Comparison of the efficacy of endoscopic tympanoplasty and microscopic tympanoplasty: A systematic review and meta-analysis

A 3D and Explainable Artificial Intelligence Model for Evaluation of Chronic Otitis Media Based on Temporal Bone Computed Tomography: Model Development, Validation, and Clinical Application

BACKGROUND

Temporal bone computed tomography (CT) helps diagnose chronic otitis media (COM). However, its interpretation requires training and expertise. Artificial intelligence (AI) can help clinicians evaluate COM through CT scans, but existing models lack transparency and may not fully leverage multidimensional diagnostic information.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to develop an explainable AI system based on 3D convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for automatic CT-based evaluation of COM.

METHODS

Temporal bone CT scans were retrospectively obtained from patients operated for COM between December 2015 and July 2021 at 2 independent institutes. A region of interest encompassing the middle ear was automatically segmented, and 3D CNNs were subsequently trained to identify pathological ears and cholesteatoma. An ablation study was performed to refine model architecture. Benchmark tests were conducted against a baseline 2D model and 7 clinical experts. Model performance was measured through cross-validation and external validation. Heat maps, generated using Gradient-Weighted Class Activation Mapping, were used to highlight critical decision-making regions. Finally, the AI system was assessed with a prospective cohort to aid clinicians in preoperative COM assessment.

RESULTS

Internal and external data sets contained 1661 and 108 patients (3153 and 211 eligible ears), respectively. The 3D model exhibited decent performance with mean areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves of 0.96 (SD 0.01) and 0.93 (SD 0.01), and mean accuracies of 0.878 (SD 0.017) and 0.843 (SD 0.015), respectively, for detecting pathological ears on the 2 data sets. Similar outcomes were observed for cholesteatoma identification (mean area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.85, SD 0.03 and 0.83, SD 0.05; mean accuracies 0.783, SD 0.04 and 0.813, SD 0.033, respectively). The proposed 3D model achieved a commendable balance between performance and network size relative to alternative models. It significantly outperformed the 2D approach in detecting COM (P≤.05) and exhibited a substantial gain in identifying cholesteatoma (P<.001). The model also demonstrated superior diagnostic capabilities over resident fellows and the attending otologist (P<.05), rivaling all senior clinicians in both tasks. The generated heat maps properly highlighted the middle ear and mastoid regions, aligning with human knowledge in interpreting temporal bone CT. The resulting AI system achieved an accuracy of 81.8% in generating preoperative diagnoses for 121 patients and contributed to clinical decision-making in 90.1% cases.

CONCLUSIONS

We present a 3D CNN model trained to detect pathological changes and identify cholesteatoma via temporal bone CT scans. In both tasks, this model significantly outperforms the baseline 2D approach, achieving levels comparable with or surpassing those of human experts. The model also exhibits decent generalizability and enhanced comprehensibility. This AI system facilitates automatic COM assessment and shows promising viability in real-world clinical settings. These findings underscore AI's potential as a valuable aid for clinicians in COM evaluation.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Chinese Clinical Trial Registry ChiCTR2000036300; https://www.chictr.org.cn/showprojEN.html?proj=58685.

Endoscopic Versus Microscopic Tympanoplasty: A Systematic Review and Metanalysis

OBJECTIVE

Endoscopic ear surgery is no longer a promising technique, but a well-established one. This study aims to compare endoscopic and microscopic tympanoplasty based on current literature evidence, in terms of their efficacy and safety characteristics.

DATA SOURCES

We conducted a systematic literature search of four medical databases (Pubmed, Cochrane Library, Scopus, ClinicalTrials.gov), focusing on randomized controlled or observational studies comparing microscopic to endoscopic tympanoplasty.

REVIEW METHODS

Data related to the efficacy and safety of each technique were extracted. Outcome data were summarized using pooled mean differences or pooled odds ratio along with their 95% confidence intervals. The risk of bias was estimated, by using the ROBINS-I and RoB-II assessment tools, while the overall quality of evidence was evaluated according to the GRADE working group.

RESULTS

Thirty-three studies, with 2646 patients in total, were included in the meta-analysis. Success rate was evaluated by estimating tympanic graft failure (pooled mean difference:-0.23; 95% CI: -0.61, 0.14, I2 = 33.42%), and air-bone gap improvement (pooled mean difference:-0.05; 95% CI:-0.23, 0.13, I2 = 52.69%), resulting in comparable outcomes for the two techniques. A statistically significant difference favoring the endoscopic technique was detected regarding postoperative wound infection (OR: -1.72; 95% CI: -3.39, -0.04, I2 = 0%), dysgeusia (OR: -1.47; 95% CI: -2.47, -0.47, I2 = 0%), otitis externa development (OR: -1.96; 95% CI: -3.23, -0.69, I2 = 0%), auricular numbness (OR: -2.56; 95% CI: -3.93, -1.19, I2 = 0%), as well as surgical duration (OR: -1.86; 95% CI: -2.70, -1.02, I2 = 43.95%), when compared to the postauricular microscopic approach.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic tympanoplasty is an innovative alternative to the microscopic technique, resulting in commensurate outcomes regarding success rate. Furthermore, it offers superior results concerning postoperative complications, while it presents a significant reduction in the duration of surgery, mainly when it is compared to the postauricular microscopic approach.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 134:3466-3476, 2024.

Comparison of endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy in the same patients: a prospective randomized controlled trial

PURPOSE

This study aimed to conduct a comparative analysis of audiological and postoperative clinical outcomes between the endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy approaches.

METHODS

This study employed a randomized, controlled design. Twenty-seven patients with bilateral otosclerosis underwent stapedotomy in both ears, with randomized allocation of the surgical technique (endoscopic vs. microscopic) for the first operated ear. Air-bone gap (ABG) and ABG gain were measured at least 12 months postoperatively. Postoperative outcomes including pain (Visual Analog Scale-VAS), dizziness, early-term (day 1) and late-term (6 months) dysgeusia were evaluated. The Glasgow Benefit Inventory (GBI) assessed health-related quality of life at one month postoperatively, and operative time was measured.

RESULTS

This study compared endoscopic (n = 27 ears) and microscopic (n = 27 ears) stapedotomy for otosclerosis. Both groups achieved similar hearing improvement with no significant differences in pre-operative and post-operative bone/air conduction thresholds, ABG, and ABG gain (all p > 0.05). The endoscopic stapedotomy group demonstrated reduced postoperative pain (lower VAS scores, p < 0.001), lower early dysgeusia (3.7% vs. 33.3%, p = 0.005), shorter operative time (47.3 vs. 75.4 min, p < 0.001) and improved patient-reported outcomes (higher GBI score, p = 0.014) when compared to microscopic stapedotomy group. No significant differences were observed in postoperative dizziness or late-term dysgeusia between groups.

CONCLUSION

This study found similar hearing improvement with both endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy for otosclerosis. However, the endoscopic approach showed advantages in reduced postoperative pain, early dysgeusia, and operative time, with improved patient-reported quality of life. These findings suggest endoscopic stapedotomy as a valuable alternative to the conventional microscopic approach.

Outcomes After Exoscopic Versus Microscopic Type 1 Tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the outcomes of exoscopic versus microscopic type 1 tympanoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

Tertiary care otology-neurotology practice.

PATIENTS

Adult subjects with a diagnosis of tympanic membrane perforation from 2018 to 2022.

INTERVENTION

Exoscopic or microscopic tympanoplasty with cartilage + perichondrium or perichondrium/fascia graft.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Primary outcomes were graft success rate (1 wk, 3 wk, 3 mo, and 6 mo postoperatively) and operative time. Secondary outcomes included audiometric outcomes of postoperative air-bone gap (ABG), change in ABG, pure tone average (PTA), speech reception threshold (SRT), and word recognition score (WRS) at 6-month follow-up and complication rates of cerebrospinal fluid leak, facial nerve injury, persistent tinnitus, and persistent vertigo.

RESULTS

Seventy-one patients underwent type 1 tympanoplasty by a single surgeon. Thirty-six patients underwent exoscopic tympanoplasty, and 35 patients underwent microscopic tympanoplasty. Cartilage and perichondrium were utilized in 27 subjects (75.0%) in the exoscopic group and in 25 subjects (71.4%) in the microscopic group (p = 0.7, Cramer's V = 0.04). Graft success rate was as follows (exoscope versus microscope): 100% (36/36) versus 100% (35/35) at 1 week (p = 1.0, Cramer's V = 0.0), 97.2% (35/36) versus 100% (35/35) at 3 weeks (p = 1.0, Cramer's V = 0.1), 97.2% (35/36) versus 94.3% (33/35) at 3 months (p = 1.0, Cramer's V = 0.07), and 91.7% (33/36) versus 91.4% (32/35) at 6 months (p = 0.7, Cramer's V = 0.0). Operative time was 57.7 minutes for the exoscopic group and 65.4 minutes for the microscopic group (p = 0.08, 95% CI [-16.4, 0.9], Cohen's d = 0.4). There were no serious complications. All preoperative and postoperative audiometric outcomes were comparable.

