Applications of NMR diffusion methods with emphasis on ion pairing in inorganic chemistry: a mini-review

Tracking nitrite's deviation from Stokes-Einstein predictions with pulsed field gradient 15N NMR spectroscopy

Predicting the behavior of oxyanions in radioactive waste stored at the Department of Energy legacy nuclear sites requires the development of novel analytical methods. This work demonstrates 15N pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy to quantify the diffusivity of nitrite. Experimental results, supported by molecular dynamics simulations, indicate that the diffusivity of free hydrated nitrite exceeds that of free hydrated sodium despite the greater hydrodynamic radius of nitrite. Investigations are underway to understand how the compositional and dynamical heterogeneities of the ion networks at high concentrations affect rheological and transport properties.

Simple Route to [PSH][B9H14] and a Contemporary Study of Its Solid-State Dynamic Behavior

The 1,8-bis(dimethylamino)naphthalenium ([PSH]+) decaborane salt, [PSH][B10H13], has been found to react in ethanol to form [PSH][B9H14] (1), affording a simple route to the synthesis of the arachno-nonaborate anion. This new polyhedral salt is characterized by NMR spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. The measurement of diffusion coefficients by NMR methods demonstrates that the [PSH]+ cation and the [B9H14]- anion form ion pairs in a non-coordinating solvent such as CH2Cl2, whereas in CD3CN the formation of ion pairs was not observed. Insights into the long-known low-energy dynamic behavior, which involves the bridging and endo-terminal hydrogen atoms, are elucidated using DFT calculations. Salts [PSH][B9H14] (1) and [PSH][B9H14]·0.5CHCl3 (solvated, 1·0.5CHCl3) have also been studied by X-ray diffraction analysis. A solid-state NMR study has demonstrated that K[B9H14] and [PSH][B9H14] (1) undergo significantly different motion regimes, being a low-energy, weakly temperature-dependent process for 1, which may be ascribed to some type of low-amplitude reorientation of the whole boron cages. This process may be the mechanism for the low- to-room-temperature order-disorder hidden transition found by X-ray analysis.

Electrostatically Enhanced 3- and 4-Pyridyl Borate Salt Nucleophiles and Bases

A variety of electrostatically enhanced 3- and 4-pyridylborate salt catalysts are reported and show significant improvement over an activated noncharged neutral control compound. Their nucleophilicity in a stoichiometric SN2 reaction and catalytic performance in a urethane synthesis are evaluated along with three methods for rapidly evaluating the basicity of these species. That is, qualitative titrations in CH2Cl2 and CHCl3 were carried out, two separate solution-state IR studies in CCl4 and CDCl3 are reported, and the proton affinities of the anionic components of the salts were computed. Charge differences between the anion and its protonated zwitterionic conjugate acid are evaluated along with the highest occupied molecular orbitals of the anions in relationship to some of the surprising reactivity findings that were observed in the two kinetic studies.

Exploration of Solid-State vs Solution-State Structure in Contact Ion Pair Systems: Synthesis, Characterization, and Solution-State Dynamics of Zinc Diphenyl Phosphate, [Zn{O2P(OPh)2}2], Donor-Base-Supported Complexes

