Comparison of bulk enucleation methods for porcine oocytes

Biotechnological bases of the development of cloned pig embryos

The term ‘clone’ in animal biotechnology refers to an organism derived from non-sexual reproduction, which is both a direct offspring and a genetic copy of the parent organism. To date, the pig appears to be the most interesting object in cloning research. Somatic cell nuclear transfer in pigs has a wide range of potential applications in various fields of human scientific and economic activities. However, the efficiency of producing cloned embryos in swine is still lower than that of other livestock species, in particular horses and cattle. Somatic cell nuclear transfer is a technically complex multi-stage technology, at each stage of which the pig oocytes, which are more susceptible to changes of surrounding conditions, are affected by various factors (mechanical, physical, chemical). At the stage of oocyte maturation, changes in the cell ultrastructures of the ooplasm occur, which play an important role in the subsequent nuclear reprogramming of the transferred donor cell. Before transfer to the oocyte donor somatic cells are synchronized in the G0/G1 stage of the cell cycle to ensure the normal ploidy of the cloned embryo. When removing the nucleus of pig oocytes maturated in vitro, it is necessary to pay attention to the problem of preserving the viability of cells, which were devoid of their own nuclear material. To perform the reconstruction, a somatic cell is placed, using micro-tools, in the perivitelline space, where the first polar body was previously located, or in the cytoplasm of an enucleated oocyte. The method of manual cloning involves the removal of the oocyte nucleus with subsequent fusion with the donor cell without the use of micromanipulation techniques. The increased sensitivity of oocytes to the environmental conditions causes special requirements for the choice of the system for in vitro culture of cloned pig embryos. In this work, we have reviewed the modern methods used for the production of cloned embryos and identified the technological issues that prevent improving the efficiency of somatic cloning of pigs.

Bovine somatic cell nuclear transfer using mitomycin C-mediated chemical oocyte enucleation

SummaryChemical oocyte enucleation holds the potential to ease somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), although high enucleation rates remain limited to micromanipulation-based approaches. Therefore, this study aimed to test mitomycin C (MMC) for use in bovine functional chemical oocyte enucleation. Incubation of denuded eggs in 10 µg ml-1 MMC for different periods did not affect most maturation rates (0.5 h: 85.78%A, 1.0 h: 72.77%B, 1.5 h: 83.87%A, and 2.0 h: 82.05%A) in comparison with non-treated controls (CTL; 85.77%A). Parthenogenetic development arrest by MMC was efficient at cleavage (CTL: 72.93%A, 0.5 h: 64.92%A,B, 1.0 h: 60.39%B,C, 1.5 h: 66.35%A,B, and 2.0 h: 53.84%C) and blastocyst stages (CTL: 33.94%A, 0.5 h: 7.58%B, 1.0 h: 2.47%C, 1.5 h: 0.46%C, and 2.0 h: 0.51%C). Blastocysts were obtained after nuclear transfer (NT) using MMC enucleation [NT(MMC): 4.54%B] but at lower rates than for the SCNT control [NT(CTL): 26.31%A]. The removal of the meiotic spindle after MMC incubation fully restored SCNT blastocyst development [NT(MMC+SR): 24.74%A]. Early pregnancies were obtained by the transfer of NT(MMC) and NT(MMC+SR) blastocysts to synchronized recipients. In conclusion, MMC leads to functional chemical oocyte enucleation during SCNT and further suggests its potential for application towards technical improvements.

Procedure used for denuding pig oocytes influences oocyte damage, and development of in vitro and nuclear transfer embryos

The effects of different denuding procedures used during the in vitro culture of porcine embryos on oocyte damage and aspects of porcine embryo development were investigated in a series of studies. Oocytes were denuded by vortexing or pipetting after 44h in vitro maturation (IVM) or pre-denuded after 22h IVM. The total oocyte death rate was significantly (P<0.05) higher for pre-denuded (27.3±1.4%) than for vortexed (20.3±1.2%) or pipetted (16.2±2.2%) oocytes. There was no significant difference between the treatments in the percentage of oocytes that extruded the first polar body. The type I cortical granule distribution (reflecting complete maturity) and normal spindle formation rates were significantly lower in the pre-denuding than in the vortexing and pipetting treatments. Blastocyst formation rates were significantly lower for the pre-denuding treatment in PA (25.7±4.5%) and IVF (6.1±1.5%) culture than in the vortexing (PA 42.0±4.5%; IVF 11.2±0.5%) and pipetting (PA 43.4±3.1%; IVF 9.4±1.6%) treatments. The proportion of oocytes developing to blastocysts in SCNT culture was not significantly different between treatments ranging from 9.9±1.8% for pre-denuding to 12.3±2.7% for vortexing. No significant differences in apoptosis or embryonic fragmentation were observed. This study shows that the denuding procedure used for porcine oocytes during the in vitro production of embryos can significantly affect oocyte damage, spindle patterns, oocyte maturation, embryo development but not embryonic apoptosis or the frequency of fragmentation.

