Reduced anterior tibial translation associated with adaptive changes in the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient joint: goat model

Risk factors for passive anterior tibial subluxation on MRI in complete ACL tear

INTRODUCTION

In anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear, passive spontaneous anterior tibial subluxation (ATS), with respect to the femur, is sometimes observed on MRI. In a case-control study, ATS>3.5mm showed 100% specificity (±3.6, 95% CI) for complete ACL tear. The aim of the present study was to assess the relation between ATS on MRI and associated lesions in complete ACL tear. The study hypothesis was that associated lesions are a risk factor for ATS.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective study included patients operated on for complete ACL tear between 2010 and 2015. Exclusion criteria comprised associated posterior cruciate ligament tear, partial ACL tear, and history of knee surgery. Preoperative MRI was performed with the patient in supine position and the knee in 20° flexion in neutral rotation. ATS was measured by axial superimposition of the bicondylar slice on the slice through the tibial plateau. Associated lesions were assessed: medial and lateral menisci, collateral ligaments, posteromedial and posterolateral corners, tibiofemoral compartment cartilage and cancellous bone. Factors associated with ATS>3.5mm were analyzed. Ninety-one patients were included: mean age, 31.1±10.1 years; 34 female, 57 male. Mean time from injury to MRI was 7.8±11.7 months (range, 0.7-60 months).

RESULTS

Mean ATS was 4.7±2.3mm. Inter- and intra-observer reproducibility for ATS measurement were excellent. On preoperative MRI, 61.1% of patients showed bone edema, 48.4% medial meniscal tear, and 36.3% lateral meniscal tear. ATS was significantly greater in case of medial meniscal tear (5.4±2.3mm vs. 4±2.1mm; p=0.003). No significant differences were found according to other lesions. Fifty-four patients (59.3%) showed ATS>3.5mm; risk factors comprised medial meniscal tear (OR=2.6, 95%CI [1.1-6.2]; p=0.03) and injury-to-MRI time>9 months (OR=9.8, 95% CI [1.1-85.2]; p=0.04).

CONCLUSION

Spontaneous anterior tibial subluxation on MRI in complete ACL tear was significantly associated with medial meniscal tear and accident-to-MRI time.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, retrospective cohort study.

Large Animal Models for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Research

Large animal (non-rodent mammal) models are commonly used in ACL research, but no species is currently considered the gold standard. Important considerations when selecting a large animal model include anatomical differences, the natural course of ACL pathology in that species, and biomechanical differences between humans and the chosen model. This article summarizes recent reports related to anatomy, pathology, and biomechanics of the ACL for large animal species (dog, goat, sheep, pig, and rabbit) commonly used in ACL research. Each species has unique features and benefits as well as potential drawbacks, which are highlighted in this review. This information may be useful in the selection process when designing future studies.

Passive anterior tibial subluxation in anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees

BACKGROUND

Abnormal anterior-posterior and rotational motion secondary to anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency is typically described in terms of dynamic laxity. An original description of the abnormal tibiofemoral relationship in the setting of ACL insufficiency has highlighted the presence of a fixed anterior tibial subluxation in this population of failed ACL reconstruction (ACLR); however, no study has quantified the degree of tibial subluxation in both the medial and lateral compartments.

PURPOSE

To measure and compare the amount of anterior tibial subluxation among various states of ACL competency, including (1) intact ACL, (2) acute ACL disruption, and (3) failed ACLR (ie, patients requiring revision ACLR). We hypothesized that anterior tibial displacement would be greater in the lateral compartment and in cases of failed ACLR compared with intact and acute ACL injured states.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

Using sagittal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and a standardized measurement technique, we determined the amount of anterior tibial subluxation relative to a constant posterior condylar reference point. Measurements were performed in both the medial and the lateral compartments and were compared with 1-way analysis of variance. The presence of meniscal tears along with meniscal volume loss and chondral damage was correlated with the amount of subluxation in each group.

RESULTS

Compared with the intact ACL state, the medial tibial plateau was positioned more anteriorly relative to the femur in both acute ACL injured knees (mean 1.0 mm) and those that failed ACLR (mean 1.8 mm) (P = .072). In the lateral compartment, there was 0.8 mm of mean anterior tibial displacement after acute ACL injury and 3.9 mm of mean anterior subluxation in patients who failed ACLR (P < .001). Mean anterior displacement of the lateral plateau in patients who failed ACLR was almost 5 times greater than the amount observed in patients with acute ACL injuries. There was no correlation between meniscal/chondral injury and the amount of subluxation.

CONCLUSION

Patients who require revision ACLR have an abnormal tibiofemoral relationship noted on MRI that is most pronounced in the lateral compartment and should be taken into account during revision surgery. These observations may explain the suboptimal clinical results seen in some patients who undergo revision ACLR.

