Complications and parent satisfaction in pediatric osseointegrated bone-conduction hearing implants: Pediatric Osseointegrated Implants

Feasibility and Outcomes of an Active Osseointegrated Bone Conduction Implant in Children as Young as 5 Years of Age

INTRODUCTION

This study reviews the feasibility of implanting active osseointegrated bone conduction devices in young children, below the prior age for FDA indication (<12 years), which has recently been reduced to 5 years. Outcomes included differences in adverse event rates and operative time between two groups (<12 and 12 years or older).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study is a retrospective review of children receiving active osseointegrated bone conduction devices at a tertiary referral center academic hospital. One hundred and twenty-four children received 135 active osseointegrated bone conduction devices (May 2018-March 2024).

RESULTS

Of 135 devices, 77 (57%) were in children <12 years (mean age (SD) = 7.9 (2.0) years, range = 4.9-11.9 years) and 58 (43%) were in 12 years or older (mean age (SD) = 15.1 (1.7) years, range = 12-18 years). Adverse events were significantly higher in the older group, occurring in 8 (10%) of 77 devices in children <12 years and 15 (26%) of 58 devices in children 12 years and older (26%) (Fisher's exact test = 0.0217 at p < 0.05). Major adverse events occurred in 5/124 (4%) patients, with 2 in patients <12 years (2/73, 3%) and 3 in children 12 and older (3/51, 6%). The proportion of major events between groups was not significantly different (Fisher's exact test = 0.4, p < 0.05). Mean surgical time was significantly less (t = -2.8799, df = 120.26, p = 0.005) in the children <12 years (mean (SD) = 66.5 (22.4) min) compared to those 12 and over (mean (SD) = 78.32 (23.1) min).

CONCLUSIONS

Implantation of active osseointegrated bone conduction devices is feasible in children as young as 5 years and demonstrates low rates of complication. Further miniaturization may allow even earlier safe intervention.

Evaluating the effectiveness of bone conduction hearing implants in rehabilitation of hearing loss

PURPOSE

Implantable hearing devices are indicated for candidates who could not benefit from conventional hearing aids. This study aimed at evaluating their effectiveness in rehabilitation of hearing loss.

METHODS

This study included patients who received bone conduction implants at Tertiary Teaching Hospitals, between December 2018 and November 2020. Data were collected prospectively, and patients were assessed both subjectively using COSI and GHABP questionnaires and objectively using bone conduction and air conduction thresholds, unaided and aided free field speech thresholds. Outcomes of transcutaneous (tBCHD) and percutaneous (pBCHD) bone conduction hearing devices were compared as well as outcomes of unilateral versus bilateral fitting. Postoperative skin complications were recorded and compared.

RESULTS

A total of seventy patients were included, thirty-seven of them were implanted with tBCHD and thirty-three with pBCHD. Fifty-five patients were fitted unilaterally compared to 15 bilateral fitting. Preoperative mean of bone conduction (BC) of the overall sample was 23.27 ± 10.91 dB, the Air conduction (AC) mean was 69.27 ± 13.75 dB. There was significant difference between unaided free field speech score (88.51% ± 7.92) and the aided score (96.79 ± 2.38) with P value = 0.00001. The postoperative assessment using GHABP showed a benefit score mean of 70.95 ± 18.79, patient satisfaction score mean of 78.15 ± 18.39. The disability score improved significantly from a mean of 54.08 ± 15.26 to residual score of only 12.50 ± 10.22 with P < 0.00001 postoperatively. There was significant improvement in all parameters of COSI questionnaire following fitting. Comparison of pBCHDs vs tBCHDs showed a non-significant difference regarding FF speech as well as GHABP parameters. Comparison of the post-operative skin complications was in favor of tBCHDs as (86.5%) of the patients had normal skin postoperatively, compared to 45.5% of patients with pBCHDs devices. Bilateral implantation showed significant improvement of FF speech scores, GHABP satisfaction score, as well as COSI score results.

CONCLUSION

Bone conduction hearing devices are effective solution for rehabilitation of hearing loss. Bilateral fitting yields satisfactory outcomes in suitable candidates. Transcutaneous devices carry significantly lower skin complication rates compared to percutaneous devices.

First Generation Osseointegrated Steady State Implant Benefits in Children With Hearing Loss

OBJECTIVE

To assess outcomes of a new Osseointegrated Steady State Implant (OSSI) for bone conduction in adolescents.

METHOD

In an initial trial, 14 adolescents (14.5 years of age, SD = 2.22) were provided with an OSSI; unilateral OSSI (n = 13), bilateral OSSI in sequential surgeries (n = 1). Outcomes measured were surgical duration, complications, hearing thresholds, speech perception and self-reported hearing benefits using the Speech and Spatial Quality of Hearing Questionnaire.

