IV-S neuroblastoma: a cooperative study of 30 children

Revisiting the role of radiotherapy in the treatment of neuroblastoma 4S: 30 years of institutional experience and systematic review

Background and purpose

Neuroblastoma 4S is a rare subtype of metastatic neuroblastoma found in children younger than 12 months, characterized by liver, skin, or bone marrow metastases. While the prognosis for patients is generally favorable, rapid progression of liver metastases can lead to life-threatening organ insufficiency. In such cases, immediate treatment with chemotherapy or radiotherapy is necessary. Given the recent decline in radiotherapy utilization, this study aims to reassess its role, evaluating its effectiveness and toxicity.

Materials and methods

We conducted a systematic review and an institutional retrospective analysis to assess the use of radiotherapy for hepatomegaly in patients with neuroblastoma 4S. The study included data from 164 patients from the literature and 16 patients from our institutional cohort. We extracted and analyzed data on short- and long-term outcomes, as well as reports of radiotherapy-induced toxicity.

Results

Our institutional data showed that 81 % of patients responded to low-dose radiotherapy administered at a median dose of 450 cGy in three fractions, resulting in liver shrinkage and symptom resolution. Based on the systematic review, 1-year survival rate was 80 %, while 5-year survival rate was 75 %. No serious toxicity was observed with the current low-dose radiotherapy; however, one case of induced secondary malignancy was reported.

Conclusion

Radiation therapy is an effective treatment modality for hepatomegaly in patients with neuroblastoma 4S, with a success rate of about 80 %. Despite being administered to infants, a low dose of 450-600 cGy does not result in toxicity related to the kidneys, liver, or posture defects.

Neuroblastome surrénalien bilatéral et syndrome de Pepper : à propos de quatre observations

4S neuroblastoma with bilateral adrenal involvement is defined by small primitive tumors (stage 1 or 2) with disseminated disease restricted to the liver, skin, and/or bone marrow. Children are less than one year old. These tumors are rare and of multicentric origin.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Our multicentric study analyzed four children less than four months old at diagnosis.

RESULTS

All had a favourable histology, with normal MYC-N copy number, and one case had a diploid tumor. The four patients had first supportive care at the beginning, but three cases received chemotherapy because of progressive disease, with liver radiotherapy in two cases because of massive hepatomegaly; three cases had surgery (unilateral adrenal resection in two cases and bilateral in one case) and one had only a biopsy. Surgery was the only treatment in one case. One patient relapsed 17 months after initial treatment and was treated with intensive chemotherapy and stem cell rescue. The outcome is favorable for the four patients, without evidence of recurrent disease.

CONCLUSION

Children with 4S neuroblastoma with bilateral adrenal tumors have a good prognosis. Treatment should be the less aggressive as possible. The group with favorable prognostic parameters should have supportive care if spontaneous regression occurs. But we have to treat with chemotherapy neonates with massive hepatomegaly and children with one or more unfavorable prognostic factors (unfavorable histology, high MYC-N copy number).

Treatment of stage 4s neuroblastoma--report of 10 years' experience of the French Society of Paediatric Oncology (SFOP)

Stage 4s neuroblastoma (NB) is usually associated with a favourable outcome, despite a large tumour burden, as spontaneous regression frequently occurs. However, in some infants rapid disease progression can be observed with severe functional impairment. Thus, for all patients the potential risks of cytotoxic therapy must be weighed against the benefits of early medical intervention. We have retrospectively reviewed the charts of 94 infants treated for stage 4s NB in centres of the French Society of Paediatric Oncology between 1990 and 2000, and describe the different first-line treatment approaches that were, successively, liver irradiation, chemotherapy using a cyclophosphamide-vincristine regimen, and chemotherapy using a carboplatin-etoposide regimen. The overall survival was 88% (+/-7.6%), with a mean follow-up of 64 months. Elevated serum neuron-specific enolase (>100 nmol ml(-1)), ferritin (>280 ng ml(-1)) and urinary dopamine levels (>2500 nmol mmol(-1) creatinine) were associated with a poor outcome, as were the genetic markers N-myc amplification and chromosome 1p deletion (P<0.0005 and P=0.0016, respectively). Patients who required medical intervention at diagnosis fared worse than those who received supportive treatment only (P<0.005). The clinical evolution observed with the different successive treatment approaches suggests that if infants do require therapy, the prompt initiation of a more intensive regimen such as carboplatin-etoposide may be more beneficial.

