A comparison of two methods of endoscopic dilation of acute subglottic stenosis using a ferret model

Establishing an Endoscopic Chronic Subglottic Stenosis Rabbit Model

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To develop a reproducible and consistent chronic subglottic stenosis (SGS) in an endoscopic animal model.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective study.

METHODS

We conducted a prospective study using New Zealand white rabbits. Chronic SGS was induced endoscopically by Bugbee electrocautery to 50% to 75% of the subglottic area's circumference, followed by 4-hour endotracheal intubation. The rabbit airways were endoscopically assessed and sized with uncuffed endotracheal tubes (ETTs) before the injury, during follow-up, and at the endpoints. There were four endpoints: 2, 4, 6, and 8 weeks post SGS induction. Animals were humanely euthanized for histopathological examination of the subglottic injury site and microscopic measurement of the cricoid lumen.

RESULTS

Twenty-two rabbits reached the endpoints, and 18 rabbits developed chronic SGS. ETT size significantly decreased by 0.5 from preinjury to the endpoint in all groups, P < .001. Control median cricoid lumen measurements were 20.48 mm² , the median cricoid lumen measurement for the 2 weeks endpoint was 14.3 mm² , 4 weeks 11.69 mm² , 6 weeks 16.03 mm² , and 8 weeks endpoint median was 16.33 mm² . Histopathological examination showed chronic scar tissue and new cartilage formation at the cricoid level, mainly at the posterior subglottic injury site starting from 4 weeks postinjury. Collagen staining revealed substantial amounts of organized collagen and different collagen orientation starting 4 weeks postinjury lasting until 8 weeks postinjury.

CONCLUSION

We developed an animal model to study chronic SGS. This model will be utilized to compare different endoscopic treatment interventions in acute SGS versus chronic SGS and further define the molecular basis of SGS.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 2021.

Subglottic Stenosis: Development of a Clinically Relevant Endoscopic Animal Model

OBJECTIVE

Develop a clinically relevant and reproducible endoscopic animal model for subglottic stenosis amenable to testing of minimally invasive therapeutic modalities.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study.

SETTING

Division of Laboratory Animals Research, University of Pittsburgh.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Subglottic stenosis was induced endoscopically via microsuspension laryngoscopy in 26 New Zealand white rabbits. A trimmed polypropylene brush connected to a novel electronic stenosis induction apparatus was used to create circumferential trauma to the subglottis. By using open source image analysis software, the cross-sectional areas of the stenotic and native airways were compared to calculate the percentage of stenosis and the Myer-Cotton classification grade.

RESULTS

Of the 26 rabbits, 24 (92%) exhibited stenosis after the first attempt. The mean percentage of airway stenosis was 57% (range, 34%-85%; SD, 15%). Five rabbits (19.2%) died on the day of stenosis induction from procedural complications. Of the 21 rabbits, 2 demonstrated no stenosis 7 days after initial injury and so underwent reinduction of airway injury, upon which they developed stenosis. Overall, 14 of the 21 rabbits (67%) exhibited moderate to severe stenosis (grade 2 or 3).

CONCLUSION

The stenosis induction apparatus reliably induced stenosis with a low mortality rate as compared with that of other methods in the literature. The device could be improved to generate a predetermined potentially reproducible grade of stenosis as desired by the operator. This method sets the stage for a clinically relevant and reproducible subglottic stenosis disease model that is amenable to testing of minimally invasive treatment modalities.

Development of a survival animal model for subglottic stenosis

OBJECTIVE

To develop a reproducible survival animal model for subglottic stenosis.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective study.

METHODS

We evaluated five methods of inducing airway injury in 30 New Zealand white rabbits to produce a subglottic stenosis model. Experimental groups comprised: group 1 (n = 5), which underwent 4-hour intubation; group 2 (n = 5), which underwent induced subglottic injury with a nylon brush; group 3 (n = 10), which underwent subglottic injury with a nylon brush, followed by 4-hour intubation; group 4 (n = 5), which underwent subglottic injury with Bugbee cautery in 50% of the subglottic circumference, followed by 4-hour intubation; and group 5 (n = 5), which underwent subglottic injury with Bugbee cautery in 75% of the subglottic circumference, followed by 4-hour intubation. Five animals were used as controls. Endoscopy of the airway and sacrifice of animals were planned at an interval of 14 days postinjury. Histologic measurements were analyzed.

RESULTS

No animals in groups 1 or 2 developed stenosis. In group 3, 50% of animals developed symptomatic grade 3 subglottic and tracheal stenosis, necessitating early endoscopy and sacrifice in three animals. Four animals in group 4 developed grade 1 subglottic stenosis, and four in group 5 developed grade 2 subglottic stenosis. Histologic measurements of lumen areas within each of these two groups were similar; all animals survived the follow-up period.

CONCLUSION

We successfully developed a reproducible survival model for induced subglottic stenosis using a combination of cautery-induced subglottic injury followed by 4-hour intubation. This model lays the foundation for future studies that evaluate endoscopic interventions for the management of subglottic stenosis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 129:989-994, 2019.