Achieving interfragmentary compression without special drilling technique or screw design

Compression generated by cortical screws in an artificial bone model of an equine medial femoral condylar cyst

Objective

Determine compression generated by lag and neutral screws over 12 h using two bone analogs.

Study design

Experimental study.

Sample population

Bone analogs were made of composite synthetic bone (CSB) or three‐dimensional printed polylactic acid (PLA). Analogs had a 2 mm exterior shell with a 10 mm thick internal layer of open‐cell material.

Methods

Bone analogs were opposed, making a 4‐sided box with open ends. A central channel contained the sensor and the screws passed through it to engage both paired analogs. Four screw/analog conditions were tested: neutral and lag screw with bicortical engagement, neutral and lag screw with unicortical engagement. All screws were tightened to 2 Nm torque and compression values recorded at 0, 0.5, 1, 2, 6, and 12 h (six trials per condition). Medians were compared across groups for statistical significance.

Results

There was no difference in median compression between lag and neutral bicortical screws. For PLA, greater median compression was generated by neutral (median 437 N) and lag (median 379 N) bicortical screws compared to neutral unicortical screws (median 208 N, p < .001); lag bicortical screws generated greater median compression than lag unicortical screws (median 265 N, p = .012). For CSB, lag bicortical screws (median 293 N) generated greater median compression than neutral unicortical screws (median 228 N, p = .008).

Conclusion

Lag and neutral screws generated similar compression. Bicortical screws had higher median compression than unicortical screws in bone analogs.

Clinical significance

Neutral screws generate compression in cancellous bone analogs that can be increased with bicortical bone engagement.

The failure mode of a mechanically loaded equine medial femoral condyle analog with a void and the impact of lag and neutral screw placement

OBJECTIVE

To determine the failure method of simulated equine medial femoral condyle (MFC) subchondral bone defects under compression and the influence of screw placement on failure resistance.

STUDY DESIGN

In vitro study.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Composite disks (CD) simulating the moduli of yearling bone in the MFC.

METHODS

Four CD conditions were tested, all with a 12.7 mm void (n = 6 per condition): intact (no void), void only, void with a 4.5 mm screw placed in neutral fashion, and void with a 4.5 mm screw placed in lag fashion. Composite disks of each condition were tested under monotonic compression to 6000 N and cyclic compression to 10 000 cycles. Observable failure, load at first observable failure, and displacement at peak 2000 N load were compared among conditions.

RESULTS

Specimens failed by cracking at the superior aspect of the void or the screw exit hole. After monotonic loading, cracks were observed 6/6 CD with a void, 6/6 CD with a void/lag screw, and 5/6 CD with a void/neutral screw. After cyclical testing, cracks were noted only on the superior aspect of 6/6 CD with a void and 3/6 CD with a void/lag screw. Displacement at peak load was 0.06 mm (intact), 0.32 mm (void), 0.24 mm (void/lag screw), and 0.11 mm (void/neutral screw).

CONCLUSION

Model MFC voids failed by superior cracking that was resisted by lag and neutral screw placement.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

Neutral screws may be an acceptable treatment for subchondral lucencies in the MFC.