Cloned sheep blastocysts derived from oocytes enucleated manually using a pulled pasteur pipette

The potential applications of a simplified method of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) that is improved in both efficiency and throughput is considerable. Technically, a major step of SCNT is to produce large pools of enucleated oocytes (cytoplasts) efficiently, a process that requires considerable micromanipulation skill and expensive equipment. Here, we have developed an efficient and high-throughput method of manual oocyte enucleation using a simple device, a pulled Pasteur pipette, that can be connected to standard zona-free method of embryo reconstitution. Common Pasteur pipettes were pulled on a flame to produce finely drawn pipettes with inner diameters approximately less than half the oocyte diameter (∼50-60 μm), and slightly larger than cytoplasmic protrusion (∼20-30 μm) that was induced after demecolcine treatment of MII-stage oocytes. Oocyte manipulation was performed under a stereomicroscope by either bisecting the oocyte into two approximately equal demioocytes (blind manual enucleation), or by positioning the oocytes so that the cytoplasmic extrusion that contains the MII chromosome mass is removed with the minimum amount of cytoplasm (oriented manual enucleation). The survival rate of the manually enucleated oocytes was 81.4-91.5%, comparable to standard zona-free method of oocyte enucleation (>95%). A total of 80-120 oocytes could be enucleated in 10 min, which was considerably higher than standard zona-free enucleation method. In vitro development rates of cloned embryos derived from manually enucleated cytoplasts with varying cytoplasmic volumes (50%, 95%, and 100%) was comparable, and embryonic developmental rates of the two latter groups were at least as good as standard zona-free method. The manual method of oocyte enucleation described here can be learned and mastered for simple, fast, and cheap production of cloned embryos with comparable efficiency to other available methods.

Simple, fast, and efficient method of manual oocyte enucleation using a pulled Pasteur pipette

Cloning mammals by somatic cell nuclear transfer entails the replacement of oocyte chromosomes with the nucleus of a somatic cell. A major step in this technique is to efficiently produce large batches of enucleated oocytes, a process that requires considerable micromanipulation skills and expensive equipments. Here, a simple, fast, and efficient method of manual oocyte enucleation was introduced that can be adopted in every laboratory with the minimum equipments. Common laboratory glass pipettes were pulled on the flame of a burner and then used for manual bisection or enucleation of sheep and goat zona-free oocytes by passing them through the discontinuous cutting border of culture medium and mineral oil. The described techniques showed a certain efficiency to conveniently bisect or enucleate large batches of sheep, and goat oocytes being pre-treated with demecolcine. The method may be straightforward for simple manipulation of oocytes of other species and for development of automated cloning methods as well.

Demecolcine effects on microtubule kinetics and on chemically assisted enucleation of bovine oocytes

This study aimed to evaluate the effect of demecolcine, a microtubule-depolymerizing agent, on microtubule kinetics; to determine the best concentration of demecolcine as a chemically assisted enucleation agent in metaphase I (MI) and metaphase II (MII) bovine oocytes, and to evaluate the embryonic development after nuclear transfer (NT) using chemically assisted enucleation of recipient oocytes. Oocytes in vitro matured for 12 h (MI) and 21 h (MII) were exposed to several concentrations of demecolcine and evaluated for enucleation or membrane protrusion formation. Demecolcine concentration of 0.05 microg/mL produced the highest rates of enucleation in group MI (15.2%) and protrusion formation in group MII (55.1%), and was employed in the following experiments. Demecolcine effect was seen as early as 0.5 h after treatment, with a significant increase in the frequency of oocytes with complete microtubule depletion in MI (58.9%) and MII (21.8%) compared to initial averages at 0 h (27.4% and 1.9%, respectively). Microtubule repolymerization was observed when MII-treated oocytes were cultured in demecolcine-free medium for 6 h (42.4% oocytes with two evident sets of microtubules). Chemically assisted enucleated oocytes were used as recipient cytoplasts in NT procedures to assess embryonic development. For NT, 219 of 515 oocytes (42.5%) formed protrusions and were enucleated, and reconstructed, resulting in 58 nuclear-transferred one-cell embryos. Cleavage (84.5%) and blastocyst development (27.6%) rates were assessed. In conclusion, demecolcine can be used at lower concentrations than routinely employed, and the chemically assisted enucleation technique was proven to be highly efficient allowing embryonic development in bovine.

A comparative study on the efficiency of two enucleation methods in pig somatic cell nuclear transfer: effects of the squeezing and the aspiration methods

In this study, two enucleation methods, the squeezing and the aspiration methods, were compared. The efficiency of these two methods to enucleate pig oocytes and the in vitro and in vivo viability of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) pig embryos, were evaluated. In the squeezing method, the zona pellucida was partially dissected and a small amount of cytoplasm containing metaphase II (MII) chromosomes and the first polar body (PB) were pushed out. In the aspiration method, the PB and MII chromosomes were aspirated using a beveled micropipette. After injection of fetal fibroblasts into the perivitelline space, reconstructed oocytes were fused and activated electrically, and then cultured in vitro for 6 days or transferred to surrogates. The squeezing method resulted in a higher proportion of degenerated oocytes than the aspiration method (14% vs. 5%). The squeezing method took longer to enucleate 100 oocytes (306 minutes) than the aspirating method (113 minutes). Fusion rate (72-78%) and cleavage rate (67%) were not influenced by the enucleation method but blastocyst formation was improved (P < 0.05) in oocytes enucleated by the aspiration method (5 vs. 9%). When SCNT embryos were transferred to recipients, pregnancy rates to term were similar (27%, 3/11 and 27%, 3/11) in both methods with the birth of 10 piglets/3 litters and 16 piglets/3 litters in the squeezing and the aspiration methods, respectively. Our results indicate that the aspiration method for oocyte enucleation is more efficient than the squeezing method in producing a large number of pig SCNT embryos with normal in vivo viability.

