Laryngeal fracture presentation and management in United States emergency rooms

External laryngotracheal trauma: a case series and an algorithmic management strategy

OBJECTIVES

External laryngotracheal trauma (ELT), blunt or penetrating, is a rare but potentially life-threatening injury. Immediate care in the emergency department can be challenging because it requires managing a potentially unstable airway and may have associated vascular injuries with massive bleeding. Here, we look at the details of injury, treatment measures, and outcomes in patients following ELT.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 22 patients treated at our center for ELT from January 2005 up to December 2021 with varying grades of injury. We looked at their status at presentation, management strategy and functional status.

RESULTS

In our report, we include 18 men and 4 women having varying Schaefer injury grades. Eight patients had tracheostomy at presentation and eight had vocal fold immobility. Two patients were treated endoscopically, 12 had open surgery and 8 received no treatment. Of the patients undergoing open surgery, thyroid cartilage fracture was seen in 9 patients, thyroid plus cricoid fracture and cricotracheal separation were seen in 3 patients each. All patients were safely decannulated and spontaneous recovery of vocal cord palsy was seen in some patients.

CONCLUSION

The success of managing ELT relies on fast decision-making, correct patient evaluation, securing the airway and maintaining the hemodynamic stability. Early surgical intervention must be aimed at optimally treating the larygotracheal injuries to prevent long-term disastrous consequences.

Changes in occurrence and management of laryngeal fractures at the Helsinki University Hospital during 25 years

PURPOSE

Laryngeal fracture is a rare but potentially life-threatening trauma. Fractures vary from mild to dislocated and extensive with risk of severe complications. This study investigated the occurrence, clinical characteristics and management of laryngeal fractures in the last 15 years.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective population-based cohort study reviewing all laryngeal fractures at the Helsinki University Hospital in 2005-2019. Patient records and imaging studies were systematically reviewed for mode of injury, fracture type, secondary complications, treatment modality, possible airway management, length of stay, and mortality. Results were compared with corresponding data from 1995 to 2004.

RESULTS

Overall 80 fracture patients were recorded (5.3/year); 79% were men and mean age was 42 years (range 18-78). Altogether 91% were closed and 9% open. While unintentional traumas were most common (54%), an increasing proportion were from intentional injury (10%) or Schaefer Gr IV in severity (35%). Altogether 46% had compromised airway and 21% needed airway intervention; airway narrowing was more common with cricoid (p = 0.042) and multiple fractures (p = 0.07) and correlated positively with amount of dislocation (p = 0.001) and number of fracture lines (p = 0.006). Surgery was performed for 33%, of which 46% were Schaefer Gr IV and 62% from intentional trauma. Mortality was 1.4%.

CONCLUSIONS

Deliberate and violence-related laryngeal fractures have increased. These often result in more extensive injuries predisposing to compromised airway and requiring surgical intervention and longer treatment. Most fractures are still treated conservatively with good long-term outcomes. An observation period of 24 h is recommended to detect any delayed complications. Mortality remains low.

Systematic Review of Laryngeal Fractures and Trends in Operative Management

Study Design

Systematic review of the literature.

Objective

The goal of this study is to review the current literature on the trends in management of laryngeal fractures following trauma.

Methods

Independent searches of the PubMed and MEDLINE databases were performed. Articles from the period of 1963 to 2020 were collected. All studies which described laryngeal fractures using the Boolean method and relevant search term combinations, including "Laryngeal", "Fracture", "Operative", and "Management" were collected.

Results

A total of 588 relevant unique articles were identified for analysis. Of these, 24 articles were deemed appropriate for inclusion in the literature review. Due to variability in study design and outcome measures, formal synthesis of data in the form of a meta-analysis was not possible.

Conclusions

Laryngeal fractures are rare traumatic injuries that require early identification and evaluation with complex management options. This comprehensive review aims to highlight the breadth of the topic with regard to presentation and clinical management. Though there remains no clear best practice for laryngeal fracture management, we review trends in clinical practice throughout the literature.

Laryngeal trauma: a review of current diagnostic and management strategies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this review is to provide the most up to date information on evaluation and management of laryngeal trauma.