CONCLUSIONS

The outcomes after exoscopic versus microscopic type 1 tympanoplasty are comparable.

To detach or not to detach the umbo in type I tympanoplasty: functional results

PURPOSE

To compare the audiological outcomes, tympanic membrane (TM) healing rates and complication rates in patients undergoing endoscopic underlay and over-under tympanoplasty type I (TTI).

METHODS

The study includes 95 patients who underwent endoscopic TTI in the period between 2018 and 2023: 56% of the patients had the underlay technique and 41% had the over-under technique. Data regarding pre- and postoperative hearing, perforation characteristics, surgical procedures, graft types and complications were retrospectively analyzed. Audiometrical assessment included air conduction (AC) and bone conduction (BC) pure tone averages (PTA) and air-bone gap (ABG), pre- and postoperatively.

RESULTS

Both underlay and over-under techniques significant improved AC PTA, with a mean ABG improvements of 5.9 dB and 7.2 dB, respectively. There was no significant difference in BC PTA between pre- and post-operative, indicating no inner ear damage in both techniques. The over-under technique showed a significantly higher TM closure rate (94.4%) compared to the underlay technique (80.6%). Complications were rare, with only one case of TM lateralization requiring revision surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic TTI is an effective treatment in improving auditory function in chronic middle ear diseases. In our cohort, the detachment of the umbo does not negatively influence the postoperative hearing results and does not increase rate of complications. Moreover, the over-under technique demonstrates superior TM closure rates, making it a valuable option for specific cases. However, future prospective studies with larger sample sizes and longer term follow-up are needed to validate these findings and provide more comprehensive insights.

Validity of endoscopic ossiculoplasty immediately after its introduction for ossicular chain disruption

BACKGROUND

Transcanal endoscopic ear surgery (TEES) reportedly requires a long learning curve and may be associated with more complications and longer operative times than microscopic ear surgery (MES). In this study, we aimed to examine the usefulness and validity of TEES for ossicular chain disruption in the early stages of its introduction in our institution.

METHODS

TEES was performed on 11 ears (10 with congenital ossicular chain discontinuity and 1 with traumatic ossicular chain dislocation), and MES was performed with a retroauricular incision on 18 ears (6 with congenital ossicular chain discontinuity and 12 with traumatic ossicular chain dislocation) in a tertiary referral center. Postoperative hearing results, operative times, and postoperative hospital length of stay were retrospectively reviewed. The Mann-Whitney U test and Fisher's exact test was performed to compare variables between the TEES and MES groups. Pre- and postoperative air- and bone-conduction thresholds and the air-bone gap of each group were compared using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. The Mann-Whitney U test and Wilcoxon signed-rank was performed to compare the pre- and postoperative air-bone gaps between the diagnoses.

RESULTS

No significant differences in the postoperative air-conduction thresholds, bone-conduction thresholds, air-bone gaps, or incidence of air-bone gap ≤ 20 dB were observed between the TEES and MES groups. The air-conduction thresholds and air-bone gaps of the TEES group significantly improved postoperatively. The air-conduction thresholds and air-bone gaps of the MES group also significantly improved postoperatively. No significant difference was observed in the operative times between the groups (TEES group: median, 80 min; MES group: median, 85.5 min). The TEES group had a significantly shorter postoperative hospital stay (median, 2 days) than the MES group (median, 7.5 days).

CONCLUSIONS

TEES was considered appropriate for the treatment of ossicular chain disruption, even immediately after its introduction at our institution. For expert microscopic ear surgeons, ossicular chain disruption may be considered a suitable indication for the introduction of TEES.

Comparison of endoscope-assisted and microscope-assisted type I tympanoplasty; a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To analyze and compare the available data about the outcomes of endoscopic and microscopic type I tympanoplasty.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Cochrane library Ovid, Scopus, Google scholar, and ClinicalTrials.

METHODS

We conducted a meta-analysis in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. We included comparative studies describing type I tympanoplasty, and comparing surgical outcomes of the endoscope with the microscope in terms of efficacy and safety.

RESULTS

Our systematic search yielded 22 studies meeting the inclusion criteria and eligible for analysis. The pooled graft uptake rates and audiological results of endoscopic and microscopic tympanoplasty demonstrated non-significant differences. In contrast, endoscopic type I tympanoplasty outperforms microscopic tympanoplasty regarding a highly significant decrease not only in pooled mean operative time but also in the pooled complications rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on our meta-analysis, the surgical outcomes of endoscope-assisted and microscope-assisted type I tympanoplasty in terms of postoperative hearing outcomes and the graft uptake rate were comparable. On the contrary, operative time and complications rate proved to be significantly reduced with endoscopy compared to microscopy. Hence, the endoscope is as efficient as the microscope in type I tympanoplasty but less invasive, fewer in complications and shorter in operative time.

Endoscopic Versus Microscopic Type I Tympanoplasty: An Updated Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing the clinical outcomes after endoscopic and microscopic type I tympanoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled trials, two-arm prospective studies, and retrospective studies were included.

SETTING

Medline, Cochrane, EMBASE, and Google Scholar databases were searched until March 1, 2022 using the combinations of search terms: "endoscopic," "microscopic," and "tympanoplasty."

METHODS

Two independent reviewers utilized the abovementioned search strategy to identify eligible studies. If any uncertainty existed regarding eligibility, a third reviewer was consulted. Primary outcome measures were graft success rate, air-bone gap (ABG) improvement, and operative time. Secondary outcomes were the rate of need for canalplasty, the proportion of self-rated excellent cosmetic results, and pain visual analog scale (VAS).

RESULTS

Forty-three studies enrolled a total of 3712 patients who were undergoing type I tympanoplasty and were finally included. The pooled result showed endoscopic approach was significantly associated with shorter operative time (difference in means: -20.021, 95% confidence interval [CI]: -31.431 to -8.611), less need for canalplasty (odds ratio [OR]: 0.065, 95% CI: 0.026-0.164), more self-rated excellent cosmetic results (OR: 87.323, 95% CI: 26.750-285.063), and lower pain VAS (difference in means: -2.513, 95% CI: -4.737 to -0.228). No significant differences in graft success rate or ABG were observed between the two procedures.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic type I tympanoplasty provides a similar graft success rate, improvement in ABG, and reperforation rate to microscopic tympanoplasty with a shorter operative time, better self-rated cosmetic results, and less pain. Unless contraindicated, the endoscopic approach should be the procedure of choice in type I tympanoplasty.

Endoscopic Tympanoplasty as an Alternative to Microscopic Tympanoplasty: A Comparative Study on Surgical Outcomes and patient satisfaction

Background

Chronic otitis media treatment has evolved, with microscopic surgeries as the gold standard and endoscopic surgeries as a newer addition.

Materials and Methods

This retrospective study includes 209 patients who underwent type 1 tympanoplasty, utilizing both endoscopic and microscopic techniques, between January 2019 and December 2022 at a tertiary care institute in India. The study aims to compare hearing outcomes, graft uptake, hospital stay, postoperative pain, and cosmesis between the two groups.

Results

Mean AB gap closure was 17.09 + 5.98 dB in the endoscopic group and 16.74 + 5.05 dB in the microscopic group (P = 0.687). The duration of surgery was 79.26 ± 17.37 min in the Endoscopic group and 91.92 ± 15.35 min in the Microscopic group. (P = < 0.00001). The Endoscopic group experienced less post-operative pain, shorter hospital stay (P = < 0.00001, P = 0.0008), and exhibited better cosmetic outcomes (P = 0.00001) compared to the microscopic group.

Conclusion

Endoscopic tympanoplasty is a better alternative to microscopic tympanoplasty, delivering comparable hearing outcomes, shorter surgical duration, improved pain scores, and better cosmesis.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12070-023-04184-4.

Does myringosclerosis affect the success of butterfly myringoplasty?

OBJECTIVES

Butterfly inlay myringoplasty is a simple and practical surgical technique used in the repair of tympanic membrane perforation offering good outcomes in terms of hearing. The present study evaluates the effects of myringosclerosis on the success of surgery by reviewing demographic data, perforation size and hearing outcomes of patients undergoing endoscopic inlay butterfly myringoplasty due to chronic otitis media.

