Haplotype analysis at the DYT1 locus in Ashkenazi Jewish patients with occupational hand dystonia

Focal Hand Dystonia Affecting Musicians. Part I: An Overview Of Epidemiology, PathoPhysiology And Medical Treatments

In 1911, Oppenheim coined the term ‘dystonia’ to describe disordered motor control, characterised by an association of hypotonia and tonic muscle spasm. Focal hand dystonia is one form of this disorder, in which symptoms are often task-specific and occur during skilled movements such as writing (writer's cramp) or playing a musical instrument (musician's cramp). Much research has been conducted on the pathophysiology of dystonia, but the underlying mechanisms still remain unclear. Hypotheseses about functional central nervous system alterations continue to gain more support. Scientific treatment-based publications on focal dystonia are sparse, and progress in evidence-based treatment options are necessary in order to assist this patient group. This paper will review the literature, documenting dystonia classification criteria, manifestations, pathophysiology and medical treatment techniques for musicians affected by focal hand dystonia.

Changes in resting-state brain networks in writer's cramp

OBJECTIVES

Writer's cramp (WC) is characterized by excessive cocontractions of agonist and antagonist hand and forearm muscles during writing. Changes in functional magnetic resonance imaging activation patterns in such conditions can be ambiguous as they might either reflect some aspect of the primary pathophysiological mechanism or, alternatively, may be the result of adaptive actions during task execution. To circumvent this problem, we examined WC patients during rest, i.e., without a task, using independent component analysis (ICA) applied to the blood oxygen level-dependent time series.

METHODS

Functionally connected brain networks during rest were defined by ICA to assess differences between WC patients (n = 16) and healthy controls (n = 16). Analysis was carried out using FMRIB's Software Library.

RESULTS

Two functional networks showed between-group differences, the sensorimotor network and the default-mode network. In WC patients, the connectivity was reduced in the left postcentral area and increased in basal ganglia in contrast to healthy controls. These changes were not reversed after treatment with botulinum toxin.

CONCLUSIONS

In line with other studies, the results show a dysfunction in cortico-subcortical circuits in WC involving somatosensory cortex, areas interfacing the sensory and motor systems, and putamen contralateral to symptomatic hand.

Task-specific dystonias: a review

Task-specific dystonias are primary focal dystonias characterized by excessive muscle contractions producing abnormal postures during selective motor activities that often involve highly skilled, repetitive movements. Historically these peculiar postures were considered psychogenic but have now been classified as forms of dystonia. Writer's cramp is the most commonly identified task-specific dystonia and has features typical of this group of disorders. Symptoms may begin with lack of dexterity during performance of a specific motor task with increasingly abnormal posturing of the involved body part as motor activity continues. Initially, the dystonia may manifest only during the performance of the inciting task, but as the condition progresses it may also occur during other activities or even at rest. Neurological exam is usually unremarkable except for the dystonia-related abnormalities. Although the precise pathophysiology remains unclear, increasing evidence suggests reduced inhibition at different levels of the sensorimotor system. Symptomatic treatment options include oral medications, botulinum toxin injections, neurosurgical procedures, and adaptive strategies. Prognosis may vary depending upon body part involved and specific type of task affected. Further research may reveal new insights into the etiology, pathophysiology, natural history, and improved treatment of these conditions.

Learning-based animal models: task-specific focal hand dystonia

Dystonia is a disabling, involuntary disorder of movement that leads to writhing, twisting end-range movements or abnormal postures. Inadequate inhibition could account for excessive excitation and near synchronous co-contractions of agonists and antagonists. Dystonia may be generalized or specific, affecting only one part of the body or involving only a well-learned task (e.g., writing, keyboarding, golfing, playing a musical instrument). Task-specific and other focal dystonias are considered idiopathic, with multiple factors such as genetics, anatomy, physiology, psychology, environment, and behavioral characteristics contributing to the development of symptoms. This article provides detailed descriptions of two behavioral animal models (a primate [owl monkey] model and a rodent [Sprague-Dawley rat] model) developed to study the effect of excessive repetition as a potential etiology of focal hand dystonia (FHd). The hypothesis is that repetitive, near simultaneous hand movements can degrade the topographic representations of the hand on the somatic sensory and motor cortices, creating the involuntary movements characteristic of dystonia. While animal studies permit the opportunity for greater control to determine efficacy, the findings must always be confirmed by clinical studies to evaluate sensitivity and specificity of diagnosis and effectiveness of treatment in the home, work, and personal environment. This article presents a review of the etiology and clinical implications for intervention strategies from animal and clinical studies that support learning-based mechanisms for FHd. Other animal models are also briefly reviewed.

