Vascularized bone allografts: review of current concepts

Versatility of the medial corticoperiosteal flap: from recalcitrant non-unions up to large bony defects

BACKGROUND

Reconstructive microsurgery techniques using vascularized bone grafts have revolutionized the treatment of complex cases associated with recalcitrant non-unions or osteomyelitis. The medial femoral corticoperiosteal flap (MFCP flap) has emerged as a valuable option in bone reconstruction. Its clinical applications have been extended over the years considering this flap from non-unions with minimal bone lost, up to large intercalary defects of the upper and lower extremities. This article aims to present the clinical applications and outcomes of the MFCP flap in various reconstructive scenarios.

METHODS

Seventy-nine patients with persistent non-union and bone defects of the upper and lower limb were evaluated from June 2008 to October 2020. All of them were reconstructed with a corticoperiosteal flap from the medial femoral condyle in our hospital. Previous procedures, bone gap and type of flap used were recorded. Postoperative functional status was assessed with time of bone healing, complications and clinical final outcome.

RESULTS

Radiological evidence of bone union was observed at 4.09 months (range 2-9). Healing rate was 97% with periosteal corticocancellous flaps (PCC flaps) and 93% with corticoperiosteal flaps (CP flaps). Average follow-up was 14.5 months (range 5-28). There were no significant donor site complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The MFCP flap offers a versatile and reliable option for bone reconstruction. Its ability to provide vascularized bone tissue with low morbidity enhances the healing process and improves outcomes. The MFCP flap has been increasing its applications and it serves as a valuable option in the treatment of recalcitrant non-unions or bony defects irrespective of site and size up to 5 cm in the upper and lower extremities.

Surgical Solution for Total Carpectomy due to Destructive Wrist Pan-Osteomyelitis Using a Free Femoral Condyle Osteocutaneous Flap for Wrist Arthrodesis

Osteomyelitis of the hand is rare, even more so in the carpal bones. Patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have a higher infection rate overall, and up to a 14-fold increase in the incidence of septic arthritis of the hand. The destruction of immunologic barriers, such as cartilage and joint capsules, as well as the use of immunosuppressive medications will have an impact on the higher incidence of articular infections and osteomyelitis in these patients. Infection in these cases is often overlooked because of the similarity of presentation to an acute event of RA. When osteomyelitis is present, rapid and aggressive treatment should be given. Surgical debridement, lavage, and excision of necrotic bone is the best choice, followed by cemented antibiotic impregnated spacer to resolve the acute scenario. Vascularized bone grafts (VBG) can then be used for a definitive solution, as these have great biologic properties that increase the possibility of a good outcome. We hereby present a report of a wrist arthrodesis, using a free medial femoral condyle VBG for the treatment of destructive osteomyelitis of the carpal bones in a female patient with RA.

Transplant chimerism in porcine structural vascularized bone allotransplants

BACKGROUND

Bone allotransplant viability can be maintained long-term by implanting arteriovenous (AV) bundles and creating an autogenous neoangiogenic circulation. Only short-term immunosuppression is required. This study investigates the origin of viable osteocytes observed in areas of active bone remodeling in orthotopically transplanted tibiae in a Yucatan mini-pig model.

METHODS

Segmental tibial defects created in female Yucatan minipigs (N = 14) were reconstructed with a matched vascularized composite allotransplant from a male donor. The circulation was microsurgically restored, with simultaneous autogenous AV-bundle implantation in group 1 (N = 7). A ligated AV-bundle was implanted as a no-angiogenesis control in group 2 (N = 7). After 20-weeks, repopulation of the allotransplant was assessed by real-time qPCR measurement of relative copy numbers of a Y chromosome-specific gene (SRY) and an autosomal housekeeping gene, ribosomal protein L4 (RPL4). A lower SRY/RPL4 ratio demonstrates replacement of male allogeneic cells with female, autogenous cells in the sample. Genomic DNA was extracted from cross-sections of the allotransplant, liver and spleen. Additionally, areas of new bone formation within the allotransplant were sampled by laser capture microdissection. A comparison was made between groups as well as male control samples. RNA was extracted from bone as well, as a measure of metabolically active cells.

