Starch granule stabilized Pickering emulsions: an 8-year stability study

From theoretical aspects to practical food Pickering emulsions: Formation, stabilization, and complexities linked to the use of colloidal food particles

We noticed that in literature, the term Pickering emulsion (PE) is used as soon as ingredients contain particles, and in this review, we ask ourselves if that is done rightfully so. The basic behavior taking place in particle-stabilized emulsions leads to the conclusion that the desorption energy of particles is generally high making particles highly suited to physically stabilize emulsions. Exceptions are particles with extreme contact angles or systems with very low interfacial tension. Particles used in food and biobased applications are soft, can deform when adsorbed, and most probably have molecules extending into both phases thus increasing desorption energy. Besides, surface-active components will be present either in the ingredients or generated by the emulsification process used, which will reduce the energy of desorption, either by reduced interfacial tension, or changes in the contact angle. In this paper, we describe the relative relevance of these aspects, and how to distinguish them in practice. Practical food emulsions may derive part of their stability from the presence of particles, but most likely have mixed interfaces, and are thus not PEs. Especially when small particles are used to stabilize (sub)micrometer droplets, emulsions may become unstable upon receiving a heat treatment. Stability can be enhanced by connecting the particles or creating network that spans the product, albeit this goes beyond classical Pickering stabilization. Through the architecture of PEs, special functionalities can be created, such as reduction of lipid oxidation, and controlled release features.

Deep-Eutectic-Solvent-in-Water Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by Starch Nanoparticles

Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have received extensive attention in green chemistry because of their ease of preparation, cost-effectiveness, and low toxicity. Pickering emulsions offer advantages such as long-term stability, low toxicity, and environmental friendliness. The oil phase in some Pickering emulsions is composed of solvents, and DESs can serve as a more effective alternative to these solvents. The combination of DESs and Pickering emulsions can improve the applications of green chemistry by reducing the use of harmful chemicals and enhancing sustainability. In this study, a Pickering emulsion consisting of a DES (menthol:octanoic acid = 1:1) in water was prepared and stabilized using starch nanoparticles (SNPs). The emulsion was thoroughly characterized using various techniques, including optical microscopy, transmission microscopy, laser particle size analysis, and rheological measurements. The results demonstrated that the DES-in-water Pickering emulsion stabilized by the SNPs had excellent stability and retained its structural integrity for more than 200 days at room temperature (20 °C). This prolonged stability has significant implications for many applications, particularly in the field of storage and transportation. This Pickering emulsion based on DESs and SNPs is sustainable and stable, and it has great potential to improve green chemistry practices in various fields.

Effect of ultrasonic power on delivery of quercetin in emulsions stabilized using octenyl succinic anhydride (OSA) modified broken japonica rice starch

In this study, emulsions stabilized by octenyl succinic anhydride-modified broken japonica rice starch (OSA-BJRS) were prepared at different ultrasonic power intensities for the delivery, controlled release, and improved bioavailability of quercetin. The OSA-BJRS emulsions ultrasonicated at 400 W exhibited the highest encapsulation efficiency (89.37 %) and loading efficiency (58.34 %) of quercetin, the smallest volume-average droplet diameter (0.51 μm) and polydispersity index (0.19), the highest absolute value of the ζ-potential (26.73 mV), and the highest apparent viscosity and viscoelasticity. The oxidation stability, storage stability, thermal stability, and salt ion stability of the emulsions were also notably improved by the ultrasonication treatment. In addition, the results of the simulated in vitro digestion demonstrated that the ultrasonicated OSA-BJRS emulsions had an enhanced quercetin delivery performance and could stably transport quercetin to the small intestine for digestion. The OSA-BJRS emulsion ultrasonicated at 400 W exhibited the highest cumulative release rate (95.91 %) and the highest bioavailability (30.48 %) of quercetin. This suggests that OSA-BJRS emulsions prepared by ultrasonication can be considered effective delivery systems for hydrophobic functional components.