A family of zinc phosphate complexes supported by nitrogen donor-base ligands have been synthesized, and their molecular structures were identified in both the solid (X-ray crystallography) and solution state (DOSY NMR spectroscopy). [Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]_∞ (1), formed from the reaction of Zn[N(SiMe₃)₂]₂ with HO(O)P(OPh)₂ coordinates to donor-base ligands, i.e., pyridine (Py), 4-methylpyridine (4-MePy), 2,2-bipyridine (bipy), tetramethylethylenediamine (TMEDA), pentamethyldiethylenetriamine (PMDETA), and 1,3,5-trimethyl-1,3,5-triazacyclohexane (Me₃-TAC), to produce polymeric 1D structures, [(Py)₂Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]_∞ (2) and [(4-MePy)₂Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]_∞ (3), the bimetalic systems, [(Bipy)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]₂ (4), [(TMEDA)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]₂ (5), and [(Me₃-TAC)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]₂ (7), as well as a mono-nuclear zinc bis-diphenylphosphate complex, [(PMDETA)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂] (6). ¹H NMR DOSY has been used to calculate averaged molecular weights of the species. Studies are consistent with the disassembly of polymeric 3 into the bimetallic species [(Me-Py)₂·Zn₂{O₂P(OPh)₂}₄], where the Me-Py ligand is in rapid exchange with free Me-Py in solution. Further ¹H DOSY NMR studies of 4 and 5 reveal that dissolution of the complex results in a monomer dimer equilibrium, i.e., [(Bipy)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]₂ ⇆ 2[(Bipy)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂] and [(TMEDA)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂]₂ ⇆ 2[(TMEDA)Zn{O₂P(OPh)₂}₂], respectively, in which the equilibria lie toward formation of the monomer. As part of our studies, variable temperature ¹H DOSY experiments (223 to 313 K) were performed upon 5 in d₈-tol, which allowed us to approximate the enthalpy [ΔH = -43.2 kJ mol^-1 (±3.79)], entropy [ΔS = 109 J mol^-1 K^-1 (±13.9)], and approximate Gibbs free energy [ΔG = 75.6 kJ mol^-1 (±5.62) at 293 K)] of monomer-dimer equilibria. While complex 6 is shown to maintain its monomeric solid-state structure, ¹H DOSY experiments of 7 at 298 K reveal two separate normalized diffusion coefficients consistent with the presence of the bimetallic species [(TAC)_2-xZn₂{O₂P(OPh)₂}₄], (x = 1 or 0) and free TAC ligand.

NMR and luminescence experiments reveal the structure and symmetry adaptation of a europium ionic liquid to solvent polarity

By combining NMR data (nuclear Overhauser effect and pseudocontact shifts) with luminescence measurements, we uncover how the structure of an anionic europium complex adapts to different solvent polarities as a result of the different relative proximities of the ion pairs. In nonpolar solvents, the detected contact ion pairs, CIPs, indicate that the ions remain in proximity, with the molecular cation, and then perturbing and distorting the coordination polyhedron of the anion complex to a low symmetry configuration, which promotes luminescence. Differently, solvent separated ion pairs occur in polar solvents, indicating that the molecular ions have been disconnected. Thus, in polar solvents, the europium complex anion becomes free from the close influence of the molecular cation, allowing the coordination polyhedron to increase its symmetry, which in turn reduces the luminescence of the anionic europium complex. This reduction of coordination polyhedron symmetry by the close proximity of the molecular cation in nonpolar solvents was confirmed by additional photophysical measurements combined with quantum chemical RM1 calculations, suggesting that, in nonpolar solvents, the symmetry point group of the coordination polyhedron is C1, whereas in polar solvents it is either D2d or S4. The nonpolar solvents used were benzene, chloroform and dichloromethane; and the polar ones were acetone and acetonitrile. The synthesized ionic liquids were tetrakis [C5mim][La(BTFA)4] and [C5mim][Eu(BTFA)4], where BTFA stands for 4,4,4-trifluoro-1-phenyl-1,3-butanedione, lanthanoids (La3+ and Eu3+) and C5mim stands for 1-methyl-3-isopentylimidazolium. They were synthesized by a microwave methodology that is both fast and green (the synthetic reaction takes about 15 min) and also leads to more easily purifiable crystals.

Trialkylammonium salt degradation: implications for methylation and cross-coupling

Trialkylammonium (most notably N,N,N-trimethylanilinium) salts are known to display dual reactivity through both the aryl group and the N-methyl groups. These salts have thus been widely applied in cross-coupling, aryl etherification, fluorine radiolabelling, phase-transfer catalysis, supramolecular recognition, polymer design, and (more recently) methylation. However, their application as electrophilic methylating reagents remains somewhat underexplored, and an understanding of their arylation versus methylation reactivities is lacking. This study presents a mechanistic degradation analysis of N,N,N-trimethylanilinium salts and highlights the implications for synthetic applications of this important class of salts. Kinetic degradation studies, in both solid and solution phases, have delivered insights into the physical and chemical parameters affecting anilinium salt stability. ¹H NMR kinetic analysis of salt degradation has evidenced thermal degradation to methyl iodide and the parent aniline, consistent with a closed-shell S_N2-centred degradative pathway, and methyl iodide being the key reactive species in applied methylation procedures. Furthermore, the effect of halide and non-nucleophilic counterions on salt degradation has been investigated, along with deuterium isotope and solvent effects. New mechanistic insights have enabled the investigation of the use of trimethylanilinium salts in O-methylation and in improved cross-coupling strategies. Finally, detailed computational studies have helped highlight limitations in the current state-of-the-art of solvation modelling of reaction in which the bulk medium undergoes experimentally observable changes over the reaction timecourse.

