Visualization by magnetic resonance imaging of focal cartilage lesions in the excised mini-pig knee

Dynamic MR imaging of a minipig's knee using a high-density multi-channel receive array and a movement device

OBJECT

To construct an optimised, high-density receive array and a movement device to achieve dynamic imaging of the knee in orthopedic large animal models (e.g., minipigs) at 1.5 T.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A 13-channel RF receive array was constructed, and the crucial choice of the array element size (based on considerations like region of interest, geometry of the minipig's knee, achievable signal-to-noise ratio, applicability of parallel imaging, etc.) was determined using the Q factors of loops with different sizes. A special movement device was constructed to guide and produce a reproducible motion of the minipig's knee during acquisition.

RESULTS

The constructed array was electrically characterised and the reproducibility of the cyclic motion was validated. Snapshots of dynamic in vivo images taken at a temporal resolution (308 ms) are presented. Some of the fine internal structures within the minipig's knee, like cruciate ligaments, are traced in the snapshots.

CONCLUSION

This study is a step towards making dynamic imaging which can give additional information about joint injuries when static MRI is not able to give sufficient information, a routine clinical application. There, the combination of a high-density receive array and a movement device will be highly helpful in the diagnosis and therapy monitoring of knee injuries in the future.

Computer-aided quantification of focal cartilage lesions using MRI: accuracy and initial arthroscopic comparison

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the study was to validate a Gradient Peak Method (GPM) by evaluating its accuracy and consistency at different magnetic field strengths. The GPM using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was previously proposed to quantitatively assess the morphology of focal cartilage lesions, and its feasibility was demonstrated.

METHODS

GPM quantifies the morphologic properties of cartilage lesions based on their three-dimensional geometry. Twenty-two conical and cylindrical lesions were surgically created on fresh porcine knees, and the results obtained by GPM were compared with manually measured lesion dimensions. Another 15 focal lesions of various shapes were created and scanned, and the quantification results were compared at 1.5 Tesla and 3 Tesla. Additionally, cartilage lesions in three patients were scanned, quantified by GPM, and compared with arthroscopic visualization and measurements.

RESULTS

The average absolute errors of GPM (depth: < or =0.4mm; diameter: < or =1.4mm) were within twice the in-plane resolution in depth estimates and within the slice thickness in diameter estimates. Analysis also suggested that the quantifications of GPM using 1.5 Tesla and 3 Tesla data were not statistically different. Moreover, the GPM results were shown to be consistent with the lesion measurements obtained arthroscopically.

CONCLUSIONS

The GPM using MRI provides estimates of lesion thickness, depth, diameter, and area. With this validation, the method can be potentially used as an auxiliary tool to help radiologists and physicians assess cartilage lesions quantitatively and monitor disease progression.

Reliability of diffraction enhanced imaging for assessment of cartilage lesions, ex vivo

OBJECTIVE

The assessment of articular cartilage integrity is of value for the detection of early degenerative joint disease in both the clinical and the research settings. It was the purpose of this study to determine the accuracy and reliability of identifying articular cartilage defects through Diffraction Enhanced Imaging (DEI), a high contrast radiographic imaging technique. DEI provides two new sources of image contrast to radiography: refraction and scatter rejection, besides the absorption of conventional radiography.

DESIGN

Cadaveric tali were DEI imaged in the anterior-posterior position at the National Synchrotron Light Source. Two independent observers provided gross score evaluations (on a five point scale) of the trochlear surfaces. The DEI image of each trochlear surface was then graded (on a five point scale) by two additional independent observers who were blinded with regard to the gross evaluation of the articular surfaces. Inter-observer agreement for DEI grades was assessed with the weighted kappa statistic. Correlation of diffraction enhanced image score to the gross score was assessed with Spearman correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

The defects of articular cartilage of talar trochleae could be visualized through DEI. The Spearman correlation of gross grades with DEI grades on the 165 talar regions for observers 1 and 2 were 0.91 and 0.91, respectively. The overall weighted kappa value for inter-observer agreement was 0.93, thus considered high agreement.

CONCLUSIONS

DEI is accurate and reliable for detection of articular cartilage defects ex vivo. Even early stages of degeneration of cartilage can be visualized with this high contrast technique. Future studies will focus on the application of DEI to the identification of such lesions in vivo.

Computer-aided quantification of focal cartilage lesions of osteoarthritic knee using MRI

Noninvasive assessment of articular cartilage using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has gained popularity in the diagnosis of osteoarthritis (OA), a condition that affects 20 million Americans. Focal cartilage lesions, a defect found in roughly 19% of the OA population, currently can only be evaluated with confidence using minimally invasive arthroscopy. This article presents a computer-aided procedure using MRI to quantify focal cartilage lesions and aims to support clinical practices of diagnosis and monitoring of lesion progress. Upon a local minima search for identifying focal lesions, the proposed gradient peak method outlines lesion boundaries and then generates morphological properties, such as lesion volume and lesion area. The procedure was evaluated using simulated and in vivo data. First, a simulated lesion was created and analyzed, and the results were compared with the exact solutions. Second, an in vivo evaluation was carried out on seven human knees in which nine focal lesions were identified and quantified. Three of the subjects had follow-up analyses, at either 1 or 2 years. Finally, in an attempt to characterize local biochemical changes underlying focal lesions, MR-derived T2 values of defective cartilage within the lesion boundaries were examined and compared with the values of adjacent cartilage compartments.