Polymorphic nanostarch-mediated assembly of bioactives

Starch as an edible, biosafe, and functional biopolymer, has been tailored at nanoscale to deliver bioactive guests. Nanostarches fabricated in various morphologies including nanosphere, nanorod, nanoworm, nanovesicle, nanopolyhedron, nanoflake, nanonetwork etc., enable them to assemble different kinds of bioactives due to structural particularity and green modification. Previous studies have reviewed nanostarch for its preparation and application in food, however, no such work has been done for the potential of delivery system via polymorphic nanostarches. In this review, we focus on the merits of nanostarch empowered by multi-morphology for delivery system, and also conclude the assembly strategies and corresponding properties of nanostarch-based carrier. Additionally, the advantages, limitations, and future perspectives of polymorphic nanostarch are summarized to better understand the micro/nanostarch architectures and their regulation for the compatibility of bioactive molecules. According to the morphology of carrier, nanostarch effectively captures bioactives on the surface and/or inside core to form tight complexes, which maintains their stability in the human microenvironment. It improves the bioavailability of bioactive guests by different assembly approaches of carrier/guest surface combination, guest@carrier embedment, and nanostarch-mediated encapsulation. Targeted release of delivery systems is stimulated by the microenvironment conditions based on the complex structure of nanostarch loaded with bioactives.

Comparative study on the in vitro digestion of different lipids in starch-based Pickering emulsions

Starch-based Pickering stabilizer has attracted more attentions due to its health-friendly attribute. Lipid digestion in Pickering emulsion is the key to its delivery ability for active substances. Herein, in vitro oral-gastric-intestinal digestions of Pickering emulsions stabilized by starch particles with different oil phases (e.g., coconut, corn, olive, and sunflower oils) were investigated. The highest rate of lipid digestion was coconut oil (25.71 %), followed by olive (12.64 %), corn (11.16 %), and sunflower (8.99 %) oils. The lipid digestibility was influenced by saturation of fatty acids: coconut (91.41 %)>olive (16.58 %)>corn (14.63 %)>sunflower (10.85 %) oils. The increase of starch concentration (0.5 % - 4.0 %, w/w) had positive effects, while the increase of oil fraction (25 % - 70 %, v/v) had negative impacts on free fatty acid release due to the formation of different initial droplet sizes. The microstructures observed using confocal laser scanning microscope indicated that starch-based Pickering emulsion possessed super stability against oral and gastric digestions, which made it a superior delivery system for lipophilic active substances under severe gastric environment. These results may promote the design of functional food emulsions stabilized by starch particles which can regulate digestion of triglycerides.

Diffusion across particle-laden interfaces in Pickering droplets

Emulsions stabilized by nanoparticles, known as Pickering emulsions, exhibit remarkable stability, which enables applications ranging from encapsulation, to advanced materials, to chemical conversion. The layer of nanoparticles at the interface of Pickering droplets is a semi-permeable barrier between the two liquid phases, which can affect the rate of release of encapsulates, and the interfacial transfer of reactants and products in biphasic chemical conversion. A gap in our fundamental understanding of diffusion in multiphase systems with particle-laden interfaces currently limits the optimal development of these applications. To address this gap, we developed an experimental approach for in situ, real-time quantification of concentration fields in Pickering droplets in a Hele-Shaw geometry and investigated the effect of the layer of nanoparticles on diffusion of solute across a liquid-liquid interface. The experiments did not reveal a significant hindrance on the diffusion of solute across an interface densely covered by nanoparticles. We interpret this result using an unsteady diffusion model to predict the spatio-temporal evolution of the concentration of solute with a particle-laden interface. We find that the concentration field is only affected in the immediate vicinity of the layer of particles, where the area available for diffusion is affected by the particles. This defines a characteristic time scale for the problem, which is the time for diffusion across the layer of particles. The far-field concentration profile evolves towards that of a bare interface. This localized effect of the particle hindrance is not measurable in our experiments, which take place over a much longer time scale. Our model also predicts that the hindrance by particles can be more pronounced depending on the particle size and physicochemical properties of the liquids and can ultimately affect performance in applications.

Characterization of quinoa starch nanoparticles as a stabilizer for oil in water Pickering emulsion

Quinoa starch nanoparticles (QSNPs) prepared by nanoprecipitation had a uniform particle size of 191.20 nm. QSNPs with amorphous crystalline structure had greater contact angle than QS with orthorhombic crystalline structure, which can therefore be utilized to stabilize Pickering emulsions. QSNPs-based Pickering emulsions prepared by suitable formulations (QSNPs concentration of 2.0-2.5 %, oil volume fraction of 0.33-0.67) exhibited good stability against pH of 3-9 and ionic strength of 0-200 mM. The oxidative stability of the emulsions increased with increasing starch concentration and ionic strength. Microstructural and rheological results indicated that the structure of the starch interfacial film and the thickening effect of the water phase affected the emulsion stability. The emulsion had excellent freeze-thaw stability and can be produced as a re-dispersible dry emulsion using the freeze-drying technique. These results implied that the QSNPs had great potential for application in the preparation of Pickering emulsions.