Favorable biology and outcome of stage IV-S neuroblastoma with supportive care or minimal therapy: a Children's Cancer Group study

PURPOSE

Stage IV-S neuroblastoma is a metastatic disease associated with spontaneous regression and good survival, but 10% to 20% of infants die from early complications. The purpose of this study was to evaluate outcome and prognostic factors in infants with stage IV-S neuroblastoma treated prospectively with supportive care only or, in symptomatic patients, with low-dose cytotoxic therapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Eighty eligible infants were studied for response and survival with supportive care or, for symptomatic patients, cyclophosphamide 5 mg/kg/d for 5 days with or without hepatic radiation of 4.5 Gy over 3 days. Staging was reviewed centrally, and MYCN gene copy number, Shimada histopathologic classification, serum ferritin levels, and bone marrow immunocytology were determined.

RESULTS

Stage IV-S and International Neuroblastoma Staging System stage 4S were 98% concordant. MYCN was not amplified in any of the tumors tested (n = 58), and Shimada histopathologic classification was favorable in 96% (n = 68/71). The 5-year event-free survival (EFS) rate for all infants was 86% and the survival rate was 92%. Supportive care was the only treatment provided for 44 (55%) of 80 infants, and their 5-year survival rate was 100%, compared with 81% survival for those requiring cytotoxic therapy for symptoms (P =.005). Five of six deaths were in infants younger than 2 months of age at diagnosis and were due to complications of extensive abdominal involvement with respiratory compromise or disseminated intravascular coagulation. Although age </= 3 months at diagnosis was significant for EFS (P =. 043), it was less significant for survival (P =.077). The only other significant factor predictive for improved survival was favorable Shimada histopathologic classification. Sites of metastatic involvement (liver, skin, or bone marrow) and surgical resection of the primary tumor were not significant for survival.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms the favorable biologic features and excellent survival of infants with stage IV-S neuroblastoma with minimal therapy. Infants younger than 2 months old at diagnosis with rapidly progressive abdominal disease may benefit from earlier and more intensive treatment.

Successful management of stage 4S neuroblastoma and severe hepatomegaly using absorbable mesh in an infant

This report describes the use of an absorbable mesh in an infant with stage 4S neuroblastoma who required decompressive laparotomy. At the time of laparotomy, a SILASTIC silo was placed. After 12 days, the liver had not reduced in size despite chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Because of concern for infection, the silo was removed, and an absorbable polygalactin (Vicryl) mesh was placed. Wet-to-dry dressings were used to manage the mesh. A granulation base developed that provided a physiological closure of the abdominal cavity. Forty-two days after placement of the absorbable mesh, the liver had reduced to a size that permitted mobilization of skin flaps for a surgical abdominal closure. The liver continued to reduce in size, allowing the fascial edges to draw together. The patient is now 2 years old with no signs of residual tumor or ventral hernia.

Stage IVS neuroblastoma: a clinical, histological, and biological analysis of 45 cases

This study reports clinicopathologic and biological analysis of 45 stage IVS neuroblastomas (IVS-NBs). All IVS-NB cases had small or undetectable primary tumors associated with disease involving the liver, skin, or bone marrow. Their ages at diagnosis ranged from 1 day to 12 months, with a median age of 4 months. The primary sites were adrenal in 34 cases, retroperitoneum in two, mediastinum in one, and unknown in eight; the liver was involved in 24 of 31 cases, the bone marrow in 11 of 27, and the skin in 4 of 29. According to the histopathological evaluation (Shimada classification), 43 IVS-NB tumors had a favorable histology, and 2 cases showed an unfavorable histology. Three patients died of progressive disease and six of indirect tumor death. Among these three deceased cases with tumor progression, two cases showed unfavorable histology, and one case had amplified N-myc (20 copies). These data suggest that most IVS-NB can be described as a tumor presenting characteristic dissemination pattern in the younger age group, having a favorable histology and showing an excellent outcome of the patients. However, poor prognosis group in stage IVS does exist, and this group could be detected histopathologically and biologically.