RESULTS

Laser-captured areas of new bone formation in animals with both normal and ligated AV-bundles were found to have significantly lower relative copy numbers of SRY (p = 0.03) than control specimens from male bone, indicating replacement by female (autogenous) bone-forming cells. Analysis of an entire segment of the allotransplant from Group 1 was similarly reduced (p = 0.04), unlike that from Group 2. RNA expression of SRY was observed in both groups. No chimerism could be found in non-bone tissues (liver and spleen).

CONCLUSION

We observed a significant level of transplant chimerism in areas of new bone formation sampled by laser capture microdissection. The migration of autogenous cells including osteocytes was seen in both groups. Survival of some allogeneic (male) cells was also demonstrable. No microchimerism was found in liver and spleen.

Applied Bioengineering in Tissue Reconstruction, Replacement, and Regeneration

IMPACT STATEMENT

The use of autologous tissue in the reconstruction of tissue defects has been the gold standard. However, current standards still face many limitations and complications. Improving patient outcomes and quality of life by addressing these barriers remain imperative. This article provides historical perspective, covers the major limitations of current standards of care, and reviews recent advances and future prospects in applied bioengineering in the context of tissue reconstruction, replacement, and regeneration.

Current status of vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation

Vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation (VCA) offers treatment options of complex functional deficiencies that cannot be repaired with conventional reconstructive methods. VCAs consist of blocks of functional units comprising different tissue types such as skin, bone, muscle, nerves, blood vessels, tendons, ligaments and others, and are thus substantially different from the composition of organ transplants. The field of VCA has made fascinating progresses in the recent past. Among other VCAs, numerous successful hand, face and limb transplants have been performed in the world. At the same time, specific questions in regard to innate and adaptive immunity, consequences of ischemia/reperfusion injury, immunosuppression, preservation, and regenerative capacity remain. In spite of this, the field is poised to make significant advances in the near future.

Surgical angiogenesis with short-term immunosuppression maintains bone viability in rabbit allogenic knee joint transplantation

BACKGROUND

Vascularized composite allotransplantation has the potential for reconstruction of joint defects but requires lifelong immunosuppression, with substantial risks. This study evaluates an alternative, using surgical angiogenesis from implanted autogenous vessels to maintain viability without long-term immunotherapy.

METHODS

Vascularized knee joints were transplanted from Dutch Belted donors to New Zealand White rabbit recipients. Once positioned and revascularized microsurgically, a recipient-derived superficial inferior epigastric fascial flap and a saphenous arteriovenous bundle were placed within the transplanted femur and tibia, respectively, to develop a neoangiogenic, autogenous circulation. There were 10 transplants in group 1. Group 2 (n = 9) consisted of no-angiogenesis controls with ligated flaps and arteriovenous bundles. Group 3 rabbits (n = 10) were autotransplants with patent implants. Tacrolimus was used for 3 weeks to maintain nutrient flow during angiogenesis. At 16 weeks, the authors assessed bone healing, joint function, bone and cartilage mechanical properties, and histology.

RESULTS

Group 1 allotransplants had more robust angiogenesis, better healing, improved mechanical properties, and better osteocyte viability than ligated controls (group 2). All three groups developed knee joint contractures and arthritic changes. Cartilage thickness and quality were poorer in allograft groups than in autotransplant controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical angiogenesis from implanted autogenous tissue improves bone viability, healing, and material properties in rabbit allogenic knee transplants. However, joint contractures and degenerative changes occurred in all transplants, regardless of antigenicity or blood supply. Experimental studies in a larger animal model with improved methods to maintain joint mobility are needed before the merit of living joint allotransplantation can be judged.