Starch physical treatment, emulsion formation, stability, and their applications

Pickering emulsions are increasingly preferred over typical surfactant-based emulsions due to several advantages, such as lower emulsifier usage, simplicity, biocompatibility, and safety. These types of emulsions are stabilized using solid particles, which produce a thick layer at the oil-water interface preventing droplets from aggregating. Starch nano-particles (SNPs) have received considerable attention as natural alternatives to synthetic stabilizers due to their unique properties. Physical formulation processes are currently preferred for SNP production since they are environmentally friendly procedures that do not require the use of chemical reagents. This review provides a thorough overview in a critical perspective of the physical processes to produce starch nano-particles used as Pickering emulsion stabilizers, fabricated by a 2-step process. Specifically, the reviewed physical approaches for nano-starch preparation include high hydrostatic pressure, high pressure homogenization, ultrasonication, milling and antisolvent precipitation. All the essential parameters used to evaluate the effectiveness of particles in stabilizing these systems are also presented in detail, including the hydrophobicity, size, and content of starch particles. Finally, this review provides the basis for future research focusing on physical nano-starch production, to ensure the widespread use of these natural stabilizers in the ever-evolving field of food technology.

An "intelligent -responsive" bactericidal system based on OSA-starch Pickering emulsion

Pickering emulsion based on OSA-starch was developed in this study as an intelligent delivery system for the application of thymol against foodborne pathogens. Morphology and microstructure characterization showed that the Pickering emulsion was an O/W type emulsion and stayed stable at starch concentration of 200 mg/mL and oil fraction at 30 % with particle size of 10 μm and absolute Zeta potential of -12.5 mV. Low field nuclear magnetic resonance and rheology experiments indicated that a denser network structure was formed in this stable Pickering emulsion. Besides, the Pickering emulsion could endure long-time storage, low pH (3,5) and additional NaCl (50, 100, 200, 400 mM) and it showed enhanced bactericidal effects against Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus (thymol =1.48 μmol/L) and Aspergillus flavus (thymol = 0.624 μmol/L) by inducing ROS eruption, membrane lipid peroxidation and cell shrink. Moreover, the bactericidal assay demonstrated that thymol could be intelligently released and a considerable 75 % timely bactericidal effect was detected after 9 days' intermittently exposing to E. coli, S. aureus and A. flavus in vitro, by comparison thymol alone showed only 20 % bactericidal effect due to its volatility. The results are of great importance to offer an intelligent delivery system of bio-actives defending foodborne pathogens.

Preparation and Physico-Chemical Characterization of OSA-Modified Starches from Different Botanical Origins and Study on the Properties of Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by These Starches

Native starch (NS) from different botanical origins (native rice/tapioca/oat starch, NRS/NTS/NOS) were hydrophobically modified by octenyl succinic anhydride (OSA), and the octenyl succinic (OS) groups were successfully introduced in the starch molecules which obtained OS-starch (OSRS, OSTS and OSOS) with different levels of modification (0.5%, 1.0%, 1.5%, 2.0%, 2.5%, 3.0%) and degree of substitution (DS). The structural properties of the OS-starch, such as granule size, crystal, wettability and morphology were studied, and the OS-starch was used as particulate stabilizers to produce oil-in-water (O/W) Pickering emulsions. The emulsion index, droplet size distribution and microstructures of Pickering emulsions produced by different OS-starches were compared. OSA modification had almost no effect on the morphology or crystal structure types of three kinds of NS and OS-starch but markedly increased the contact angle and particle size distribution of OSRS, OSTS and OSOS. Esterification reaction of OSA and starch mainly occurred in amorphous regions of starch, and the OSA significantly improved the emulsifying capacity of OSRS, OSTS and OSOS granules and thus stabilized emulsions formed at higher levels (2.5% and 3.0%) of modification of OS-Starch exhibited better stability; the ability of OS-starch to stabilize Pickering emulsion was 3.0% OSRS > 3.0% OSOS > 3.0% OSTS, respectively. Observation and structural properties analysis of OS-starch granules and Pickering emulsion droplets showed that the number and thickness of the starch granules on the oil-water interface of the emulsion droplets increased with improvement of the OSA modification level, and an aggregation state was formed between the OS-starch granules, which was also enhanced with the OSA modification levels. These were all necessary for the Pickering emulsion stabilized by starch granules to remain in a steady state.