RESULTS

The surgical times were mean 93.6 minutes (SD = 33.3). Surgery was slightly longer in three adolescents who required skin flap reduction (n = 1) or significant bone polishing (n = 2) (121.33 minutes, SD = 8.14). Adverse events occurred in two adolescents post-implant poor external device retention in one child requiring revision flap reduction and inflammation at the incision site due to magnet overuse in another. The "Digital Link Calibration" measure was a good proxy predictor of the strength of magnet required for external device adherence (p = 0.002). The OSSI increased audibility in the implanted ear by mean 31.48 dB HL (SE = 1.58). Aided thresholds were best at 1 kHz (mean 25.33 dB HL, SD = 22.60) and only slightly poorer at 3000 and 4000 Hz (estimate decrease = 8.33 dB HL, SE = 3.54), reflecting good auditory sensitivity even at high frequencies. Speech perception when using the new device alone was good (89.67%, SD = 7.84%) and self-reported hearing by participants and parents improved in all domains assessed by the Speech and Spatial Quality of Hearing Questionnaire (estimate = 1.90 points, SE = 0.25, p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The OSSI provides hearing benefits with surgical safety in a carefully selected cohort of adolescents.

The efficacy of bone-anchored hearing implant surgery in children: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the efficacy of Bone-Anchored Hearing implants (BAHIs) in children and to elucidate the usage and outcomes of new surgical techniques and implants in this specific population.

DATA SOURCES

Embase and PubMed.

STUDY SELECTION

We identified studies evaluating surgical outcomes of BAHIs in children. Retrieved articles were screened using predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. Critical appraisal included directness of evidence and risk of bias. Studies that successfully passed critical appraisal were included.

DATA EXTRACTION

Outcome measures included patient demographics, follow-up time, surgical technique (one-versus two-stage surgery), tissue handling technique (reduction versus preservation), type of implant used, and complications.

DATA SYNTHESIS

We selected 20 articles published between 2000 and 2017 for data extraction, encompassing 952 implanted BAHIs. The overall mean age at implantation was 8.6 years (range, 2-21 years). Adverse soft-tissue reactions occurred in 251 of the 952 implants (26.4%; range 0%-89% across studies). Revision surgery was performed in 16.8% (142 of the 845) of the implants. The total rate of implant loss, i.e. caused by OIF (n = 61), trauma (n = 33), recurrent infection (n = 15), elective removal due to insufficient benefit (n = 1), cosmetic reasons (n = 1), or unknown reason (n = 16), was 13.3% of the implants (127 out of 952; range 0%-40% across studies). Differences are seen in the type of implants used; wide-diameter implants seem to be superior in terms of implant survival, and similar in terms of adverse skin reactions, while one-stage surgery and soft-tissue preservation do not seem to result in higher implant loss rates or increased adverse skin reactions based upon limited amounts of literature.

CONCLUSION

In general, BAHIs are a safe method for hearing rehabilitation in children, although large differences between studies are observed. The outcomes of new surgical techniques and implant designs in the pediatric population seem promising, but more research is needed before definitive conclusions can be drawn.

Complications of bone-conduction hearing implants (BCHI) implantation surgery

PURPOSE

Bone-conduction Hearing Implants (BCHIs) are surgically implanted hearing devices. As the implantation surgery involves soft tissue dissection through periosteum and drilling of skull, complications related to the skin and soft tissue remain common despite several modifications of surgical techniques over the years. This study aims to evaluate a single centre's BCHI implantation complication rates over time, identify the effects of surgical modifications, and compare these to data from the literature.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective case review was performed on all patients who received BCHI implantation from 2013 to 2018. 11 complication rates over time were recorded. Changes to practice occurring during the study period were also recorded and their effects on complication rates were identified. A literature search was performed to identify the complication rates reported in the literature and compared with that of our cohort.

RESULTS

162 BCHI implantations were performed over the 5 years. 23 articles were included in the study after the literature review process. In our cohort, complications related to skin and soft tissue were most common, which was in line with that reported in the literature. Complication rates have overall decreased following the introduction of innovative practices, including adoption of minimally-invasive single-stage procedures and the training of specialist nurses.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study we have highlighted the changes in complication rates of BCHI implantation over time at a single centre with reference to changes in clinical practice. Continued review of practice and on-going technological developments will facilitate continued reductions in complications of BCHI surgery.

Transcutaneous Osseointegrated Implants for Pediatric Patients With Aural Atresia

Importance

Patients with aural atresia typically have maximal conductive hearing loss, which can have negative academic and social consequences. Transcutaneous osseointegrated implants (TOIs) can potentially restore hearing on the affected side.

Objectives

To review the demographic, audiological, and surgical outcomes of TOI placement in pediatric patients with aural atresia and to describe a modification in incision technique in anticipation of later auricular reconstruction.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This retrospective case series reviewed 41 cases of TOI placement in pediatric patients between January 1, 2014, and September 30, 2016, at Lurie Children's Microtia and Aural Atresia Clinic. Patients, all younger than 18 years and with atresia or microtia, received at least 6 months of follow-up and underwent testing before and after surgery.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Patient age, indication for procedure, ear sidedness, case length, incision type, complications, and other postoperative events. Audiological outcomes before and after implantation were measured using pure-tone averages and the Hearing In Noise Test for Children, presented in variable signal to noise ratios.

