Stage-specific appearance of the mouse antigen TEC-3 in normal and nuclear transfer bovine embryos: re-expression after nuclear transfer

Early and delayed aspects of nuclear reprogramming during cloning

The successful production of viable progeny following adult somatic cell nuclear transfer (cloning) provides exciting new opportunities for basic research for investigating early embryogenesis, for the propagation of valuable or endangered animals, for the production of genetically engineered animals, and possibly for developing therapeutically valuable stem cells. Successful cloning requires efficient reprogramming of gene expression to silence donor cell gene expression and activate an embryonic pattern of gene expression. Recent observations indicate that reprogramming may be initiated by early events that occur soon after nuclear transfer, but then continues as development progresses through cleavage and probably to gastrulation. Because reprogramming is slow and progressive, cloned embryos have dramatically altered characteristics in comparison with fertilized embryos. Events that occur early following nuclear transfer may be essential prerequisites for the later events. Additionally, the later reprogramming events may be inhibited by sub-optimum culture environments that exist because of the altered characteristics of cloned embryos. By addressing the unique requirements of cloned embryos, the entire process of reprogramming may be accelerated, thus increasing cloning efficiency.

Changes in the structure of nuclei after transfer to oocytes

Nuclear transfer and the potential for cloning animals have refocused attention on the oocyte. This focus is not limited to the use of the oocyte as a recipient in nuclear transfer procedures, but more broadly in terms of what factors are present in the oocyte that are responsible for establishing the developmental pattern of RNA synthesis and subsequent protein production. Deviations in the pattern of RNA synthesis can result in abortions, as well as abnormalities at birth. This paper will focus on the changes to nuclear structure that result from transfer to the cytoplasm of an oocyte, as well as some of the changes in the patterns of RNA synthesis that have been described.

Reprogramming of fibroblast nuclei after transfer into bovine oocytes

Recent landmark achievements in animal cloning have demonstrated that the events of cell differentiation can, in principle, be reversed. This reversal necessarily requires large-scale genetic reprogramming, of which little is known. In the present study we characterized the extent to which blastocyst stage-specific mRNA expression would be conserved in bovine embryos produced by nuclear transfer (NT) using fetal fibroblasts as nuclei donors (FF NT). The mRNA pool of FF NT embryos was compared with that of NT embryos reconstructed from embryonic blastomeres (Emb NT), with embryos produced under in vivo or in vitro conditions, and finally with fibroblast cells. Embryo/cell-specific mRNA pools were contrasted using differential display methodology. Random oligonucleotide primer pair combinations were used to subfractionate mRNA populations and represent individual mRNAs as copy DNA (cDNA) bands ranging in size from 100 to 800 base pairs. Regardless of whether bovine blastocysts developed in vivo or in vitro, or were derived after nuclear transplantation with embryonic blastomeres or fetal fibroblasts, their mRNA profile was highly conserved and distinct from that of fetal fibroblast cells. There was approximately 95% conservation in cDNA banding patterns between FF NT, Emb NT, and in vivo derived blastocysts, when compared with in vitro derived blastocysts. In contrast, the cDNA banding in fibroblasts was only 67% conserved with in vitro derived blastocysts (p < 0.0001), indicating that dramatic changes in gene transcription are induced by nuclear transplantation. After nuclear transplantation, gene expression in fetal fibroblasts is reprogrammed so to mimic that of preimplantation embryo development. Future characterization of these changes will be invaluable for the identification of suitable cell types to serve as nuclear donors for embryo reconstruction and provide information that can be used to improve the efficiency of cloning animals by nuclear transplantation.

Human cloning: can it be made safe?

There are continued claims of attempts to clone humans using nuclear transfer, despite the serious problems that have been encountered in cloning other mammals. It is known that epigenetic and genetic mechanisms are involved in clone failure, but we still do not know exactly how. Human reproductive cloning is unethical, but the production of cells from cloned embryos could offer many potential benefits. So, can human cloning be made safe?