Effect of emulsification methods on the physicochemical properties of emulsion stabilized by calcium carbonate and sodium alginate

Our lab’s studies have found that heavy calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) with sodium alginate (SA) can synergistically stabilize Pickering emulsion. However, there were significant differences in the flow characteristics of the emulsions obtained by different preparation methods during storage. Herein, in this current work, Pickering emulsions were prepared by two-step emulsifying method (SA was added into the primary emulsion stabilized by CaCO₃ for secondary shearing, M1) and one-step emulsifying method (oil phase was added to homogeneous dispersed CaCO₃-SA solution for one-step shearing, M2), respectively. The particle size, microstructure, rheology and microrheological properties of these two kinds of emulsions and the interaction of CaCO₃ with SA were analyzed. The results showed that the droplet size of M1 emulsion was 21.78–49.62 μm, and that of M2 emulsion was 6.50–11.87 μm. M1 emulsion had stronger viscoelasticity, and could transform into a gel state during storage. However, M2 emulsion remained in flow condition all the time which was related to the interaction between SA and CaCO₃ in the aqueous phase.

Pickering Emulsion Stabilized by Tea Seed Cake Protein Nanoparticles as Lutein Carrier

To effectively deliver lutein, hydrothermally prepared tea seed cake protein nanoparticles (TSCPN) were used to fabricate Pickering emulsion, and the bioaccessibility of lutein encapsulated by Pickering emulsion and the conventional emulsion was evaluated in vitro. The results indicated that the average size and absolute value of zeta potential of TSCPN increased along with the increase in the protein concentration, and 2% protein concentration was adopted to prepare TSCPN. With the increase in the concentration of TSCPN, the size of Pickering emulsion decreased from 337.02 μm to 89.36 μm, and when the TSCPN concentration was greater than 0.6%, all emulsions exhibited good stability during the 14 days storage. Combined with the microstructure result, 1.2% TSCPN was used to stabilize Pickering emulsion. With the increase in ionic concentration (0-400 mM), the particle size of the emulsions increased while the absolute value of zeta potential decreased. TSCPN-based Pickering emulsion was superior to the conventional emulsion for both lutein encapsulation (96.6 ± 1.0% vs. 82.1 ± 1.4%) and bioaccessibility (56.0 ± 1.1% vs. 35.2 ± 1.2%). Thus, TSCPN-based Pickering emulsion in this study have the potential as an effective carrier for lutein.

Oxidative stability of Pickering emulsions

•

Oxidative stability of O/W Pickering emulsions depends on their interfacial layer.

•

Solid particles can reduce Pickering emulsion oxidation by creating a thick interface.

•

Manipulating the charge of the interface can control Pickering emulsion oxidation.

•

Adding antioxidants to solid particles can reduce oxidation in Pickering emulsions.

In recent years, Pickering emulsions have been the focus of growing interest because of their possible role as alternatives to conventional emulsions. Some reviews have investigated the physical stability of Pickering emulsions, but the oxidative stability of these emulsions remains largely unexplored. In this review, the oxidation mechanism and factors affecting lipid oxidation rates in Pickering emulsions are discussed. Then, different food-grade solid particles are evaluated for their ability to stabilize Pickering emulsions. Finally, several strategies are reviewed for improving the oxidative stability of Pickering emulsions. These strategies are based on efforts to manipulate the physical and chemical properties of the interfacial layer, increase the concentration of antioxidants at the interfacial layer through incorporating them into solid particles, cause oil droplets to crowd at high packing fractions, trap oil droplets in a gel network and increase the viscosity of the continuous phase.

Pickering emulsion stabilized by composite-modified waxy corn starch particles

The starch-based Pickering stabilizer has attracted more research interest recently, however, its application in food system is limited due to the low digestibility of raw starch particles. In this study, waxy corn starches were modified with octenyl succinic anhydride and then treated by dry heating at 180 °C for 20-60 min. Pickering emulsions stabilized by the composite-modified starch particles were fabricated, the physical stability, rheology property and microstructure of the emulsions were investigated. The results showed that the composite-modified starches maintained granule structure, their gelatinization temperatures and enthalpy significantly reduced after heat treatment (p < 0.05). Compared with native starch, the composite-modified starches had bigger three-phase contact angles and higher in vitro digestibility, while the relative crystallinity decreased from 32.46% to 24.87%. Pickering emulsions stabilized by composite-modified starch particles had long-term stability up to 300 days. The rheology results showed that all emulsions exhibited pseudoplastic behaviors and had higher storage modulus than loss modulus. Moreover, the viscosities decreased when the starch was roasted for 40 and 60 min. The composite-modified starch particles and few starch macromolecules at oil-water interface stabilized the emulsions collectively. These results provide a new strategy for designing an edible Pickering stabilizer.