Retrospective analysis of biological factors in a recurrent IV-S neuroblastoma with intermediate-grade malignancy

A clinical stage of IV-S neuroblastoma is known to include heterogeneous tumors. The authors report a case of IV-S neuroblastoma that relapsed after regression 4 years and 10 months after diagnosis. Multiagent chemotherapy was necessary to control the disease, and the patient has been doing well with no evidence of disease for more than 5 years. Although Shimada's classification showed favorable characteristics, N-myc protein was positive and DNA ploidy was diploidy in the tumor at diagnosis. Discrepancy in DNA ploidy was observed and aneuploidy was shown in tumor specimens at recurrence. Experience in this case showed the following important clinical features: (1) IV-S neuroblastoma of intermediate-grade malignancy does exist, and patients with such a disease may be cured by aggressive treatment; (2) Identifying IV-S patients with an unfavorable clinical course is possible by examining biological prognostic factors.

Neuroblastomas in Denmark 1943-80. Epidemiological and clinical studies

Two-hundred-and-fifty patients were registered in a population-based study of neuroblastomas in Denmark in the period 1943-80. The major epidemiological findings were an increased incidence with an unchanged mortality rate during the study period. The increase in incidence related solely to children 0-4 years of age and was most pronounced in infants under 1 year of age. Several reasons for the observed epidemiological rates include (i) changes in the composition of the population, (ii) improved diagnostic procedures, (iii) a shift in the diagnostic criteria, and (iv) an increase in environmental carcinogens of importance in the induction of neuroblastoma. Associated with an increased risk were lower socio-economic levels and young or advanced parental age, suggesting the importance of environmental as well as genetic factors for the induction of neuroblastoma. The epidemiological findings of an increased incidence with an unchanged mortality rate, which suggests the inclusion of borderline lesions in recent years, are of major importance in interpreting the results of mass screening for the disease. The clinical findings in 253 patients treated in Denmark from 1943 to 1980 (including 5 patients resident outside Denmark and excluding 2 patients without available hospital records) were analysed. The major finding was a zero-time shift, that is, earlier diagnosis of the disease during the study period, with increasing survival rates from decade to decade mostly due to a better age and stage distribution, a zero-time shift which was also apparent in the changes of the symptomatology. Independent prognostic variables were age, stage, and treatment with chemotherapy for children over 1 year of age with stage II disease, and for infants with stages III-IV disease. Analysis of data from a subset of the 253 children suggested that high proliferative activity detected by flow cytometry may be an important prognostic variable. The study also suggests that the pattern of metastatic spread might have changed as a consequence of prolonged survival obtained by improved treatment modalities, stressing the importance of a high frequency of autopsy among cancer patients. Hypotheses generated by the study included (i) that most neuroblastomas might be congenital, (ii) that the age influence on prognosis might be explained in terms of growth rate, cell cycle transit time, and duration of the disease, and (iii) that some neuroblastomas might be borderline lesions.

Neuroblastoma stage IV-S

A review of stage IV-S neuroblastoma is provided. The possible uses of prognostic features to guide treatment options in this group of infants with neuroblastoma are suggested. The biologic basis for the spontaneous regression of widespread tumor involvement in some infants with stage IV-S neuroblastoma is discussed. The reasons that some infants with IV-S disease progress to a fatal outcome, while most undergo maturation or involution and eventual long term cure are suggested. The influence of such factors as age at diagnosis, clinical staging, and tumor biology on eventual outcome are covered. Biological variables and markers discussed include: genetic (cytogenetics (1p deletions), nuclear genomic content), molecular biologic (N-myc oncogene amplification, mdr-1, ras, and trk, gene expression), immunological (major histocompatibility antigen density, cellular and humoral immunity), and biochemical (creatine kinase isoenzyme profile, neuron specific enolase, ferritin, chromatograffin, lactic acid dehydrogenase and catecholamine levels).

