6
|
Tomizza MA, Jessome MA, Barbosa J, Beattie KA, Bensen WG, Bobba RS, Cividino AA, Emond PD, Gordon C, Hart L, Ioannidis G, Koh MXP, Larché M, Tavares R, Tytus S, Adachi JD. Assessing the Reliability of a Semiautomated Segmentation Algorithm for Quantifying Erosions in the Metacarpophalangeal Joints of Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis. J Rheumatol 2015; 42:1582-6. [PMID: 26178277 DOI: 10.3899/jrheum.141139] [Citation(s) in RCA: 1] [Impact Index Per Article: 0.1] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Accepted: 05/13/2015] [Indexed: 11/22/2022]
Abstract
OBJECTIVE Assess the reliability of early erosions in rheumatoid arthritis (EERA) software for quantifying erosive damage to the metacarpophalangeal joints of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS One hundred magnetic resonance image sets from 68 patients with early referral RA were evaluated. Reliability was assessed using 95% limits of agreement and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) with 95% CI. RESULTS Limits of agreement linearly depended on erosion volume: 0.44× between readers and 0.19× within readers. Interrater ICC was 0.976 (95% CI 0.965-0.984) and intrarater ICC was 0.996 (95% CI 0.994-0.997). CONCLUSION EERA is highly reproducible for quantifying erosions in patients with early RA.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Michael A Tomizza
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Matthew A Jessome
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Joshua Barbosa
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Karen A Beattie
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - William G Bensen
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Raja S Bobba
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Alfred A Cividino
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Patrick D Emond
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Chris Gordon
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Lawrence Hart
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - George Ioannidis
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Melissa X P Koh
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Maggie Larché
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Ruben Tavares
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Stephen Tytus
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
| | - Jonathan D Adachi
- From the Department of Medical Sciences, Department of Medicine, and Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; Department of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.M.A. Tomizza, BSc, Department of Medical Sciences, McMaster University; M.A. Jessome, BHSc; J. Barbosa, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; K.A. Beattie, PhD; W.G. Bensen, MD; R.S. Bobba, MD; A.A. Cividino, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; P.D. Emond, PhD; C. Gordon, PhD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; L. Hart, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; G. Ioannidis, PhD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; M.X. Koh, BHSc, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University; M. Larché, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; R. Tavares, PhD; S. Tytus, MD, St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton; J.D. Adachi, MD, Department of Medicine, McMaster University, and St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton.
| |
Collapse
|