The dual reactivity of N,N,N-trimethylanilinium salts towards arylation and methylation is decoupled in this mechanistic investigation to enable more strategic application of these salts in either reaction class.

Analysis of Ion Pairing in Solid State and Solution in p-Cymene Ruthenium Complexes

The importance of ion pairing in different fields of chemistry is widely recognized. In this work, we have synthesized a set of cationic p-cymene ruthenium complexes of general formula [(p-cym)Ru(L')(κ²-O^N-L)]X (p-cym = p-cymene; L' = N-methylimidazole (MeIm), N-ethylpiperidylimidazole (EpipIm), 1,3,5-triaza-7-phosphaadamantane (PTA); L = 2-(1H-benzimidazol-2-yl)phenolato (L1), 2-(1,3-benzothiazol-2-yl)phenolato (L2); X = Cl^-, BF₄^-, OTf^-, BPh₄^-). X-ray diffraction studies on selected complexes revealed relatively strong anion-cation interactions in the solid state mainly based on N-H···X (X = Cl, F, O) and C-H···π interactions, also observed in the DFT-modeled complexes in the gas phase. Moreover, NMR studies showed that they exist as intimate ion pairs in solution and, remarkably, as head-to-tail quadruples in the particular case of the cation [(p-cym)Ru(MeIm)(κ²- O^N-L1)]⁺ ([1]⁺) with Cl^- and BPh₄^- as counteranions. Furthermore, a value of ΔG = -2.9 kcal mol^-1 at 299 K has been estimated for the equilibrium {[1]BPh₄···[1]BPh₄} ⇆ 2{[1]⁺···BPh₄^-} in concentrated CDCl₃ solutions. In addition, preliminary studies concerning the cytotoxic properties against HeLa cell lines of the derivatives suggested a positive effect derived from the presence of the lipophilic BPh₄^- anion and also from the NH group of the benzimidazolyl fragment.

Curing Behaviors of Alkynyl-Terminated Copolyether with Glycidyl Azide Polymer in Energetic Plasticizers

Alkynyl-terminated polyethylene oxide−tetrahydrofuran (ATPET) and glycidyl azide polymer (GAP) could be linked through click-chemistry between the alkynyl and azide, and the product may serve a binder for solid propellants. The effects of the energetic plasticizers A3 [1:1 mixture of bis-(2,2-dinitropropy) acetal (BDNPA) and bis-(2,2-dinitropropyl) formal(BDNPN)] and Bu-NENA [N-butyl-N-(2nitroxyethyl) nitramine] on the curing reaction between ATPET and GAP have been studied. A diffusion-ordered nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (DOSY-NMR) approach has been used to monitor the change in the diffusion coefficient of cross-linked polytriazole polyethylene oxide−tetrahydrofuran (PTPET). The change in the diffusion coefficient of PTPET with A3 plasticizer is significantly higher than that of PTPET with Bu-NENA. Viscosity analysis further highlighted the difference between A3 and Bu-NENA in the curing process—the curing curve of PTPET (A3) with time can be divided into two stages, with an inflection point being observed on the fourth day. For PTPET (Bu-NENA), in contrast, only one stage is seen. The above methods, together with gel permeation chromatography (GPC) analysis, revealed distinct effects of A3 and Bu-NENA on the curing process of PTPET. X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) analysis showed that Bu-NENA has little effect on the valence oxidation of copper in the catalyst. Thermogravimetric (TG) analysis indicated that Bu-NENA helps to improve the thermal stability of the catalyst. After analysis of several possible factors by means of XPS, modeling with Material Studio and TG, the formation of molecular cages between Bu-NENA and copper is considered to be the reason for the above differences. In this article, GAP (Mn = 4000 g/mol) was used to replace GAP (Mn = 427 g/mol) to successfully synthesize the PTPET elastomer with Bu-NENA plasticizer. Mechanical data measured for the PTPET (Bu-NENA) sample included ε = 34.26 ± 2.98%, and σ = 0.198 ± 0.015 MPa.