Gene expression patterns in bovine in vitro-produced and nuclear transfer-derived embryos and their implications for early development

Bovine in vitro-produced (IVP) and nuclear transfer (NT)-derived embryos differ from their in vivo-developed counterparts in a number of characteristics. A preeminent observation is the occurrence of the large offspring syndrome, which is correlated with considerable embryonic fetal and postnatal losses. We summarize here results from our studies in which we compared gene expression patterns from IVP and NT-derived embryos with those from their IVP counterparts. Numerous aberrations were found in IVP and NT-derived embryos, including a complete lack of expression, an induced expression, or a significant up- or downregulation of a specific gene. These alterations may affect a number of physiological functions and are considered as a kind of stress response of the embryos to deficient environmental conditions. We hypothesize that the alterations are caused by epigenetic modifications, primarily by changes in the methylation patterns. Unravelling these epigenetic modifications is promising to reveal the underlying mechanisms of the large offspring syndrome.

Oct4 distribution and level in mouse clones: consequences for pluripotency

Somatic cell clones often fail at a developmental stage coincident with commencement of differentiation. The transcription factor Oct4 is expressed during cleavage stages and is essential for the differentiation of the blastocyst. Oct4 expression becomes restricted to the inner cell mass and epiblast. After gastrulation Oct4 is active only in germ cells and is silent in somatic cells. Here, Oct4 and an Oct4-GFP transgene were used as markers for which gene reprogramming could be directly related to the developmental potential of somatic cell clones. Cumulus cell clones initiated Oct4 expression at the correct stage but showed an incorrect spatial expression in the majority of blastocysts. The ability of clones to form outgrowths was reduced, and the outgrowths had low or even undetectable levels of Oct4 RNA or GFP. The quality of GFP signals in blastocysts correlated with the ability to generate outgrowths that maintain GFP expression and the frequency of embryonic stem (ES) cell derivation. Abnormal Oct4 expression in clones is either directly or indirectly caused by reprogramming errors and is indicative of a general failure to reset the genetic program. The abnormal Oct4 expression may be associated with aberrant expression of other crucial developmental genes, leading to abnormalities at various embryonic stages. Regardless of other genes, the variations observed in Oct4 levels alone account for the majority of failures currently observed for somatic cell cloning.

Nuclear transfer protocol affects messenger RNA expression patterns in cloned bovine blastocysts

The successful production of embryos by nuclear transfer (NT) employing cultured somatic donor cells depends upon a variety of factors. The objective of the present study was to investigate the effects 1) of two different activation protocols, 2) the use of quiescent or nonquiescent donor cells (G(0) or G(1) of the cell cycle), and 3) passage number of donor cells on the relative abundance (RA) of eight specific mRNAs (DNA methyltransferase, DNMT; mammalian achaete-scute homologue, Mash2; glucose transporter-1, Glut-1; heat shock protein 70.1, Hsp; desmocollin II, Dc II; E-cadherin, E-cad; interferon tau, IF; insulin-like growth factor 2 receptor, Igf2r) in single blastocysts employing a semiquantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction assay. The results were compared with those for their in vitro (IVP)- and in vivo-generated noncloned counterparts. In experiment 1, employing either FBA (fusion before activation) or AFS (fusion and activation simultaneously) to generate NT blastocysts, Hsp mRNAs were not found in NT embryos from either protocol, whereas Hsp transcripts were detectable in IVP embryos. The relative abundance (RA) of IF transcripts was significantly increased in the AFS and IVP groups compared to the FBA treatment. In experiment 2, the use of either G(0) or G(1) donor cells to produce cloned embryos both significantly reduced the relative amount of DNMT transcripts and significantly increased the RA of Mash2 compared to the IVP embryos. In addition, IF transcript levels were significantly elevated in NT blastocysts employing G(1) donor cells for NT compared to IVP embryos and those generated using G(0) cells. In experiment 3, donor cells, either from passsage 5/6 or 8, were employed for NT. DNMT transcripts were significantly decreased, whereas Mash2 transcripts were significantly increased in both NT groups compared to their IVP counterparts. The amount of IF mRNA was significantly higher in P8-derived than in P5/6 and IVP embryos. In experiment 4, the RA of DNMT transcripts was decreased in in vivo-derived blastocysts compared to those produced in vitro. Mash2 expression was increased in in vivo embryos and those IVP embryos produced in medium containing Sigma BSA. The RA of Hsp was higher in IVP embryos produced in serum containing medium than in those produced in Sigma BSA or in vivo. In vivo embryos and those produced in Life Technologies BSA had the lowest expression of IF transcripts. Expression of all other genes was not affected by variation in NT methodology or IVP culture systems throughout experiments 1-4. In conclusion, depending on steps of the cloning procedure NT-derived embryos display marked differences from their IVP- and in vivo-derived counterparts. An aberrant expression pattern in NT embryos was found with respect to genes thought to be involved in stress adaptation, trophoblastic function, and DNA methylation during preimplantation development.