Development and characterization of medium and high internal phase novel multiple Pickering emulsions stabilized by hordein nanoparticles

Medium and high internal phase W₁/O/W₂ multiple Pickering emulsions (MPEs) were fabricated by physically-modified hordein nanoparticles. A triphasic system was developed at dispersed phase volume fraction (Φ) of 0.5 with an overrun value of ∼40%. No overrun was detected in high internal phase MPEs (Φ 0.8). Optical and confocal laser scanning microscopy confirmed the formation of MPEs. Monomodal droplet size distribution with a mean diameter of 32.90 and 21.48 μm was observed for MPEs at Φ 0.5 and Φ 0.8, respectively. Static multiple light scattering confirmed that creaming was the main mechanism behind the instability of MPEs. Both MPEs revealed pseudo-plastic behavior and predominant storage modulus (G') over the applied frequency range. The encapsulation efficiency of vitamin B₁₂ in MPEs was 98.3% and remained relatively constant during 28 d. These results suggested the excellent potential of hordein nanoparticles as appropriate candidate for designing multi-structural colloidal systems using plant proteins.

Recent progress in Pickering emulsions stabilised by bioderived particles

In recent years, the demand for non-surfactant based Pickering emulsions in many industrial applications has grown significantly because of the option to select biodegradable and sustainable materials with low toxicity as emulsion stabilisers. Usually, emulsions are a dispersion system, where synthetic surfactants or macromolecules stabilise two immiscible phases (typically water and oil phases) to prevent coalescence. However, synthetic surfactants are not always a suitable choice in some applications, especially in pharmaceuticals, food and cosmetics, due to toxicity and lack of compatibility and biodegradability. Therefore, this review reports recent literature (2018-2021) on the use of comparatively safer biodegradable polysaccharide particles, proteins, lipids and combinations of these species in various Pickering emulsion formulations. Also, an overview of the various tuneable factors associated with the functionalisation or surface modification of these solid particles, that govern the stability of the Pickering emulsions is provided.

Resveratrol loaded Pickering emulsions stabilized by OSA modified rice starch granules

Resveratrol is a photosensitive, bioactive molecule which has received increasing research interest during the past decade for its antioxidant properties. However, it has low solubility in water or common triglyceride oils. Resveratrol solubilization in oil can only be achieved in essential oils, such as flavour oils, but the stability of emulsions produced with this type of oils is low as they are prone to creaming phenomena and Oswald ripening. In this study, resveratrol was first dissolved in orange oil which was mixed into a medium-chain triglyceride (Miglyol) at different ratios and used as the internal phase of oil-in-water emulsions (O/W). The emulsions were stabilized by octenyl succinic anhydride (OSA) modified rice starch granules using two different ratios of starch particle:oil to study the influence of interfacial coverage on the final emulsion droplet size and emulsion stability. The results of this study indicated that stable Pickering emulsions could be prepared using OSA-modified rice starch granules even at partial coverage conditions. Emulsions prepared at an oil fraction of 0.5 using 30% v/v mixture of orange oil in Miglyol as the dispersed phase seemed to be an appropriate resveratrol carrier system, obtaining encapsulation efficiency values close to 90% which results in emulsions with a resveratrol concentration of 8.45 mg/L. Hence, the emulsions prepared are suitable for food fortification applications.

Electrostatic pair-interaction of nearby metal or metal-coated colloids at fluid interfaces

In this paper, we theoretically study the electrostatic interaction between a pair of identical colloids with constant surface potentials sitting in close vicinity next to each other at the fluid interface. By employing a simplified yet reasonable model system, the problem is solved within the framework of classical density functional theory and linearized as well as nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) theory. Apart from providing a sound theoretical framework generally applicable to any such problem, our novel findings, all of which contradict common beliefs, include the following: first, quantitative and qualitative differences between the interactions obtained within the linear and the nonlinear PB theories; second, the importance of the electrostatic interaction between the omnipresent three-phase contact lines in interfacial systems; and, third, the occurrence of an attractive electrostatic interaction between a pair of identical metal colloids. The unusual attraction we report largely stems from an attractive line interaction, which although scales linearly with the size of the particle can compete with the surface interactions and can be strong enough to alter the nature of the total electrostatic interaction. Our results should find applications in metal or metal-coated particle-stabilized emulsions where densely packed particle arrays are not only frequently observed but also sometimes required.