RECENT FINDINGS

Timely diagnosis and proper treatment of laryngeal fractures are imperative for preserving a functional larynx. This review will focus on evaluation and management strategies.

SUMMARY

The larynx provides significant functions including respiration, phonation, and airway protection. Algorithms have been developed in order to standardize the evaluation and management of these injuries to preserve a functional larynx. Physicians must diagnose and treat these laryngeal traumas in a timely fashion in order to prevent morbidity and, rarely, mortality.

Characterization of Laryngotracheal Fractures and Repairs: A TQIP Study

OBJECTIVES

Laryngotracheal trauma is poorly studied and associated with serious morbidity and mortality. This study reports features associated with laryngotracheal fractures, and factors associated with laryngeal fracture repair.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective database study SETTING: American College of Surgeons Trauma Quality Improvement Program (ACS-TQIP®) METHODS: ACS-TQIP® 2014-2015 participant user data files were queried for laryngotracheal fractures using the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) 9th edition encodings. Demographic, diagnostic and procedure characteristics were analyzed with univariate chi-squared analysis and multivariate logistic regression.

RESULTS

We extracted 635 cases of laryngotracheal injury, with a median Injury Severity Score of 16 (IQR: 10 - 25). Most were caused unintentionally (65.7%), followed by assault (28.8%). Blunt trauma (79.5%) was more common than penetrating trauma (20.0%). These trends were upheld in the subgroup of repaired fractures, which made up 12.6% (80/635) of cases. The median length of hospital stay was 6 days (IQR: 3 - 13) in all fractures and 10 days (IQR: 6 - 14) in the subgroup of repaired fractures, while the median length of ICU stay was 4 days (IQR: 2 - 9) in all fractures and 4.5 (IQR: 6 - 14.3) in the subgroup of repaired fractures. Cut/pierce injuries (OR: 4.7, P < 0.001) and ISS (OR: 0.97, pP = 0.026) significantly affected rate of laryngeal fracture repair.

CONCLUSION

Laryngotracheal fractures are uncommon but serious injuries. Our results show that penetrating causes of injuries have the shortest time to repair, and that a higher ISS score is negatively associated with repair.

Clinical, Radiologic, and Endolaryngeal Findings in Laryngeal Fractures: A 15-Year Case Series

Objective

Laryngeal fractures are rare injuries; recent data describing these injuries and associated examination findings are limited. This study aims to describe injury etiology and outcomes associated with laryngeal fractures.

Study Design

Retrospective case series.

Setting

Academic tertiary center.

Methods

Patients with laryngeal fractures from 2005 to 2020 were identified in a retrospective chart review. Patient demographics, injury mechanisms, management, and voice outcomes were examined. Fracture type, radiologic, and endolaryngeal examination findings were analyzed for associations between fracture etiology and examination characteristics.

Results

Laryngeal fractures most commonly occurred at the thyroid cartilage. Fractures were most commonly due to sport-related injuries. Mechanism of injury was not associated with specific radiologic or endolaryngeal findings. Mechanism of injury was additionally not significantly associated with the need for intubation, surgical intervention, or tracheotomy. Fracture location was significantly associated with intubation requirement (P = .015), with 40% of patients with concomitant thyroid and cricoid fractures requiring intubation. Mechanism of injury significantly correlated with dysphonia at follow-up (P = .033). Mechanism of injury, fracture location, and surgical management were not associated with increased vocal fold injury or dysphonia.

Conclusion

There are no significant correlations between injury mechanism and fracture location, characteristics, radiologic findings, or endolaryngeal findings. These features emphasize the importance of a thorough and comprehensive laryngeal examination.

CT-based assessment of laryngeal fracture patterns and associated soft tissue abnormality

OBJECTIVE

Acute traumatic injuries to the larynx, including fractures of the hyoid bone, cricoid, and thyroid cartilage, are uncommon injuries. The purpose of this study was to assess fracture and soft tissue patterns associated with laryngeal trauma.

METHODS

This was a retrospective review of patients with laryngeal fractures who presented to two level I trauma centers and underwent CT imaging. Imaging findings, including fractures of the cartilaginous structures of the larynx and hyoid bone, and soft tissue abnormalities including focal hematoma, edema with non-focal hemorrhage, and additional penetrating injuries were recorded. Frequencies of fracture patterns were recorded.