METHODS

The study included 75 patients who underwent endoscopic inlay butterfly myringoplasty with the diagnosis of chronic suppurative otitis media in the Department of Otorhinolaryngology at Fırat University Faculty of Medicine between March 2018 and July 2021. The patients were divided into three groups as the following. Group I: Patients without a myringosclerotic focus in the neighborhood of tympanic membrane perforation, Group II: Patients with a less than 50% myringosclerotic focus in the neighborhood of tympanic membrane, and Group III: Patients with a more than 50% myringosclerotic focus in the neighborhood of tympanic membrane.

RESULTS

The comparison of all preoperative and postoperative parameters and the reduction in air-bone gap between the groups did not show statistically significant difference (p>0.05). The comparison of air-bone gaps between preoperative and postoperative measurements showed a statistically significant difference in all groups (p<0.05). The grafting success rate was 100% in Group I, 96.4% in Group II, and 95.6% in Group III. The mean operation time was 28.57±2.54 min in Group I, 32.14±2.44 min in Group II, and 30.69±3.43 in Group III; there was a statistically significant difference only between Group I and Group II (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The graft success rate and hearing gain in patients with myringosclerosis were similar to those in patients without myringosclerosis. Therefore, butterfly inlay myringoplasty is applicable to patients with chronic otitis media regardless of the presence or absence of myringosclerosis.

Opioid stewardship and perioperative management of pediatric tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To provide insight into the intraoperative management, admission course, pain management, and graft success of microscope- and endoscope-assisted tympanoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective Chart Review.

METHODS

This study included children 18 years and younger who underwent ambulatory tympanoplasty at a tertiary pediatric hospital between January 2018 and December 2020. Medical records were reviewed and information about intraoperative factors, surgical approach, laterality, complications, and post-operative perforation closure success rates was collected. Multivariate analysis was performed to compare and contrast the two surgical approaches.

RESULTS

The review included 321 pediatric patients who underwent a tympanoplasty. Endoscopic tympanoplasty accounted for 17.4%, while microscopic tympanoplasty accounted for 82.6%. In both approaches, the rate of intraoperative complications, postoperative complications, audiological improvements, and perforation closure success rates were statistically similar. However, patients who underwent endoscopic tympanoplasty were 3.96 times less likely to require opioids in the post-anesthesia care unit (PACU) and had a shorter post-operative admission length. This pattern emerged regardless of the type of graft used. Obtaining an autograft was not associated with a higher opioid requirement in the PACU.

CONCLUSION

While both approaches are viable, our findings demonstrate the reduced need for opioids with similar success rates following an endoscopic tympanoplasty. Ultimately, the trade-off for the minimally invasive endoscopic approach appears to be a less painful experience for the child while promoting clinically appropriate opioid stewardship in the perioperative setting.

Application of Machine Learning to Predict Hearing Outcomes of Tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVE

This retrospective study aimed to evaluate the performance of machine learning techniques in predicting air-bone gap after tympanoplasty compared with conventional scoring models and to identify the influential factors.

METHODS

We reviewed the charts of 105 patients (114 ears) with chronic otitis media who underwent tympanoplasty. Two numerical scoring systems (middle ear risk index [MERI] and ossiculoplasty outcome parameter staging [OOPS]) and three algorithms (random forest [RF], support vector machine [SVM], and k nearest neighbor [kNN]) were created. Experimental variables included age, preoperative air-bone gap, soft-tissue density lesion in the tympanic cavity in CT, otorrhea, surgical history, ossicular bone problems in CT, tympanic perforation location, perforation type (central or marginal), grafting material, smoking history, endoscopy use, and the operator whose experience was 20 years or longer, or shorter. Binary classification, postoperative air-bone gap ≤15 or >15 dB, and multiclass classification, classification into seven categories by 10 dB, were performed, and the percentages of correct prediction were calculated. The importance of features in the RF model was calculated to identify influential factors.

RESULTS

The percentages of correct prediction in binary classification were 62.3%, 72.8%, 81.5%, 81.5%, and 81.5% in MERI, OOPS, RF, SVM, and kNN, respectively, and those in multiclass classification were 29.8%, 21.9%, 63.1%, 44.7%, and 50% in the same order. The RF model suggested larger preoperative air-bone gap, and older age could make the postoperative air-bone gap larger.

CONCLUSION

The machine learning techniques, especially the RF model, are promising methods for precise postoperative air-bone gap prediction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 133:2371-2378, 2023.

Endaural microscopic approach versus endoscopic transcanal approach in treatment of attic cholesteatomas

PURPOSE

Compare the audiological results and postoperative outcomes of the endoscopic approach versus the endaural microscopic approach for treatment of attic cholesteatomas, using a randomized prospective model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eighty patients were consecutively enrolled in the study and randomized into two groups of treatment of 40 patients: Group A -tympanoplasty with a microscopic endaural approach; Group B -tympanoplasty with an exclusive trans-meatal endoscopic approach. Preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative outcomes were evaluated. Hearing was assessed preoperatively and at 1 month, 3 months and 6 months after surgery in both groups.

RESULTS

There were no differences in the parameters analyzed (CT findings, patient age, disease duration, intraoperative cholesteatoma characteristics,) between the group A and B patients. No statistical difference between the two groups regarding hearing improvement, abnormal taste sensation, dizziness, post-operative pain and healing times emerged. Graft success rate was 94.5 % and 92.1 % for MES and ESS respectively.

CONCLUSION

Both microscopic and exclusively endoscopic endaural approaches offer similar and excellent results in the surgical treatment of attic cholesteatomas.

Postoperative Outcomes of Endoscopic versus Microscopic Myringoplasty in Patients with Chronic Otitis Media-A Systematic Review

Endoscopes are increasingly being used in middle ear surgery as an adjunct to or replacement for the operative microscope. The superior visualization of hidden areas and a minimally invasive transcanal approach to the pathology are some of the endoscope's advantages. The aim of this review is to compare the surgical outcomes of a totally endoscopic transcanal approach with a conventional microscopic approach for type 1 tympanoplasty in patients with chronic otitis media (COM) in order to establish if endoscopic myringoplasty (EM) could be a better alternative to microscopic myringoplasty (MM). A literature review was performed using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis recommendations. The selected articles were identified by searching PubMed Central, PubMed, MEDLINE and Embase databases for the relevant publications. Only studies where the same surgeon in the department performed both endoscopic and microscopic myringoplasty have been included in the review. The results suggest that with an endoscopic approach, minimally invasive myringoplasty can be achieved with a similar graft success rate and postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) improvement, a shorter operative time and less postoperative complications compared to a microscopic approach.

Correlation of Eustachian tube function with the results of type 1 tympanoplasty: a prospective study

OBJECTIVES

This study aims to evaluate Eustachian tube (ET) function tests and their impact on outcomes of tympanoplasty in patients with inactive chronic suppurative otitis media.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective study was conducted involving patients diagnosed with chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) and having a central dry perforation. Assessment of the ET function was done for all included cases by three tests; pressure swallow equalization test, saccharine test and methylene blue test. The primary outcome is the graft success rate defined as intact graft without any residual perforation at 6 months postoperatively. Secondary outcomes include hearing assessment and possible associated complications.

RESULTS

64 patients were included in the study with an average age of 36.59 ± 11.96 years. All patients underwent assessment of the ET function by saccharine test, methylene blue test and pressure equalization test (PET) followed by microscopic post-auricular tympanoplasty. Successful tympanoplasty is achieved in 93.75% of cases with residual perforation in four patients. Mean air-bone gap is significantly improved from 23.73 ± 2.80 preoperatively to 10.93 ± 5.46 postoperatively. Results of Methylene blue test has no statistical impact on graft take rate (p value = 0.379), while saccharine test and pressure equalization test results have statistically significant correlation with graft success (p value ≤ 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Saccharine and Pressure equalization tests have a good positive correlation with the graft healing in tympanoplasty, while methylene blue test was found to have no correlation with the success rate.

Comparison between endoscopic and microscopic butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of endoscopic and microscopic approaches for butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasty regarding anatomical and hearing outcomes through a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

A search of PubMed, Embase, MEDLINE, and Virtual Health Library was performed from inception to July 3rd, 2021, using keywords, such as tympanoplasty, cartilage graft, and inlay technique. Data from articles that met inclusion criteria were extracted by two authors independently. The PRISMA statement was followed. RoB-2 and ROBINS-I tools were used to assess risk of bias. The primary outcome was tympanic membrane closure rate. The secondary outcome was improvement of the air-bone gap.

RESULTS

Five studies were included, one randomized clinical trial and four retrospective cohorts, in which a total of 318 patients were included. Graft take rate was 91.3% in the endoscopic group and 93.6% in the microscopic group (RR 0.98; 95% CI 0.93-1.03; I² 0%; P = 0.68). Four studies provided data about the secondary outcome, all showing significant reductions in air-bone gap, ranging from 5.7 to 11.0 in the endoscope group and from 5.8 to 11.6 in the microscope group, with a mean difference between groups of 0.85 (95% CI - 0.79 to 2.48).

