Infrequent transforming mutations in the transmembrane domain of the neu oncogene in spontaneous rat schwannomas

Causation of nervous system tumors in children: insights from traditional and genetically engineered animal models

Pediatric neurogenic tumors include primitive neuroectodermal tumors (PNETs), especially medulloblastoma; ependymomas and choroid plexus papillomas; astrocytomas; retinoblastoma; and sympathetic neuroblastoma. Meningiomas and nerve sheath tumors, although uncommon in childhood, are also significant because they can result from exposures of children to ionizing radiation. Specific chromosomal loci and specific genes are related to each of these tumor types. Virtually all these genes appear to act as tumor suppressor genes, which are inactivated in tumor cells by mutations or by chromosomal loss. In genetically engineered mice, some genes that are clearly associated with specific human tumors (e.g., RB1 in retinoblastoma and NF2 in meningiomas and schwannomas) have no such effect. Other genetic constructs in mice involving the genes p53, ptc1, and Nf1 have produced tumors remarkably similar to some of the human pediatric neoplasms. Some of these tumors become clinically apparent after only a few weeks, while the mice are still juveniles, especially when two or more tumor suppressor genes are inactivated in the same genetic construct. Conversely, at least one genetic pathway in rodents involving point mutation in the coding region of a transforming gene (neu in malignant schwannomas) does not appear to operate in any human tumors. The nervous system is markedly susceptible to experimental carcinogenesis during early life in rodents, dogs, primates, and other nonhuman species, and there is no obvious reason why this generalization should not also apply to humans. However, except for therapeutic ionizing radiation, no physical, chemical, or biological cause of human pediatric nervous system tumors is known. The failure of experimental transplacental carcinogenesis to mirror human pediatric experience more closely may reflect the need for multiple mutational events in target cells, and for experimental carcinogens that are capable of causing the full spectrum of mutations that occur in cancer-related genes in pediatric neurogenic tumors.

Studies of oncogene activation and tumor suppressor gene inactivation in normal and neoplastic rodent tissue

Emerging short-term bioassays for chemically-induced carcinogenesis are dependent for their relevance to human risk assessment on the degree of coincidence of human and rodent tumor pathways. Since these pathways do not always converge, these new tests may have a number of unanticipated pitfalls. Models of liver and renal tumors are described. The results from Rb and p53 tumor suppressor gene transgenic animals are compared to human tumor syndromes. The question of mutagenic and epigenetic fingerprints of chemicals versus the cell-specific selection of spontaneous mutations is debated. Examples of specific pitfalls, such as the recently discovered Helicobacter hepaticus promoted liver tumors in mice are presented. The rat pseudogenes for p53 and the rare role of p53 in most important rodent tumor models other than epithelial tumors present experimental quandaries. The differential effects of carcinogens during various stages of rodent perinatal and adult development are also discussed. It is concluded that the pathways of both animal models and their human counterparts should be better identified so that realistic endpoint markers can be chosen for human carcinogenic risk assessment.