Genetic reprogramming of lactate dehydrogenase, citrate synthase, and phosphofructokinase mRNA in bovine nuclear transfer embryos produced using bovine fibroblast cell nuclei

Adult animal cloning has progressed to allow the production of offspring cloned from adult cells, however many cloned calves die prenatally or shortly after birth. This study examined the expression of three important metabolic enzymes, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), citrate synthase, and phosphofructokinase (PFK), to determine if their detection in nuclear transfer (NT) embryos mimics that determined for in vitro produced embryos. A day 40 nuclear transfer produced fetus derived from an adult cell line was collected and fetal fibroblast cultures were established and maintained. Reconstructed NT embryos were then produced from this cell line, and RT-PCR was used to evaluate mRNA reprogramming. All three mRNAs encoding these enzymes were detected in the regenerated fetal fibroblast cell line. Detection patterns were first determined for IVF produced embryos (1-cell, 2-cell, 6-8 cell, morula, and blastocyst stages) to compare with their detection in NT embryos. PFK has three subunits: PFK-L, PFK-M, and PFK-P. PFK-L and PFK-P were not detected in bovine oocytes. PFK subunits were not detected in 6-8 cell embryos but were detected in blastocysts. Results from NT embryo RT-PCR demonstrated that PFK was not detected in 8-cell NT embryos but was detected in NT blastocysts indicating that proper nuclear reprogramming had occurred. Citrate synthase was detected in oocytes and throughout development to the blastocyst stage in both bovine IVF and NT embryos. LDH-A and LDH-B were detected in bovine oocytes and in all stages of IVF and NT embryos examined up to the blastocyst stage. A third subunit, LDH-C was not detected at the blastocyst stage in IVF or NT embryos but was detected in all earlier stages and in mature oocytes. In addition, LDH-C mRNA was detected in gonad isolated from the NT and an in vivo produced control fetus. These results indicate that the three metabolic enzymes maintain normal expression patterns and therefore must be properly reprogrammed following nuclear transfer.

Mechanisms and control of embryonic genome activation in mammalian embryos

Activation of transcription within the embryonic genome (EGA) after fertilization is a complex process requiring a carefully coordinated series of nuclear and cytoplasmic events, which collectively ensure that the two parental genomes can be faithfully reprogrammed and restructured before transcription occurs. Available data indicate that inappropriate transcription of some genes during the period of nuclear reprogramming can have long-term detrimental effects on the embryo. Therefore, precise control over the time of EGA is essential for normal embryogenesis. In most mammals, genome activation occurs in a stepwise manner. In the mouse, for example, some transcription occurs during the second half of the one-cell stage, and then a much greater phase of genome activation occurs in two waves during the two-cell stage, with the second wave producing the largest onset of de novo gene expression. Changes in nuclear structure, chromatin structure, and cytoplasmic macromolecular content appear to regulate these periods of transcriptional activation. A model is presented in which a combination of cell cycle-dependent events and both translational and posttranslational regulatory mechanisms within the cytoplasm play key roles in mediating and regulating EGA.