CONCLUSION

Although the overall evidence of the included studies was low, endoscopic and microscopic butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasties have similar results on anatomical and hearing outcomes, making the selection between such approaches an individual choice for the surgeon.

Learning curve comparable study of microscopic and endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVES

The comparative efficacy of microscopic tympanoplasty (MT) and endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) has been widely studied to some extent through meta-analyses. However, most studies on learning curve comparisons between the two surgeries were performed by experienced ET surgeons. We compared the surgical outcomes of MT and ET and evaluated the difference of learning curve between ET and MT performed by a single unskilled, in both MT and ET, surgeon.

DESIGN

A total of 91 patients underwent ET and MT at a tertiary hospital. We reviewed the patients' medical records and analyzed all findings, including otoscopic pictures, pure tone audiometry (PTA) before and after surgery, and operation records. All operations were performed by a single otologist who had an experience of a year of otology fellowship at a tertiary university hospital. We compared the demographic and clinical characteristics, including age, sex, admission duration, and audiological outcomes before and after surgery. We also assessed the difference in the decrease in operation time.

RESULTS

Among 91 patients, 44 were in the ET group and 47 were in the MT group. The mean age was 51.15 years, and 37 (40.7%) were men. Eighty-two (90.1%) patients were administered local anesthesia. Graft failure was observed in 19 (20.9%) patients, and the mean postoperative follow-up duration was 66.42 days. There were no statistically significant differences in age, sex, affected side, graft failure rate, and operation time between the ET and MT groups. There was a significant improvement in air conduction hearing and air-bone gap after surgery in both groups. Bone conduction hearing did not change before and after the surgery in either group. However, the improvement in air condition and reduction in the air-bone gap did not differ between the two groups. Multivariate linear regression analysis showed that there were no significant variables that affected operation time among age, sex, operation method (ET or MT), anesthesia, graft material, and technique. The spline regression analysis showed the decrease in operative time in ET was significantly faster than MT in the period from 8th to 19th cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The surgical outcomes of ET are comparable to those of MT in terms of operation time, graft uptake, and postoperative hearing results, even in surgeons who are not experienced with both MT and ET. The operation time of ET was longer than that of MT in the early phase, and the decrease in the operating time was significantly faster in ET than in MT. Both MT and ET reached a plateau in the operation time, and this plateau appeared to be similar in both surgeries.

Endoscopic Versus Microscopic Pediatric Tympanoplasty: Is There a Difference Between Closure Rates and Hearing Outcomes?

OBJECTIVE

To compare closure rates and hearing outcomes of microscopic and endoscopic tympanoplasty in pediatric patients.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

Tertiary university medical center.

PATIENTS

Pediatric patients who underwent tympanoplasty surgery by a fellowship-trained neurotologist between 2010 and 2019 with a minimum of 2 months of follow-up, a tympanic membrane perforation, and no preoperative cholesteatoma.

INTERVENTIONS

Transcanal endoscopic tympanoplasty or microscopic tympanoplasty (MT) surgery.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome is postoperative closure of the tympanic membrane perforation, assessed using otomicroscopy at the last follow-up appointment. Secondary outcomes include operative time and changes in the air-bone gap (ABG) and pure-tone average (PTA).

RESULTS

Two hundred eleven tympanoplasty operations were analyzed: 121 in the transcanal endoscopic ear surgery (TEES) group and 90 in the MT group. Tympanic membrane closure rates were no different between the two groups (TEES, 82.6%; MT, 88.9%; p = 0.24), and no significant association was found on multivariable analysis (TEES: odds ratio, 0.8; p = 0.61). Both groups showed improvements in the 4-month PTA and ABG and the 12-month PTA, but the 12-month ABG only improved in the TEES group ( p < 0.01). The TEES group had a shorter average operative time (109.8 versus 123.5 min; p = 0.03) and less need for a postauricular incision (2.5% versus 93.3%; p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

In pediatric tympanoplasty, TEES gives similar membrane closure and hearing outcomes as the microscopic technique, with less operative time and less need for a postauricular incision.

Comparison of Surgical Outcome of Endoscopic with Microscopic Type I Tympanoplasty in Chronic Otitis Media: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Aim of the study was to compare the surgical outcome of endoscopic with microscopic Type 1 tympanoplasty in dry, mucosal type of chronic otitis media with respect to graft uptake rate, hearing gain and duration of surgery. This randomized controlled trial of 3 years was carried out at Tertiary Care Hospital of Central India. Total 80 cases of mucosal type of chronic otitis media posted for Type I tympanoplasty were included in the study. They were randomly divided into two groups viz. Endoscopic tympanoplasty and microscopic tympanoplasty with 40 patients in each group. Chi-square test was used to compare the qualitative results and student's t-test was used to compare quantitative results with a level of significance of p ≤ 0.05. Intraoperatively, widening of external auditory canal and auxiliary incision were required in 45% and 47.5% patients of microscopic group respectively. Mean operative time for endoscopic tympanoplasty (62.5 ±14.94  mins) was less as compared to microscopic tympanoplasty (74.88 ± 15.83  mins). Graft uptake rate was 95% and 92.5% in endoscopic and microscopic tympanoplasty groups respectively with statistically insignificant difference (p = 0.32). The preoperative mean air bone gap in both the groups was improved significantly 6 months postoperatively. Air bone gap closure was of 13.21± 4.37 dB in endoscopic group and 12.54  ± 4.14 dB in microscopic group with statistically insignificant difference. Endoscope provides superior visualization of hidden areas of middle ear cavity and has shorter operative time than microscopic tympanoplasty with comparable surgical and functional outcomes. hence endoscopic tympanoplasty can be a good option to microscopic surgery.

Endoscopic tympanoplasty type I using interlay technique

Background

Tympanoplasty using the interlay technique has rarely been reported in transcanal endoscopic ear surgery, unlike the underlay technique. This is because many surgeons find it challenging to detach the epithelial layer of the tympanic membrane using only one hand. However, the epithelial layer can be easily detached from the inferior part of the tympanic membrane. Another key point is to actively improve anteroinferior visibility even if the overhang is slight because most perforations and postoperative reperforations are found in the anteroinferior quadrant of the tympanic membrane. We report the application of the interlay technique in endoscopic tympanoplasty type I for tympanic perforations.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 51 patients who had undergone tympanoplasty using the interlay technique without ossiculoplasty between 2017 and 2020. We then compared the data with those of patients who underwent microscopic surgery (MS) using the underlay technique between 1998 and 2009 (n = 104). No other technique was used in each group during this period. Repair of tympanic membrane perforation and hearing outcomes were assessed for > 1 year postoperatively.

Results

The perforation sites were limited to the anterior, posterior, and anterior–posterior quadrants in 23, 1, and 27 ears, respectively. Perforations were closed in 50 of the 51 ears (98.0%), and the postoperative hearing was good (average air-bone [A-B] gap was 6.8 ± 5.8 dB). The surgical success rate for the repair of tympanic membrane perforation was not significantly different from the MS group (93.3%, P = 0.15). The average postoperative average A-B gap in the group that underwent the interlay technique was significantly different from that in the MS group (10.1 ± 6.6 dB, P < 0.01).

Conclusion

The interlay technique should be considered as one of the treatment methods in endoscopic surgery for tympanic perforations. Further study of the postoperative outcomes of this procedure should be conducted to establish the optimal surgical procedure for tympanic perforations.

Trial registration: This study was retrospectively approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Jikei University, Tokyo, Japan (approval number: 32-205 10286).

Video abstract

Outcomes and learning curve of endoscopic tympanoplasty: A retrospective analysis of 376 patients

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the procedural outcomes and learning curve of type I endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) performed by a single surgeon.

Methods

This was a retrospective study of 376 patients who underwent type I ET performed by a single surgeon over 7 years. We evaluated the pre/post air-bone gap (ABG), time required for surgery, changes in pain after surgery, success, and failure rate of type I ET.

Results

Hearing results indicated an ABG of approximately 17.8 dB before surgery but decreased significantly to 9.8 dB at 6 months after surgery. The time required for the operation gradually decreased. In particular, the time required for the procedure was 67.6 min in the first year and decreased to 31.5 minutes in the fifth year, a drastic reduction. The graft failure rate up to 6 months after surgery was 13.0% and was the same for both primary and revision surgeries. Graft failure was significantly greater with increasing size of the preoperative tympanic perforation. The success rate varied depending on graft material, and the group with only acellular allogenic dermal matrix showed the lowest success rate. Postoperative pain significantly decreased from 2.01 immediately after surgery to 0.78 points the next day, and there were no severe complications during surgery.

