NMR on emulsions: characterisation of liquid dispersed systems

New insights into protein stabilized emulsions captured via neutron and X-ray scattering: An approach with β-lactoglobulin at triacylglyceride-oil/water interfaces

HYPOTHESIS

To analyze protein stabilized emulsions, SAXS and SANS are emerging techniques capturing oil droplet radius, interfacial coverage and structure. Protein shape, thus protein structure change during interfacial adsorption with partial protein unfolding is detected via SAXS analysis at and below the monolayer concentration for proteins, known as critical interfacial concentration (CIC). SANS determines the same phenomena below and above the CIC, via contrast variation and coarse-grained modelling.

EXPERIMENTS

β-lactoglobulin concentration dependent SAXS experiments were performed focusing on molecular length scales to characterize protein shape in water, and interfacial structure in emulsions. Complementary SANS experiments with contrast variation via deuterated triacylglyceride-oil provided insight into oil droplet radius, interfacial coverage and structure via data analysis with scattering models and low-resolution shape reconstruction with the DENFERT model.

FINDINGS

SAXS and SANS experiments allowed to determine the interfacial structure below and above the CIC, as well as oil droplet radius and interfacial coverage. These findings were identified via Q-4 Porod scattering at low-Q, protein scattering at high Q, and a Q-2 scattering of the interface. Since SANS with accurate contrast variation highlights the interface in comparison to other techniques like FTIR, the presented results show a high impact to understand interfaces in emulsions.

Effect of surfactant concentration on diffusion and microstructure in water-in-oil emulsions studied by low-field benchtop NMR and optical microscopy

Emulsions are ubiquitous in many consumer products, including food, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. Whilst their macroscopic characterisation is well-established, understanding their microscopic behaviour is very challenging. In our previous work we investigated oil-in-water emulsions by studying the effect of water on structuring and dynamics of such systems. In the present work, we investigate the effect of surfactant concentration on microstructure and diffusion within the water-in-oil emulsion system by using low-field pulsed-field gradient (PFG) NMR studies carried out with a benchtop NMR instrument, in conjunction with optical imaging. The results reveal that at high surfactant concentration the formation of smaller droplets gives rise to a third component in the PFG NMR attenuation plot, which is mostly attributed to restricted diffusion near the droplet boundaries. In addition, structuring effects due to increase in surfactant concentration at the boundaries could also contribute to further slowing down water diffusion at the boundaries. As the surfactant concentration decreases, the average droplet size becomes larger and both restriction and structuring effects at the droplet boundaries become less significant, as suggested by the PFG NMR plot, whereby the presence of a third diffusion component becomes less pronounced.

Signatures of nanoemulsion jamming and unjamming in stimulated-echo NMR

The unjamming of elastic concentrated nanoemulsions into viscous dilute nanoemulsions, through dilution with the continuous phase, offers interesting opportunities for a pulsed-field gradient (PFG) NMR, particularly if the nanoemulsion is designed to take advantage of the nuclear specificity offered by NMR. Here, we make and study size-fractionated oil-in-water nanoemulsions using a perfluorinated copolymer silicone oil that is highly insoluble in the aqueous continuous phase. By studying these nanoemulsions using ^{19}F stimulated-echo PFG-NMR, we avoid any contribution from the aqueous continuous phase, which contains a nonfluorinated ionic surfactant. We find a dramatic change in the ^{19}F PFG-NMR decays at high field-gradient strengths as the droplet volume fraction, ϕ, is lowered through dilution. At high ϕ, observed decays as a function of field-gradient strength exhibit decay-to-plateau behavior indicating the jamming of nanodroplets, which contain ^{19}F probe molecules, in an elastic material reminiscent of a nanoporous solid. In contrast, at lower ϕ, only a simple decay is observed, indicating that the nanodroplets have unjammed and can diffuse over much larger distances. Through a comparison with bulk mechanical rheometry, we show that this dramatic change coincides with the loss of low-frequency shear elasticity of the nanoemulsion.

Updated insight into the characterization of nano-emulsions

INTRODUCTION

In most of the studies, nano-emulsion characterization is limited to their size distribution and zeta potential. In this review, we present an updated insight of the characterization methods of nano-emulsions, including new or unconventional experimental approaches to explore in depth the nano-emulsion properties.

AREA COVERED

We propose an overview of all the main techniques used to characterize nano-emulsions, including the most classical ones, up to in vitro, ex vivo and in vivo evaluation. Innovative approaches are then presented in the second part of the review that presents innovative, experimental techniques less known in the field of nano-emulsion such as the nanoparticle tracking analysis, small-angle X-ray scattering, Raman spectroscopy, and nuclear magnetic resonance. Finally, in the last part we discuss the use of lipophilic fluorescent probes and imaging techniques as an emerging tool to understand the nano-emulsion droplet stability, surface decoration, release mechanisms, and in vivo fate.

EXPERT OPINION

This review is mostly intended for a broad readership and provides key tools regarding the choice of the approach to characterize nano-emulsions. Innovative and uncommon methods will be precious to disclose the information potentially reachable behind a formulation of nano-emulsions, not always known in first intention and with conventional methods.