Disseminated neuroblastoma (stage IV and IV-S) in the first year of life. Outcome related to age and stage. Italian Cooperative Group on Neuroblastoma

BACKGROUND

Infants (age 0-11 months) with disseminated neuroblastoma are known to have a better prognosis than older children with the disease, but there is little information regarding factors that influence the outcome of the disease in these patients.

METHODS

The authors report a series of 110 infants with disseminated neuroblastoma with disease diagnosed between March 1976 and February 1991 in 21 institutions participating in the Italian Cooperative Group on Neuroblastoma (ICGNB). Of the 110 infants, 34 had Stage IV disease, and 76 had Stage IV-S disease.

RESULTS

The 5-year survival probability was 77% for all patients, 71% for those with Stage IV disease, and 81% for those with Stage IV-S disease. Of the 34 infants with Stage IV disease, the 9 who were 5 months or younger at the time of disease diagnosis are all alive (1 with active disease) at 7-143 months after diagnosis, whereas of the 25 infants who were 6-11 months of age at the time of disease diagnosis, 10 have died. Of the 76 infants with Stage IV-S disease, 12/64 who were 5 months of age or younger at the time of disease diagnosis died (mostly of massive hepatomegaly); 9 of these deaths occurred in infants with disease diagnosed before they were 2 months old, whereas 1 death occurred in the 12 infants with disease diagnosed when they were 6-11 months old. Four infants with Stage IV-S disease achieved complete disease remission and subsequently had relapse of disease. High levels of serum LDH and low urinary excretion of vanillylmandelic acid were associated with worse prognosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors suggest that infants older than 6 months of age who have Stage IV disease require aggressive therapy. For infants with disease diagnosed before they are 2 months old, Stage IV-S disease may have a worse prognosis than Stage IV disease.

P-glycoprotein expression as a predictor of the outcome of therapy for neuroblastoma

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

Multidrug resistance in chemotherapy for cancer is characterized by increased genetic expression of P-glycoprotein, which acts as an ATP-dependent drug-efflux pump. To determine whether P-glycoprotein levels are of prognostic value in such cases, we measured these levels immunohistochemically in a retrospective study of sequential tumor samples from 67 children with neuroblastoma.

RESULTS

P-glycoprotein was not detected in pretreatment samples from either of the 2 patients with Stage I disease, any of the 21 with Stage II disease, or any of the 8 with Stage IVS disease, but it was detected in the samples from 1 of the 17 patients with Stage III disease (6 percent) and 12 of the 19 with Stage IV disease (63 percent). Of the 44 patients with nonlocalized neuroblastoma (Stage III, IVS, or IV), 26 of the 31 who were negative for P-glycoprotein had a complete response to primary treatment, as compared with 6 of the 13 who were positive for P-glycoprotein (84 percent vs. 46 percent, P = 0.0232 by Fisher's exact test). Log-rank analysis of outcome, with simultaneous stratification according to tumor stage and age, showed that the group that was negative for P-glycoprotein had significantly longer relapse-free survival (P = 0.0011) and overall survival (P = 0.0373) than the group that was positive.

CONCLUSIONS

Expression of P-glycoprotein before treatment may predict the success or failure of therapy for nonlocalized neuroblastoma. Neuroblastoma may be a promising tumor to treat with anticancer drug therapy combined with a chemosensitizing agent capable of reversing P-glycoprotein-mediated multidrug resistance.

Mass screening in Japan increased the detection of infants with neuroblastoma without a decrease in cases in older children

Analysis of data from the Kanto-Ko-Shin-Etsu Branch of the Japan Children's Cancer Registry revealed that mass screening for neuroblastoma increased the detection of cases in infants younger than 1 year from about 25% before screening to about 50%, and the percentage of neuroblastomas among all pediatric cancers almost doubled, from approximately 10% to 19.3%. However, when the cases found on screening were subtracted, the numbers after the onset of mass screening were similar to those before screening. It is likely that neuroblastoma mass screening has identified a unique type of tumor, which may not be recognized without mass screening, rather than that it has contributed to the earlier diagnosis of tumors in older children.

