Cost-Effectiveness of Primary Liver Transplantation Versus Hepatoportoenterostomy in the Management of Biliary Atresia in the United States

Transplantation: A Priority in the Healthcare Agenda

BACKGROUND

In November 2023, in the context of the Spanish Presidency of the Council of the European Union, the Organization National de Transplante organized a global summit discussing global action in transplantation for the next decade. This article reports the recommendations supporting the need to prioritize transplantation in healthcare systems.

METHODS

The working group investigated how transplantation addresses noncommunicable disease mortality, particularly related to kidney and liver disease. They also investigated how transplantation can contribute to the achievement of several of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, especially Goal 3 (good health and well-being), Goal 8 (sustained, inclusive, and sustainable economic growth and employment for all), and Goal 13 (combat climate change and its impact).

RESULTS

By prioritizing transplantation, the increased availability and accessibility of life-saving organs and tissues to the public will not only lead to saving more lives and improving health outcomes for individual patients but also contribute to the development of a resilient health system in general in that country as a consequence of developing the infrastructure required for transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

The ethical principles associated with transplantation promote the principles of solidarity in society by fostering the donation process and equity in access to therapy. This article aims to advocate for the widespread availability of solid organ, tissue, and cell transplantation for all patients.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of adult living-donor liver transplantation in Japan

AIM

Living-donor liver transplantation (LDLT) is a highly effective life-saving procedure; however, it requires substantial medical resources, and the cost-effectiveness of LDLT versus conservative management (CM) for adult patients with end-stage liver disease (ESLD) remains unclear in Japan.

METHODS

We performed a cost-effectiveness analysis using the Diagnostic Procedure Combination (DPC) data from the nationwide database of the DPC research group. We selected adult patients (18 years or older) who were admitted or discharged between 2010 and 2021 with a diagnosis of ESLD with Child-Pugh class C or B. A decision tree and Markov model were constructed, and all event probabilities were computed in 3-month cycles over a 10-year period. The willingness-to-pay per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) was set at 5 million Japanese yen (JPY) (49,801 US dollars [USD]) from the perspective of the public health-care payer.

RESULTS

After propensity score matching, we identified 1297 and 111,849 patients in the LDLT and CM groups, respectively. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for LDLT versus CM for Child-Pugh classes C and B was 2.08 million JPY/QALY (20,708 USD/QALY) and 5.24 million JPY/QALY (52,153 USD/QALY), respectively. The cost-effectiveness acceptability curves showed the probabilities of being below the willingness-to-pay of 49,801 USD/QALY as 95.4% in class C and 48.5% in class B. Tornado diagrams revealed all variables in class C were below 49,801 USD/QALY while their ranges included or exceeded 49,801 USD/QALY in class B.

CONCLUSIONS

Living-donor liver transplantation for adult patients with Child-Pugh class C was cost-effective compared with CM, whereas LDLT versus CM for class B patients was not cost-effective in Japan.

Prognostic Factors Related to In-hospital Death in Children with Biliary Atresia: Analysis of a Nationwide Inpatient Database

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Patients with biliary atresia (BA) are prone to hepatic decompensation, which might eventually lead to death. This study aimed to identify the possible risk factors affecting in-hospital death in BA patients in China.

METHODS

We collected data from the Hospital Quality Monitoring System, a national inpatient database. All patients aged up to 2 years old with a diagnosis of BA were included. The subjects were divided to three groups, including Kasai portoenterostomy (KP), liver transplantation (LT), and no surgery. Logistic regression with Firth's method was performed to identify potential influencing variables associated with in-hospital death.

RESULTS

During the year 2013 to 2017, there were 14,038 pediatric admissions with a diagnosis of BA. The proportion of in-hospital death in pediatric BA admissions was 1.08%. Compared with patients under six months, there was a higher risk of in-hospital death for children aged six months to 1 year and 1-2 years old. Clinical signs, including cirrhosis, variceal bleeding, and hepatic encephalopathy, were significantly associated with the risk of in-hospital death. In no surgery group, compared to those in Beijing and Shanghai, BA patients admitted in other districts had a lower risk of in-hospital death (OR=0.39, 95% CI: 0.21, 0.70). However, in the LT group, patients admitted in other districts had a higher risk of in-hospital death (OR=9.13, 95% CI: 3.99, 20.87).