Suture augmentation following ACL injury to restore the function of the ACL, MCL, and medial meniscus in the goat stifle joint

Functional tissue engineering (FTE) approaches have shown promise in healing an injured anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) of the knee. Nevertheless, additional mechanical augmentation is needed to maintain joint stability and appropriate loading of the joint while the ACL heals. The objective of this study was to quantitatively evaluate how mechanical augmentation using sutures restores the joint kinematics as well as the distribution of loading among the ACL, medial collateral ligament, and medial meniscus (MM) in response to externally applied loads. Eight goat stifle joints were tested on a robotic/universal force-moment sensor testing system under two loading conditions: (1) a 67N anterior tibial load (ATL) and (2) a 67N ATL with 100N axial compression. For each joint, four experimental conditions were tested at 30°, 60°, and 90° of flexion: the (1) intact and (2) ACL-deficient joint, as well as following (3) suture repair of the transected ACL, and (4) augmentation using sutures passed from the femur to the tibia. Under the 67N ATL, suture augmentation could restore the anterior tibial translation (ATT) to within 3mm of the intact joint (p>0.05), representing a 54-76% improvement over suture repair (p<0.05). With the additional axial compression, the ATT and in-situ forces of the sutures following suture augmentation remained 2-3 times closer to normal (p<0.05). Also, the in-situ forces in the MM were 58-73% lower (p<0.05). Thus, suture augmentation may be helpful in combination with FTE approaches for ACL healing by providing the needed initial joint stability while lowering the loads on the MM.

Evaluation of bone tunnel placement for suture augmentation of an injured anterior cruciate ligament: effects on joint stability in a goat model

Use of novel tissue engineering approaches to heal an injured anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) requires suture repair and/or augmentation to provide joint stability. We evaluated the effects of the location of suture augmentation at the femur and tibia in terms of joint stability using a goat model. Eight goat stifle joints were tested with augmentation sutures placed in two femoral tunnel locations: (1) anterior to, or (2) through the ACL footprint, and two tibial tunnel locations: (1) medial to, or (2) medial and lateral to the footprint. Using a robotic/universal force-moment sensor testing system, the anterior tibial translation (ATT) and the corresponding in situ force carried by the sutures were obtained at 30°, 60°, and 90° of flexion in response to external loads. No significant differences were found between augmentation groups due to tunnel location in terms of ATT or the in situ forces carried by the sutures at all flexion angles tested. Similar results were found under 5 N m of varus-valgus torque. Under a 67 N anterior tibial load, the ATT was restored to within 3 mm of the intact joint following suture augmentation (p > 0.05). Suture augmentation, when placed close to the ACL insertion, could be helpful in providing initial joint stability to aid ACL healing in the goat model.

Biomechanics of the goat three bundle anterior cruciate ligament

The goat is a widely used animal model for basic research on the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), but the biomechanical role of the different bundles [intermediate (IM), anteromedial (AM), posterolateral (PL)] of the ACL is unclear. Therefore, the aim of this study is to describe the biomechanical function of the different bundles and evaluate its use for a double bundle ACL reconstruction model. A CASPAR Stäubli RX90 robot with a six degree-of-freedom load cell was used for measurement of anterior tibial translation (ATT) (mm) and in situ forces (N) at 30 degrees (full extension), 60 degrees , 90 degrees as well as rotational testing at 30 degrees in 14 paired goat knees before and after each bundle was cut. When the AM-bundle was cut, the ATT increased significantly at 60 degrees and 90 degrees of flexion (p < 0.05). When the PL-bundle was cut, the ATT increased only at 30 degrees. However, most load was transferred through the big AM-bundle while the PL-bundle shared significant load only at 30 degrees, with only minimal contribution from the IM-bundle at all flexion degrees. The observed biomechanical results in this study are similar to the human ACL observed previously in the literature. Though anatomically discernible, the IM-bundle plays only an inferior role in ATT and might be neglected as a separate bundle during reconstruction. The goat ACL shows some differences to the human ACL, whereas the main functions of the ACL bundles are similar.

The impact of radiofrequency shrinkage on the mechanical and histologic properties of the elongated anterior cruciate ligament in a sheep model

PURPOSE

Shrinkage of the elongated anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and its grafts with radiofrequency (RF) energy has become increasingly popular as an alternative to ACL reconstruction in the field of knee surgery. Although there have been a few clinical studies on the outcome and complications of RF shrinkage of the elongated ACL, there is a substantial lack of in vivo basic science studies to evaluate the mechanical and histologic changes of such treated tissue. Therefore, it was the aim of this study to simulate an ACL elongation in an animal model, treat this pathology with RF shrinkage, and analyze the mechanical and histologic changes at 6 months after initial treatment.

TYPE OF STUDY

Experimental in vivo animal study.

METHODS

A chronic elongation of the ACL was simulated in 16 mature female merino sheep. In group A, no treatment was applied; in group B, RF shrinkage was used. For biomechanical testing anteroposterior (AP) laxity was measured at time zero and 24 weeks. A load-to-failure test was also performed at 24 weeks. For histologic analysis, cell number and crimp pattern were measured by conventional histologic examination and the vascular status by immunohistochemical histologic examination.