Conclusions

ET produces superior cosmetic results with minimal pain and is associated with stable hearing improvement and high success rate. The operation time decreased with surgeon experience and continued to decrease until the fifth and final year of this analysis.

Level of Evidence

4.

Anatomic and audiometric outcomes of porcine intestinal submucosa for tympanic membrane repair

Objective

Surgical repair of tympanic membrane perforations has been traditionally performed with autologous soft-tissue grafts with high success rates. Newer allografts such as porcine small intestine submucosa (pSIS) have been employed as alternatives to minimize donor morbidity and surgical time, and in cases where autologous tissue may not be available. The comparative anatomic and audiometric success rates of these tissues is still unclear.

Study design

Retrospective case-control series of anatomic and audiometric outcomes of autologous soft tissue versus pSIS graft for primary, isolated transmeatal tympanic membrane repair.

Methods

Analysis of patients undergoing primary transmeatal tympanic membrane repair with autologous soft tissue or pSIS. Patients with otorrhea, cholesteatoma or retraction pockets, those who had cartilage grafts or ossicular reconstruction, and revision procedures were excluded. Pre- and post-surgery air-bone gaps (ABG) and pure tone averages (PTA) were compared. Graft success was defined as closure of the perforation at 2-month follow-up visit.

Results

The success rate for both the autologous soft tissue and the pSIS arm is 93.8%. There was no statistical significance (p < .05) between the post-op ABG, change in ABG, post-op PTA, change in PTA, or graft success rate between the two groups with either lumped cohort or matched-pairs analysis.

Conclusions

pSIS grafts are effective for repair of tympanic membrane perforations with hearing outcomes and graft success rates comparable to autologous soft tissue.

Lay summary

Repair of tympanic membrane perforations is traditionally done using a soft-tissue graft harvested from the patient at the time of surgery. pSIS is a newer graft material that is equally effective in terms of anatomical and audiometric outcomes.

Level of evidence

Level 3b.

Transcanal Endoscopic Versus Microscopic Tympanoplasty: Is There a Difference in Perforation Closure Rates?

Objective

To compare closure rates of endoscopic and microscopic tympanoplasty (MT) as influenced by perforation size, perforation location, and graft position.

Study Design

Retrospective chart review.

Setting

Tertiary university medical center.

Patients

Adult patients who underwent tympanoplasty by a fellowship-trained neurotologist from January 2010 to December 2019, had at least 2 months of follow-up, and had a tympanic perforation with no cholesteatoma before surgery.

Interventions

Transcanal endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) or MT.

Main Outcome Measures

The primary outcome is postoperative closure of the tympanic membrane perforation as assessed using otomicroscopy at the last follow-up appointment.

Results

Two-hundred and eleven patients-98 in the transcanal ET group and 113 in the MT group-were identified. Tympanic membrane closure rates were not significantly different between the ET and MT groups (79.6% and 84.1% respectively; P = 0.473), and further multivariable analysis revealed that closure rates for ET relative to MT had an insignificant odds ratio (0.56; P = 0.144). Similar analyses also found no significant difference between the 2 methods in subsets of perforation size (small, large, subtotal/total), perforation location (anterior, posterior, inferior), and graft position (underlay, overlay).

Conclusions

ET resulted in similar rates of postoperative closure rates compared with the microscopic technique.

Endoscopic transcanal tympanoplasty type I in children: Evolving experience in tragus perichondrium vs. acellular porcine small intestinal sub-mucosa grafts

OBJECTIVES

Endoscopic trans-canal tympanoplasty type I (ETT) is gradually diffusing worldwide. It mainly allows less invasive surgery in children with respect to a microscope approach by avoiding post-auricular access. The aim of this study is to illustrate our experience in endoscopic reconstruction of tympanic membrane, using autologous tragus perichondrium (TP) and non-autologous acellular porcine small intestinal sub-mucosa (SIS) as grafts.

METHODS

Between January 2011 and December 2020, the results of a prospective non-randomized series of consecutive ETT were analyzed. The primary outcome was closure rate at 6 months and secondary outcomes are closure rates associated with age, size of perforation, type of perforation and middle ear status, presence of myringosclerosis, type of graft, status of contralateral ear, adenoidectomy and pre-postoperative ABG change. Statistical analysis was performed using the SPSS statistical package.

RESULTS

One hundred and sixteen consecutive procedures, mean age 9.4 years (range 4-17 years), were evaluated. TP and SIS grafts were used in 65 (56%) and 51 (44%) procedures, respectively. Mean duration of surgical procedure was 53 ± 21 min for SIS and 77 ± 18 min for TP (P = 0.001) Total graft intake was 82.8%; TP and SIS intake were 86.2% and 78.4% (P = 0.3), respectively. Graft intake w.r.t. in age stratified age groups was not statistically significant. Average preoperative and postoperative air-bone gap was 12.1 ± 7.6 dB and 5.5 ± 3.8 dB, respectively (P = 0.001). The difference in closure rates was not significant. Neither intra- nor postoperative complications were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

In children, ETT is an applicable and less invasive technique compared to the microscope and offers less morbidity. The use of SIS contributes additional less invasiveness to endoscopic surgery by avoiding tragus harvesting with a comparable success rate and granting significantly less surgical duration.

The Feasibility and Treatment Results of Transcanal Endoscopic Myringoplasty

OBJECTIVE

We reported on transcanal endoscopic myringoplasty in 25 cases preliminarily in 2014. Now our number of transcanal endoscopic myringoplasty reached to 209 ears and allowed us to adequately investigate the visibility, necessity of canalplasty, treatment results, and multivariate analysis.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective case series.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Transcanal endoscopic myringoplasty was performed on 209 ears in 201 patients between 2011 and 2019 and followed up over 1 year.

METHODS

Preoperative endoscopic and microscopic views for the same patient were compared. We examined success rates at 1 year after surgery according to operation type, perforation size, operation side, gender, cause of perforation, and age, and also examined hearing results. Logistic regression analysis was performed to investigate the basic demographic and clinical characteristics of the patients associated with perforation closure.

RESULTS

The anterior edge of the preoperative perforation was not visible under microscopy in 14.4% of patients. In contrast, endoscopic views revealed the entire tympanic membrane in one field. However, canalplasty was required in 2.4% of tympanic procedures due to difficulty of manipulation. The overall closure rate for perforations was 90.4%. Logistic regression analysis revealed that age > 11 was the only significant factor associated with perforation closure. The average reduction in air-bone gap was 12.1 dB.

CONCLUSION

The endoscopic myringoplasty produced better visualization, the same or better closure rates, and the same or lower complication rates as compared with traditional microscopic techniques.

Comparison of endoscopic and microscopic management of attic cholesteatoma: A randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Attic cholesteatoma is a common disease encountered by otologists.

OBJECTIVES

To compare the endoscopic approach to attic cholesteatoma with conventional microscopic technique.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 190 patients (192 ears) diagnosed with attic cholesteatoma extending to the antrum area (stages Ib and II) were randomly assigned into two groups undergoing endoscopic approach and the other microscopic technique. The outcomes were preoperative and intraoperative findings, access to hidden areas expressed in MESVI, mean operative time from first incision to ear-packing, and postoperative findings. Statistical analysis was performed by SPSS version 24.0, and P ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

The median Middle Ear Structural Visibility Index of the endoscopic group was better than the microscopic group (P < 0.05). The mean operating time by the endoscopic approach was less than the microscopic approach (P < 0.05). The median postoperative pain score in the endoscopic group was lower than the microscopic group (P < 0.05). In addition, there were no statistically significant differences in taste, hearing, vertigo, healing time and long term outcomes between the two groups.

CONCLUSION AND SIGNIFICANCE

Endoscopic management of limited attic cholesteatoma showed definite advantages over the conventional microscopic approach, such as providing better visualization, requiring less postoperative time, subjecting the patients to less pain, and decreasing the incidence of complications.

Comparing two different techniques to repair pediatric anterior tympanic membrane perforations

OBJECTIVE

Compare outcomes between a microscopic and endoscopic technique for anterior tympanic membrane (TM) perforation.

METHODS

Results of microscopic overlay (MT) and endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) for management of anterior TM perforations from a single surgeon.

