subunits beta 1, alpha 5, alpha 6, and alpha v. Between 3 and 7 days, the wounded medial collateral ligament demonstrated a striking increase in staining for the beta 1, alpha 5, and alpha v subunits on the fibroblasts, within the repair site, and on capillary endothelium. Increased staining was most marked for the beta 1 subunit and less marked for the alpha 5 and alpha v subunits. The alpha 6 subunit stained exclusively vascular structures within the healing medial collateral ligament. In marked contrast, the anterior cruciate ligament, which does not mount an effective repair response, demonstrated no comparable alteration of integrin expression from baseline levels.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Changes of cytoskeletal architecture and incorporation of 3H-proline in contracted anterior cruciate ligament

Changes of cytoskeletal architecture and incorporation of 3H-proline were investigated in contracted anterior cruciate ligaments with use of a model of contracture. In control ligaments, fibroblasts were shown by immunofluorescence microscopy to contain actin, vimentin, and myosin in their cytoplasm. Cytoskeletons were visualized by electron microscopy as a mesh network of microfilaments among cell organelles. In contracted anterior cruciate ligaments, fibroblasts were spindle-shaped and their cytoplasm could not be observed clearly in sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin. Actin staining was distributed irregularly and extensively, whereas vimentin and myosin staining was not scattered so extensively. When compared electromyographically, the actin staining appeared in cytoplasmic pseudopods of the fibroblasts. It was thought that these cytoplasmic pseudopods contained mainly actin and little or no other cytoskeletal elements such as vimentin and myosin. In autoradiographs, contracted anterior cruciate ligaments were shown, with use of 3H-proline, to experience a decrease in the number of labeled cells. On the basis of these findings of cytoskeletal rearrangement and of decreased incorporation of 3H-proline, we hypothesized that fibroblasts of the anterior cruciate ligament had the capacity to change their character during knee immobilization and to play a role in ligament contracture.

An in vitro assay of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and medial collateral ligament (MCL) cell migration

Explants from rabbit anterior cruciate ligaments (ACL) and medial collateral ligaments (MCL) were utilized to compare the relative rates that fibroblasts migrate onto glass and plastic culture surfaces in vitro. During the first two weeks in culture, a monolayer of cells appeared on the periphery of all the ACL and MCL explants. From 45 to 134 hrs in culture, the mean total MCL cell count per explant was 6-12 times greater than that for the ACL on the plastic culture dishes, and this difference was even greater for the cells attached to the glass cover slides over the explants. These differences were significant at the p < .005 level. The rates of cell proliferation were quite similar for primary cultures of ACL and MCL grown in the same medium as that used for the migration assay. The large difference in cell number at early times of culture is thus due to the more rapid MCL cell migration out of the explants, and not to a difference in the rate of cell proliferation. These data support the hypothesis that differences in cell migration rate play a role in the greater healing capacity of the MCL as compared with the ACL. The assay described in this work may then be useful in assessing factors that promote wound healing.