RESULTS

The initial reduction of AP laxity after RF shrinkage could not be maintained at 24 weeks. A significant reduction in ultimate load was found at 24 weeks in the RF-treated group B compared with the untreated group A. At 24 weeks, an intensive process of tendon remodeling was ongoing in the RF-treated group that differed substantially from the untreated elongated ACLs and the intact ACL.

CONCLUSIONS

The treatment of an elongated ACL with RF energy resulted in a significant impairment of its ultimate load and induced a process of intensive remodeling that was not completed at 24 weeks. Therefore, strong caution is warranted during the time of rehabilitation, considering the impaired ligamentous structure.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This study provides insights into the consequences of RF shrinkage of the ACL that will guide the clinician in the appropriate rehabilitation of patients and informs of possible complications associated with this procedure.

Instrumented measurement of in vivo anterior-posterior translation in the canine knee to assess anterior cruciate integrity

This study was designed to objectively quantify in vivo anterior-posterior canine knee translation relative to anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) integrity. Tibial translation was determined in one knee of 43 crossbreed hounds from radiographs performed while a set anterior and then posterior force was applied to the tibia using a custom designed device. The total (TTT), anterior (ATT), and posterior (PTT) tibial translation were measured (absolute) and normalized to the width of the tibia (normalized). Absolute and normalized TTT was significantly greater in ruptured ACL knees than in partially disrupted (PD) ACL knees, which were significantly greater than in intact ACL knees. ATT and PTT was significantly greater in ruptured ACL knees than in PD or intact ACL knees, which were not significantly different. The sensitivity and specificity of normalized TTT to distinguish knees with intact from PD ACLs were both 100%. Normalized TTT to distinguish knees with PD from ruptured ACLs had a sensitivity and specificity of 100% and 92%, respectively. Intra- and inter-observer intra-class correlation coefficients were 0.84 or higher for all translations. This precise non-invasive technique to assess canine knee translational stability and ACL integrity permits repetitive, objective measurements for diagnostic use and to assess therapeutic intervention efficacy.

A comparison of joint stability between anterior cruciate intact and deficient knees: a new canine model of anterior cruciate ligament disruption

Transection of the canine anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is a well-established osteoarthritis (OA) model. This study evaluated a new method of canine ACL disruption as well as canine knee joint laxity and joint capsule (JC) contribution to joint stability at two time points (16 and 26 weeks) after ACL disruption (n=5/time interval). Ten crossbreed hounds were evaluated with force plate gait analysis and radiographs at intervals up to 34 weeks after monopolar radiofrequency energy (MRFE) treatment of one randomly selected ACL. Each contralateral ACL was sham treated. The MRFE treated ACLs ruptured approximately eight weeks (mean 52.5 days, SEM+/-1.0, range 48-56 days) after treatment. Gait analysis and radiographic changes were consistent with established canine ACL transection models of OA. Anterior-posterior (AP) translation and medial-lateral (ML) rotation were measured in each knee at 30 degrees, 60 degrees, and 90 degrees of flexion with and then without JC with loads of 40 N in AP translation and 4 Nm in ML rotation. A statistically significant interaction in AP translation included JC by cruciate (P=0.02), and there was a trend for a cruciate by time (P=0.07) interaction. Significant interactions in ML rotational testing included the presence of joint capsule (P=0.0001) and angle by cruciate (P=0.0012). This study describes a model in which canine ACLs predictably rupture approximately eight weeks after arthroscopic surgery and details the contribution of JC to canine knee stability in both ACL intact and deficient knees. The model presented here avoids the introduction of potential surgical variables at the time of ACL rupture and may contribute to studies of OA pathogenesis and inhibition. This model may also be useful for insight into the pathologic changes that occur in the knee as the ACL undergoes degeneration prior to rupture.

Fixed tibial subluxation after successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction results in improved function and stability in many patients. However, it is not known whether the improved stability is associated with an improved tibiofemoral relationship. We used stress radiographs to determine not only stability but also the tibiofemoral relationship in 15 patients who had a clinically successful anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Their results were compared with those of 14 volunteers with normal knees. The average Lysholm score for the patients was 94. None of the patients had more than 3 mm of side-to-side difference on KT-1000 arthrometer testing. Maximal anteroposterior tibial translation as measured by stress radiography was slightly increased in the reconstructed knees but was not statistically significantly different (6.6 +/- 3.2 mm versus 5.0 +/- 3.3 mm). However, with a posteriorly directed stress the tibia in the reconstructed knees did not translate posteriorly to the same extent as did the control knees, resulting in a significant difference in tibial position (-1.2 +/- 3.0 mm versus -4.0 +/- 3.3 mm). Surgical anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction may result in reduced anteroposterior tibial translation, accomplished, in part, through restraining posterior translation, leaving the tibia with persistent subluxation. Fibrosis and contracture of the posterior structures may explain this phenomenon.