Nucleolar ultrastructure in bovine nuclear transfer embryos

Nuclear transfer experiments in mammals have attempted to reprogram a donor nucleus to a state equivalent to the zygotic one. Reprogramming of the donor nucleus is, among other features, indicated by a synthesis of ribosomal RNA (rRNA). The initiation of rRNA synthesis is simultaneously reflected in nuclear morphology as a transformation of the nucleolus precursor body into a functional rRNA synthesising nucleolus with a characteristic ultrastructure. We examined nucleolar ultrastructure in bovine in vitro produced (control) embryos and in nuclear transfer embryos reconstructed from a MII phase (nonactivated) or S phase (activated) cytoplasts. Control embryos were fixed at the two-, four-, early eight- and late eight-cell stages; nuclear transfer embryos were fixed at 1 and 3 hr post fusion and at the two-, four-, and eight-cell stages. Control embryos possessed a nucleolar precursor body throughout all three cell cycles. In the eight-cell stage embryo, a primary vacuole appeared as an electron lucid area originating in the centre of the nucleolar precursor body. In nuclear transfer embryos reconstructed from nonactivated cytoplasts, the nuclear envelope was fragmented or completely broken down at 1 hr after fusion and, by 3 hr after fusion, it was restored again. At this time, the reticulated fibrillo-granular nucleolus had an almost round shape. The nucleolar precursor body seen in the two-cell stage nuclear transfer embryos consisted of intermingled filamentous components and secondary vacuoles. A nucleolar precursor body typical for the two-cell stage control embryos was never observed. None of the reconstructed embryos of this group reached the eight-cell stage. Nuclear transfer embryos reconstructed from activated cytoplasts, in contrast, exhibited a complete nuclear envelope at all time intervals after fusion. In the two-cell stage nuclear transfer embryo, the originally reticulated nucleolus of the donor blastomere had changed into a typical nucleolar precursor body consisting of a homogeneous fibrillar structure. A primary vacuole appeared in the four-cell stage nuclear transfer embryos, which was one cell cycle earlier than in control embryos. Only nuclear transfer embryos reconstructed from activated cytoplasts underwent complete remodelling of the nucleolus. The reorganisation of the donor nucleolar architecture into a functionally active nucleolus was observed as early as in the four-cell stage nuclear transfer embryo. These ultrastructural observations were correlated with our autoradiographic data on the initiation of RNA synthesis in nuclear transfer embryos.

Epigenetic modification and imprinting of the mammalian genome during development

Genomic imprinting in mammals results in the differential expression of maternal and paternal alleles of certain genes. Recent observations have revealed that the regulation of imprinted genes is only partially determined by epigenetic modifications imposed on the two parental genomes during gametogenesis. Additional modifications mediated by factors in the ooplasm, early embryo, or developing embryonic tissues appear to be involved in establishing monoallelic expression for a majority of imprinted genes. As a result, genomic imprinting effects may be manifested in a stage-specific or cell type-specific manner. The developmental aspects of imprinting are reviewed here, and the available molecular data that address the mechanism of allele silencing for three specific imprinted gene domains are considered within the context of explaining how the imprinted gene silencing may be controlled developmentally.

Development of the techniques for nuclear transfer in pigs

Nuclear transfer in pigs was developed in the late 1980's. The techniques were based on previous studies in frogs, mice and cattle. Within stage nuclear transfer, pronuclear exchange, was followed by the transfer of nuclei from cleavage stage embryos. While these have resulted in term development, many problems remain. Recently progress on the problem of inadequate oocyte activation has been made and now there can be a refocus on the other aspects of the nuclear transfer procedure. The emphasis in developing the cloning/transgenic technology is easily justified, not so much by the ability to produce genetically identical animals for production agriculture, but for the potential to use a cell line that can be genetically engineered prior to the nuclear transfer. Pigs with specific genetic modifications will have a great impact on production agriculture as well as human medicine.