Enantioselective remote C-H activation directed by a chiral cation

Chiral cations have been used extensively as organocatalysts, but their application to rendering transition metal-catalyzed processes enantioselective remains rare. This is despite the success of the analogous charge-inverted strategy in which cationic metal complexes are paired with chiral anions. We report here a strategy to render a common bipyridine ligand anionic and pair its iridium complexes with a chiral cation derived from quinine. We have applied these ion-paired complexes to long-range asymmetric induction in the desymmetrization of the geminal diaryl motif, located on a carbon or phosphorus center, by enantioselective C-H borylation. In principle, numerous common classes of ligand could likewise be amenable to this approach.

Extraction of Reliable Molecular Information from Diffusion NMR Spectroscopy: Hydrodynamic Volume or Molecular Mass?

Measuring accurate translational self-diffusion coefficients (D_t ) by NMR techniques with modern spectrometers has become rather routine. In contrast, the derivation of reliable molecular information therefrom still remains a nontrivial task. In this paper, two established approaches to estimating molecular size in terms of hydrodynamic volume (V_H ) or molecular weight (M) are compared. Ad hoc designed experiments allowed the critical aspects of their application to be explored by translating relatively complex theoretical principles into practical take-home messages. For instance, comparing the D_t values of three isosteric Cp₂ MCl₂ complexes (Cp=cyclopentadienyl, M=Ti, Zr, Hf), having significantly different molecular mass, provided an empirical demonstration that V_H is the critical molecular property affecting D_t . This central concept served to clarify the assumptions behind the derivation of D_t =ƒ(M) power laws from the Stokes-Einstein equation. Some pitfalls in establishing log (D_t ) versus log (M) linear correlations for a set of species have been highlighted by further investigations of selected examples. The effectiveness of the Stokes-Einstein equation itself in describing the aggregation or polymerization of differently shaped species has been explored by comparing, for example, a ball-shaped silsesquioxane cage with its cigar-like dimeric form, or styrene with polystyrene macromolecules.

Diffusion NMR for the characterization, in solution, of supramolecular systems based on calixarenes, resorcinarenes, and other macrocyclic arenes

The use of diffusion NMR in studying calixarenes and other arene-based supramolecular systems is described, emphasizing the pivotal role played by the calixarene community in transforming the methods into a routine tool used in supramolecular chemistry.

Design and synthesis of a family of 1D-lanthanide-coordination polymers showing luminescence and slow relaxation of the magnetization

We have designed and synthesized eight isostructural 1D coordination polymers (CPs) with the general formula {[Ln(aapc)3(DMF)]}n [where Ln(iii) = Y (2), La (3), Nd (4), Eu (5), Gd (6), Tb (7), Dy (8), Er (9); and aapc = 3-((anthraquinone-1-yl)amino)propanoate]. These CPs consist of Ln-carboxylate infinite rods in which the bulky anthraquinone scaffolds arise from it in such a way that the resulting supramolecular packing exhibits isolated 1D chains. Solution structures have been corroborated through NMR methods including PGSE and EXSY NMR studies and, due to the presence of lanthanide ions, magnetic and luminescence properties have been studied. Alternating current magnetic measurements of compound 8 show slow relaxation of the magnetization, a characteristic of single molecule magnets (SMMs). The evaluation of solid-state photophysical properties reveals that the aapc scaffold sensitizes lanthanide(iii) based emission of compounds 4-9 both in the visible and near-infrared (NIR) regions at 10 K.

A Free Silanide from Nucleophilic Substitution at Silicon(II)

A computationally guided synthetic route to a free silanide derived from tris(3-methylindol-2-yl)methane ([(tmim)Si]- ) through nucleophilic substitution on the SiII precursor (Idipp)SiCl2 is reported (Idipp=2,3-dihydro-1,3-bis(2,6-diisopropylphenyl)-1H-imidazol-2-ylidene). This approach circumvents the need for strained tetrahedral silanes as synthetic intermediates. Computational investigations show that the electron-donating properties of [(tmim)Si]- are close to those of PMe3. Experimentally, the [(tmim)Si]- anion is shown to undergo clean complexation to the base metal salts CuCl and FeCl2 , demonstrating the potential utility as a supporting ligand.