Effect of sensory discrimination training on structure and function in patients with focal hand dystonia: a case series

OBJECTIVE

To measure the effects of sensorimotor training based on the principles of neuroplasticity for patients with focal hand dystonia.

DESIGN

Case series of 3 subjects with focal hand dystonia of the left hand, compared with age-matched normative controls.

SETTING

Outpatient clinic.

PARTICIPANTS

Three consecutive clinic patients-musicians with focal hand dystonia-who described a history of repetitive practice and performance (2 women; ages, 23 y and 35 y; 1 man; age, 24 y).

INTERVENTION

Subjects were asked to stop performing the tasks that caused the abnormal movements, to participate in a wellness program (aerobics, postural exercises, stress free hand use), and to carry out supervised, attended, individualized, repetitive sensorimotor training activities at least once week for 12 weeks and reinforced daily at home.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Standard tests documenting somatosensory hand representation, target-specific hand control, and clinical function.

RESULTS

On the affected side, the 3 subjects improved an average of 86.8% on somatosensory hand representation, 117% on target-specific performance, 23.9% on fine motor skills, 22.7% on sensory discrimination, 31.9% on musculoskeletal skills, and 32.3% on independence. All 3 subjects improved 10% or more on 90% of the subtests with 20% improvement on 50% of the subtests.

CONCLUSION

Individuals with focal hand dystonia who have a history of repetitive hand use can improve cortical somatosensory responses and clinical motor function after individualized sensorimotor training consistent with the principles of neural adaptation.

The DYT1 GAG deletion is infrequent in sporadic and familial writer' s cramp

A 3-base pair (GAG) deletion in the DYT1 gene has recently been found to be responsible for most cases of early-onset primary generalized dystonia. In some cases, this mutation has been associated with writer's cramp. To determine the frequency of this mutation in a larger series of patients, we examined 44 index patients with sporadic or familial (seven patients) writer's cramp for the presence of the DYT1 GAG deletion, including eight patients with segmental dystonia involving at least one upper limb. We found the mutation in none of these index patients, which confirms that isolated writer's cramp is only in rare cases a phenotypic manifestation of this mutation, even if a positive family history of writer's cramp is present.

Treatment effectiveness for patients with a history of repetitive hand use and focal hand dystonia: a planned, prospective follow-up study

Recent studies show that rapid, nearly simultaneous, stereotypical repetitive fine motor movements can degrade the sensory representation of the hand and lead to a loss of normal motor control with a target task, referred to as occupational hand cramps or focal hand dystonia. The purpose of this prospective follow-up study was to determine whether symptomatic patients in jobs demanding high levels of repetition could be relieved of awkward, involuntary hand movements following sensory discriminative retraining complemented by a home program of sensory exercises, plus traditional posture, relaxation, mobilization, and fitness exercises. Twelve patients participated in the study. They all had occupational hand cramps, as diagnosed by a neurologist. Each patient was evaluated by a trained, independent research assistant before treatment and three to six months after treatment, by use of a battery of sensory, motor, physical, and functional performance tests. Care was provided by a physical therapist or a supervised physical therapist student in an outpatient clinic. Patients were asked to stop performing the target task and to come once a week for supervised treatment that included 1) heavy schedules of sensory training with and without biofeedback to restore the sensory representation of the hand, and 2) instructions in stress-free hand use, mirror imagery, mental rehearsal, and mental practice techniques designed to stop the abnormal movements and facilitate normal hand control. Patients were instructed in therapeutic exercises to be performed in the home to improve postural alignment, reduce neural tension, facilitate relaxation, and promote cardiopulmonary fitness. Following the defined treatment period, all patients were independent in activities of daily living, and all but one patient returned to work. Significant gains were documented in motor control, motor accuracy; sensory discrimination, and physical performance (range of motion, strength, posture, and balance). This descriptive study that includes patients with occupation-related focal hand dystonia provides evidence that aggressive sensory discriminative training complemented by traditional fitness exercises to facilitate musculoskeletal health can improve sensory processing and motor control of the hand.