Influence of fat crystallization in W/O emulsions on the water droplet size determination by NMR diffusometry

HYPOTHESIS

It is expected that low resolution (LR) NMR diffusometry enables (more) accurate water droplet size determination for solid-fat based water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions with (sub)-micron size water droplets in comparison to liquid-oil based W/O emulsions due to hindered extra-droplet water diffusion.

EXPERIMENTS

W/O emulsions with a volume-weighed mean diameter of about 1 µm and a solid fat content (SFC) ranging from 0% to 74% were produced. The aqueous phase contained the ionic marker tetraphenylphosphonium chloride (TPPCl). The water droplet size was estimated using LR and high resolution (HR) NMR diffusometry.

FINDINGS

HR-NMR diffusometry showed that the diffusion behavior of water and TPPCl was different, indicating water diffusion beyond the droplet's interfacial boundaries. From a certain SFC onwards, a slower echo decay was observed for the water molecules, thus decreasing the overestimation of the water droplet size in (sub)micron W/O emulsions. For those emulsions, the solid fat matrix is believed to hinder extra-droplet water diffusion, which is most likely to be related to the increased tortuosity of the diffusive path in the porous fat crystal network. Using LR-NMR, it can be verified whether the water echo attenuation is mono-exponential or bi-exponential by increasing the gradient pulse duration for the maximum gradient strength, which is more convenient for routine analysis compared to HR-NMR.

Low-field NMR for quality control on oils

Oil is a prominent, but multifaceted material class with a wide variety of applications. Technical oils, crude oils as well as edibles are main subclasses. In this review, the question is addressed how low-field NMR can contribute in oil characterization as an analytical tool, mainly with respect to quality control. Prerequisite in the development of a quality control application, however, is a detailed understanding of the oils and of the measurement. Low-field NMR is known as a rich methodical toolbox that was and is explored and further developed to address questions about oils, their quality, and usability as raw materials, during production and formulation as well as in use.

High-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in microfluidic droplets

A generic approach is presented that allows high-resolution NMR spectroscopy of water/oil droplet emulsions in microfluidic devices. Microfluidic NMR spectroscopy has recently made significant advances due to the design of micro-detector systems and their successful integration with microfluidic devices. Obtaining NMR spectra of droplet suspensions, however, is complicated by the inevitable differences in magnetic susceptibility between the chip material, the continuous phase, and the droplet phases. This leads to broadening of the NMR resonance lines and results in loss of spectral resolution. We have mitigated the susceptibility difference between the continuous (oil) phase and the chip material by incorporating appropriately designed air-filled structures into the chip. The susceptibilities of the continuous and droplet (aqueous) phases have been matched by doping the droplet phase with a Eu3+ complex. Our results demonstrate that this leads to a proton line width in the droplet phase of about 3 Hz, enabling high-resolution NMR techniques.

Diffusion and Molecular Exchange in Hollow Core-Shell Silica Nanoparticles

The diffusion behavior of small molecules in hollow core-shell nanocapsules was studied using pulsed field gradient NMR. By purposefully selecting the liquid saturating the hollow core and the porous shell and the solvent between the nanocapsules, two different situations corresponding to the excluded and admitted molecular exchange between the intra- and intercapsule liquids at the external boundary of the nanoparticles were covered. In the former case, corresponding to the reflective boundary condition for the molecules approaching the nanocapsule boundary, restricted diffusion in the complex pore space formed by the hollow core and the mesoporous shell was observed. The time-dependent diffusivities measured in the experiment were inter-related with the geometry of the intraparticle pore space. The thus assessed structural information was found to be in a good agreement with that provided by electron microscopy. In the case of the molecular exchange occurring between the two pools of molecules in the nanocapsules and between them, the diffusive dynamics of only the molecules remaining in the nanocapsules during the entire observation times was studied.

Properties and prospects of adjuvants in influenza vaccination - messy precipitates or blessed opportunities?

Influenza is a major challenge to healthcare systems world-wide. While prophylactic vaccination is largely efficient, long-lasting immunity has not been achieved in immunized populations, at least in part due to the challenges arising from the antigen variation between strains of influenza A virus as a consequence of genetic drift and shift. From progress in our understanding of the immune system, the mode-of-action of vaccines can be divided into the stimulation of the adaptive system through inclusion of appropriate vaccine antigens and of the innate immune system by the addition of adjuvant to the vaccine formulation. A shared property of many vaccine adjuvants is found in their nature of water-insoluble precipitates, for instance the particulate material made from aluminum salts. Previously, it was thought that embedding of vaccine antigens in these materials provided a "depot" of antigens enabling a long exposure of the immune system to the antigen. However, more recent work points to a role of particulate adjuvants in stimulating cellular parts of the innate immune system. Here, we briefly outline the infectious medicine and immune biology of influenza virus infection and procedures to provide sufficient and stably available amounts of vaccine antigen. This is followed by presentation of the many roles of adjuvants, which involve humoral factors of innate immunity, notably complement. In a perspective of the ultrastructural properties of these humoral factors, it becomes possible to rationalize why these insoluble precipitates or emulsions are such a provocation of the immune system. We propose that the biophysics of particulate material may hold opportunities that could aid the development of more efficient influenza vaccines.