CONCLUSIONS

In-hospital survival remains unsatisfactory for pediatric BA patients with severe complications. Furthermore, more resources and training for BA treatment, especially LT, are essential for districts with poor medical care in the future.

Health Care Resource Utilization by Patients with Alagille Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To assess and characterize health care resource utilization (HRU) in children with the rare, genetic, multisystem disorder, Alagille syndrome.

STUDY DESIGN

This retrospective analysis reviewed commercially insured and Medicaid-insured claims from October 1, 2015 to December 31, 2019 to assess HRU in patients with Alagille syndrome. As there is no specific International Classification ofDiseases-10 code for Alagille syndrome, patients were identified using the following algorithm: ≥1 claim with diagnosis code Q44.7 (other congenital malformations of the liver); <18 years of age, with no history of biliary atresia (International Classification ofDiseases-10 code: Q44.2); and ≥6 months of insurance eligibility prior to diagnosis. HRU was summarized per patient per year over all available claims postdiagnosis.

RESULTS

A total of 171 commercially insured and 215 Medicaid-insured patients with Alagille syndrome were available for analysis. Annually, commercially insured and Medicaid-insured patients averaged 31 medical visits (range, 1.5-237) and 48 medical visits (range, 0.7-690), respectively. The most common visits were outpatient with the majority encompassing lab/imaging and primary care visits (commercially insured: 21 [range, 0.0-183]; Medicaid-insured: 26 [range, 0.0-609]). Inpatient visits were the highest driver of costs in both the commercial and Medicaid populations.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with Alagille syndrome have a substantial HRU burden driven largely by numerous outpatient visits and costly inpatient stays. Given the complexity and variability of Alagille syndrome presentation, patients may benefit from multidisciplinary and subspecialized care.

Primary vs. salvage liver transplantation for biliary atresia: A retrospective cohort study

INTRODUCTION

Kasai hepatoportoenterostomy is the standard of care for children with biliary atresia, but a majority of patients progress to end-stage liver disease and require a salvage liver transplant. Given the high failure rates of the hepatoportoenterostomy operation, some have advocated for primary liver transplantation as a superior treatment approach. The aim of this study was to compare outcomes of pediatric candidates with biliary atresia listed for primary vs. salvage liver transplantation.

METHODS

The SRTR/OPTN database was retrospectively reviewed for all children with biliary atresia listed for liver transplant between March 2002 and February 2021. Candidates were categorized as primary liver transplant if they had not undergone previous abdominal surgery prior to listing and salvage liver transplant if they had. Salvage transplants were further categorized as early failure if listed within the first year of life or late failure if listed at an older age.

RESULTS

3438 children with biliary atresia were listed for transplant during the study period, with 15% of them listed for a primary transplant, 17% for salvage transplant after early failure, and 67% after late failure. Recipients of salvage liver transplant with late failure had lower bilirubin levels and were less critically ill as demonstrated by MELD/PELD scores and hospitalization status. Correspondingly, these recipients had higher waiting list and graft survival, though this did not remain statistically significant after adjustment in multivariable models. There were no differences in waiting list, recipient, or graft survival with primary vs. salvage liver transplant after early failure.

CONCLUSION

Kasai hepatoportoenterostomy should remain the standard of care in biliary atresia as it may delay need for transplant beyond the first year of life in a subset of recipients and does not jeopardize subsequent transplant outcomes, even with early failure.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Retrospective cohort study (Level III).

Management of biliary atresia: To transplant or not to transplant

Kasai procedure (KP) and liver transplantation (LT) represent the only therapeutic options for patients with biliary atresia (BA), the most common indication for LT in the pediatric population. However, KP represents by no means a radical option but rather a bridging one, as nearly all patients will finally require a liver graft. More and more experts in the field of transplant surgery propose that maybe it is time for a paradigm change in BA treatment and abandon KP as transplantation seems inevitable. Inadequacy of organs yet makes this option currently not feasible, so it seems useful to find ways to maximize the efficacy of KP. In previous decades, multiple studies tried to identify these factors which opt for better results, but in general, outcomes of KP have not improved to the level that was anticipated. This review provides the framework of conditions which favor native liver survival after KP and the ones which optimize a positive LT outcome. Strategies of transition of care at the right time are also presented, as transplantation plays a key role in the surgical treatment of BA. Future studies and further organization in the transplant field will allow for greater organ availability and better outcomes to be achieved for BA patients.