Development to the Blastocyst Stage of Porcine Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer Embryos Reconstructed by the Fusion of Cumulus Cells and Cytoplasts Prepared by Gradient Centrifugation

The present study was designated to examine the possibility of producing somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) embryos in pigs using oocyte cytoplasm fragments (OCFs), prepared by centrifugations, as recipient cytoplasts. In Experiment 1, in vitro matured oocytes were centrifuged at 13,000 x g for 3, 6, and 9 min to stratify the cytoplasm, and then the oocytes were freed from zona pellucida and recentrifuged at 5,000 x g for 4 sec in Percoll gradient solution to produce OCFs as the source of recipient cytoplasts. It was found that a long duration of the first centrifugation tends to produce large-sized OCFs after the second centrifugation. In Experiment 2, two or three cytoplasts without chromosomes were aggregated, and then they were fused with a cumulus cell to produce SCNT embryos. The results showed that 66.4 +/- 9.4% of the reconstructed embryos underwent premature chromosome condensation at 1 h after activation, and 85.2 +/- 7.1% and 61.6 +/- 7.0% of them had pseudopronuclei at 10 and 24 h after activation, respectively. In Experiment 3, when SCNT embryos reconstructed by the fusion of three cytoplasts and one cumulus cell, a significantly higher (p < 0.05) rate of reconstructed embryos developed to the blastocyst stage (10.6 +/- 1.8%) than that of reconstructed with two cytoplasts and one cumulus cell (5.2 +/- 1.5%). These results indicate that cytoplasts obtained by two centrifugations can support the remodeling of a transferred somatic nucleus, resulting in the development of the reconstructed porcine embryos to the blastocyst stage.

Development to the blastocyst stage of immature pig oocytes arrested before the metaphase-II stage and fertilized in vitro

In vitro fertilization (IVF) and embryonic development of mature and meiotically arrested porcine oocytes were compared in the present study. After in vitro maturation (IVM) of cumulus-oocyte complexes for 48 h, 75.4% of them extruded a visible polar body (PB). Most of the oocytes with a first polar body (PB+ group) were at the metaphase-II (M-II) stage (91.4%). Most of the oocytes without a visible polar body (PB- group) appeared to be arrested at the germinal vesicle (GV) (41.6%) and metaphase-I (M-I) (34.0%) stages. After IVF of oocytes (day of IVF=Day 0), there was no difference between PB+ and PB- groups in rates of sperm penetration, mono-spermy, however oocyte activation rate after penetration was greater in the PB+ than in the PB- group (P<0.05). On Day 2, there was no difference between rates of embryos cleaved at the 2-4 cell stages in PB+ and PB- groups (42.1+/-48.8% and 33.6+/-2.1%, respectively). On Day 4, the rate of PB+ embryos developing beyond the 4-cell stage was greater than that of PB- embryos (P<0.05, 31.7+/-3.9% and 14.1+/-1.5%, respectively), and PB+ embryos had more cells than the PB- embryos (P<0.05, 8.3+/-0.4 and 6.0+/-0.8 cells, respectively). On Day 6, a greater proportion of PB+ embryos developed to the blastocyst stage than did PB- embryos (P<0.05, 34.6+/-2.4% and 20.7+/-2.8%, respectively). However, when the GV oocytes of the PB- group were not included in recalculations, there was no difference in blastocyst rates between M-I arrested and M-II oocytes (35.3 and 34.6%, respectively). The number of blastomere nuclei in embryos obtained from the PB+ group (52.0+/-2.5) was greater than that from the PB- group (P<0.05, 29.1+/-2.8). The proportion of degenerated parts in the blastocysts, as determined by morphological appearance, was the same in the PB+ and PB- groups. Although the quality of PB+ embryos was enhanced as compared with that of the PB- group, the proportion of inner cell mass and trophectoderm cells in PB+ and PB- blastocysts did not differ (1:1.9 and 1:2.2, respectively). Chromosome analysis revealed that PB+ blastocysts had more diploidy (P<0.05, 69.7%) than did PB- blastocysts (44.0%), whereas PB- blastocysts had more triploid cells (P<0.05, 34.0%) than did PB+ oocytes (8.4%). These results indicate that pig oocytes arrested before the M-II stage (M-I oocytes) undergo cytoplasmic maturation during maturation culture and have the same ability to develop to blastocysts after IVF as M-II oocytes, but some of them resulted in degeneration or delayed development with poor embryo quality.