RESULTS

There were 28 patients in the MT group and 35 in the ET group. The mean age was 7.1 years and 10.9 years (p < 0.001) MT and ET groups respectively. There was no statistical differences in perforation location (p = 0.1), etiology (p = 0.52) or size (p = 0.1) between both groups. Mean operating time was 119.0 min and 131.0 min in the MT and ET groups respectively (p = 0.23). Follow up was 30.9 months and 9.0 months (p = 0.001) MT and ET respectively. The perforation was successfully closed in 29 patients at 6 weeks in the ET (82.9%) and 25 in the MT (89.3%), p = 0.47. Adjusting for age revealed no significant difference between groups. Long term follow up, resulted in 10 failures (28.6%) and 7 patients (25.0%) in the ET and MT groups respectively, p = 0.75. Adjusting for the follow-up period or age, there was no significant difference between groups. The change in ABG and PTA measures were not statistically different between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

An anteriorly based ET is a novel technique for management of anterior TM perforations. Results from this pilot study indicate that this ET approach may be an appropriate alternative to MT for difficult to repair anterior perforations. A longer follow-up will be necessary to determine its role in these perforations.

Robot-Assisted Middle Ear Endoscopic Surgery: Preliminary Results on 37 Patients

Background: Endoscopy during middle ear surgery is advantageous for better exploration of middle ear structures. However, using an endoscope has some weaknesses as surgical gestures are performed with one hand. This may trouble surgeons accustomed to using two-handed surgery, and may affect accuracy. A robot-based holder may combine the benefits from endoscopic exposure with a two-handed technique. The purpose of this study was to assess the safety and value of an endoscope held by a teleoperated system.

Patients and Methods: A case series of 37 consecutive patients operated using endoscopic exposure with robot-based assistance was analyzed retrospectively. The RobOtol^® system (Collin, France) was teleoperated as an endoscope holder in combination with a microscope. The following data were collected: patient characteristics, etiology, procedure type, complications, mean air and bone conduction thresholds, and speech performance at 3 months postoperatively. Patients had type I (myringoplasty), II (partial ossiculoplasty), and III (total ossiculoplasty) tympanoplasties in 15, 14, and 4 cases, respectively. Three patients had partial petrosectomies for cholesteatomas extending to the petrous apex. Finally, one case underwent resection of a tympanic paraganglioma. Ambulatory procedures were performed in 25 of the 37 patients (68%).

Results: Complete healing with no perforation of the tympanic membrane was noted postoperatively in all patients. No complications relating to robotic manipulation occurred during surgery or postoperatively. The mean air conduction gain was 3.8 ± 12.6 dB for type I (n = 15), 7.9 ± 11.4 dB for type II (n = 14), and −0.9 ± 10.8 for type III tympanoplasties (n = 4), and the postoperative air-bone conduction gap was 13.8 ± 13.3 dB for type I, 19.7 ± 11.7 dB for type II and 31.6 ± 13.0 dB for type III tympanoplasty. They was no relapse of cholesteatoma or paraganglioma during the short follow-up period (<1 year).

Conclusion: This study indicates that robot-assisted endoscopy is a safe and trustworthy tool for several categories of middle ear procedures. It combines the benefits of endoscopic exposure with a two-handed technique in middle ear surgery. It can be used as a standalone tool for pathology limited to the middle ear cleft or in combination with a microscope in lesions extending to the mastoid or petrous apex.

Surgical results of tympanoplasty after conversion to the endoscopic approach performed by a surgeon experienced in microscopic surgery

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to analyze the surgical outcomes of endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) type I, and to investigate the learning curve of ET type I in a surgeon experienced in microscopic surgery.

METHODS

We retrospectively studied patients with tympanic membrane perforations who had undergone ET type I from January 2015 to June 2020. All procedures were performed by a single senior surgeon with considerable microscopic experience. We compared the perforation closure rate in relation to age, previous ear surgery history, graft material, size, and location of perforation. We compared the operation time according to the number of operated patients.

RESULTS

A total of 399 patients were enrolled. The success rate of ET type I was 92.7%. Age, prior ear surgery, graft material, size, and location of perforation did not influence the surgical outcomes. The surgical time for the initial ten cases was the longest (78.3 min), and stabilized after the first 100 cases to under 60 min. The surgical success rate was 96.0% in the first 50 cases, and decreased to approximately 92% afterwards.

CONCLUSION

The surgical time largely decreased with the number of operated patients. Since the operations were performed by a surgeon experienced in microscopy, the success rate of initial cases was not low, even though the operation time of these initial cases was longer. We believe that endoscope provides a new perspective on ear surgery if it could overcome the difficulties in the early stage.

Composite gelfoam/fascia graft: a novel technique in tympanoplasty surgery

BACKGROUND

Traditional tympanoplasty techniques require graft placement and then supporting material (GelFoam) as a two-step process. Both steps potentially disrupt accurate graft placement leading to failure and persistence of the perforation.

METHODS

We demonstrate a novel technique for graft preparation and placement using composite gelfoam/fascia in which the gelfoam and fascia are compressed into a common layer and applied to the perforation and drum remnant in a single step. Placement is ergonomically efficient and effective.

CONCLUSION

This novel modification of traditional graft preparation and placement is simple and ergonomically efficient.

Teaching Endoscopic Ear Surgery

Endoscopic ear surgery (EES) has become an integral part of otologic surgery. Training in EES involves learning fundamental techniques for endoscopic visualization, becoming proficient at one-handed dissection, mastering use of instruments designed for endoscopic ear surgery, and learning to optimize the operating room setup specifically for EES. Despite the steep learning curve, EES offers several advantages over the microscope for otologic procedures. With the rise in the demand for minimally invasive approaches, EES has a clear role in the future of otologic surgery. Identifying strategies to improve the training process of EES for the novice and experienced otolaryngologist is paramount.

Shifting from postauricular to transcanal microscopic tympanoplasty may have similar frequency-specific improvements with better air-bone-gap closure at low frequencies and a minimal learning-curve effect

The shift from postauricular to transcanal microscopic tympanoplasty brings potential advantages of minimal morbidity, less postoperative pain, patient comfort, and surgical ease and speed, but also uncertainties of unfamiliar grafting material, an inadequate operation view, and an uncertain learning curve. These challenges might affect the successful repair rate and the frequency-specific hearing outcome, which is important for hearing perception. Rare studies reported frequency-specific hearing outcome with the learning curve for shifting from postauricular to transcanal microscopic tympanoplasty. Here, from Jul. 2013 to Nov. 2018, we compared patients in a shift from postauricular approach (35 ears) to transcanal approach (35 ears) of microscopic type-1 tympanoplasty. The results show that both of postauricular and transcanal microscopic tympanoplasties reduced the mean air-bone gap, 0.5k Hz gap, and 1k Hz gap after the surgery. The further analyses on gap change as a function of frequency (0.5, 1, 2, and 4k Hz) show that both of postauricular and transcanal tympanoplasties improved postoperative air-bone gap among the levels of frequency. The post hoc comparisons display a common gap reduction difference between 0.5k and 4k Hz. The successful repair rate did not differ between the 2 groups. There was no correlation between the postoperative mean gap change and the surgery date, suggesting a minimal learning-curve effect. The results of similar frequency-specific improvements and a minimal learning-curve effect may help to ease the concerns of those uncertainties before the shift.

Comparison of efficacy of endoscopic versus microscopic transcanal inlay butterfly cartilage myringoplasty

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Butterfly cartilage myringoplasty has been widely practiced over two decades due to its simplicity and feasibility. The present study is aimed to compare the efficacy of endoscopic versus microscopic transcanal inlay butterfly cartilage myringoplasty.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

In this randomised control trial, fifty patients with small to medium sized perforation were included. The first group underwent butterfly cartilage myringoplasty using endoscope and the second group using microscope and, outcomes were compared.

RESULTS

Graft success rates in the endoscopic group was 96% ± 4% and in the microscopic group was 92% ± 8%. The improvement in the Air-Bone Gap was 11.00 ± 7.21 dB in the endoscopic group and 10.8 ± 7.59 dB in the microscopic group. The difference was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall success rates and hearing outcomes were similar in the endoscopic and microscopic group with added advantages of less pain, shorter operative time and better field of vision in the endoscopic group.

Prospective Comparison of Pediatric Endoscopic Lateral Graft and Interlay Tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To compare outcomes and complications of endoscopic lateral graft (LGT) and interlay (IT) tympanoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective observational cohort study of totally endoscopic ear surgery (TEES) tympanoplasty.

SETTING

Pediatric tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

One hundred fourteen surgeries for children with tympanic membrane perforation without cholesteatoma.

INTERVENTION

Porcine-derived collagen graft tympanoplasty using either LGT or IT.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Closure rates of perforation, hearing outcomes (four-tone average air conduction [AC] and air bone gap), and complications that required further surgery were assessed 12 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Perforation closure rates did not differ between LGT (52/59 (88%)) and IT (45/51 (88%)), (Fisher's exact p = 1.00) (four ears lost to follow-up). AC thresholds (p = 0.32) and air bone gap (p = 0.88) improved similarly after surgery with LGT (median 8.8 dB) and IT (median 7.5 dB). The proportion of ears with serviceably normal hearing (AC ≤ 30 dB HL) postoperatively was similar (LGT 40/49 (82%), IT 36/46 (78%), Fisher's exact p = 0.80). Following IT, three (6%) ears developed inclusion cholesteatoma requiring revision surgery. One (2%) LGT ear developed blunting after myringitis.