Bone quality and healing in a swine vascularized bone allotransplantation model using cyclosporine-based immunosuppression therapy

Although vascularized bone and joint allotransplantation is a promising new treatment option for reconstructing large bone defects, the need for immunosuppressive agents to prevent rejection in these procedures poses a major problem. This problem stems from the fact that several of these agents can cause harmful side effects, such as alterations in bone quality and healing. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine what effect the commonly used immunosuppressant regimen cyclosporine A-based combination therapy has on bone quality and healing. In 10 pigs, vascularized bone allografts with skin and muscle components (osteomyocutaneous free flaps) were transplanted from size-matched donor animals. Recipient animals received oral cyclosporine A/mycophenolate mofetil/prednisone therapy for 90 days. Bone quality was studied before and after transplantation by measuring the bone's acoustic velocity and density and calculating the bone's elastic coefficient. Bone healing was assessed using radiographic analysis. Four animals were lost as a result of graft rejection or immunosuppression-related complications before the 90-day endpoint of the study. Although bone specimens taken from the six animals that completed the 90-day protocol had histological signs of rejection, they all seemed to have normal bone healing. Posttransplant bone density values were significantly decreased (p < 0.05) (1544.7 +/- 47.5 kg/m3) as compared with pretransplant values (1722.7 +/- 44.1 kg/m3). Results of the acoustic velocity and elastic coefficients measurements showed a significant decrease (p < 0.05) in posttransplant values (from 3503.0 +/- 165.1 meters/sec to 2963.0 +/- 54.6 meters/sec and from 21.6 +/- 2.2 GPa to 13.6 +/- 0.5 GPa, respectively), indicating diminished bone quality. The findings indicate that cyclosporine A/mycophenolate mofetil/prednisone combination therapy is ineffective in preventing bone rejection, that it decreases bone quality, and that it is associated with systemic toxicity, suggesting that this immunosuppressive regimen at the doses used in this study is not ideal for vascularized bone allotransplantation procedures.

Gradual graft-cell repopulation with recipient cells following vasularized bone and limb allotransplantation

Little is known about the fate of graft cells following vascularized bone allografting. This study was conducted to define the process of graft-cell repopulation with recipient cells. Sixty-five vascularized tibial bone and 50 limb allotransplantations were performed in rat sex-mismatched pairs. FK 506 was used for immunosuppression. The ratio of donor and recipient cells in the graft was evaluated by semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction, using the Y-chromosome primers. Allografted bones had no rejection episodes. In the vascularized bone allograft model, donor-derived cells were gradually replaced by cells of recipient origin, such that by 24 weeks, they comprised only 10% of total cells. In the limb allograft model, male recipient cells were detected in female grafts not at 1 week but at 48 weeks posttransplantation. The ratio of recipient cells was more than 10% in the femur and tibia. Recipient-derived cells gradually migrated into the grafted bone cells with the passage of time.

Effects of cessation of immunosuppression on skeleton reconstructed by vascularized bone allograft in rats

In the present study, we investigated the effects of cessation of immunosuppression on skeleton reconstructed by vascularized allogenic bone transplantation in a rat tibio-fibula graft model. Twelve-week-old male 25 Dark Agouti rats with the major histocompatibility antigen (MHC) RT1a were used as donors and age-matched male 25 Lewis rats with MHC RT1l were used as recipients. Among them, 20 rats were randomly allocated to 8-week cyclosporine A (CsA) followed by 8-week CsA vehicle group or continuous 16-week CsA group. The remaining 5 rats received CsA for 8 weeks followed by no further treatment for next 40 weeks (long-term observation group). In the CsA followed by vehicle group as well as the continuous CsA group, the structure of the reconstructed bones was maintained, though the transplanted bones in former group were found to be partly non-vital. The CsA followed by vehicle group had higher bone mineral density of the transplanted bones and stronger strength of the reconstructed bones than the continuous CsA group. In the long-term observation group, the structure of the reconstructed bones was still maintained and the transplanted bones were almost vital. These results suggest that long-term strong immunosuppression may not be necessary for successful reconstruction of large bone defect by vascularized bone allograft.