Neuroblastoma stage IV-S: a heterogeneous disease

Eighteen patients were diagnosed and treated for Stage IV-S neuroblastoma at The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto between January 1971 and December 1988. All patients were 6 months of age or younger at diagnosis. Nine patients (50%) have remained disease free with a mean follow-up of 9.3 years. Of the seven patients under 6 weeks of age at presentation, four presented in the early neonatal period and died, three due to mechanical complications related to progressive disease, and one due to late recurrence. The remaining three patients under 6 weeks of age, two of whom had skin involvement at diagnosis, are alive and disease free. Six of the 11 patients over 6 weeks of age at presentation survived, combined modality therapy (CMT) being more effective than single modality treatment. N-myc was studied from tumor tissue at diagnosis in four patients and was amplified in three (25x, 25x, 100x), all of whom had late disease progression and died. The patient with a single gene copy has no evidence of disease 24 months following diagnosis. Our study confirms the heterogeneity described in this clinically defined group of patients. Because of it, management of Stage IV-S neuroblastoma cannot be uniform and until further development of a subclassification, or a reclassification based on molecular biologic markers is developed, pediatric oncologists will regularly be confronted with a decision whether or not to treat a newly presenting patient that fits into the clinical classification IV-S.

N-myc oncogene and stage IV-S neuroblastoma. Preliminary observations on ten cases

We studied the clinical significance of genomic amplification of N-myc in Stage IV-S neuroblastoma, with reference to spontaneous regression. Among 103 neuroblastomas in which N-myc was measured, ten were Stage IV-S (eight children were younger than and two were older than 1 year of age). The number of copies of N-myc was 1 to 3 in five patients, four to ten in one patient, and more than ten in four patients, and the survivors of each group were four, one, and one (recurrent), respectively. Of 41 patients younger than 1 year of age, N-myc amplification of more than three copies was found only in Stage IV-S neuroblastoma. Cure with a tendency to regress spontaneously was seen in five of eight patients younger than 1 year of age. However, two patients older than 1 year of age classified as Stage IV-S (one with N-myc amplification) died of progressive disease. In two patients (1 and 3 months of age) with a huge hepatic involvement and in whom the tumor had an amplified N-myc of more than ten copies, tumor regression occurred but there was a relapse to a progressive state later. The overexpression of N-myc mRNA occurred in nine of ten stage IV-S tumors and did not correlate with the prognosis. The vanillylmandelic acid (VMA) to homovanillic acid (HVA) ratio was low in tumors with an increased number of copies of N-myc. Serum lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) levels were increased in Stage IV-S patients with N-myc amplification but not in those with regressing tumors and without N-myc amplification. These data suggest that N-myc amplification may affect the final outcome in the patient classified as Stage IV-S, but tumor regression can occur early after birth and appears to be independent of N-myc amplification.

Advances and management of solid tumors in children

In recent years there has been a significant improvement in the survival rate of children with malignant solid tumors. With Wilms' tumor, the survival rate has risen to 80%, but a subset of these patients with unfavorable histologies and therefore a higher rate of relapse need a different strategy. For those patients with soft tissue sarcoma, brain tumors, and bone tumors the combination of preoperative chemotherapy, surgery, and radiotherapy followed by maintenance multiagent chemotherapy has resulted in a survival rate of 45% to 70%. In the case of neuroblastoma, a similar aggressive approach has not resulted in an improved survival. A different approach that uses screening of infants by urinary testing for VMA and HVA to detect earlier and potentially less malignant tumors has begun in Japan and North America in the hope that preclinical detection will reduce mortality.

Complete pathologic maturation and regression of stage IVS neuroblastoma without treatment

Spontaneous maturation of Stage IVS neuroblastoma has been postulated as a mechanism for its favorable prognosis, but this has rarely been documented pathologically. We report on a patient with congenital Stage IVS neuroblastoma who had extensive subcutaneous and bone-marrow involvement. Serial photographs, biopsies, and vanillomandelic acid determinations documented the tumor's initial progression which was followed by spontaneous maturation and involution of the patient's disease over a 6-year period. No cytotoxic therapy was administered. Favorable biologic prognostic factors were documented, including tumor DNA and protein analyses for N-myc amplification or overexpression and analysis for serum neuron-specific enolase and ferritin. Implications for management and therapy of Stage IVS neuroblastoma are discussed with reference to this case and the recent literature.