CONCLUSIONS

IT and LGT provide similar perforation closure rates and hearing outcomes. When choosing between these two techniques to repair pediatric tympanic membrane perforations, LGT would seem to be preferable than IT due to the risk of inclusion cholesteatoma after IT. There is a small risk of anterior blunting after LGT.

Tympanic Membrane Perforation After Intratympanic Steroid Injection: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the incidence of tympanic membrane (TM) perforations induced after intratympanic steroid injection (ITSI) in patients with sudden sensorineural hearing loss (SSNHL) through a systematic review and meta-analysis.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE.

REVIEW METHODS

Primary database searches were performed, and 1901 records were identified. After removal of 1802 articles through abstract screening, the remaining 99 full-text journals were assessed for eligibility to be included in the study. Fifty-eight studies that used either ventilation tubing (VT) or tympanocentesis (TC) for ITSI were selected for analysis. The subjects were divided into VT and TC groups. The rate of TM perforation after ITSI in 2 groups, sites of ITSI, needle gauge, and influence on residual hearing were investigated.

RESULTS

The cohorts comprised patients who underwent VT (n = 257, 9.6%) and TC (n = 2415, 90.4%). The proportion of TM perforation after ITSI in each group was 0.073 (95% CI, 0.0469-0.1113) and 0.010 (95% CI, 0.0045-0.0215), respectively, which suggested that the VT group showed a significantly higher TM perforation rate than the TC group (P < .001). In the subgroup analyses, there was no significant difference in the odds ratio for the rate of TM perforation according to the injection site and needle gauge for TC. The proportion of surgical repair showed no significant difference between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSION

ITSI via VT may have a significantly higher risk of TM perforation than ITSI via TC, although those are relatively small overall. ITSI should be performed in the direction to minimize possible adverse effects.

Butterfly Cartilage Tympanoplasty as an Alternative to Conventional Surgery for Tympanic Membrane Perforations: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness of butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty (BCT) with that of conventional surgical approaches in the treatment of tympanic membrane perforations.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed by screening the PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library databases up to October 31, 2020. Two coauthors independently identified studies in accordance with the selection criteria. Data were pooled and analyzed via Review Manager version 5.3 and Stata version 12.0 software. The postoperative outcomes were measured and expressed as odds ratios (ORs) and standardized mean differences (SMDs). Additionally, heterogeneity was assessed through the I² statistic.

RESULTS

A total of 15 articles were eligible for final inclusion. The OR values for the graft uptake rate, compared to conventional tympanoplasty, were 1.12 (95%CI: 0.56-2.22, I² = 52%, P = .75) and 1.22 (95%CI: 0.58-2.59, I² = 0%, P = .60), and the OR compared to fat plug myringoplasty was 3.02 (95%CI: 1.04-8.77, I² = 0%, P = .04). The qualitative analysis of the hearing results reflected significant postoperative auditory gains with no significant differences between the BCT and control groups, indicating satisfactory and similar postoperative hearing improvement. Moreover, the operation time was shortened (SMD = -2.19, 95%CI: -2.79 to -1.59, I² = 82%, P < .05), and the postoperative pain was less with the BCT approach.

CONCLUSION

Butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty has satisfactory efficacy in terms of anatomical and functional results in small to medium perforations. It reduces operation time and postoperative pain. However, the effectiveness on large perforation requires further assessment by well-designed studies.

Limits in endoscopic ear surgery

BACKGROUND

In recent decades, endoscopic ear surgery (EES) has been rapidly evolving, expanding its boundaries from the middle ear to the lateral skull base. Nonetheless, the advantages of the endoscopic technique are associated with a number of intrinsic limitations.

METHODS AND OBJECTIVE

A narrative review was conducted to investigate the current limits of EES, analyzing the different otologic and skull base surgery procedures.

RESULTS

Limitations of EES can be divided into general and procedure-related. General limitations have been extensively described in the literature and are related to the bidimensional image provided by the endoscope, as well as the one-handed surgical technique and its implications in the management of bleeding. Procedure-related limits are continuously evolving and are also discussed in the present review.

CONCLUSION

Although endoscope use is intrinsically associated with general limitations, these have been systematically overcome by the refinement of the surgical technique as a consequence of the increasing surgical experience gained over the last 20 years. The main limits of EES are currently associated with specific procedure- and disease-related situations. This review describes the general limitations and their management, as well as the current limits in the endoscopic management of various otologic diseases, from the external ear to the lateral skull base.

Totally endoscopic tympanic membrane repair

BACKGROUND

Transcanal totally endoscopic ear surgery (TEES) has become increasingly popular internationally; however, for surgeons trained with a two-handed microscope-guided approach, the potential challenges of adopting TEES can appear off-putting.

OBJECTIVES

This article outlines the pros and cons of TEES for tympanic membrane repair and describes aspects of surgical technique relevant to those who might adopt this approach.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data are provided from the author's experience along with a review of relevant literature, including several meta-analyses of tympanoplasty outcome.

RESULTS

Meta-analyses show that TEES tympanoplasty is as effective at closing tympanic membrane perforations and improving hearing as microscope-guided surgery. Yet patients benefit from avoidance of a skin incision and faster recovery.

CONCLUSION

Repair of the tympanic membrane with TEES is feasible and effective. This minimally invasive approach is very appealing to patients.

Endoscopic Transcanal Push-Trough Myringoplasty for Different Types of Tympanic Membrane Perforations

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to explore the feasibility of endoscopic transcanal push-trough myringoplasty (ETPM) for all types of tympanic membrane perforations (TMPs), and compare the outcomes with those of endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty (ETT) with meatal flap elevation.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective, controlled study.

METHODS

In the present study, inpatients with TMPs were divided into two groups according to the manner of tympanic membrane repair: one group received ETPM without raising the meatal flap, and the other received ETT. The operation duration, postoperative healing rate, visual analogue scale (VAS) of pain, and complication rates were compared between these two groups.

RESULTS

Regardless of the size and location of the perforation, and its relationship with the malleus manubrium, myringoplasty can be completed using the ETPM method. The operation duration for different types of TMPs was shorter in the ETPM group than in the ETT group, and the difference was statistically significant (p<0.05). However, there was no statistical difference in the short-term healing rate (p>0.05) and pain VAS score (p>0.05) between these two groups. Furthermore, no intraoperative or postoperative complications occurred in both groups.

CONCLUSION

ETPM without raising the meatal flap can be applied for all types of TMPs, regardless of how large the perforation is, or where it is located. This can shorten the operation duration, and has a high healing rate comparable to ETT and mild postoperative pain. Mastering some essential surgical skills under the endoscope would be helpful to ensure the success of the surgery.

Tympanic membrane perforations: a critical analysis of 1003 ears and proposal of a new classification based on pathogenesis

PURPOSE

To present a large series ears with tympanic membrane perforations (TMP), to describe their characteristics, and to propose a new classification system based on the pathogenesis of TMP.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study was conducted at a tertiary university hospital with 1003 ears (792 consecutive patients with TMP in at least 1 ear). Otoendoscopy and audiometry were performed. Perforation measurements and their locations were digitally assessed. TMP with no suggestive signs of previous retraction were classified as Group 1, and those with possible previous retraction were classified as Group 2. Signs of retraction previous to the TMP, symptom length, perforation size and location, status of the contralateral ear, and hearing status were compared.

RESULTS

Group 1 comprised 63.5% of the included ears. Compared to Group 2, Group 1 presented a higher rate of central perforations (99% vs. 53%), a shorter duration of symptoms, smaller perforations (mean area: 18.5% vs. 41.4%), a higher rate of perforations in the anterior quadrants, better hearing levels (mean tritonal gap: 23.9 dB vs. 29.2 dB), and a lower rate of abnormal contralateral ears (28% vs. 66%).

CONCLUSION

The classification of TMP into two groups based on signs of previous retractions is feasible and indicates two different levels of disease severity. While the group without previous signs of retraction comprises ears with more limited disease, membranes with previous retraction seem to show more severe disease and, consequently, a less functional middle ear.

Endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty; a composite graft technique for subtotal and total perforations

OBJECTIVE

Demonstrate feasibility of performing endoscopic transcanal type 1 tympanoplasty in total and subtotal perforations, using an underlay technique that minimizes the risk of anterior medialization of the graft. Compare audiometric and clinical outcomes of this technique with our series of endoscopic tympanoplasty with classical underlay grafts, and with previously reported outcomes of microscopic post-auricular lateral graft tympanoplasty and other transcanal techniques.

METHODS

We describe a surgical technique using an L-shaped cartilage and its perichondrium, with exclusive transcanal endoscopic approach. A retrospective review of patients undergoing this technique at the Centenario University Hospital of Rosario, Argentina between January 2017 and December 2019 was performed, and it was compared with a group of patients who underwent endoscopic tympanoplasty with classical underlay technique in a previous period of time. Patients with smaller perforations and other middle ear pathologies that required other techniques were not included in this study. Minimum follow up was 6 months. The main outcome measures were membrane closure rates and hearing results.

RESULTS

73 patients with total or subtotal perforations undergoing endoscopic transcanal tympanoplasty between 2015 and 2019 were included. The group of patients that underwent the technique described showed no anterior medialization of the graft, and better graft take rates. The hearing outcomes were similar in all successful graft patients, with postoperative average air-bone gap of 10db (+  - 10 dB).

CONCLUSION

Transcanal endoscopic tympanoplasty with the technique described is an excellent option for closure of total and subtotal tympanic perforations. The rate of perforation closure is better than endoscopic tympanoplasty with classical underlay graft with similar audiometric outcome.

Current trends and applications in endoscopy for otology and neurotology

There has been a rapid increase in endoscopic ear surgery for the management of middle ear and lateral skull base disease in children and adults over the last decade. In this review paper, we discuss the current trends and applications of the endoscope in the field of otology and neurotology. Advantages of the endoscope include excellent ergonomics, compatibility with pediatric anatomy, and improved access to the middle ear through the external auditory canal. Transcanal endoscopic ear surgery has demonstrated comparable outcomes in the management of cholesteatoma, tympanic membrane perforations, and otosclerosis as compared to microscopic approaches, while utilizing less invasive surgical corridors and reducing the need for postauricular incisions. When a postauricular approach is required, the endoscopic-assisted transmastoid approach can avoid a canal wall down mastoidectomy in cases of cholesteatoma. The endoscope also has utility in treatment of superior canal dehiscence and various skull base lesions including glomus tumors, meningiomas, and vestibular schwannomas. Outside of the operating room, the endoscope can be used during examination of the outer and middle ear and for debridement of complex mastoid cavities. For these reasons, the endoscope is currently poised to transform the field of otology and neurotology.

Heads-up Surgery: Endoscopes and Exoscopes for Otology and Neurotology in the Era of the COVID-19 Pandemic

A new era of surgical visualization and magnification is poised to disrupt the field of otology and neurotology. The once revolutionary benefits of the binocular microscope now are shared with rigid endoscopes and exoscopes. These 2 modalities are complementary. The endoscope improves visualization of the hidden recesses through the external auditory canal or canal-up mastoidectomy. The exoscope provides an immersive visual experience and superior ergonomics compared with binocular microscopy. Endoscopes and exoscopes are poised to disrupt the standard of care for surgical visualization and magnification in otology and neurotology.

Risk stratification in endoscopic type I. tympanoplasty

PURPOSE

Several risk factors were studied in endoscopic type I. tympanoplasty, however, an easy-to-use risk stratification model is still missing.

METHODS

Retrospective chart review, focusing on individual risk factors and middle ear risk index (MERI). Patients who underwent endoscopic type I. tympanoplasty were included.

RESULTS

Closed tympanic cavity was succesfully created in 88.1% of the 42 cases, the overall 21,5 dB air-bone gap (ABG) was reduced by 9,8 dB. The average MERI score of the patients was 2.1 ± 1.5. 78.6% of the patients were categorised into the mild, while 21.4% into the moderate risk group. The perforation was considered small in 81.0% of the cases, while large in 19.0%. The size of the perforation and the preoperative ABG, but not the MERI status were the only single predictors of success. Using a risk stratification model that is based on the size of the perforation, the preoperative ABG and MERI status, patients could be referred into two distinct groups of risk: the majority expecting excellent outcomes with maximum one risk factor present, and patients with deteriorated rate of success when having two or three risk factors.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic type I. tympanoplasty with underlay perichondrium graft can be performed with good chance of success. However, if more than one risk factors are present, the chance of residual perforation becomes great. In addition to the established risk factors, our results point out that despite its strong correlation with perforation size, ABG may have a predictive role.

Endoscopic tympanoplasty type I for tympanic perforations: analysis of prognostic factors

PURPOSE

To assess the anatomical and functional outcomes of endoscopic transcanal tympanoplasty type I for tympanic membrane perforations.

METHODS

Eight hundred thirty-five patients who underwent tympanoplasty between January 2011 and January 2019 were selected. Patients with tympanic membrane perforation treated with a transcanal endoscopic tympanoplasty type 1 and a follow-up period longer than 6 months have been retrospectively reviewed. The presence of cholesteatoma or ossicular chain dysfunctions were considered exclusion criteria. Eighty-one patients were included in the present study population. The main outcome was the rate of overall graft success. Secondary outcomes included hearing results. Prognostic factors related to both the abovementioned outcomes were assessed.

RESULTS

Overall, 66 patients (81.5%) had a successful graft at the last follow-up evaluation. Mean follow-up was 22.1 (range 6-104) months. The anterior quadrants were entailed by the perforation in 62 (76.5%) cases. The overall success rate with cartilage (or cartilage and perichondrium) was 91.2% (p < 0.01). The median preoperative and postoperative ABG were 18.7 (13.4-25.6) and 7.5 (2.5-12.5), respectively, revealing a significant median improvement of 11.2 (p < 0.001). The type of graft and the postoperative tympanic membrane status were significantly associated with the audiologic outcome with p = 0.01 and p = 0.02, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic tympanoplasty type I is a reliable technique with reasonable anatomic and audiologic results. Tympanic membrane grafting with cartilage (or cartilage and perichondrium) guarantees a higher rate of perforation closure and satisfactory hearing results. Anterior eardrum perforations can be successfully and safely managed with transcanal endoscopic approach avoiding postauricular approach and canalplasty.

Ossicular chain reconstruction: endoscopic or microscopic?

OBJECTIVE

To compare the results of endoscopic and microscopic ossicular chain reconstruction surgery.

METHODS

Patients undergoing ossicular chain reconstruction surgery via an endoscopic (n = 31) or microscopic (n = 34) technique were analysed for age, gender, Middle Ear Risk Index, ossicular chain defect, incision type, ossicular chain reconstruction surgery material, mean air conduction threshold, air-bone gap, air-bone gap gain, word recognition score, mean operation duration and mean post-operative follow up.

RESULTS

Post-operative air conduction, air-bone gap and word recognition score improved significantly in both groups (within-subject p < 0.001 for air conduction and air-bone gap, and 0.026 for word recognition score); differences between groups were not significant (between-subject p = 0.192 for air conduction, 0.102 for air-bone gap, and 0.709 for word recognition score). Other parameters were similar between groups, except for incision type. However, endoscopic ossicular chain reconstruction surgery was associated with a significantly shorter operation duration (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic ossicular chain reconstruction surgery can achieve comparable surgical and audiological outcomes to those of microscopic ossicular chain reconstruction surgery in a shorter time.

Comparative study of endoscopic and microscopic tympanoplasty performed by a single experienced surgeon

PURPOSE

The use of endoscopes in otologic procedures has been increasing worldwide. This study aimed to compare the efficacy of microscopic tympanoplasty (MT) and endoscopic tympanoplasty (ET) for tympanic membrane and middle ear surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 81 patients who underwent MT (n = 44) and ET (n = 37) for chronic otitis media with tympanic membrane perforation performed by a single surgeon between January 2013 and September 2019. The hearing outcomes, graft success rate, complications, operation time and hospital stay, and cost-effectiveness were recorded and compared between groups. Hearing outcomes were determined by pure tone audiometry. Cost-effectiveness was determined by the operation cost and total cost.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference between the MT and ET groups regarding demographic characteristics, with the exception of the male:female ratio. There was no significant difference in the pre- and postoperative air conduction, bone conduction thresholds, and air-bone gap values between the two groups, but a significant audiologic improvement was observed in both groups (p < 0.05). In terms of recurrence of tympanic membrane perforation, postoperative otorrhea, and discomfort symptoms, there was no significant difference between groups (p > 0.05). The operation time and hospital stay were shorter in the ET group than in the MT group (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences in operation cost between the two groups (p > 0.05), but the total cost was significantly lower in the ET group than the MT group (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

ET is as safe and medically efficacious as conventional MT, shortens the operation time and hospital stay, and is cost-effective.