In vivo contrast-enhanced micro MR-imaging of experimental osteoarthritis in the rabbit knee joint at 7.1T1

OBJECTIVE

In this longitudinal MR study the early stages of joint pathology in two surgically-induced rabbit models of osteoarthritis (OA) were monitored by in vivo contrast-enhanced MRI at 7.1T. Qualitative and quantitative MR data were compared with macroscopic and microscopic findings.

METHOD

Scanning of mature, male New Zealand White rabbits (N=12) was performed before surgery, and at 2, 4, and 8 weeks after unilateral transection of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACLT), medial meniscectomy (ME), or sham operation. MR-images were simultaneously obtained of both knee joints after intravenous injection of Magnevist. We implemented a 2D T1-weighted (T1w) coronal, fat-saturated gradientecho protocol (68 x 138 microm2, slice thickness 1 mm). Additionally, consecutive 3D gradientecho images were obtained from two sham-operated and two rabbits of the ME group (234 x 273 x 234 microm(3)). ACLT animals were sacrificed at 2 weeks (N=1), and 8 weeks (N=3), ME animals were sacrificed at 4 weeks (N=2), and 8 weeks (N=4), and sham-operated animals were sacrificed at 2 weeks (N=1) and 8 weeks (N=1), respectively.

RESULTS

Both OA models reflected important characteristics of the clinical picture of OA. With MR we were able to monitor time dependently the decline of synovial effusion and the formation of osteophytes. Morphologic MR examination showed a moderate to high accuracy for detecting synovial effusion (75%), meniscus (86%) and cruciate ligament (91%) lesions, and osteophytes (88%) as assessed by macroscopic examination. False-negative MR findings for gross macroscopic changes were due to the relative high slice thickness in 2D scans and the fact that the slices only covered the main weightbearing area of the femorotibial joint. Contour abnormalities of articular cartilage were not reliably detected. Quantitative analysis revealed a statistically significant increase of cartilage signal intensity in medial tibial cartilage (48+/-9% ACLT, and 29+/-9% ME in 2D datasets) as compared to contralateral control knees in two-week scans. Signal enhancement persisted or increased at later dates.

CONCLUSION

With high-resolution contrast-enhanced MRI at 7.1T the time course of gross pathologic changes in rabbit knees with surgically induced OA can be monitored. Still insufficient spatial resolution and image contrast of the applied 2D protocols limit the sensitivity and prohibit detection of articular cartilage contour abnormalities. However, signal alterations in the cartilage layer indicate alterations of tissue composition at a very early stage of OA development. When used with 3D protocols, contrast-enhanced MRI offers a promising tool for qualitative and quantitative in vivo monitoring of OA in rabbit models.

Inter-rater and intra-rater reliability of subchondral bone and cartilage thickness measurement from MRI☆

MRI is often used to visualize and quantify the articular cartilage layer of load bearing joints affected by degenerative diseases, such as osteoarthritis (OA). Although the role played by the subchondral bone in the etiology and/or progression of OA may be important, the ability to visualize and quantify subchondral bone with MRI has received little attention. In this report we examined the inter-rater and intra-rater reliability of subchondral bone and cartilage thickness measurements from MR images of cadaver femoral head specimens. A 3D-SPGR pulse sequence tuned to eliminate chemical shift artifact through phase cancellation was used to image the specimens. Three raters manually segmented four specimens on two different occasions. Subchondral bone and cartilage thickness measurements were calculated from the segmented images. Inter-rater and intra-rater reliabilities were very high (>.98) for both cartilage and subchondral bone thickness measurements. We conclude that subchondral bone thickness can be measured as reliably as cartilage thickness from MR images.

Measurement accuracy of focal cartilage defects from MRI and correlation of MRI graded lesions with histology: a preliminary study

OBJECTIVES

Although accurate spatial measurement of cartilage thickness from MRI is possible, no studies have assessed the accuracy of measuring cartilage defect dimensions from MRI. In addition, current MR grading scales for assessing cartilage lesions have limited categories, and little is known about how well these scales correlate with histological assessment of the lesion. The objective of this preliminary study is to address both these issues.

METHODS

We performed two experiments on four cadaver knee joints from elderly donors: Experiment 1 assessed the accuracy of measuring controlled defects in cartilage, and Experiment 2 compared MRI grading (Noyes scale) of natural cartilage lesions to histological grading (Mankin scale) of the sectioned cartilage tissue. MRI was performed on 1.5 T clinical scanner (fat-suppressed 3D-SPGR at TR/TE/alpha=55/13.5/45 and 256 x 256 matrix).

RESULTS

The mean difference between defect diameters measured and introduced was less than 0.1mm, which was statistically insignificant (P=0.754). Defect depth was less accurate at >0.4mm, significantly under predicting actual defect depth (P=0.004). Correlation between Noyes grading scores and Mankin grading scores of natural lesions was moderately high (r=0.7) and statistically significant (P=0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensional mapping of cartilage thickness shows great promise for the accurate measurement of focal cartilage defects, though improvement is needed. The Noyes grading scale is consistent with histological Mankin grading of cartilage lesions, though enhancement of MR grading scales is needed, and warranted, based on the signal intensity information available from clinical MRI. Integration of these two analyses-focal defect measurement and signal intensity analysis-could potentially result in a valuable clinical tool for early osteoarthritis diagnosis and longitudinal tracking.