Is Benign Hereditary Chorea Really Benign? Brain-Lung-Thyroid Syndrome Caused by NKX2-1 Mutations

Moreno J, Blasco-Amaro JA, Léger J, Ortigoza-Escobar JD. Systematic review of thyroid function in NKX2-1-related disorders: Treatment and follow-up

BACKGROUND

NKX2-1, a crucial transcription factor in thyroid, lung, and brain development, is associated with rare disorders featuring thyroid dysfunction, neurological abnormalities, and respiratory symptoms. The primary challenge in managing NKX2-1-related disorders (NKX2-1-RD) is early diagnosis of the genetic defect and treating specific endocrine disorders. Levothyroxine (LT4) serves as the standard hypothyroidism treatment, with required dosages influenced by the severity of the individual's disorder, which varies widely among affected individuals.

OBJECTIVES

This systematic review aims to assess the effectiveness of LT4 treatment in NKX2-1-RD and explore optimal dosing strategies. The primary focus is on the challenges associated with the prompt diagnosis of genetic defects, rather than the established treatment protocols for individual endocrine failures.

METHODS

Adhering to PRISMA guidelines, the review includes 42 studies involving 110 genetically confirmed NKX2-1-RD patients with hypothyroidism. The study investigates congenital hypothyroidism as the most prevalent endocrine alteration, along with gestational and overt hypothyroidism. The administration of LT4 treatment, dosages, and patient responses are analyzed.

RESULTS

Among the findings, congenital hypothyroidism emerges as the predominant endocrine alteration in 41% of patients. Notably, LT4 treatment is administered in only 10% of cases, with a mean dose of 52 μg/day. The variability in initiation and dosage is likely influenced by the age at diagnosis. Positive responses, characterized by TSH adjustments within normal ranges, are observed in 11 monitored patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Early detection of congenital hypothyroidism is emphasized for timely LT4 initiation. Challenges in standardization are highlighted due to the variability in clinical manifestations and diagnostic procedures across NKX2-1-RD cases. While this review provides valuable insights into thyroid and pituitary disease treatment, limited details on LT4 treatment represent a significant study limitation. Key reporting points for future case studies are proposed to enhance the understanding and management of NKX2-1-RD hypothyroidism.

Differential diagnosis of Huntington's disease- neurological aspects of NKX2-1-related disorders

Benign hereditary chorea (BHC) is an inherited neurological disorder consisting of childhood-onset, nonprogressive chorea, generally without any other manifestations. In most reported cases, the inheritance of BHC is autosomal dominant but both incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity are observed and can be caused by NKX2-1 mutations. The spectrum contains choreoathetosis, congenital hypothyroidism, and neonatal respiratory distress syndrome. The neurological symptoms can be misdiagnosed as Huntington's disease (HD). The two Polish families were diagnosed with NKX2-1 gene mutations and a literature review concerning the NKX2-1-related disorders was conducted. All family members were examined by experienced movement disorders specialists. PubMed database was searched to obtain previously described NKX2-1 cases. Whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed in one proband (Family A) and direct NKX2-1 sequencing in the second (Family B). Two Polish families were diagnosed with NKX2-1 gene mutations (p.Trp208Leu and p.Cys117Alafs*8). In one family, the co-occurrence of HD was reported. Forty-nine publications were included in the literature review and symptoms of 195 patients with confirmed NKX2-1 mutation were analyzed. The most common symptoms were chorea and choreiform movements, and delayed motor milestones. The NKX2-1 mutation should always be considered as a potential diagnosis in families with chorea, even with a family history of HD. Lack of chorea does not exclude the NKX2-1-related disorders.

Haploinsufficiency of NKX2-1 is likely to contribute to developmental delay involving 14q13 microdeletions

Nucleotide variations or deletions in the NK2 homeobox 1 gene (NKX2-1), located at 14q13.3, lead to symptoms associated with the brain, lungs, and thyroid, and the combination of these phenotypes is clinically recognized as the brain-lung-thyroid syndrome. Many types of nucleotide variants of NKX2-1 have been identified, and phenotypic variability has been reported. Chromosomal deletions involving NKX2-1 have also been reported; however, phenotypic differences between patients with nucleotide variants of NKX2-1 and patients with chromosomal deletions involving NKX2-1 have not been well established. Recently, we identified seven patients with 14q13 microdeletions involving the NKX2-1. Most patients exhibited developmental delay. This inquiry arises regarding the potential existence of haploinsufficiency effects beyond those attributed to NKX2-1 within the 14q13 microdeletion. However, a literature review has shown that developmental delay is not rare in patients with nucleotide alterations in NKX2-1. Rather, motor function impairment may have affected the total developmental assessment, and the haploinsufficiency of genes contiguous to NKX2-1 is unlikely to contribute to developmental delay.

Systematic review of drug therapy for chorea in NXK2-1-related disorders: Efficacy and safety evidence from case studies and series

BACKGROUND

The NKX2-1-related disorders (NKX2-1-RD) is a rare disorder characterized by choreiform movements along with respiratory and endocrine abnormalities. The European Reference Network of Rare Neurological Disorders funded by the European Commission conducted a systematic review to assess drug treatment of chorea in NKX2-1-RD, aiming to provide clinical recommendations for its management.