Successful allogeneic leg transplantation in rats in conjunction with intra-bone marrow injection of donor bone marrow cells1

BACKGROUND

We have recently established a new method for bone marrow transplantation (BMT) in mice: bone marrow cells are directly injected into the intra-bone marrow (IBM) cavity. IBM-BMT induces persistent donor-specific tolerance and enhances the rapid recovery or reconstitution of the hematolymphoid system of donor origin without any signs of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) or graft failure. Furthermore, the prior injection of fludarabine can reduce the irradiation dose to the sublethal level (4.5 Gy x 2). Therefore, we hypothesize that IBM-BMT plus fludarabine is applicable to allogeneic leg transplantation in rats.

METHODS

Brown Norway (BN; RT1An) rats were injected intravenously with 50 mg/kg of fludarabine phosphate, followed by sublethal fractionated irradiation (4.5 Gy x 2) 1 day before IBM-BMT. The hind limbs from Fischer 344 (F344; RT1Al) rats were transplanted on day 0, and bone marrow cells (3 x 10(7) cells/50 microL) obtained from the donor F344 rats were injected into the bone marrow cavity of the left tibias of the recipient BN rats.

RESULTS

The hematolymphoid cells in the recipient BN rats were completely reconstituted by the cells of the donor F344 rats. The limbs transplanted from the donor F344 rats were accepted for >1 year without any clinical signs of rejection (10 of 10). The lymphocytes of the BN rats showed tolerance to both donor-type and recipient-type major histocompatibility complex determinants in mixed lymphocyte reaction, but showed a significant response to the third-party major histocompatibility complex determinants.

CONCLUSIONS

Using a combination of the injection of fludarabine, low-dose irradiation, and IBM-BMT, we have succeeded in allogeneic limb transplantation without using any immunosuppressants after the operation. This strategy would be applicable to the transplantation of other vascularized organs in humans.

Fate of donor cells in vascularized bone grafts: identification of systemic chimerism by the polymerase chain reaction

Systemic chimerism, or the movement of cells from a transplanted tissue into host organs, is a phenomenon known to occur in association with development of immunological tolerance in allotransplantation. However, little is known about the fate and movement of cells into or out of autogenous free tissue transfers, including vascularized bone grafts. The purpose of this study was to identify systemic chimerism in vascularized bone grafts by transplantation of a vascularized tibiofibular graft from isogenous (inbred) male Lewis rats to female recipients. Donor (male) cells could be identified in the recipient (female) tissues by semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction analysis for a Y chromosome-specific DNA sequence. Chimerism was assessed at 1, 12, 18, and 24 weeks after transplantation. Competitive polymerase chain reaction study using the specific primers for a Y-chromosome marker ( gene) and an autosomal gene (GAPDH) allowed detection of small amounts of male cells in a large pool of female cells and measurement of their relative proportions as a function of time. Of 19 nonimmunosuppressed recipients, nine animals (47 percent) showed low-level chimerism (<0.1 percent) in the peripheral blood. Nine (47 percent), three (16 percent), and two (11 percent) recipients showed high-level chimerism (>1 percent) in the spleen, liver, and thymus, respectively, at final assessment. Donor cells were detected in all bone grafts and in six contralateral tibial bones (i.e., 67 percent of sampled contralateral tibial bones) at 18 and 24 weeks after transplantation. Twenty-four recipients were immunosuppressed with FK506 (tacrolimus) to suppress reaction to a minor histocompatibility barrier present on the Y chromosome. In this group, 14 animals (58 percent) showed low-level chimerism in peripheral blood and 12 (50 percent), eight (33 percent), and one (4 percent) recipients showed high-level chimerism in the spleen, thymus, and liver, respectively. Transplanted cells were detected in nine contralateral tibial bones (i.e., 60 percent of sampled contralateral tibial bones) at 12 and 18 weeks after surgery. The results indicate that polymerase chain reaction for the Y chromosome is a useful tool for differentiating between donor and recipient cell populations experimentally using sex-mismatched tissues in a rat model. This study demonstrated that systemic chimerism occurs after successful vascularized bone transplantation. Transplanted cells not only survive in the graft but also gradually migrate into the recipient's body.