RESULTS

Thyroid cartilage fractures were most frequently observed occurring in 45/55 patients, followed by cricoid fractures in 13/55 patients. Hyoid fractures were encountered in 8/55 patients. Multi-site fractures were observed in 12/55 patients with thyroid-cricoid fractures occurring in 8/12 patients, followed by thyroid-hyoid fractures in 2/12 patients. Most multi-site fractures occurred in association with focal supraglottic hematomas (10/12), supraglottic edema and non-focal hemorrhage (11/12), and focal subglottic hematoma (5/12). All 13 cricoid fractures occurred with either focal supraglottic hematoma (7), focal subglottic hematoma (4), or edema with non-focal hemorrhage (13).

CONCLUSIONS

Thyroid cartilage fractures were the most frequently encountered fracture, followed by cricoid cartilage fractures. Cricoid fractures always occurred with soft tissue abnormalities. Recognition of fracture patterns in the setting of laryngeal trauma and associated patterns of soft tissue injury is important for practicing radiologists for early diagnosis of these conditions and reduction of associated morbidity.

KEY POINTS

• Acute fractures to the larynx may be isolated fractures or occur as multi-focal fractures. • Thyroid cartilage fractures are the most frequent fractures followed by cricoid cartilage fractures. • Cricoid cartilage fractures always occurred in association with soft tissue abnormalities.

Damage control of laryngotracheal trauma: the golden day

Laryngotracheal trauma is rare but potentially life-threatening as it implies a high risk of compromising airway patency. A consensus on damage control management for laryngotracheal trauma is presented in this article. Tracheal injuries require a primary repair. In the setting of massive destruction, the airway patency must be assured, local hemostasis and control measures should be performed, and definitive management must be deferred. On the other hand, management of laryngeal trauma should be conservative, primary repair should be chosen only if minimal disruption, otherwise, management should be delayed. Definitive management must be carried out, if possible, in the first 24 hours by a multidisciplinary team conformed by trauma and emergency surgery, head and neck surgery, otorhinolaryngology, and chest surgery. Conservative management is proposed as the damage control strategy in laryngotracheal trauma.

Laryngeal fractures in professional and semiprofessional ice hockey players

OBJECTIVE

Injuries in professional ice hockey players are common, however significant laryngeal trauma is rare. Here, we present a case series of professional and semiprofessional ice hockey players to demonstrate the mechanism and nature of laryngeal injuries they sustain during play, and to recommend best practices for treatment, prevention, and return to the ice.

METHODS

A retrospective case review was done of hockey-related laryngeal injuries between 2016 and 2019 at a tertiary laryngology practice. Only semiprofessional and professional hockey players were included.

RESULTS

In total, four cases were included. All cases involved trauma from a hockey puck to the neck. No cases were the result of punching, fighting, high sticks or routine checking. Notably, 1 of 4 presented with severe airway compromise, requiring urgent intubation, whereas most presented with pain or a significant voice complaint. Two patients required operative intervention with open reduction and internal fixation of significantly displaced fractures. One patient experienced significant mucosal disruption with cartilaginous exposure at the posterior vocal complex requiring microflap. The average return to ice was 6 weeks for those who required operative intervention and 4 weeks for those who were managed conservatively. One patient had persistent mild dysphonia and all others had a return to baseline phonation. None were wearing neck guards or other protective equipment at the time of injury.

CONCLUSION

Though voice and airway injuries are rarely sustained by ice hockey players, they may require urgent intervention. We recommend that protective equipment be worn and improved to prevent laryngeal trauma.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4.

Awake tracheal intubation for blunt airway trauma

A 64-year-old man sustained blunt trauma to the anterior neck following a mechanical fall resulting in an isolated laryngeal fracture of the left cricoarytenoid complex. Although there was no acute airway compromise, he developed worsening airway oedema which necessitated tracheal intubation. He underwent oral awake tracheal intubation with a flexible bronchoscope to facilitate formation of a tracheostomy under general anaesthesia. The challenges encountered in the clinical management of this case relate to decision making for the patient with airway trauma in the absence of the need for emergency tracheal intubation. We describe the advantages and pitfalls of various airway management strategies in the context of blunt airway trauma.