The stage-specific expression of TEC-1, -2, -3, and -4 antigens on bovine preimplantation embryos

The preimplantation developmental period is associated with constant changes within the embryo, and some of these changes are apparent on the embryo cell surface. For example, during transition from maternal to embryonic genome control and the compaction and differentiation of embryonic cells, the cell surface undergoes morphologic alterations that reflect changes in gene control. In order to gain insight into the events occurring during embryonic development and cellular differentiation, monoclonal antibodies specific for cell surface antigens (TEC antigens) of embryonic cells have been generated previously and shown to recognise either the carbohydrate moiety of embryoglycan or a developmentally regulated protein epitope. The TEC antigens have been identified on mouse preimplantation embryos, and their expression is specific to particular developmental stages. To determine whether these antigens are conserved in higher mammals, we examined the expression of four TEC antigens (TEC-1 to TEC-4) on in vitro-derived bovine and murine embryos during the preimplantation stage of development. It was found that bovine oocytes and embryos derived from in vitro maturation (IVM) and in vitro fertilisation (IVF) showed stage-specific expression of each of the TEC antigens investigated, with the pattern of expression overlapping but not identical to that seen in the mouse. Immunoprecipitation together with Western blot analysis showed that the TEC monoclonal antibodies recognised a single glycoprotein band with an apparent molecular weight of 70 kDa. Confocal microscopy of immunofluorescence staining of the bovine cells showed this protein to be located on the cell surface. The apparent negative expression of these TEC antigens by immunohistochemistry and immunoprecipitation at particular stages of development appears to be due to the epitopes being inaccessible to the TEC antibodies, since Western blotting revealed the TEC antigens to be present at all stages of development examined. Antibodies identifying stage-specific antigens will provide useful markers to characterise early embryonic cells, monitor normal embryonic development in vitro, and identify cell surface structures having a function in cell-cell interactions during embryogenesis and differentiation.

Nucleolar and mitochondrial morphology in bovine embryos reconstructed by nuclear transfer

The nucleolar and mitochondrial morphology of developing reconstructed bovine nuclear transfer (NT) embryos and stage-matched in vivo-produced control embryos were examined under the electron microscope. Each reconstructed embryo at the one-cell (n = 12), two-cell (n = 5), three-cell (n = 3), four-cell (n = 5), 5-8-cell (n = 5) and blastocyst (n = 3) stages was produced by fusion of a 16-32-cell-stage blatomere with an aged enucleated bovine oocyte. The normal and reconstructed embryos showed similar mitochondrial morphology. However, NT embryos produced several pleiomorphic forms not seen in controls, and were more heterogeneous at early stages of development. Control embryos exhibited nucleolar features considered indicative of rRNA synthesis from the eight-cell stage onwards. In contrast, the NT embryos presented nucleoli with morphology consistent with rRNA synthesis in all embryos examined, except in the three-cell and in two of the five four-cell embryos. From this nucleolar morphology, it was concluded that nuclear reprogramming does not occur immediately following nuclear transfer, but occurs gradually over the first two or three cell cycles.

Quantitative control of gene expression by nucleocytoplasmic interactions in early mouse embryos: consequence for reprogrammation by nuclear transfer

HSP 70.1 is one of the first genes to be expressed in the mouse embryo at the time of zygotic genome activation. We studied the regulation of this gene, using a transgene associating HSP 70.1 promoter and the firefly luciferase reporter gene, which allows the precise quantification of HSP 70.1 level of expression on individual embryos. In the present work, we show first that the level of HSP 70.1 expression at the two-cell stage is significantly higher (around two-fold) in embryos whose maternal cytoplasm is from C3H strain than with BALB/c strain. We verified that this difference is not an artefact of the use of transgenic embryos, of the time of first cleavage, or of in vitro culture. This regulation of HSP 70.1 level of expression is controlled by strain-specific maternal modifiers and is independent of replication, syngamy, and mitosis. Following nuclear transfer, reactivation of HSP 70.1 is also subjected to the same epigenetic influence. Only the strain-of-origin of the recipient cytoplast modulates the level of HSP 70.1 reprogrammation; the origin of donor nucleus is not significant, demonstrating the reversibility of this strain effect. These results point out the importance of the quality of recipient cytoplast in the intensity of gene reprogrammation, which may be of importance for nuclear transfer efficiency.