Long-term viability of articular cartilage after microsurgical whole-joint transplantation and immunosuppression with rapamycin, mycophenolate mofetil, and tacrolimus

The survival or rejection of articular cartilage in heterotopic vascularized joint transplants in rats immunosuppressed with rapamycin (SDZ RAD), mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), and tacrolimus was evaluated histologically up to 1 year after surgery. The vascularized knee joint of an ACI donor rat was transplanted to the groin of a Lewis recipient rat. Nonimmunosuppressed allografts were evaluated after 6 weeks and 3 months, and immunosuppressed allografts and control isografts were evaluated after 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year. No rejection was seen in the control isografts. All allografts without immunosuppression were rejected at 6 weeks and 3 months. Eighteen of 21 knee joint transplants immunosuppressed with SDZ RAD and 17 of 22 knee joint transplants immunosuppressed with MMF were rejected between 6 weeks and 1 year. SDZ RAD and MMF caused significant side effects including compromised wound healing and bone marrow suppression culminating in weight loss and death. Eighteen of 19 knee joints immunosuppressed with tacrolimus showed no signs of rejection up to 1 year after surgery. Long-term intermittent immunosuppression with tacrolimus was significantly superior to SDZ RAD and MMF in preventing rejection of the transplanted articular cartilage of a vascularized knee joint allograft up to 1 year after surgery.

Lower extremity microsurgical reconstruction

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

After studying this article, the participant should be able to: 1. Understand the indications for the use of free-tissue transfer in lower extremity reconstruction. 2. Understand modalities to enhance the healing and care of soft tissue and bone before free-tissue transfer. 3. Understand the lower extremity reconstructive ladder and the place of free-tissue transfer on the ladder. 4. Understand the specific principles of leg, foot, and ankle reconstruction. 5. Understand the factors that influence the decision to perform an immediate versus a delayed reconstruction. Free-tissue transfer using microsurgical techniques is now routine for the salvage of traumatized lower extremities. Indications for microvascular tissue transplantation for lower extremity reconstruction include high-energy injuries, most middle and distal-third tibial wounds, radiation wounds, osteomyelitis, nonunions, and tumor reconstruction. The authors discuss the techniques and indications for lower extremity reconstruction.

Clinical experience in allogeneic vascularized bone and joint allografting

The allotransplantation of vascularized femoral diaphyses and total knee joints is a novel approach in orthopedic surgery. Allogeneic femoral diaphyses were transplanted into three patients suffering from chondrosarcoma or posttraumatic defects. Total knee joints allografts were transplanted in five patients with large bone defects of the knee and loss of the extensor apparatus caused either by major trauma alone or infection after a major trauma. Bone segments and total joints were harvested from multi-organ donors, perfused with UW-solution and transplanted within cold ischemia times of 18-25 h. Patients were immunosuppressed postoperatively primarily with cyclosporine (Cyclosporin A) and azathioprine. Two allografts (1 femur, 1 knee) were lost due to infections. Seven of the eight patients are able to walk with full weight-bearing posttransplant. Two of the patients with transplanted joint allografts subsequently received total knee arthroplasty implantations. Vascularized bone and joint allotransplantation may serve as a last line of defense treatment before considering lower limb amputation.