METHODS

A systematic pairwise review using various databases, including MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane, CINAHL, and PsycInfo, was conducted. The review included patients diagnosed with chorea and NKX2-1-RD genetic diagnosis, drug therapy as intervention, no comparator, and outcomes of chorea improvement and adverse events. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed, and the study protocol was registered in PROSPERO.

RESULTS

Of the 1417 studies examined, 28 studies met the selection criteria, consisting of 68 patients. The studies reported 22 different treatments for chorea, including carbidopa/levodopa, tetrabenazine, clonazepam, methylphenidate, carbamazepine, topiramate, trihexyphenidyl, haloperidol, propranolol, risperidone, and valproate. No clinical improvements were observed with carbidopa/levodopa, tetrabenazine, or clonazepam, and various adverse effects were reported. However, most patients treated with methylphenidate experienced improvements in chorea and reported only a few negative effects. The quality of evidence was determined to be low.

CONCLUSIONS

The management of chorea in individuals with NKX2-1-RD presents significant heterogeneity and lack of clarity. While the available evidence suggests that methylphenidate may be effective in improving chorea symptoms, the findings should be interpreted with caution due to the limitations of the studies reviewed. Nonetheless, more rigorous and comprehensive studies are necessary to provide sufficient evidence for clinical recommendations.

Chorea: An unusual manifestation of endocrine diseases

Chorea is a movement disorder involving involuntary movements of muscles of the face, neck, and limbs, usually caused by basal ganglia lesions. As an important part of the presentation of many neurological diseases, chorea is also an unusual manifestation of endocrine diseases and can be challenging to diagnose. Although the most common etiology of chorea is genetic, it is vital to identify acquired or symptomatic chorea, as these are potentially treatable conditions. This review summarizes the latest developments in various endocrine disease-related chorea, which will help clinicians to correctly identify and accurately treat it.

Altered pituitary morphology as a sign of benign hereditary chorea caused by TITF1/NKX2.1 mutations

Benign hereditary chorea (BHC) is a rare genetically heterogeneous movement disorder, in which conventional neuroimaging has been reported as normal in most cases. Cystic pituitary abnormalities and features of empty sella have been described in only 7 patients with BHC to date. We present 4 patients from 2 families with a BHC phenotype, 3 of whom underwent targeted pituitary MR imaging and genetic testing. All four patients in the two families displayed a classic BHC phenotype. The targeted pituitary MR imaging demonstrated abnormal pituitary sella morphology. Genetic testing was performed in three patients, and showed mutations causing BHC in three of the patients, as well as identifying a novel nonsense mutation of the TITF1/NKX2-1 gene in one of the patients. The presence of the abnormal pituitary sella in two affected members of the same family supports the hypothesis that this sign is a distinct feature of the BHC phenotype spectrum due to mutations in the TITF1 gene. Interestingly, these abnormalities seem to develop in adult life and are progressive. They occur in at least 26% of patients affected with Brain-lung-thyroid syndrome. As a part of the management of these patients we recommend to perform follow-up MRI brain with dedicated pituitary imaging also in adult life as the abnormality can occur years after the onset of chorea.

Working memory, attention and planning abilities in NKX2.1-related chorea

BACKGROUND

Although NKX 2.1 related chorea has been considered benign due to the favourable course of motor phenotype during life, the neurological condition is not limited to chorea, including non-motor symptoms in the developmental, cognitive and psychiatric domain. Aim of our study was to test working memory, attention and planning abilities of a cohort of NKX2.1 choreic patients compared to healthy controls.

METHODS

patients and healthy controls were assessed for working memory (Visual Digit Span test), response inhibition and sustained attention (Cued Go/No-Go test), and spatial problem-solving and planning task (Tower of London test). For experimental protocol, we used a computer based tool for neuropsychological experiments, Inquisit 5.0 software (Millisecond Software®). Non-parametric tests were performed for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

six patients and fifteen healthy paediatric controls were recruited. In the Digit Span test, both in forward and backward recall, patients showed statistically significant lower scores than controls. In the Cued Go/No-Go test as well as in the Tower of London, NKX 2.1 patients showed similar scores in the error rate and total score respectively, whereas in both tests they appeared to be slower than controls suggesting a poor performance in the execution of the tests.

CONCLUSIONS

our findings demonstrate that patients with NKX2.1-related chorea show a selective impairment in working memory with increased latencies in both planning and attention. A developmental alteration of the cholinergic neurotransmission in the basal forebrain and the disruption of striatal networks could explain, at least in part, this neuropsychological profile.

Tics, tremors and other movement disorders in childhood

Movement disorders presenting in childhood include tics, dystonia, chorea, tremor, stereotypy, myoclonus, and parkinsonism, each of which can be part of various clinical syndromes with distinct etiologies.  Some of these conditions are benign and require only reassurance; others are bothersome and require treatment, or may be clues that herald underlying pathology.  Answers lie in the inherent characteristics of the movements themselves, together with the clinical context provided in the history obtained by the examiner.  The aim of this review is to present an overview of the categories of involuntary movements, along with examples of common acquired and genetic causes, and an approach to history-taking, examination, and treatment.