Results

In total, 46 TOIs were performed in 38 pediatric patients, but only 41 implantations in 34 patients were included in this study. Of the 34 patients, 13 (38%) were males and 21 (62%) were females, with a mean age of 8.9 (range, 5-17) years at the time of TOI placement. Microtia on the implanted side was present in 39 cases (95%). A modified posterior-superior scalp incision technique was used in 30 (73%) of 41 ears, all in cases of microtia. One perioperative surgical complication occurred: a seroma requiring drainage. Two patients developed minor skin irritation and erythema at the magnet site related to the overnight use of the processor, which resolved when removed while sleeping. The mean (SD; range) score for the Speech In Noise test at 5 dB signal to noise ratio improved from 75.3% (14.4%; range, 50%-92%) correct in unaided/preoperative condition to 93.6% (6.95%; range, 80%-100%) correct in the aided/postoperative condition. The mean improvement in score was 18.3% (95% CI, 10.8%-25.9%), with an effect size of 1.62 (95% CI, 0.95-2.29). The mean pure-tone averages (SD; range) similarly improved from 63.7 (13.2; range, 25-11) dB to 9.6 (4.9; range, 5-15) dB.

Conclusions and Relevance

Transcutaneous osseointegrated implantation has a low complication rate among pediatric patients with atresia or microtia and can provide excellent audiological results. It should be included as a treatment option for this population of patients who meet audiological criteria.

Management of Traumatic Injury and Osseointegration Failure in Children With Percutaneous Bone Conduction Implants

OBJECTIVE

This study examines the incidence and management of traumatic loss or osseointegration failure of percutaneous bone conduction implants in children.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series.

SETTING

Pediatric tertiary care institution.

PATIENTS

Children who underwent percutaneous osseointegrated implant placement from 1996 to 2016.

INTERVENTIONS

Clinical evaluation and revision surgery after implant loss.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

This study compares the characteristics of children who experienced traumatic loss of implant to those who did not to calculate odds ratios (ORs) describing the risk of injury and investigate device utilization after implant failure.

RESULTS

One hundred forty-seven children received percutaneous bone conduction devices; 129 were followed for at least 1 year. Trauma occurred in 19 of 129 cases (15%). Among children with traumatic injury, mean age at initial surgery was 5 years (SD = ±3.3), and 42% had a developmental delay. Among children without traumatic injury, mean age at initial surgery was 6.5 years (SD = ±4.4), and 28% had a developmental delay. Multivariate logistic regression found no significant differences in age, sex, or developmental delay associated with implant loss. In five of 19 traumatic cases (26%), the implant remained in situ due to either skull fracture or abutment loss. In the remaining 14 of 19 cases (74%), there was osseointegration failure with extrusion of the implant. Seventeen children underwent revision surgery utilizing previously placed "sleeper," or backup, osseointegrated implant, and 14 (82%) of these continued to use their device. Two patients with extruded implants did not undergo revision surgery.

CONCLUSION

Traumatic injury or osseointegration failure leads to loss of percutaneous bone conduction implants in approximately 15% of children. Revision surgery is often successful.

Long-Term Conductive Auditory Deprivation During Early Development Causes Irreversible Hearing Impairment and Cochlear Synaptic Disruption

Conductive hearing loss is a prevalent condition globally. It remains unclear whether conductive hearing loss that occurs during early development disrupts auditory peripheral systems. In this study, a mouse model of conductive auditory deprivation (CAD) was achieved using external auditory canal closure on postnatal day 12, which marks the onset of external ear canal opening. Short-term (2 weeks) and long-term (6 weeks) deprivations involving external ear canal closure were conducted. Mice were examined immediately, 4 weeks, and 8 weeks after deprivation. Short-term deprivation induced reversible auditory brainstem response (ABR) threshold and latencies of ABR wave I, whereas long-term deprivation caused irreversible ABR thresholds and latencies of ABR wave I. Complete recovery of ribbon synapses and latencies of ABR wave I was observed in the short-term group. In contrast, we observed irreversible ABR thresholds, latencies of ABR wave I, and quantity of ribbon synapses in the long-term deprivation group. Positive 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine signals were noted in cochlear hair cells in the long-term group, suggesting that long-term auditory deprivation could disrupt auditory maturation via mitochondrial damage in cochlear hair cells. Conversely, no significant changes in cellular morphology were observed in cochlear hair cells and spiral ganglion cells in either short- or long-term groups. Collectively, our findings suggest that long-term conductive hearing deprivation during early stages of auditory development can cause significant and irreversible disruption that persists into adulthood.