Limb allotransplantation in rats: combined immunosuppression by FK-506 and 15-deoxyspergualin

The immunosuppressive effect of combined therapy using FK-506 and 15-deoxyspergualin was investigated in rat limb allotransplantation. The right hindlimb of an inbred Dark Agouti rat (RT1a) was transplanted to a Lewis rat (RT1l) and observed for 120 days. Eighty-eight transplantations were performed. Rejection of the grafts was evaluated histologically as well as macroscopically. A pathologic grading system was used to rate the severity of rejection. Limb survival time in Lewis rats receiving FK-506 therapy for days was significantly prolonged by combined therapy with 15-deoxyspergualin. Histologic study showed practically no rejection in all the graft-composing tissues except the skin and bone marrow, in which there was rejection. These results suggest that tissues like bone, cartilage, and muscle may survive transplantation with short-term combination FK-506 and 15-deoxyspergualin therapy even after withdrawal of both agents.

Allogeneic vascularized transplantation of human femoral diaphyses and total knee joints--first clinical experiences

This article has presented the preliminary results of three patients who received vascularized allogeneic femoral diaphyses and three patients having undergone vascularized transplantation of fresh and perfused total human knee joints. The large osseous defects in the femora followed osteomyelitis and chondrosarcoma. The three knee joints were lost due to various trauma mechanisms. All grafts were harvested within 25 hours from multiorgan donors perfused with 4 L of UW solution. All osteosyntheses were performed employing intramedullary nails. Vascular pedicles of the grafts were anastomosed end-to-side to the superficial femoral artery and vein in the adductorial canal of the recipient thigh. Immunosuppression was based mainly on two drugs: CyA and AZA. Perfusion of the grafts was demonstrated by DSA, and bone metabolism in the graft by SPECT scintigraphy. Six months after the operation all osteotomies demonstrated callus formation and osseous consolidation in conventional radiographs. Biopsies of the grafted bone revealed intact osteocytes, and arthroscopy of the transplanted knee joints demonstrated intact synovial, chondral, and ligamentous structures. From the surgical aspect, the vascularized transplantation of the femoral diaphyses and total knee joints is technically feasible. The main problems are immunologic. All transplantations were performed with respect to ABO compatibility, but with a large HLA mismatch. Therefore, acute and chronic rejection crises were observed. In total synovial joints, lifelong immunosuppression of graft recipients seems to be currently unavoidable.

Functional and morphological outcome of knee joint transplantation in dogs depends on control of rejection

BACKGROUND

The reconstruction of massive osteochondral defects extending to weight-bearing joints remains a surgical challenge. Total knee joint transplantation has been performed experimentally, but these studies lacked prospective evaluation of functional outcome, graft vascularization, and graft viability.

METHODS

Replantation and transplantation of vascularized knee joints was performed in dogs (n=4 per group), comparing functional and morphological results during a 6-month follow-up.

RESULTS

All replant recipients and three transplant recipients survived the 6-month follow-up period. At this time, duplex sonography and angiography revealed patent anastomoses in all animals. Increases in volumetric flow rates and vascular collateralization were observed in allografts, as compared with replanted joints (100+/-16 ml/min vs. 31+/-15 ml/min at 6 months after transplantation). Bone fusion at the graft-host interface was verified by fluorography in all animals at 3 months after transplantation. Six months after transplantation, microradiographies and computerized tomographies revealed spongialization of the cortical bone and filling of the medullary space by trabecular bone in transplanted joints. Such alterations were not detectable in replanted joints. Chondrocyte viability exceeded 80% in all but one transplanted joint. Lymphocyte infiltration of synovia and arterial walls was detected in all transplanted joints, suggesting the presence of chronic rejection. Weight-bearing capacity recovered in all replanted animals (weight-bearing index before transplantation: 0.499+/-0.080; 6 months after transplantation: 0.38+/-0.16) but only in two of four transplanted animals (weight-bearing index 6 months after transplantation: 0.37, 0.28, and 0.00).

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate the potential of joint grafting and the critical dependence of allotransplantation on the control of rejection.