Electrofusion parameters for nuclear transfer predicted using isofusion contours produced with bovine embryonic cells

Electrofusion is a valuable technique for the nuclear transfer procedure. An enucleated oocyte is electrofused with a blastomere to create a nuclear transfer embryo. The present study constructed isofusion contours after the electrofusion of identical coupled cells that characterized all the bovine embryonic cell types used in nuclear transfer. The intersection of isofusion contours for enucleated oocytes and blastomeres provided the parameters for electrofusion during nuclear transfer. Blastomeres isolated from in vitro produced embryos 3-6 days after (in vitro fertilization) were electrofused with oocytes enucleated by centrifugation (85, 87, 89, and 73% electrofusion, respectively). The cleavage (46, 40, 37, and 28%, respectively) of the nuclear transfer embryos produced a trend that decreased as the age of the blastomeres increased. The isofusion contours provided information about the interaction between different cell types in an electric field, and gave precise electrofusion parameters for a range of bovine embryonic cell types used in nuclear transfer.

Effect of bovine sperm separation by either swim-up or Percoll method on success of in vitro fertilization and early embryonic development

The objectives of these experiments were to characterize separation of frozen-thawed bovine spermatozoa on a Percoll gradient and then to compare sperm separation by either a swim-up or Percoll gradient procedure for the ability of spermatozoa to fertilize oocytes in vitro. The Percoll gradient was a 45 and 90% discontinuous gradient. Initial experiments found that centrifugation of semen on the Percoll gradient for 15 min at 700 g was sufficient to obtain optimal recovery of motile spermatozoa. Most of the nonmotile spermatozoa were recovered at the interface of the 45 and 90% Percoll layers, while the motile spermatozoa were primarily in the sperm pellet at the bottom of the gradient. When frozen-thawed semen from each of 7 bulls was separated by swimup, a mean +/- SEM of 9% +/- 1 of the motile spermatozoa were recovered after the procedure. In contrast, more spermatozoa were recovered after Percoll gradient separation (P < 0.05), with 40% +/- 4 of the motile spermatozoa recovered. The effect of separation procedure on in vitro fertilization found swim-up separated spermatozoa penetrated a mean +/- SEM of 74% +/- 5 of the oocytes, while fewer oocytes were penetrated by Percoll separated spermatozoa at 52% +/- 8 (P < 0.05). There was no effect of the separation procedure on the rates of polyspermy as measured by sperm/penetrated ova, with a mean +/- SEM of 1.25 +/-.09 for swim-up separated spermatozoa and 1.14 +/-.07 for Percoll separated spermatozoa (P>0.05). A carry over of Percoll into the fertilization medium with the Percoll separated spermatozoa was found not the cause for the decreased penetration of oocytes by these spermatozoa. In 2 of 3 bulls tested, the decreased penetration of oocytes by Percoll separated spermatozoa could be overcome by increasing the sperm concentration during fertilization from 1 x 10(6) to 5 x 10(6)/ml. When development of embryos fertilized by either swim-up or Percoll separated spermatozoa was compared for the semen from 2 bulls, a difference in cleavage rate was found in favor of swim-up separated spermatozoa (P < 0.05), but there was no effect of separation procedure on development (Day 7) to the morula + blastocyst or blastocyst stage (P>0.05). The disadvantages of the Percoll procedure could easily be overcome and the procedure was faster and yielded a six-fold greater recovery of motile spermatozoa than the swim-up method.

Isolation and characterization of permanent cell lines from inner cell mass cells of bovine blastocysts

Inner cell masses (ICM) from in vitro produced day 8 or 9 bovine blastocysts were isolated by immunosurgery and cultured under different conditions in order to establish which of two feeder cell types and culture media were most efficient in supporting attachment and outgrowth of the bovine ICM cells. The efficiency of attachment and outgrowth of the ICM cells could be markedly improved when STO feeder cells were used instead of bovine uterus epithelial cells, and by using charcoal-stripped serum instead of normal serum to supplement the culture medium. More than 20 stable cell lines were obtained. Some of these lines were examined by immunofluorescence for developmentally regulated markers. From these results we conclude that the cell lines resemble epithelial cells, rather than pluripotent ICM cells. The developmental potential of cells of one of the lines was tested in the nuclear transfer assay. The cell line could support the initial development of enucleated oocytes, but none of the reconstructed embryos passed the eight-cell block.