Hypoxaemia and interstitial lung disease in an infant with hypothyroidism and hypotonia

A 7-month-old-term male infant presented with cough, tachypnoea, hypoxaemia and post-tussive emesis. Clinical history was significant for respiratory failure and pulmonary hypertension in the neonatal period requiring assisted ventilation, congenital hypothyroidism, mild hypotonia, recurrent respiratory infections, hypoxaemia requiring supplemental oxygen and nasogastric tube feeds. Physical examination showed tachypnoea, coarse bilateral breath sounds and mild hypotonia. Chest radiograph revealed multifocal pulmonary opacities with coarse interstitial markings and right upper lobe atelectasis. Following antibiotic therapy for suspected aspiration pneumonia, chest CT scan was performed and showed multiple areas of pulmonary consolidation and scattered areas of bilateral ground-glass opacities. Genetic studies showed a large deletion of chromosome 14q13.1-14q21.1, encompassing the NK2 homeobox 1 (NKX2-1) gene consistent with a diagnosis of brain-thyroid-lung (BTL) syndrome. Our case highlights the importance of genetic studies to diagnose BTL syndrome in infants with hypothyroidism, hypotonia and lung disease.

Review of Hereditary and Acquired Rare Choreas

Background:

Movement disorders are often a prominent part of the phenotype of many neurologic rare diseases. In order to promote awareness and diagnosis of these rare diseases, the International Parkinson’s and Movement Disorders Society Rare Movement Disorders Study Group provides updates on rare movement disorders.

Methods:

In this narrative review, we discuss the differential diagnosis of the rare disorders that can cause chorea.

Results:

Although the most common causes of chorea are hereditary, it is critical to identify acquired or symptomatic choreas since these are potentially treatable conditions. Disorders of metabolism and mitochondrial cytopathies can also be associated with chorea.

Discussion:

The present review discusses clues to the diagnosis of chorea of various etiologies. Authors propose algorithms to help the clinician in the diagnosis of these rare disorders.

The GRIA3 c.2477G > A Variant Causes an Exaggerated Startle Reflex, Chorea, and Multifocal Myoclonus

BACKGROUND

Hemizygous mutations in GRIA3 encoding the GluA3 subunit of the amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid receptor are known to be associated with neurodevelopmental disorders, including intellectual disability, hypotonia, an autism spectrum disorder, sleep disturbances, and epilepsy in males.

OBJECTIVE

To describe a new and consistent phenotype in 4 affected male patients associated with an undescribed deleterious variant in GRIA3.

METHODS

We evaluated a large French family in which segregate a singular phenotype according to an apparent X-linked mode of inheritance. Molecular analyses using next generation sequencing and in vitro functional studies using 2-electrode voltage clamp recordings on Xenopus laevis oocytes and a β-lactamase reporter assay in transfected human embryonic kidney (HEK293) cells were performed.

RESULTS

In addition to mild intellectual disability and dysarthria, affected patients presented a tightly consistent early-onset movement disorder combining an exaggerated startle reflex with generalized chorea and multifocal myoclonus. The unreported GRIA3 missense variant c.2477G > A; p.(Gly826Asp) affecting the fourth transmembrane domain of the protein was identified in index patients and their unaffected mothers. Functional studies revealed that variant receptors show decreased current response evoked by agonist (ie, kainic acid and glutamate) and reduced expression on the cell surface in favor of pathogenicity by a loss-of-function mechanism.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, our results suggest that apart from known GRIA3-related disorders, an undescribed mutation-specific singular movement disorder does exist. We thus advocate considering GRIA3 mutations in the differential diagnosis of hyperekplexia and generalized chorea with myoclonus. © 2020 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

ADCY5-Related Dyskinesia: Improving Clinical Detection of an Evolving Disorder

BACKGROUND

The phenotypic spectrum of adenylyl cyclase 5 (ADCY5)-related disease has expanded considerably since the first description of the disorder in 1978 as familial essential chorea in a multiplex family.

OBJECTIVE

To examine recent advances in the understanding of ADCY5-related dyskinesia and outline a diagnostic approach to enhance clinical detection.

METHODS

A pragmatic review of the ADCY5 literature was undertaken to examine unique genetic and pathophysiological features as well as distinguishing clinical features.

RESULTS

With over 70 cases reported to date, the phenotype is recognized to be broad, although distinctive features include prominent facial dyskinesia, motor exacerbations during drowsiness or sleep arousal, episodic painful dystonic posturing increased with stress or illness, and axial hypotonia with delayed developmental milestones. Uncommon phenotypes include childhood-onset chorea, myoclonus-dystonia, isolated nongeneralized dystonia, and alternating hemiplegia.

CONCLUSION

The ongoing expansion in clinical features suggests that ADCY5 remains underdiagnosed and may account for a proportion of "idiopathic" hyperkinetic movement disorders. Enhanced understanding of its clinical features may help clinicians improve the detection of complex or uncommon cases.