Movement dysfunction following repetitive hand opening and closing: anatomical analysis in Owl monkeys

Repetitive strain injuries are thought to result from biomechanical stress and tissue microtrauma. The purpose of this study was to investigate the presence of local inflammation, scarring or anatomical variations of the flexor tendons and the median and ulnar nerves in four Owl monkeys behaviorally trained at a repetitive motor or sensory task. Three monkeys were trained to repetitively open and close a handpiece. The two monkeys that used rapid, stereotypical hand squeezing developed a task-specific movement dysfunction (one in 5 weeks and one in 24 weeks). The third monkey used a variable shoulder-pulling strategy and did not develop movement problems. The fourth monkey served as a control subject for the repetitive motor movements, trained on a repetitive sensory task, and did not develop a task-specific movement dysfunction. On dissection and histologic staining, there were no signs of active inflammation in the median nerve, the ulnar nerve, or the flexor tendons in any of the monkeys. However, the monkey that developed movement problems after 5 weeks of repetitive hand squeezing had an anatomical restriction of the flexor profundus tendon on the fourth digit of the trained side and the third digit of the untrained side. Reorganization of the representation of the hand on the contralateral somatosensory cortex (area 3b) was noted in the two monkeys that developed motor control problems and in the monkey performing the repetitive sensory task. These findings suggest that repetitive, stereotypical motor behaviors can lead to motor control problems without local signs of tendon or nerve inflammation. Preexisting anatomical restrictions may modify the time course for the development of movement dysfunction under conditions of stressful repetition. This animal model may simulate clinical focal hand dystonia (or occupational hand cramps) which can develop in human subjects who perform prolonged, repetitive, stereotypical movements.

Mutational and biochemical analysis of dopamine in dystonia: evidence for decreased dopamine D2 receptor inhibition

The dystonias are a group of serious movement disorders characterized by involuntary muscle spasms of different parts of the body. We recently proposed that hypofunction of dopamine D2 receptor-mediated inhibition of the indirect output pathway of the basal ganglia can result in dystonia. In this review, we discuss the results of a variety of genetic and biochemical studies in light of this hypothesis. Several forms of early-onset dystonia show distinct autosomal dominant, recessive, or X-linked genetic transmission patterns. Late onset forms of dystonia, though not showing clear Mendelian transmission patterns, also appear to be highly familial. Recently, several genetic-linkage locations have been identified for early-onset dystonia and for two of these loci, mutations decreasing dopamine synthesis have been demonstrated. Biochemical studies of monkeys and man also demonstrate that several types of dystonia occur in a dopamine-deficiency state. Similarly, mice strains developed to be deficient in several dopamine-pathway components have motor abnormalities consistent with dystonia. Hypofunction of the dopamine D2 receptor-mediated inhibition of the indirect output pathway of the putamen may be a common feature of many of these heritable and secondary dystonic syndromes.

The early-onset torsion dystonia gene (DYT1) encodes an ATP-binding protein

Early-onset torsion dystonia is a movement disorder, characterized by twisting muscle contractures, that begins in childhood. Symptoms are believed to result from altered neuronal communication in the basal ganglia. This study identifies the DYT1 gene on human chromosome 9q34 as being responsible for this dominant disease. Almost all cases of early-onset dystonia have a unique 3-bp deletion that appears to have arisen idependently in different ethnic populations. This deletion results in loss of one of a pair of glutamic-acid residues in a conserved region of a novel ATP-binding protein, termed torsinA. This protein has homologues in nematode, rat, mouse and humans, with some resemblance to the family of heat-shock proteins and Clp proteases.

The neural consequences of repetition: clinical implications of a learning hypothesis

Repetitive strain injuries (RSIs) are difficult to treat. Some individuals with RSIs may ultimately develop chronic pain syndromes or movement problems like focal hand dystonia (FDh), a disorder of motor control manifested in a specific context during skilled, hand tasks. This paper reports on the results of four neuroplasticity studies suggesting that repetitive hand opening and closing can lead to motor control problems, measurable somatosensory changes, and problems in graphesthesia and stereognosis. The experiments support a learning hypothesis for the origin of severe RSIs, particularly FDh. This degradation in the sensory representation of the hand may not only explain the therapeutic challenge of returning these patients to work, but also provide a foundation for developing more effective physical rehabilitation strategies. Implications and conjectures for the applications of this learning hypothesis to conditions of chronic pain are also discussed.