Internally Referenced DOSY-NMR: A Novel Analytical Method in Revealing the Solution Structure of Lithium-Ion Battery Electrolytes

A novel methodology is reported on the use of internally referenced diffusion-ordered spectroscopy (IR-DOSY) in divulging the solution structure of lithium-ion battery electrolytes. Toluene was utilized as the internal reference for ¹H-DOSY analysis due to its exceptionally low donor number and reasonable solubility in various electrolytes. With the introduction of the internal reference, the solvent coordination ratio of different species in the electrolytes can be easily determined by ¹H-DOSY or ⁷Li-DOSY. This new technique was applied to different carbonate electrolytes, and the results were consistent with a Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) analysis. Compared to conventional vibrational spectroscopy, this IR-DOSY technique avoids the complicated deconvolution of the spectrum and allows determination of the solvent coordination ratio of different species in electrolyte systems with two or more organic solvents.

The GNAT: A new tool for processing NMR data

The GNAT (General NMR Analysis Toolbox) is a free and open-source software package for processing, visualising, and analysing NMR data. It supersedes the popular DOSY Toolbox, which has a narrower focus on diffusion NMR. Data import of most common formats from the major NMR platforms is supported, as well as a GNAT generic format. Key basic processing of NMR data (e.g., Fourier transformation, baseline correction, and phasing) is catered for within the program, as well as more advanced techniques (e.g., reference deconvolution and pure shift FID reconstruction). Analysis tools include DOSY and SCORE for diffusion data, ROSY T₁ /T₂ estimation for relaxation data, and PARAFAC for multilinear analysis. The GNAT is written for the MATLAB® language and comes with a user-friendly graphical user interface. The standard version is intended to run with a MATLAB installation, but completely free-standing compiled versions for Windows, Mac, and Linux are also freely available.

Synthesis of Silver(I) and Gold(I) Complexes Containing Enantiopure Pybox Ligands. First Assays on the Silver(I)-Catalyzed Asymmetric Addition of Alkynes to Imines

Dinuclear complexes [Ag2(CF3SO3){(S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox}2][CF3SO3] (1), [Ag2(R-pybox)2][X]2 [R-pybox = 2,6-bis[4-(S)-isopropyloxazolin-2-yl]pyridine (S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox and X = PF6 (2) and BF4 (3); R-pybox = 2,6-bis[(3aS,8aR)-8,8a-dihydro-3aH-indeno[1,2-d]oxazol-2-yl]pyridine (3aS,3a'S,8aR,8a'R)-indane-pybox and X = CF3SO3 (4)], [Ag2{(S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox}{(3aS,3a'S,8aR,8a'R)-indane-pybox}][CF3SO3]2 (5), and [Ag2(R-pybox)3][X]2 [R-pybox = (3aS,3a'S,8aR,8a'R)-indane-pybox and X = CF3SO3 (10), SF6 (11), and PF6 (12)] as well as mononuclear complexes [Ag(R-pybox)2][X] [R-pybox = (S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox and X = SbF6 (6), PF6 (7), and BF4 (8); R-pybox = (3aS,3a'S,8aR,8a'R)-indane-pybox) and X = BF4 (9)] have been prepared by the reaction of the corresponding silver salts and pybox ligands using the appropriate molar ratio conditions. The first gold(I)/pybox complex [Au6Cl4{(S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox}4][AuCl2]2 (13) has been synthesized by the reaction of [AuCl{S(CH3)2}] and (S,S)-(i)Pr-pybox (1:1 molar ratio) in acetonitrile. The structures of the dinuclear (1, 4, 5, 10, and 11) and mononuclear (6 and 9) silver complexes and the hexanuclear gold complex 13 have been determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. These studies have been complemented with a solution-state study by NMR spectroscopy, which included structure elucidation, variable-temperature measurements, and diffusion studies using diffusion-ordered spectroscopy (DOSY; for complexes 1, 4, 10, and 12). Complexes 1, 2, 4, and 10 have been assayed as catalysts in the asymmetric addition of phenylacetylene to N-benzylideneaniline.

A PGSE NMR approach to the characterization of single and multi-site halogen-bonded adducts in solution

The diffusional PGSE NMR technique allows a detailed characterization of single- and multi-site halogen-bonded systems.